The Syndicate

Elohcin wrote:

Keterman wrote:I see the end of Night 1 post does not state anything about Epignosis' role. I don't like that, and I find it weird that just about everyone posted "RIP Epi" when it was unconfirmed that he was a civilian. Scumslips or carelessness? He did seem to be scumhunting well when he was alive so I can see how something like that could be overlooked, but I still find it strange and bothersome.

Most of the time, I think we assume the nightkilled were civ unless we are sure that there is a civvie night kill in the role descriptions. Do you have any reason to think Epi was not civ?

We don't usually assume that when there are two baddie teams though. But even then I sometimes just say RIP without the qualifier when I personally felt the victim was probably civvie (as in the case of Epi)

Damn it! Alisha and Simon both RIP

....does it occur to anyone that canuck appears to be cursed

Ok, I'm voting for Hedge

Bullzeye wrote:I'm gonna hold onto my vote hoping for more discussion because as of now I have opinions on two people and neither is especially strong.

This tbh.

Uh Roxy this is bothering me so I'm just going to point it out -- you took that first Boogs quote entirely out of context. Did you even read the whole sentence?:

Because if people wanted to bring up that maybe SVS was in cahoots with Sorsha, then wouldn't the same be said for DH voters?

Doesn't look to me like he's saying it's his opinion that SVS was in cahoots with Sorsha, rather that he was commenting on other people possibly thinking that. I could be interpreting this wrong of course so I will let Boogs clear up his meaning.
And I don't really understand what you're trying to say about him anyway. His posts that you quoted all look really consistent. They all say in some form or another that he had a feeling Sorsha was civ. I don't see much contradiction at all, except when he said Sorsha's self vote was odd.

I'm curious to hear more from Hedge and SVS today. I thought DH's point about Hedge saying the kill was a "strange choice" was worth noting, but I could see her posting that as innocent speculation as well. Also, I do remember something about her "top posters theory" from the Occult game. So I'd like to hear more from her on that. I'm feeling better about SVS since her latest post but I will still pay some attention to her.

RIP Epig

No idea what the note means :S

I really don't know. I'm terrible at reading her. I'm definitely going to be keeping an eye on her.

Well shit, RIP Sorsha.

The only thing Sorsha's self-vote tells me is that she's not really invested in this game and is too busy to care. Doesn't make me think strongly one way or the other about her alignment. SVS is acting a lot more subtly evasive though, and though she can be tough to read I have a funny feeling about her -- also, if she flips bad I would be more inclined to look at Sorsha as a possible teammate of hers. *Votes SVS* before I forget.

I'm fairly certain Dana and Made are both familiar with the party game version of mafia but completely new to forum-based mafia. Just to clear that up.

I don't know that there was much to make out of SVS and Sorsha, but with it being day 1 there isn't anything else so far, so it's a place to start. Gauging reactions and such. But idk what to think.

...bro, kinda the whole point of the game is to convince people you're on the good side whether you are or not

Enrique you're not playing go home

I've actually only seen through the third season. It kind of goes downhill by then and most of the original cast is gone by S4, and from what I hear it's really not very good from then on. S2 was my favorite (and it was better with Nathan too).


I'm gonna go ahead and vote for Canuck <3

SVS, I'm guessing Made's impression that I know what's going on could be explained by the fact that I introduced him to this site/forum mafia and so he's aware that I'm an experienced player. (Also I'm one of the few players who has watched Misfits, but that's probably not too important but you all should watch it, it's excellent fun)

Canuck, I brought your name up and am seriously considering voting for you because you are teh awesome

SVS, what do you find lynch-vote-able about my post(s)? Not that I know where some of this support for me is coming from either, but I am flattered

Btw, I wasn't expressing suspicion of Sorsha really, I was just pointing out that she has been successful as a baddie in past games... so her claim to being trustworthy was actually pretty sketchy.

Sorsha wrote: I think I am easy enough for most people to read, if I did happen to be bad (which I'm not), you'd all be able to tell in a day or two and could lynch me. I think I'm a good choice.

Really? I thought I'd seen you make it to the end as a sneaky baddie quite a few times...

I would more likely trust DH than SVS I think Canuck though, I'd put my money on her.

Those who have voted, is this a changeable vote?

yey game! huh, pick a leader, that's an interesting day 0 poll.