The Fall of Númenor - Game Over!

[Kami]

i dont really care if you guys lynch me not game losing but you need to vote mac tomorrow.
The post of deli purposefully calling me v and him w will make it even more obvious they were w/w if u flip me anyways

If your town.
There’s no way we lynch scum today.
Marmot won’t vote Syn and probably won’t vote Mac from the looks of it.

I don't really care if we win today or tomorrow just vote mac f3

If you are town I am gonna need you to retire honestly.

but im just getting started

[Kami]

If Gavial dying doesn't end the game the cross vote at f3 is always Kami/Mac even if I have my doubts about Syn. Yay.

??? If we are f3 I never ever snap vote regardless of how sure I am because that's fking stupid lmao

[Kami]

Mac only reason u don't want to lynch me now is cause it implicates you hard so ur saving it for f3?

[MacDougall]

Mac only reason u don't want to lynch me now is cause it implicates you hard so ur saving it for f3?

Or alternatively... I am trying to solve the game and believe Gavial is more likely to be the wolf. Could such an easy explanation be so?

[Marmot]

i dont really care if you guys lynch me not game losing but you need to vote mac tomorrow.
The post of deli purposefully calling me v and him w will make it even more obvious they were w/w if u flip me anyways

If your town.
There’s no way we lynch scum today.
Marmot won’t vote Syn and probably won’t vote Mac from the looks of it.

see @Marmot its all your fault

What's my fault?

[Syn]

Mac is being reasonable, which is scummy

Gavial is being reasonable, which is scummy

Kami is trying to start bar fights, which is scummy

Marmot what do I do

I do be liking a Gavial chop today.......

[Marmot]

enough people have showed up

being confirmed town is fun

I'm the doctor and I protected wiml. I can self target/consecutive target so I have no real qualms with claiming rn

this is a lie

Esooa claims doctor, protected wiml. Given there was no death, this obviously has to be true. Why would it be a lie unless syn knows wiml wasn’t the target of the NK??

Wtf is going on

[VOTE: deli] aubergine

the fuck is this vote

Wait a second I just realized something.
If mafia did attack WimI and if mafia knew the only one that would protect them is Esooa and that happens to be the case, how would mafia go into the next day knowing this logic?
Honestly it may make sense to insta vote WimI to push their kill target and out Esooa.
I think HK could actually be Scum.

I tried reading Syn's ISO in a negative light as if he's mafia and the thing that looked the worst wasn't even a Syn post, but a Gavial post where he sorta TMI'd that esooa was the doctor and performed a successful check on Wiml, and made a push to yeet someone who had incredible town equity.

[Gavial]

enough people have showed up

being confirmed town is fun

I'm the doctor and I protected wiml. I can self target/consecutive target so I have no real qualms with claiming rn

this is a lie

Esooa claims doctor, protected wiml. Given there was no death, this obviously has to be true. Why would it be a lie unless syn knows wiml wasn’t the target of the NK??

Wtf is going on

[VOTE: deli] aubergine

the fuck is this vote

Wait a second I just realized something.
If mafia did attack WimI and if mafia knew the only one that would protect them is Esooa and that happens to be the case, how would mafia go into the next day knowing this logic?
Honestly it may make sense to insta vote WimI to push their kill target and out Esooa.
I think HK could actually be Scum.

I tried reading Syn's ISO in a negative light as if he's mafia and the thing that looked the worst wasn't even a Syn post, but a Gavial post where he sorta TMI'd that esooa was the doctor and performed a successful check on Wiml, and made a push to yeet someone who had incredible town equity.

How did I TMI? I said “If”.

[Gavial]

Ah whatever as long as Kami promises not to insta vote Mac F3 in the case Syn is scum and Syn makes the correct choice I’m fine with dying today.

[Gavial]

Or Syn makes the correct choice*

[Gavial]

Depending on which of the 3 is scum.

[Syn]

when do you want to vote, marmot

[Marmot]

when do you want to vote, marmot

Probably later tonight when I go back and reread stuff. I want to do more due diligence in looking at you and Mac to be certain about where to vote.

Still leaning toward Gavial at the moment, but I'm likely the nightkill tonight, so I know whenever we hammer will be my last post.


Who do you want to yeet at this point?

[Syn]

Gavial I guess

not at all confident about any f3 that includes me tho

[Syn]

so let's hope he's the catch, gamers!!!

[Gavial]

so let's hope he's the catch, gamers!!!

I’m not but if your town I hope you take your time and figure out if it really is deep wolf Mac or if it’s just Kami.

[Syn]

snap vote immediately, got it

[Gavial]

snap vote immediately, got it

If you do and we lose to Mac, I’ll blame you for the lost and probably PL you next game.

[Syn]

snap vote immediately, got it

If you do and we lose to Mac, I’ll blame you for the lost and probably PL you next game.

don't threaten me with a good time

[Gavial]

snap vote immediately, got it

If you do and we lose to Mac, I’ll blame you for the lost and probably PL you next game.

don't threaten me with a good time

Wait? You’d enjoy being PL’ed by me? Lol.

[Kami]

so who we voting

[Syn]

you

[Syn]

jk gavial

[Gavial]

I’m still town but ok.

[Kami]

[VOTE: Gavial] aubergine

[Gavial]

Vote Me!

Let’s hope you guys can figure this out in F3!

[Marmot]

@Esooa is Kami mafia?

RN I'd say she's town. In the game I played with her previously she didn't really care that much and made few reads etc because she was scum and didn't really want to be. This game obviously she cares about reading stuff and is mad at HK because of what she's read

Kami’s caring is a function of her mood, not her alignment ime

Besides hollowkatt, who else are you up to lynch?

i'm almost at the point with hollow that like nah, idk that a wolf comes in and does that-- not going to clear them for being inconsistent but Idt it would make sense for hollow to be w/w is falcon and I'd rather flip falcon first.



Villa
Deli

Villa lean
wiml
marmot
igno?

Not clearing(hopefully not more than 1 wolf in here)
Mac
Esooa
Kami
Hollow
Creature

Lunch here(three wolves-- one time?!)
gavial
nanook
falcon


tbh tho it's early and this list could be very good or very bad or neither :O

Deli forgot to include Syn in his Day 1 readlist, would I be foolish to call this auto-town Syn?

[Marmot]

Yeah, Deli's Day 2 push of Syn is a good reminder that Syn is likely just town.

Spoiler: show

enough people have showed up

being confirmed town is fun

I'm the doctor and I protected wiml. I can self target/consecutive target so I have no real qualms with claiming rn

this is a lie

Esooa claims doctor, protected wiml. Given there was no death, this obviously has to be true. Why would it be a lie unless syn knows wiml wasn’t the target of the NK??

Wtf is going on

I’m saying syn probably wolf slipped, and they targeted someone else, which means JK also went thru…

Unless there is some other mech reason Esooa could be lying that I’m missing?

I’m saying syn probably wolf slipped, and they targeted someone else, which means JK also went thru…

Unless there is some other mech reason Esooa could be lying that I’m missing?

You think Syn is claiming JK?

How would that make sense? Unless he JKd Esooa?

And if Syn is a wolf I presume he knows where the NK was lmao what is this

I’m saying syn probably wolf slipped, and they targeted someone else, which means JK also went thru…

Unless there is some other mech reason Esooa could be lying that I’m missing?

ok couple things.
1 - nobody has mentioned JK, just doctor, so that's bad
2 - esooa claiming doc on wiml and syn saying that's a lie doesn't mean syn knows where the NK was, please think that logic through.

Pretty sure Jk is a role in this game, bruh

pretty sure the 4 roles given in the OP said town will have 3 of them.

… forget about it, I didn’t read closely

Regardless, I don’t understand what syn is doing and Occam’s razor feels like syn is just a wolf here

Syn/hk/nanook team doesn’t seem unrealistic

I’m saying syn probably wolf slipped, and they targeted someone else, which means JK also went thru…

Unless there is some other mech reason Esooa could be lying that I’m missing?

ok couple things.
1 - nobody has mentioned JK, just doctor, so that's bad
2 - esooa claiming doc on wiml and syn saying that's a lie doesn't mean syn knows where the NK was, please think that logic through.

Pretty sure Jk is a role in this game, bruh

pretty sure the 4 roles given in the OP said town will have 3 of them.

… forget about it, I didn’t read closely

Regardless, I don’t understand what syn is doing and Occam’s razor feels like syn is just a wolf here

Syn/hk/nanook team doesn’t seem unrealistic

that is not what occam's razor is

man what a pandora's box

Simplest solution is often the right solution. All you’ve done is say Esooa is lying, no reason why, nothing. It’s just wolfy tbh

Syn should be hiding his claim or just claim it, instead he is doing this weird middle ground vague thing that doesn’t make sense

Regardless we lunch outside of the claims 100% of the time here I’m pretty sure.

Whatever Syn is doing is anti town so unless he tracked Esooa and she did not visit wiml, or he JKd Esooa, there is no reason not to believe her. There could have been a JK somewhere else that caused the no NK, either thru protecting the Jk target or by preventing w!jktarget from getting off their kill. We have very little information and what Syn has done has been anti-town and tbh between it and the petty fighting it’s all been pretty demoralizing.

I’m busy, have a job interview tomorrow I’m really excited about. I’m working the 25 minutes leading up to EoD so I’ll only be here tomorrow during a short window. Someone else solve the fucking game.

[Kami]

Vote Me!

Let’s hope you guys can figure this out in F3!

honestly this seems fake coming from you

[MacDougall]

0% Mac
0% Marmot
10% Syn
30% Kami
60% Gavial

I lose to 10%

[Syn]

0% Mac
0% Marmot
10% Syn
30% Kami
60% Gavial

I lose to 10%

thank you mac very cool

[VOTE: Gavial] aubergine

[Syn]

@Urist hammered

[Gavial]

@Urist hammered

I want you to know, I fought to make you death immune day 1 and you didn’t go over.

[Gavial]

Yeah would have been insta scum.

[Gavial]

Well people would have thought that at least

[Syn]

thank god I don't have to do another f3

[MacDougall]

did we win?

[MacDougall]

@Kami @Syn look at us. We didn't even need the confirmed town to vote.

[Marmot]

You know I was gonna vote Gav

[MacDougall]

Pfft we did it without you.

[Marmot]

Waitin' for that flip!

[Urist]

Vote Count 5.Final

Gavial (3) - MacDougall, Kami, Syn
Kami (1) - Gavial

Not Voting (1) - Marmot

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to execute.



Day Five Final Post Counts

Syn - 187 / 205 (18 left)
MacDougall - 185 / 209 (24 left)
Marmot - 156 / 184 (28 left)
Kami - 122 / 156 (34 left)
Gavial - 178 / 219 (41 left)

[Urist]

Our agents failed to stop the King's invasion of Valinor. Under cover of night we fled, gathering our loved ones and belongings, to the harbour and the nine ships awaiting us. We had planned to sail West to Middle-Earth, and to found a new life there in Eriador. Alas, there was a great storm. A wave tall enough to eclipse the peak of Meneltarma swallowed Númenor whole. Our masts were broken and our sails were tattered by the gale, and I thought us doomed, but by some miracle the wave bore our ships to the safe port of Lindon. Alas, Isildur's ship was borne South, and although I spend every waking hour gazing into the Palantír, I have not yet made contact with my son. I fear the worst, but I refuse to lose hope. I will find him, and together we will found a new Kingdom for our people in Middle-Earth, one free from Sauron's influence. For not even he could survive such a catastrophe. And to my people, I swear this oath: Et Eärello Endorenna utúlien. Sinome maruvan ar Hildinyar tenn' Ambar-metta.
- From the journal of Elendil, High King of Arnor and Gondor.

Spoiler: show

Gavial was executed. They were Elendili.

[Urist]

The game is over. The Loyalists win! Congratulations!

@MacDougall
@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
@hollowkatt
@Esooa
@Gavial
@Creature
@Wiml
@Kami
@Syn
@Marmot
@falcon45ca
@Deli
@ignoramus


Mafia chat

Spectator chat

[hollowkatt]

hype! GG town, way to bring it home.
GG wolves, you played well.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Gg

[Urist]

Full reveal is in the spec chat linked above!

[Esooa]

ggs

[Deli]

GG

[falcon45ca]

We won!