Everyone's JOATED: Guillo's Roles (Town Wins)

[Garden Gnome]

what up my dudes?

the sun (a minor miracle) and this game! Let's catch some wicked scums!!! Who are you currently reading as scum?

mansnicks, honey, lime are the ones that are sticking out to me as scum. Mostly not caring though b/c finding town is better

All right, thank you!
Who are your strongest town reads right now?

[Garden Gnome]

what up my dudes?

LoMo has a redcheck on you.

Oooh, that exciting. And it's even more exciting than me asking a scum for scum reads? LOL.

Um, Gnome, you DO realize that LoMo has made exactly one post in this game, and it's not a red check on me?

It wasn't you, lol. In the previous post, I asked hollowkatt for scum reads, lol.
You had to check?

[Garden Gnome]

what up my dudes?

LoMo has a redcheck on you.

Oooh, that exciting. And it's even more exciting than me asking a scum for scum reads? LOL.

Um, Gnome, you DO realize that LoMo has made exactly one post in this game, and it's not a red check on me?

You had to check?

I checked when you said LoMo had a red on me b/c I didn't remember LoMo posting at all. So I thought maybe that was in the posts I didn't read from overnight.

My posts are getting more and more confused.
Did you find that red check? What do you think of it?

[hollowkatt]

what up my dudes?

the sun (a minor miracle) and this game! Let's catch some wicked scums!!! Who are you currently reading as scum?

mansnicks, honey, lime are the ones that are sticking out to me as scum. Mostly not caring though b/c finding town is better

All right, thank you!
Who are your strongest town reads right now?

me
mac
alison
dolby
ender

[Seanzie]

what up my dudes?

LoMo has a redcheck on you.

Oooh, that exciting. And it's even more exciting than me asking a scum for scum reads? LOL.

Um, Gnome, you DO realize that LoMo has made exactly one post in this game, and it's not a red check on me?

You had to check?

I checked when you said LoMo had a red on me b/c I didn't remember LoMo posting at all. So I thought maybe that was in the posts I didn't read from overnight.

My posts are getting more and more confused.
Did you find that red check? What do you think of it?

Gnome, there was no redcheck. I just said that to see how HK reacted. The fact that they felt the need to go look at LoMo's posts to figure out if I was telling the truth is troubling though.

[hollowkatt]

what up my dudes?

LoMo has a redcheck on you.

Oooh, that exciting. And it's even more exciting than me asking a scum for scum reads? LOL.

Um, Gnome, you DO realize that LoMo has made exactly one post in this game, and it's not a red check on me?

You had to check?

I checked when you said LoMo had a red on me b/c I didn't remember LoMo posting at all. So I thought maybe that was in the posts I didn't read from overnight.

My posts are getting more and more confused.
Did you find that red check? What do you think of it?

Gnome, there IS no red check. Go look at Lost Monkeys ISO. There is one post in it, shouldn't take too long.

[hollowkatt]

LoMo has a redcheck on you.

Oooh, that exciting. And it's even more exciting than me asking a scum for scum reads? LOL.

Um, Gnome, you DO realize that LoMo has made exactly one post in this game, and it's not a red check on me?

You had to check?

I checked when you said LoMo had a red on me b/c I didn't remember LoMo posting at all. So I thought maybe that was in the posts I didn't read from overnight.

My posts are getting more and more confused.
Did you find that red check? What do you think of it?

Gnome, there was no redcheck. I just said that to see how HK reacted. The fact that they felt the need to go look at LoMo's posts to figure out if I was telling the truth is troubling though.

I didn't read shite from over night, already explained that.

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

me lime th town r n

honey i will defend u with my life dw about being a ml

nvm these are both town

Side note, I highly recommend NOT voting me for NK immunity.

So that must mean you clearly want us to vote you for the yeet right?

this probly wolf

hk and Dolby town

Seanzie Alison sus

Hello everybody!


I have 2 roles this game; JOAT & GOAT


Tom Brady ain't got sheeeeet on me

I have a very strong feeling Falcon randed scum. Don't ask me to explain, but it is real.

[VOTE: Falcon] aubergine

Seanzie town

Changed my mind on Dolby he scummy

Michelle town

I recommend everyone read the setup pretty carefully since there are a lot of non-standard things going on here. For example, the poll and the in-thread voting do different things.

Also, vote for me in the poll! Seanzie for president 2024!

It’s working kinda. I can join the Dolby/Seanzie ticket until something better comes along. Dolby 2024! Seanzie 2032!

Dolby, I'll be honest, I think there's a high chance my vote will be on you at EoD.

Your entrace already showed a survival mindset.
Seanzies entrance was a to-look-good but good for nothing advice.
And now you make this post? Do you see how it looks fmpov?

@Dolby question, what did you mean by "It's working kinda"? Sounds to me like Seanzie gave you a tip in the scumchat and that sentence was in response to that - because I see nothing in the thread that it could address. What is the "it"?

this is lock town never rescind

I repeat do not vote for this person ever

anyways n0 i have dolby visiting garden gnome???

I thought you said not to claim stuff

I'm made of sugar, spice, and everything nice so I'm immune to soup kills!!! A wolf or witch would not wanna eat my soup 0> )

Idk I usually like things with honey in it, so why wouldn't wolves?

Asking for a friend.

Seanzie
tsp
honey
Alison
th
hk

these are all town. get on this wavelength.

i hereby declare that honey is town

Meta?

Sweet if so

Seanzie
tsp
honey
Alison
th
hk
mansnicks
ender

these are all town. get on this wavelength.

sorry take ender out of my list

lime
flea
ender
creature

top scum

These are posts i liked, but i just collected them and spoilered.

Still reading, day was busy

[Michelle]

Just scrolled up few posts and skimmed

Joking about rechecks in day 1? Smh
Now i have to read and see what's about

[Michelle]

Falcon and Lime Coke are partners.

Creature should either stop signing up for games with a soup kill or stop complaining about the soup kill.

Second this post as well

I feel this slot agenda-y, i am going to read further to see if i will keep my impression

[Garden Gnome]

LoMo has a redcheck on you.

Oooh, that exciting. And it's even more exciting than me asking a scum for scum reads? LOL.

Um, Gnome, you DO realize that LoMo has made exactly one post in this game, and it's not a red check on me?

You had to check?

I checked when you said LoMo had a red on me b/c I didn't remember LoMo posting at all. So I thought maybe that was in the posts I didn't read from overnight.

My posts are getting more and more confused.
Did you find that red check? What do you think of it?

Gnome, there IS no red check. Go look at Lost Monkeys ISO. There is one post in it, shouldn't take too long.

Oh, it's fake, lol.

[Garden Gnome]

LoMo has a redcheck on you.

Oooh, that exciting. And it's even more exciting than me asking a scum for scum reads? LOL.

Um, Gnome, you DO realize that LoMo has made exactly one post in this game, and it's not a red check on me?

You had to check?

I checked when you said LoMo had a red on me b/c I didn't remember LoMo posting at all. So I thought maybe that was in the posts I didn't read from overnight.

My posts are getting more and more confused.
Did you find that red check? What do you think of it?

Gnome, there was no redcheck. I just said that to see how HK reacted. The fact that they felt the need to go look at LoMo's posts to figure out if I was telling the truth is troubling though.

I just did the ISO. It was hilarious.

[lost monkey]

Mansick guy probably town. Making too many assumptions to be scum.

[lost monkey]

I didn't know I had rechecked someone.

[lost monkey]

I am reading mansnicks town primarily because his tunnel on Dolby feels like a villager who's excited to have nailed a wolf. There's a lot of small stuff that most scum players wouldn't think to fake that make the tunnel more authentic: the advance declaration of an EOD vote, the suspicion that an errant sentence was meant for scumchat, and the self-acknowledgement that it's a tunnel but going through with it anyway. Also to his credit is the fact that he's repping a pretty heavy tunnel on Dolby but has continued to solve and make posts about people other than him: one of the most common reasons to fake a big tunnel as scum is that you can just post about that person and nothing else and be relinquished of the burden of doing actual solving because you're "just too tunnelled to see the big picture!!"

Basically this and alison is probably town as well.

[listo95]

Also doing this for now to make him appear

[VOTE: CerealLord] aubergine

You have five posts in the game, haven't caught up or talked to anyone yet, but you're already pressuring inactives so they'll show up?

It doesn't matter now but I know him well. That was an extremely odd playstyle for him. Also I work in retail so it can be very difficult for me to read and when I am able to catchup being forced to have 50 posts per page kind of overwhelms me.

[TonyStarkPrime]

if I said that I thought HK was a wolf what would happen

[listo95]

Also @Alison I'm not the best at reading interactions between people without knowing some form of flips. I do much better looking at EoD votes and seeing what I think of people based on flips and where they voted. Essentially, early game is my weakest spot in all of mafia.

[lost monkey]

if I said that I thought HK was a wolf what would happen

Depending on the reasons anything can? What happened to your lime coke scum read?

[TonyStarkPrime]

i forgot about it

[lost monkey]

Ender's tone is different from what I have seen as town, either he is scum or town who got fed up of eating n1 kills.

[lost monkey]

i forgot about it

lol

[Lime Coke]

Zero people picking up my Lime Coke suspicion strengthens my suspicion even more.

What's even suspicious about me?

What about my suspicion on Mansnicks?

You are suspicious because of post #108 where you hedged on Falcon in a way designed to draw negative attention towards him while maintaining plausible deniability, followed by attempting to shade mansnicks for something that isn't scummy at all.

I think mansnicks is obvious town.

Wasn't really a hedge? I scumread off of something that I saw with my own reasoning, which has seem to have worked in the past couple of games for me. I didn't see anyone else going for Falcon or remember why they were but I just expressed it was weird of Falcon to question something that was a joke from Honey.

But I did say they (Honey and Falcon) looked better interacting with each other.

It wasn't as bad as Mansnick's "WHAT!?!?!!?!?" which I'm still just grossed out by.

Falcon and Lime Coke are partners.

Creature should either stop signing up for games with a soup kill or stop complaining about the soup kill.

so Alison is the one Falcon is trying to pocket there? Was Falcon vocally suspicious of Lime Coke before Alison started talking about Lime?

Lime Coke's "Falcon looks iffy for questioning this, but is overall fine" feels more like a cowardly shade than an interaction with a partner. Falcon attacks Lime Coke aggressively shortly thereafter, which also does not fit with two wolf buddies taking a hedgy stance towards each other. I also independently townread Falcon, so for all those reasons I don't think they're W/W.

Is it cowardly shade or hedging off a read? Which one is it?

like alison will find it wolfy but to me it just comes across as like insecure

I don't think it should be wolfy? She's relatively comfortable.

Plus she's got her town entitlement already which is a strong towntell for her.

Elaborate?

When Honey is town majority of her responses to anyone scumreading or voting her would be "I'm town, what the fuck are you doing? Fuck off with that shit." Like her despise in people voting her when she's town, or not townreading her in general, is extremely strong.

like alison will find it wolfy but to me it just comes across as like insecure

i wouldnt say insecure i'm literally just trying to joke and be playful but it's too srs here i think for that

Because people here are boring as hell apparently.

Fun fact: I've been told I have a boring playstyle in every single game I've played seriously, video or otherwise. I like trading all the pieces and winning in endgame in chess, playing zoning characters in fighting games, afk farmers in MOBAs, control characters in BattleCON, etc.

I'm just a very boring person.

Completely off topic but I'm not against zoning? Unless there's a particular matchup that allows zoning to happen, I normally don't play a zoning style because I can't get the spacing or neutral down correctly. Going AGAINST zoners makes things interesting for me because I have to figure out how to approach them while avoiding the projectiles.

[falcon45ca]

Hello everybody!


I have 2 roles this game; JOAT & GOAT


Tom Brady ain't got sheeeeet on me

falcon, I think that you're having fun, but it's not helping your game. I am no longer convinced that you are town. Could you show me some of that GOAT and tell me a few people that you are town reading and a few people that you are scum reading?

When were you convinced I was town? Convinced is a strong word, why were you ever convinced I was town?

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

townies:
me
mac
falcon
ender
seanzie
alison
michelle
tsp

Too many players scum reading me w/o voting for me.



That's bullshit, vote me ya wieners

[VOTE: Falcon] aubergine

Side note, I highly recommend NOT voting me for NK immunity.

So that must mean you clearly want us to vote you for the yeet right?

this probly wolf

hk and Dolby town

Seanzie Alison sus

Wow me trying to make a joke gets me read as a wolf. My heart hurts so much... Now back to my break at work.

Is this a bad time to mention I'm not even remotely good at these games?

Is this a bad time to mention I'm not even remotely good at these games?

This is a bad post.

This is. Art Attack!

Is this a bad time to mention I'm not even remotely good at these games?

Join the club. I have no idea of what's going on here!

Hey Gnomey!

What's your reads, give me even paper thin ones.

I'm completely clueless! But here are a few town reads, which are probably paper thin.
I think that Honey is entertaining, so she comes across as town.
I don't know why Seanzie is getting voted. He seems townie to me.
Also falcon45ca and EnderWiggin.
I really just sort of skimmed through the game. There was a lot of fluff and I'm not sure about too much. Don't have any scumreads yet.

Finished moving in, I’ve never sweat so much in my life. Shoulda been to the apartment before buying it- apartment 4R is a SIX floor walk up in a cramped stairwell, our sofa and box spring didn’t fit, soooo we trashed them,/!;?&

Anyway, I just got done reading page 5. You ever do group presentations in like..college and all individually have to come up with a critique of the presentation you just witnessed, and end up going last? That’s how I feel. I don’t like catch up, I like to be like Troy in HSM and be IN the game, ya feel?

All this to say that I dislike Triple’s entrance solely because he’s so willingly ordaining town medals to everyone.

I also think that if SeanZie is indeed bad, HK his white knight may be a blatant partner

Zero people picking up my Lime Coke suspicion strengthens my suspicion even more.

lol im giddy

I don’t think I’ve ever encountered giddy Mac. Actually. I don’t know if anything you’ve spewed onD1 is AI tho. I ain’t voting you today.

Maybe I’ll vig you tonight tho

i think that hollowkatt's uhh shade at my slot was the worst and i also dont get their confidence on listing like 4 people they would be fine with killing today (and me being one of them when i know they're wrong is not ok to me) so that's why i voted them for now

Hi, we haven't met yet I don't think.
A few things to help you understand me:
1. N0 is never a thing, stop doing it it's bad and dumb
2. Townies shouldn't lie to other townies, don't do that either it's bad.
3. FPS is bad, stop doing it.
4. Self-voting is bad, don't do it.
5. I like killing people and strongly prefer hard reads over weasel reads. I might be wrong but dammit I'm gonna be wrong with conviction

you're wrong on 1-3 and 5

[VOTE: Lime Coke] aubergine

Scummiest slot in the game so far.

So I've hard-disliked 2 of your takes so far, good start.

she is locktown

ender/lime w/w though or no cause I'd say no

Nah Mac says we w/w so we w/w.

Let me defend my buddy pls.

Also softening slightly on mansnicks but I'd really like an explanation on how everyone was tring him for his reaction to Honey.

Busy day for me. I'm about halfway caught up. I'll post my catch-up notes later tonight.

Until now my vote is on
[VOTE: Ender] aubergine
Only for gut

and i dislike Scotty's first post because is unnecessary wordy

[TonyStarkPrime]

ok though I just read another lime coke post and like cmon

[Guillotine]

[Creature]

[VOTE: Ender] aubergine

[TonyStarkPrime]

actually no, it's town, i just don't like posts that are longer than a tweet

[lost monkey]

At the moment, falcon is my strongest scumread but none of my townreads are voting there and some even townread them so I'm hesitant on that front.

This was my exactly the same thing i said in the thread when me and falcon were scum lol. Since i dont know you i am not voting, ill be keeping my eye on you.

[Creature]

Wished I could get back into watching Avatar

[Lime Coke]

@Lime Coke - Roughly how much experience do you have playing as each alignment?

In forum mafia format, way more experience as town than I do as mafia.

My first like 15 games were all town in FM format.

I did hit a slight streak of flipping mafia in the past like...2 months? Including the one Honey has referenced a few times where I was mafia and she was town.
I've only won 1 time as mafia though, the rest were L's.

I've finally hit a town streak now though.

[Creature]

Kinda unhappy the Avatar game ended so soon and terribly. Any way we can make this game Avatar themed?

[hollowkatt]

Kinda unhappy the Avatar game ended so soon and terribly. Any way we can make this game Avatar themed?

Clearly this game is ICP themed

[Michelle]

Creature scum imo

[Michelle]

At the moment, falcon is my strongest scumread but none of my townreads are voting there and some even townread them so I'm hesitant on that front.

This was my exactly the same thing i said in the thread when me and falcon were scum lol. Since i dont know you i am not voting, ill be keeping my eye on you.

That's NAI for Osie, but that's all i can tell with so little content from him

Is he the only one you'll keep an eye on?

[Lime Coke]

Creature scum imo

I can see why.

But why?

[lost monkey]

At the moment, falcon is my strongest scumread but none of my townreads are voting there and some even townread them so I'm hesitant on that front.

This was my exactly the same thing i said in the thread when me and falcon were scum lol. Since i dont know you i am not voting, ill be keeping my eye on you.

That's NAI for Osie, but that's all i can tell with so little content from him

Is he the only one you'll keep an eye on?

For now, yeah. No one's post has pinged me more than that one.

[falcon45ca]

what up my dudes?

the sun (a minor miracle) and this game! Let's catch some wicked scums!!! Who are you currently reading as scum?

mansnicks, honey, lime are the ones that are sticking out to me as scum. Mostly not caring though b/c finding town is better

All right, thank you!
Who are your strongest town reads right now?

me
mac
alison
dolby
ender

Hmmmmm

[falcon45ca]

townies:
me
mac
falcon
ender
seanzie
alison
michelle
tsp

Hmmmm

[lost monkey]

Hey everyone, happy to play again with everyone i know

let's have a good game ^^

Right to business, i would vote now
[VOTE: Holowkatt] aubergine for whatever reason, except a logical one, so don't ask

you would vote me as a wolf currently? spicy
also Hi Michelle!

"Spicy" means a correct read?

Only read I have is HK kinda towny still. See you on 11 hours, for real this time

Explain me the coloured word please

hey guys

Hi did we ever play together?

Wait I'm a little confused about something - shouldn't I have had a role received by now?

Derp denied, but nice try

I have played here, MU and mafia cafe. If you have the same name then no.

[lost monkey]

what up my dudes?

LoMo has a redcheck on you.

lol

[lost monkey]

what up my dudes?

LoMo has a redcheck on you.

LoMo is playing?

yeah

[Michelle]

Creature scum imo

I can see why.

But why?

His vote for Ender came unnatural after mine.

His all Iso don't have a single towny vibe, and he looked suspect for me. That vote is the trigger for me expressing the read

[hollowkatt]

townies:
me
mac
falcon
ender
seanzie
alison
michelle
tsp

Hmmmm

This post brought to you by

[Michelle]

At the moment, falcon is my strongest scumread but none of my townreads are voting there and some even townread them so I'm hesitant on that front.

This was my exactly the same thing i said in the thread when me and falcon were scum lol. Since i dont know you i am not voting, ill be keeping my eye on you.

That's NAI for Osie, but that's all i can tell with so little content from him

Is he the only one you'll keep an eye on?

For now, yeah. No one's post has pinged me more than that one.

Now this is odd tbh

[Lime Coke]

Creature scum imo

I can see why.

But why?

His vote for Ender came unnatural after mine.

His all Iso don't have a single towny vibe, and he looked suspect for me. That vote is the trigger for me expressing the read

Right I don't think I've actually seen the dude out a single read yet. He's talked about soup kills and Avatar.

[Michelle]

Falcon's "hmmm"s are hilarious

No other words for the thread @Falcon?

[Michelle]

Creature scum imo

I can see why.

But why?

His vote for Ender came unnatural after mine.

His all Iso don't have a single towny vibe, and he looked suspect for me. That vote is the trigger for me expressing the read

Right I don't think I've actually seen the dude out a single read yet. He's talked about soup kills and Avatar.

You said you can see why.
What was your thought at the moment you posted that?

[Lime Coke]

Creature scum imo

I can see why.

But why?

His vote for Ender came unnatural after mine.

His all Iso don't have a single towny vibe, and he looked suspect for me. That vote is the trigger for me expressing the read

Right I don't think I've actually seen the dude out a single read yet. He's talked about soup kills and Avatar.

You said you can see why.
What was your thought at the moment you posted that?

I typically have the same reads that others obtain, but I end up having different reasons. I asked your reasoning to see what you were seeing and overall curiosity.

Plus people tend to NOT answer that when I ask why so yeah. I was shocked you even answered.