Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Thu Feb 27, 2020 10:19 am
Here’s kinda my read progression.
1) Nutella throws out some opportunistic takes on Sig and iirc, Nanook. That is, she pointed out a little not that scummy thing in Sig’s massive iso of purity which made it look like she was trying to get a mislynch. Then Nanook has a fair amount of early suspicion and it felt like she was like “oh yeah, me too” which felt like a wolf that just wanted to get a lynch not on her team, not a real thought.
1.5) At the same time, Nutella is kinda giving off townie tone outside those two posts. She’s waffley but to the point where she is saying things like “I am waffley” so it could be fake. She’s also posting a ton and Nutella tends to post less as a wolf.
2) I express that maybe Nutella is scum. Cause she’s hitting scum and town baseline behavior.
3) Nutella is immediately like “This is garbo.” This feels like a bad reaction for the reasons Jay pointed out. The last time I caught Nutella day 1, we thunderdomed and it felt fake but she skated and killed me night 1. So it really felt like wolfNutella gearing up for an inevitable confrontation. I’m not sure what the townie perspective is for her reaction.
4) I reread the Sig/Nanook posts and see Nutella call my suspicion of her garbo so I vote for her.
5) Nutella reacts as follows and it really reads like “I don’t even suspect Jack because would wolfJack even do this whatever I’m going to vote for him anyway.
nutella wrote: ↑Tue Feb 25, 2020 11:57 pm
Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Tue Feb 25, 2020 11:56 pm
Specifically, Nutella is showing waffles, wim and opportunism.
[VOTE:
Nutella] aubergine
are you like, reading from a clipboard? seriously what is this?
what have you done with jack??
would you actually be this obvious tho??
[VOTE:
jack] aubergine
And as I’m reading these posts, my scumread on Nutella is reinforced. She really does look bad from these posts in a vacuum.
6) We fight for a bit and then I leave. Then Nutella is like “Jack is probably town and wrong.”
7) ???????? Idk I haven’t read all this shit. Votes move to Radishes and come off me cause duh I’m town. And they pile onto Nutella, which implies she did something else scummy or people agree with my points.
8) Jay points out to Nutella “AHA! You shouldn’t suspect Jack for suspecting you!” and Nutella is like “No shit but what am I supposed to do?”
Then Nutella continues to hit her stride without letting herself get pulled into the thunderdome, not having mean wolf reactions, etc.
But the other thing is that almost half the players are scum and I have a bunch of townreads.
So I’m like “Either Nutella is a wolf and is handling me way better than she did last time and is mimicking her town game better or she’s a townie who had three scummy looking reads on D1 and statistically, some of my other reads are probably wrong.”
And then there’s multiball to take into account. Does wolfNutella look townier because it’s multiball and age can go after people? Does townNutella get unfairly dinged for scummy looking reads when she’s going to actually hunt regardless of alignment and so the very basis of my “Nutella does not believe these reads” line of inquiry is wrong on its face?
Idk. I kinda want to give her another day.
