A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder - Day 8

[Golden]

Llama could also be asquith sr.

[Scotty]

Llama could also be asquith sr.

I think this is more likely than him being Monty.

I do want MM or greyboneZ lynched next. Can we do that next time?

[Dom]

Llama could also be asquith sr.

I think this is more likely than him being Monty.

I do want MM or greyboneZ lynched next. Can we do that next time?

why

[Scotty]

Llama could also be asquith sr.

I think this is more likely than him being Monty.

I do want MM or greyboneZ lynched next. Can we do that next time?

why

I think I've been pretty vocal about greyboneZ since day 2 (or day 1, I'm losing track of the time)

MM feels different* this game than the games I've known him as civ.

He's not as vague, for one. He really wanted that llama lynch. He didn't seem all that excited about you coming back.

I appreciate that you're asking me questions but it's been a few days since you were almost killed. Who do you find suspicious?

[Marmot]

Hi, I'm here. What did I miss?

[Marmot]

Llama could also be asquith sr.

I think this is more likely than him being Monty.

I do want MM or greyboneZ lynched next. Can we do that next time?

why

I think I've been pretty vocal about greyboneZ since day 2 (or day 1, I'm losing track of the time)

MM feels different* this game than the games I've known him as civ.

He's not as vague, for one. He really wanted that llama lynch. He didn't seem all that excited about you coming back.

I appreciate that you're asking me questions but it's been a few days since you were almost killed. Who do you find suspicious?

Yes, I wanted that lynch very badly. You're confusing me.

[Scotty]

Llama could also be asquith sr.

I think this is more likely than him being Monty.

I do want MM or greyboneZ lynched next. Can we do that next time?

why

I think I've been pretty vocal about greyboneZ since day 2 (or day 1, I'm losing track of the time)

MM feels different* this game than the games I've known him as civ.

He's not as vague, for one. He really wanted that llama lynch. He didn't seem all that excited about you coming back.

I appreciate that you're asking me questions but it's been a few days since you were almost killed. Who do you find suspicious?

Yes, I wanted that lynch very badly. You're confusing me.

You seemed so sure when you voted him yesterday. "Don't believe a word out of that mustache" if I recall. Would you vote him again tomorrow? Do you think he is bad?


Honestly I suspect greyboneZ the most in this game and if anyone can defend his actions please show me the light. I will be voting him tomorrow if I am still alive.

[Scotty]

New theory:
Elo is greyboneZ' teammate.

She voted llama and (from what I translated) said even though she thought he was civ, she had to save herself.

GreyboneZ also had a vote at that point. Why llama over him? Llama was a safe vote for a baddie because he at least had some flak for his "my team" statement. I think it would be easy to use him as a scapegoat, while still making yourself appear innocent by apologizing for the vote.

This isn't to say that llama is NOT a baddie, I just think the odds are he is not.

[Scotty]

New theory:
Elo is greyboneZ' teammate.

She voted llama and (from what I translated) said even though she thought he was civ, she had to save herself.

GreyboneZ also had a vote at that point. Why llama over him? Llama was a safe vote for a baddie because he at least had some flak for his "my team" statement. I think it would be easy to use him as a scapegoat, while still making yourself appear innocent by apologizing for the vote.

This isn't to say that llama is NOT a baddie, I just think the odds are he is not.

But Scotty! You're just presupposing that greyboneZ is bad and it's clouding your judgment on other people!

Fine.

But let's lynch the boneZ first and we'll see how obtuse and ridiculous my theory is.

[DFaraday]

Night post up shortly. Also, the prize has been won.

[DFaraday]

Night 3 - Pushing Daisies

Monty fumed at his lack of success in recent days. Everyone he tried to kill slipped through his fingers, it was intolerable!

"Let this be known, Monty Navarro will no longer be stop-"

He was cut off by a chair from the third story of the castle. From a window high above Monty, a voice called down.

"I know it was you! I saw what you tried to do to poor, dear Sorsha! Suffer my wrath, illegitimate wretch!"

She grabbed a clock to throw down, but unfortunately Monty's accomplices, Sibella and Miss Shingle, snuck up behind her and pushed her out the window. With a heap she crashed beside a dizzy Monty. Spacedaisy was dead.

"Jolly good show, ladies!" Monty called up.

Daisy has been killed. It is now Day 4. You have 24 hours to lynch someone.

[Spacedaisy]

probably for the best. Got other stuff that needs attention now... Have fun y'all

[Sorsha]

I Link McCloud llama is good, but night actions reprint to vote nincompoop rutilant save myself, I think. ANd i know I am Titan so I have to go with that.

I guess this was your vote post for llama yesterday. Can you translate please? Why did you vote for llama?

[Elohcin]

New theory:
Elo is greyboneZ' teammate.

She voted llama and (from what I translated) said even though she thought he was civ, she had to save herself.

GreyboneZ also had a vote at that point. Why llama over him? Llama was a safe vote for a baddie because he at least had some flak for his "my team" statement. I think it would be easy to use him as a scapegoat, while still making yourself appear innocent by apologizing for the vote.

This isn't to say that llama is NOT a baddie, I just think the odds are he is not.

I cringed as I voted llama that day. I hated to do it. But I wasn't 100% sure of his alignment at the time and he had more votes than grey. I know that there is a person in this game with vote worth two and I didn't want to chance it. I will not be voting llama again in this game unless it is to save myself. I believe llama is civ. I could get behind a Grey lynch.

[thellama73]

I like you too, Eloh, but I'm sad about Daisy.

Who should we lynch today? I'm down for Metalmarsh or Greybonez, but I don't want a vote spread like last time. Vote spread bad.

[Sorsha]

I voted for greybonez.

[thellama73]

I voted for greybonez.

Do you think I should too?

[Sorsha]

I voted for greybonez.

Do you think I should too?

I think you should follow your heart and vote for who you think is bad.

[Elohcin]

this is one of the nuttiest games I have been in. Greybonez, why the hell not? Better than a split. And if I were to split my vote it would be Roxy.

[thellama73]

I voted for greybonez.

Do you think I should too?

I think you should follow your heart and vote for who you think is bad.

I think almost everyone is bad, but I only have one vote.

[thellama73]

Okay, I'll go with greybonez. I also don't like splitting the vote. Yesterday was a mess.

[Golden]

Greybonez/MM/Eloh would make sense to me as a team. Scotty is bothering me, though, in that his views just changed a lot from being llama to now being greybonez/eloh team. I almost wonder if it could be Greybonez/Scotty/MM and if scotty is setting up the lynch of one of his own so that he can turn it on to Eloh tomorrow. Also, from day one greybonez/llama still makes a decent amount of sense.

Anyway, putting that all together I think a greybonez vote is the way to go, I'm on board.

[thellama73]

Greybonez/MM/Eloh would make sense to me as a team. Scotty is bothering me, though, in that his views just changed a lot from being llama to now being greybonez/eloh team. I almost wonder if it could be Greybonez/Scotty/MM and if scotty is setting up the lynch of one of his own so that he can turn it on to Eloh tomorrow. Also, from day one greybonez/llama still makes a decent amount of sense.

Anyway, putting that all together I think a greybonez vote is the way to go, I'm on board.

Yeah, I've got a Scotty suspicion in my back pocket.

[fingersplints]

Anyone want to give me a summary on the suspicion of greybonez?
Sorry but it's unlikely I will get to read the whole thread until tomorrow

[thellama73]

Anyone want to give me a summary on the suspicion of greybonez?
Sorry but it's unlikely I will get to read the whole thread until tomorrow

He's shifty and he tried to drag me into his web of shiftiness.

[Scotty]

Greybonez/MM/Eloh would make sense to me as a team. Scotty is bothering me, though, in that his views just changed a lot from being llama to now being greybonez/eloh team. I almost wonder if it could be Greybonez/Scotty/MM and if scotty is setting up the lynch of one of his own so that he can turn it on to Eloh tomorrow. Also, from day one greybonez/llama still makes a decent amount of sense.

Anyway, putting that all together I think a greybonez vote is the way to go, I'm on board.

When new information is presented, opinions can change.

I like how you're setting up that in the case of greyboneZ flipping bad, I could possibly be his teammate. I've been on his ass since the Epi lynch. That'd be pretty ballsy of me naming my top suspect as my teammate all game.

And to be clear, llama isn't classified as good in my radar. I just think there are statistically more roles that could have stopped his death yesterday.

But I see that you have agreed with my choices of GreyboneZ/Elo and possibly MM. So apparently we're on the same page there.

What do you think of llama?

[Scotty]

Greybonez/MM/Eloh would make sense to me as a team. Scotty is bothering me, though, in that his views just changed a lot from being llama to now being greybonez/eloh team. I almost wonder if it could be Greybonez/Scotty/MM and if scotty is setting up the lynch of one of his own so that he can turn it on to Eloh tomorrow. Also, from day one greybonez/llama still makes a decent amount of sense.

Anyway, putting that all together I think a greybonez vote is the way to go, I'm on board.

Yeah, I've got a Scotty suspicion in my back pocket.

Cool story bro

[Golden]

Llama is one of a pool of people I haven't ruled out as a possible baddie, but him being bad would be more circumstantial - I haven't had any baddie vibes from him, and for me the worst strike against llama is greybonez day one drive by vote.

[Scotty]

Anyone want to give me a summary on the suspicion of greybonez?
Sorry but it's unlikely I will get to read the whole thread until tomorrow

He's shifty and he tried to drag me into his web of shiftiness.

More specifically, he has only a handful of posts, none of which translate as civ-minded. He hasn't defended himself.

His vote on day 1 came at 5 minutes before deadline to give Epi the lead in votes over the second place vote-holder Llama. His reasoning was because he didn't like the word "sis" in Epignosis. Like wtf? I understand he's new, but this seems really been-mafia to me. It's like he's laying in his crib looking at the pretty colors of his mobile and goo-goo-gah-gah'ing all the lifelong day, and I don't buy it.

And llama, it would still make it a strong possibility that he did so to save you, if he is bad.

[fingersplints]

That is a very odd vote. And I agree doesn't look great for llama if bad. I feel like a new player would be less likely to put someone in the lead day 1 unless they had good reason to.

[Roxy]

Anyone want to give me a summary on the suspicion of greybonez?
Sorry but it's unlikely I will get to read the whole thread until tomorrow

He's shifty and he tried to drag me into his web of shiftiness.

How shifty.

[Roxy]

this is one of the nuttiest games I have been in. Greybonez, why the hell not? Better than a split. And if I were to split my vote it would be Roxy.

Can you translate were you were saying yesterday? You seemed to imply you had info on me.

Otherwise my vote will go to you with zero hesitation.

[fingersplints]

Alright, I'm going to vote greybonez now then. I feel a bit bad since he is a new player, but it's day 4 (he's just new to me! Hello!) and I think good points. I promise I will read all tomorrow

[Elohcin]

this is one of the nuttiest games I have been in. Greybonez, why the hell not? Better than a split. And if I were to split my vote it would be Roxy.

Can you translate were you were saying yesterday? You seemed to imply you had info on me.

Otherwise my vote will go to you with zero hesitation.

I don't remember implying I had info on you. I will translate what I wrote yesterday if you provide the quote you'd like translated. I will try to remember what was said at that time.

You want to keep voting me but you haven't even made a case for me or provided one quote that you thought was pingy.

[birdwithteeth11]

Sticking with Elohcin for now. Still think she's bad.

Other than the Greybonez drive-by votes, I'm not really seeing anything else on the case against him.

[Marmot]

Why do people keeping throwing my name around but not voting for me?

[birdwithteeth11]

Why do people keeping throwing my name around but not voting for me?

Do you want the attention? Do you want me to vote for you? Or do you just want someone to acknowledge your small, pathetic existence as you look back and realize you're 10+ years from accomplishing any of your life's goals and ambitions?

Do you want me to be nicer to you? Do you want some ice cream?

[Dom]

Why do people keeping throwing my name around but not voting for me?

[Marmot]

Why do people keeping throwing my name around but not voting for me?

Do you want the attention? Do you want me to vote for you? Or do you just want someone to acknowledge your small, pathetic existence as you look back and realize you're 10+ years from accomplishing any of your life's goals and ambitions?

Do you want me to be nicer to you? Do you want some ice cream?

I'm not that far from accomplishing things...

[birdwithteeth11]

Why do people keeping throwing my name around but not voting for me?

Do you want the attention? Do you want me to vote for you? Or do you just want someone to acknowledge your small, pathetic existence as you look back and realize you're 10+ years from accomplishing any of your life's goals and ambitions?

Do you want me to be nicer to you? Do you want some ice cream?

I'm not that far from accomplishing things...

Accomplishing what? What are these "things" you speak of? Does it encompass all of your happiness? Are you hungry? Would you like some pancakes with strawberries and cinnamon on top? How about an iced tea with it? Are you getting tired of all these questions?

[Marmot]

Why do people keeping throwing my name around but not voting for me?

Do you want the attention? Do you want me to vote for you? Or do you just want someone to acknowledge your small, pathetic existence as you look back and realize you're 10+ years from accomplishing any of your life's goals and ambitions?

Do you want me to be nicer to you? Do you want some ice cream?

I'm not that far from accomplishing things...

Accomplishing what? What are these "things" you speak of? Does it encompass all of your happiness? Are you hungry? Would you like some pancakes with strawberries and cinnamon on top? How about an iced tea with it? Are you getting tired of all these questions?

Never mind.

[Marmot]

Golden: suddenly inserted my name into a team of players with no prior suspicion or even mention of me (aside from a few questions to me).

Spoiler: show

Greybonez/MM/Eloh would make sense to me as a team. Scotty is bothering me, though, in that his views just changed a lot from being llama to now being greybonez/eloh team. I almost wonder if it could be Greybonez/Scotty/MM and if scotty is setting up the lynch of one of his own so that he can turn it on to Eloh tomorrow. Also, from day one greybonez/llama still makes a decent amount of sense.

Anyway, putting that all together I think a greybonez vote is the way to go, I'm on board.

Scotty: continues to voice suspicion of me, but with nothing to back it up. At one point, he made the comment that "MM just feels different", but nothing more than that. Like Golden, he also inserted my name into a team of players.

Spoiler: show

If I had to pick the 3rd teammate of llama and greybonez, I'd probably pick MM. Just on a hunch.

But I still do want to hear the thought process from greybonez. This may not implicate llama at all, since there were five of us with 1 vote at the time.

RIP TH. I dont really understand why people voted you.

I'm also slightly perturbed that Llama and greyboneZ only received one vote each. MM I can get behind, but I'm sticking with my opinion that if greyboneZ flips bad, so does llama. It just fits.

I don't know if Llama slipped in his wording or not, but I can assure him that my "coming after" him is definitely self motivated, since I am not on a "team" (according to his definition of a civ). I want a civ victory here and for some reason we're lynching the wrong ones.

Lacey, same as last time, plus don't have a read on who's a baddie

I don't trust you.

You should have voted him.

Also if I could place another vote it would have been for MM.

Llama could also be asquith sr.

I think this is more likely than him being Monty.

I do want MM or greyboneZ lynched next. Can we do that next time?

why

I think I've been pretty vocal about greyboneZ since day 2 (or day 1, I'm losing track of the time)

MM feels different* this game than the games I've known him as civ.

He's not as vague, for one. He really wanted that llama lynch. He didn't seem all that excited about you coming back.

I appreciate that you're asking me questions but it's been a few days since you were almost killed. Who do you find suspicious?

Greybonez/MM/Eloh would make sense to me as a team. Scotty is bothering me, though, in that his views just changed a lot from being llama to now being greybonez/eloh team. I almost wonder if it could be Greybonez/Scotty/MM and if scotty is setting up the lynch of one of his own so that he can turn it on to Eloh tomorrow. Also, from day one greybonez/llama still makes a decent amount of sense.

Anyway, putting that all together I think a greybonez vote is the way to go, I'm on board.

When new information is presented, opinions can change.

I like how you're setting up that in the case of greyboneZ flipping bad, I could possibly be his teammate. I've been on his ass since the Epi lynch. That'd be pretty ballsy of me naming my top suspect as my teammate all game.

And to be clear, llama isn't classified as good in my radar. I just think there are statistically more roles that could have stopped his death yesterday.

But I see that you have agreed with my choices of GreyboneZ/Elo and possibly MM. So apparently we're on the same page there.

What do you think of llama?

thellama73: Same deal. Has mentioned wanting to vote for me multiple times, but only backed it up with a vote once. This happened yesterday in retaliation of my vote for him.

Spoiler: show

Sorry guys I haven't had any time for mafia today. Going into today I expected to vote for Golden but after sleeping on it and seeing his recent posts I think his suspicion of me is genuine - and this was one of my problems with him, I didn't feel like his suspicions/opinions were genuine. I'll look into him more tomorrow and respond to some of his observations about me and talk about what some of my concerns were, but I'm tabling my suspicion of him for now.

I'm voting Metalmarsh... again, but this time it's FOR REAL. I'm okay with Elo's observation about Llama, I think it was a "slip" worth bringing up and looking into... it's Metalmarsh's harping on the slip that I take issue with. His first post towards Llama is fine, his second reiteration of the point looks like someone trying to be opportunistic about a poor choice of words. It's something I expect more from baddie Marsh than a civvie one.

I also think Greybonez's vote and explanation is suspicious as hell but I don't know him well enough to decide if it's disingenuous and I don't have time to look into it.

Turnip Head expressed much wisdom here. May he rest in peace. I am happy to consider a Metalmarsh lynch tomorrow.

I'm voting llama today because I don't believe a word that comes out of that mustache.

I'm voting Metalmarsh today because I don't believe a word that comes out of that marmot.

I like you too, Eloh, but I'm sad about Daisy.

Who should we lynch today? I'm down for Metalmarsh or Greybonez, but I don't want a vote spread like last time. Vote spread bad.

Lacey, same as last time, plus don't have a read on who's a baddie

I don't trust you.

You should have voted him.

Also if I could place another vote it would have been for MM.

You and me both, brother.

birdwithteeth: He did vote for me yesterday, but suddenly was not interested today.

Spoiler: show

unexcited Rahl interest of Typhoony located particulars 6-way tie, I am going is that a piano? vote Metalmarsh.

Addendum: I still think llama is bad, and Golden as well.

[Greybonez]

Say good night to the bad guy. You're never gonna see another bad guy like this again

[Sorsha]

Good night Greybonez

[Golden]

Good night, greybonez

I always find it kind of fun when someone admits to it when things are a foregone conclusion.

[DFaraday]

Lynch post coming up!

[DFaraday]

Day 4 - Exit, Stage Left

Everyone was disturbed by Daisy's sudden death. These past days had been full of misery and grief, the likes of which such well-to-do socialites had never seen. Greybonez decided to lighten the mood.

"I shall soothe your melancholic moods with a one-man play!" he declared. "Let us meet in the parlour for my presentation!"

Greybonez' solo play was a tour de force in bad acting and stilted dialogue, with no coherent plot or structure. In a climactic scene, Greybonez crept behind the couch and reemerged dressed as Juliet (of Romeo fame), and began a soliloquy at the top of his lungs.

"YEA, NOISE? THEN I'LL BE BRIEF. O HAPPY DAGGER! THIS IS THY SHEATH-JKWERBLAWKFAWFHBABLABHRFWEABFAKSJA!!!"

He had gone to stab himself with the prop dagger he always kept on his person, but the angry mob had replaced it with a real one before the play started.

"OUT, OUT, BRIEF CANDLE! ET TU, BRUTE? TO BE OR NOT TO BE...something from Othello."

With that, he was dead. And the mob were no closer to finding Monty.

Greybonez has been lynched. He was Lady Salome D'Ysquith-Pumphrey. It i now Night. You have Twenty-THREE hours to send in your night actions.

[Sorsha]

Great

[thellama73]

I don't know which roles are bad and which are good since there is no role list on the front page. Does this mean Greybonez was good? That is a shame, then. You guys should have listened to me about MM.

[Dom]

I don't know which roles are bad and which are good since there is no role list on the front page. Does this mean Greybonez was good? That is a shame, then. You guys should have listened to me about MM.

I'm beginning to think so too, but am wary of you tricking me.