The Syndicate

Really sorry for triple posting! Want to get this down before I go to bed. FH, someone said you had a good spreadsheet that you might be willing to share, is that true?

And I either didn't know or had totally forgotten you were playing, but welcome (back?)!

and voting Ratt

Process of elimination. I can't stand Poison and am often driven crazy by overplayed Motley Crüe at work, and I haven't heard of Cinderella.

Good thing for me that this day phase will be long-it's been hard to catch up this weekend when I don't have my commute! First off, GREAT that we got a baddie last lynch! Really good work everyone. Second, MP, glad to see your role gone but I wanted to thank you for the spreadsheet anyway. Hopefully...

Thanks for the coming spreadsheet MP! And thanks LT, I'll keep your offer in mind but right now one mafia game at a game is more than enough to keep me occupied. I can't yet say I think MP is good, but I am disappointed with the way this lynch is going down. Unanimous gives us little to no informati...

Hey LT, I just noticed that when I try to link to your spreadsheet, the site says I don't have the required permissions to download it. Could you attach the file to this forum, or could MP post his spreadsheet?

Thanks, Snow Dog.

Question to Dex on your post: if MP is mafia, wouldn't it be best to get him first before looking at boo voters? Only 1 of them could be his teammate if he were mafia anyway, so we'd be looking at 1 probable accomplice and 3 civvies in that group.

EBWOP: realized I miscounted and am not the last vote, we're waiting on He-Man and INH. Knife is still my choice though.

And looks like I'm the last to vote on this poll...I was waffling between the Swiss Army Knife as my first instinct and going Roxy on the twine since she's speaking from experience. I think I'll vote knife to tie it up, because though I love duct tape as much as the next person, you can run out of i...

Ok, time for my thoughts, finally! NIce to be on my computer instead of checking on my phone. First off, I agree that the mentioned civ roles are most likely why boo wasn't lynched. We don't know what the baddies' powers are, so I'm not willing to say 100% that he's civvie, but Occam's Razor says to...

Wow, I'm sorry I haven't been involved in the later stages of today's discussion, everyone. Today has been an unmitigated disaster for me in terms of things needing to be done and not getting that way. I've read through quickly, but will do it again slower tomorrow and post thoughts. For now, I need...

So what are people's thoughts on the chemistry lecture? It either came from the player with that role or from SVS, right? Either way, I think it should be given some weight. I ignored cryptic info in ny last game, which ended up being to my detriment. And ignoring lectures leads to failing. So MP, w...

Idc if you never understand my logic about Auger voters tbs :) I also am feeling slightly sad that people think I am agressive. :( I am sorry I disagreed with your logic about Augers/random voting/weak reasoning. I was just having a bit og fun with the random debate. I will no longer look for fun i...

What about me?? I'm all caught up on the thread and everything!

It seems many are agreeing about Snow Dog and INH which to me either indicates at least one of them clearly did act suspicious and they are bad or they are being used as good distractors by somebody. I haven't been getting a read on either INH or Snow Dog. Is your suspicion of them based solely on ...

Went with mousse , because hopefully if we run out this will give us a refill. And as I stated, I love mousse. Sorry LT, I didn't want to vote for you but staying alive and all that good stuff. And, I didn't get a chance to post about my opinion on d1 voting philosophy, so here goes. I always prefe...

RIP LT

At least we'll have more info for the next lynch. Hopefully we make good use of it.

I have no idea what this poll is supposed to do. I do love mousse, so I hope that doesn't run out, but I may end up choosing it just because it's fun to say. Mousse mousse mousse!

My whole point about the randomizing is that if you randomize, there is nothing to go back to later. If you vote a weak ping, or a bad fakes a weak ping, those are in the thread as evidence later in the game. Randomizing tells everyone nothing, and if you are bad, that is a good thing. So the argum...

My whole point about the randomizing is that if you randomize, there is nothing to go back to later. If you vote a weak ping, or a bad fakes a weak ping, those are in the thread as evidence later in the game. Randomizing tells everyone nothing, and if you are bad, that is a good thing. So the argum...

I was going to agree that not much could be determined from the day 0 poll, however, it appears some people got results from it. :ponder: I did not. Did the people who voted for the tool that won, all get a prize? Good question. Well, Roxy said she was taken off the lynch poll because of the Day 0 ...

Agreed with llama on 2 things, here. 1) BWT won't be getting my lynch vote today because of non-participation, for the reason llama stated. 2) I'm opposed to voting for auger-voters (obviously). Frankly, I just don't see the logic behind that notion. I doubt that the day 0 poll will be much help to ...

Also, I hope someone is watching these dumb videos, I spend more time trying to make the right video choices than i do writing the posts, lol I just got around to watching all the videos, and they (especially the first one) completely made my morning! So what are people's thoughts on who to lynch? ...

Auger!

Wow, such great choices! The auger seemed coolest to me on first glance, but we are on a boat and I love fish...it will come down to one of those two, anyway. Although if even more mousse were an option I'd do that

I must say, this is all terribly exciting to watch. I agree with llama completely here. It also reminds me, as I mentioned I was lost during the game and I still am. Afterward could we maybe have a discussion board where the more experienced players explain some of what happened and what they were ...

Sounds fun! I'll play, though I know little about Macgyver.

Also very glad to hear you're ok Epi, was a little worried about your dad.

I also have no idea if the weapon choices mean anything. Would have gone with halberd for being the most obscure, but If it's worthless within 6 feet then a spear is the next closest thing. I think it's amusing that we have been posting our reasons for picking certain weapons even though we really d...

By the way, wanted to quickly correct a mistake a lot of people discussing this have been making: Skeletor from Snake Mountain hexes people, not a Horde member.

Yeah voting BWT as well for reaso s previously stated (he STILL never told us what area his Stridit info wad for, wtf?). It seems like a moot point now anyway though. To MP and He-Man, as I said to LT, I'm not sure how reserving judgment u til I reread his posts equated to defending him. And as a si...

Whoa, quick on the draw LT! I didn't even have time to finish my reread and post. I said I wasn't sure because I hadn't reread him yet. I said it's weird that so many people are hopping on the anti-BWT train because I counted 8 people attacking him, which is a third of all players. The number who ca...

I;m not sure how to feel about BWT after my reread either. His Day 1 behavior (writing about Boomslang and LT but then voting bf) and his defensive posts today look bad to me. Between Day 1 and today, though it seems like he's tried to be helpful. BWT has also seemed weird about He-Man the entire ga...

So it seems pretty clear to me why Alex has decided to vote DH. Skeletor's hex lasts 2 days, remember? The one thing that confuses me is why Skeletor would be compelling Alex to vote DH 2 days in a row, especially since he's already been lynched (sort of) once. This makes me think Skeletor sees DH a...

Sooo I had a dream last night...has that happened to anyone else?

And by the way, excellent work Man-E-Faces! Brave. Ripiywg llama and vompatti, and good riddance to daisy. Looks like you got lucky, AATB

Just to expand on FH's theory about the food: seems to me like a lot of baddies, if they knew what the foods would do, would choose both spider and panther. Immunity and being able to be silent for a day without raising suspicion sounds like a baddie's dream to me. However, that would be assuming th...

Also, it seems like any vote at this point is a waste, but AATB and indiglo seemed very gung-ho, so why not?

Also as an aside I wanted to point out that in making this table I realized that Russtifinko voted for Wind Raider which I found amusing considering he used my vote for Wind Raider as "evidence" of my potential baddieness. Again, FH, slow your roll. I did not say that the Wind Raider was ...

Being silenced really stunk! Especially because a few people brought up my name as suspicious and even considered voting for me without giving me any chance to defend (I'm looking at you, Russ). I had quite a few thoughts while silenced that I took notes on and once I've had my morning coffee will ...

Wow, this game is crazy! I no longer have any idea ad to what is going on, and I don't even trust my own thoughts and suspicions any more. I think I may have gotten myself in too deep by joining such a complex game as a first-timer. (Can I get a holla, Snow Dog? Indiglo?) So now that timmer may actu...

You guys, what if DH is Moduk and the reason he's being so quiet is because he wants to fly under the radar long enough for him to grow as powerful as possible. Pretty great quote, DH. Ahhh I have no idea what to do, but I have to go to bed! I'm wavering between DH, who I don't want to die if Snake...

Hmmm. Well FH can't defend herself, and BWT seems out of commission as well. I may end up voting for one of them anyway. All this being said, you guys should all vote for DH instead. He's been quiet, joking, unhelpful, everything. :srsnod: I think it's fairly obvious what's going on with MP's suspic...

EBWOP: I can't actually find any post where someone was suspicious of FH. It could be that I'm the only one, and it is a mild suspicion anyway, but I thought I'd mention it.

He-Man, great to hear from you! I don't think anyone is giving timmer "civvie cred" just yet. I think he's getting "probably indie and we're not sure of his alignment" cred, coupled with "there's a reasonable chance we would be wasting our time lynching him again today anywa...

Snow Dog, from what I've gathered a lynch means Roxy's death was related to the vote, although a more experienced player would probably be able to answer more definitively. MP, I know you're busy studying, but could you elaborate on the SUPER SCARY STUFF DH is doing? That's your strongest wording ye...

By the way, welcome to stormcrow! Do you have any thoughts so far?

So does anyone have an idea why it was Roxy who got hit by the attempted lynch on timmer instead of, say, a random civvie? And I know some people have said they want to hear more from Kate today, but she ate spider so that's not happening. While her Roxy connection is interesting, it's not enough fo...

Hmmm, ok. I just noticed Dex voted in the non-player section, so that clears it up. Well the spiders were too gross for me and the horned panthers seem too awesome to eat, so I suppose that makes dinner chimp and snake-thingy . I think your theory on the Stridor info is likely spot-on. I'm all for p...

By the way, sorry for the double post, but I noticed a Dex in the poll. Someone mentioned early on that He-Man goes by Dex in other forums. Did he change his name or something, or is Dex a new player who is filling in for someone else?

I guess I'd better start by addressing the suspicion of me AATB brought up just to be safe, even though it doesn't seem to be shared by many. I can probably best defend myself using your words: Then again, I see no direct actions to back this up, I just find it a bit odd. I have tended to agree with...

Poll closes in 2 hours, and no one seems to be in a position to take over timmer's top spot on my "suspicious characters" list, so I might as well vote now. voting timmer The poll ends in approx 5-1/2hrs at 7:10pm ET. Thanks for the correction, LT. I still don't think anyone will act weir...

Poll closes in 2 hours, and no one seems to be in a position to take over timmer's top spot on my "suspicious characters" list, so I might as well vote now.

voting timmer

Search found 2062 matches