Cindy Kate & Percy Date Night Mafia <3 [ENDGAME]

[Sloonei]

I think we should be shooting the safest target within the POE.

The safest? Who is the safest?

That is the question we are currently trying to answer as a group.
Who do you think it is?

You are asking the wrong person. I would have listened to my gut and my gut only, i always do. I dont believe in consensus shots. I would have done it like Belzy did it but on a hard to solve player.

I did not ask what you would do with this shot, I asked who you think is the safesr choice?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

General prompt with little game-relevance to whoever cares:

When I do interactive reviews, do you find them easier to deal with/read/follow in the form above, with all quotes consolidated in one place followed by specific commentary, or in a post-by-post format with commentary per post the way I used to do them? The former has proven to be much more efficient for me, but I want to ensure they're useful.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I note that the poll is set to expire in 11 hours, 24 hours early. I will see if this is in error. If not, yikes.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I'm going to be on planes again tomorrow and have essentially zero time to play. And I have to be done with this for the night.

[Guillotine]

I think we should be shooting the safest target within the POE.

The safest? Who is the safest?

That is the question we are currently trying to answer as a group.
Who do you think it is?

You are asking the wrong person. I would have listened to my gut and my gut only, i always do. I dont believe in consensus shots. I would have done it like Belzy did it but on a hard to solve player.

I did not ask what you would do with this shot, I asked who you think is the safesr choice?

Personally, if i was you, i'd shoot the PGO claim, just to make sure.

[Guillotine]

Im confused with Seanzie's paranoia towards my claim by the way.

@Seanzie why is it again that my PGO claim does not make me obvious town?

[MacDougall]

there is no way you are a PGO in the same way that your red check was always fake.... you are fake news

[Guillotine]

there is no way you are a PGO in the same way that your red check was always fake.... you are fake news

The red check was a reaction test which i retracted.

I claimed my role on Day 1 without pressure and i havent retracted it, have i?
The fact that i kill my killers only, checks out with Kito being able to visit me and give me chocolates.

So why does Seanzie worry about my claim if i can be checked by non killing roles? I am confirmable.

[MacDougall]

there is no way you are a PGO in the same way that your red check was always fake.... you are fake news

The red check was a reaction test which i retracted.

I claimed my role on Day 1 without pressure and i havent retracted it, have i?
The fact that i kill my killers only, checks out with Kito being able to visit me and give me chocolates.

So why does Seanzie worry about my claim if i can be checked by non killing roles? I am confirmable.

PGO is a broken town role and I rarely ever see it. It is an absurd role and a meme claim.

[MacDougall]

My guess is you are like a 1 shot yoghurt slinger and shot your wad n1 and are trying to remain relevant.

[Guillotine]

there is no way you are a PGO in the same way that your red check was always fake.... you are fake news

The red check was a reaction test which i retracted.

I claimed my role on Day 1 without pressure and i havent retracted it, have i?
The fact that i kill my killers only, checks out with Kito being able to visit me and give me chocolates.

So why does Seanzie worry about my claim if i can be checked by non killing roles? I am confirmable.

PGO is a broken town role and I rarely ever see it. It is an absurd role and a meme claim.

Unfortunately for scum that is not the case here. Arent you happy that i can't be killed by scum unless they sacrifice themselves?
You sound bothered by actually.

[Guillotine]

My guess is you are like a 1 shot yoghurt slinger and shot your wad n1 and are trying to remain relevant.

Yah you are bothered by it by the role i got. I love it.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

You're both town, nobody cares

[Guillotine]

Im off to catch some Zzzzz.

[Guillotine]

You're both town, nobody cares

What? You got a green check on both of us?

[MacDougall]

My guess is you are like a 1 shot yoghurt slinger and shot your wad n1 and are trying to remain relevant.

Yah you are bothered by it by the role i got. I love it.

How could I be bothered by that which doesn't exist?

[bad bunny]

Ugh hey everyone I'm sorry I've been inactive last days I have has to do stuff with my family for the holiday weekend, I want to try and look into some things tomorrow when I get a chance, I think people shading or targeting Dana might be a good place to look with her flipping town as maybe there was People looking for easy target with her. I thought she look very towny from her early posts

vote me then

What was your case on Dana?

I had a fake red check on her

^ more anti-town play

your definition of anti-town is hilar

Actually self admittedly shit posting is anti town because it disrupts the thread which could be used for good solving discussion and it clogs up the thread with stuffs that we don't need. Like I've already said Gavlis did this in the last hame I played exactly the same and yes he was scum

Fake red checking someone if you are town would be hilariously anti-town so the question is Just how bad are you as town because if the answer is not very then the plausible explanation is anti-town you is not actually town this game.

Any reasonablly good town lplayer doesn't have to fake check someone to get people to vote them too they can get those votes anyway, wouldn't you agree with that?

I agree these "red checks" have not been good for town at all this game

[bad bunny]

I think speculating about who Dana protected and who the wolves shot is a fools errand. It is just wasting thread space.

agreed

[Alison]

hello again

i have no intention of reading through 10 posts of guillo having stupid arguments with whoever.

[Alison]

I vote for shooting orange, they've got nothing going for them except an entrance readslist that was kinda correct, except it was also heavily qualified.

[bad bunny]

@bad bunny a read on Allcrab and a reason for it would be appreciated.

Why do you ask me in particular? :o

I'm not 100% sure but i lean town i think? From what i saw D1 he was one of the first to suspect Owner, and he is pretty good at reading her. He was very quick to say yeah owner is likely a wolf here. He does shade his teammates as distancing of course but im not sure he would straight say they're wolf D1. He also seems like the last game where he was town where he is kinda solving but almost does not care much lol. Nothing eyebrow raising about him this game. There is a chance he's wolf I guess, but im not eager to lynch him at all.

If he's town we want him around endgame.

[bad bunny]

I do think Crab would town read me no matter his alignment lol

[Alison]

I have a townread on crab.

[Alison]

My top guess for poisoner is probably nanook because he's coasted by on good interactives with nutella and hasn't picked any hills to die on.

[bad bunny]

Ugh hey everyone I'm sorry I've been inactive last days I have has to do stuff with my family for the holiday weekend, I want to try and look into some things tomorrow when I get a chance, I think people shading or targeting Dana might be a good place to look with her flipping town as maybe there was People looking for easy target with her. I thought she look very towny from her early posts

well i still think Alisons "obvious town" read on Dana could be TMI read

It's called being good at the game

yes it could just be wanting to be a know it all, I've made room for that possibility too

[Alison]

act, gnome, orangecrush are my top mafia poe.

if I'm misclearing someone it's most likely made. I believe that martin is almost certainly town but the thin worlds where he is scum involve him being in a very sticky situation mechwise and so he will probably be outed which means I don't have to cover that possibility.

that's my solve

[Alison]

Ugh hey everyone I'm sorry I've been inactive last days I have has to do stuff with my family for the holiday weekend, I want to try and look into some things tomorrow when I get a chance, I think people shading or targeting Dana might be a good place to look with her flipping town as maybe there was People looking for easy target with her. I thought she look very towny from her early posts

well i still think Alisons "obvious town" read on Dana could be TMI read

It's called being good at the game

yes it could just be wanting to be a know it all, I've made room for that possibility too

Calling one player town is being a know it all?

That's a pretty strange definition of all.

[Actvscenei]

Act has made 13 posts in the first 11 hours of Day 4 with no more Dana alive to tunnel,

3 are snap votes.

9 are questions.

Mafia.

I stopped voting for Dana halfway through D2. We just started D4 and you’re claiming that my inactivity at day start is because Dana is dead?

[bad bunny]

Hello. I was a 1-shot universal backup. Now I am a 1-shot desperado. I wanted this to happen yesterday, but a roleblock prevented me.

I intend to shoot today. I may or may not still be protected by LC’s vest. So, who do I shoot?

if you got roleblocked wouldnt that take up the shot? I think it should have tbh, idk how 1 shot mechs work much tho

[MacDougall]

vote me then

What was your case on Dana?

I had a fake red check on her

^ more anti-town play

your definition of anti-town is hilar

Actually self admittedly shit posting is anti town because it disrupts the thread which could be used for good solving discussion and it clogs up the thread with stuffs that we don't need. Like I've already said Gavlis did this in the last hame I played exactly the same and yes he was scum

Fake red checking someone if you are town would be hilariously anti-town so the question is Just how bad are you as town because if the answer is not very then the plausible explanation is anti-town you is not actually town this game.

Any reasonablly good town lplayer doesn't have to fake check someone to get people to vote them too they can get those votes anyway, wouldn't you agree with that?

I agree these "red checks" have not been good for town at all this game

I'm sorry what?

I believe there has been two, one from Seanzie and one from Guillo. The impact either had on the game has been irrelevant. The game is going fine. You are fake news.

[Alison]

I faked a red on Tangy but it didn't have any impact

[MacDougall]

I faked a red on Tangy but it didn't have any impact

Must have missed that one. Still a make believe sentiment and I now wish to vote bad bunny off the Island.

[MacDougall]

Notwithstanding I never actually faked a red check at all @orangecrush.

[Alison]

she's poisoned and all the claimed poison healers are out of shots so she is already dead. there's no point worrying about her alignment.

[MacDougall]

I still have ptsd from that insane read sloonei made on me. I will probably wake up in the middle of the night and tunnel him for it.

[bad bunny]

I think people should only give suggestions for wolves for Sloonei to shoot. None of this "oh shoot me, it will do us good" crap I'm seeing from Orange and AllCrab. Unless you're admitting to a wolf, you should give a target that you think is a wolf to help Sloonei decide and to help us read you.

Allow me to reiterate.

@Sloonei

hey sloonei I think you should shoot me.

No no no ;p

[MacDougall]

she's poisoned and all the claimed poison healers are out of shots so she is already dead. there's no point worrying about her alignment.

Oh I forgot she was poisoned.

Lol we can feasibly win the game today.

[bad bunny]

What was your case on Dana?

I had a fake red check on her

^ more anti-town play

your definition of anti-town is hilar

Actually self admittedly shit posting is anti town because it disrupts the thread which could be used for good solving discussion and it clogs up the thread with stuffs that we don't need. Like I've already said Gavlis did this in the last hame I played exactly the same and yes he was scum

Fake red checking someone if you are town would be hilariously anti-town so the question is Just how bad are you as town because if the answer is not very then the plausible explanation is anti-town you is not actually town this game.

Any reasonablly good town lplayer doesn't have to fake check someone to get people to vote them too they can get those votes anyway, wouldn't you agree with that?

I agree these "red checks" have not been good for town at all this game

I'm sorry what?

I believe there has been two, one from Seanzie and one from Guillo. The impact either had on the game has been irrelevant. The game is going fine. You are fake news.

i find them annoying, unless youre a cop you dont have a red check ;p

[bad bunny]

town definitely have a poisoner and mafia probably do too?

3 people have claimed healer right

[MacDougall]

I had a fake red check on her

^ more anti-town play

your definition of anti-town is hilar

Actually self admittedly shit posting is anti town because it disrupts the thread which could be used for good solving discussion and it clogs up the thread with stuffs that we don't need. Like I've already said Gavlis did this in the last hame I played exactly the same and yes he was scum

Fake red checking someone if you are town would be hilariously anti-town so the question is Just how bad are you as town because if the answer is not very then the plausible explanation is anti-town you is not actually town this game.

Any reasonablly good town lplayer doesn't have to fake check someone to get people to vote them too they can get those votes anyway, wouldn't you agree with that?

I agree these "red checks" have not been good for town at all this game

I'm sorry what?

I believe there has been two, one from Seanzie and one from Guillo. The impact either had on the game has been irrelevant. The game is going fine. You are fake news.

i find them annoying, unless youre a cop you dont have a red check ;p

im a cop and I have a 3p check on guillo

[bad bunny]

Ugh hey everyone I'm sorry I've been inactive last days I have has to do stuff with my family for the holiday weekend, I want to try and look into some things tomorrow when I get a chance, I think people shading or targeting Dana might be a good place to look with her flipping town as maybe there was People looking for easy target with her. I thought she look very towny from her early posts

well i still think Alisons "obvious town" read on Dana could be TMI read

It's called being good at the game

yes it could just be wanting to be a know it all, I've made room for that possibility too

Calling one player town is being a know it all?

That's a pretty strange definition of all.

no youve done it multiple times lol

[Alison]

town definitely have a poisoner and mafia probably do too?

3 people have claimed healer right

only martin and hawk have.

[Actvscenei]

town definitely have a poisoner and mafia probably do too?

3 people have claimed healer right

I believe only Martin and Hawk. Hawk flipped.

[Alison]

Ugh hey everyone I'm sorry I've been inactive last days I have has to do stuff with my family for the holiday weekend, I want to try and look into some things tomorrow when I get a chance, I think people shading or targeting Dana might be a good place to look with her flipping town as maybe there was People looking for easy target with her. I thought she look very towny from her early posts

well i still think Alisons "obvious town" read on Dana could be TMI read

It's called being good at the game

yes it could just be wanting to be a know it all, I've made room for that possibility too

Calling one player town is being a know it all?

That's a pretty strange definition of all.

no youve done it multiple times lol

well they are in fact obvious town so what do you want me to say?

[bad bunny]

Martin and Orangecrush both have high scum equity imo but I think we should give orangecrush a chance?

[bad bunny]

town definitely have a poisoner and mafia probably do too?

3 people have claimed healer right

I believe only Martin and Hawk. Hawk flipped.

did hawk heal alison?

[Actvscenei]

town definitely have a poisoner and mafia probably do too?

3 people have claimed healer right

I believe only Martin and Hawk. Hawk flipped.

did hawk heal alison?

According to their claims, they both targeted Alison for the heal. So far Hawk is the only confirmed healer so we can speculate that Hawk healed Alison.

[bad bunny]

idk i just want to help lynch a wolf before I flip and have the crab survive.

[Actvscenei]

Martin and Orangecrush both have high scum equity imo but I think we should give orangecrush a chance?

Why should we give Orange a chance?

[bad bunny]

town definitely have a poisoner and mafia probably do too?

3 people have claimed healer right

I believe only Martin and Hawk. Hawk flipped.

did hawk heal alison?

According to their claims, they both targeted Alison for the heal. So far Hawk is the only confirmed healer so we can speculate that Hawk healed Alison.

FFS -_-