The Syndicate

Golden wrote:Here are some sweet G-Banners

I don't think I've ever seen a bad G-Man, actually.

Dom wrote:
Golden wrote:
Quin wrote:I could have put more effort into this game, I admit. Sorry for that Golden - I'd just hit sort of a mafia slump of sorts.
Everyone agreed to vomp it lol. That's going to lead to town losses.

Everyone needs games where they don't play as hard though. I tend to get lynched when I have mine.

Also, another note. Dom had no warning that I was going to do what I did with DF. It was only briefly and was just fun on my part. So good on him for running with it.

I was thinking that what people were clearing you for was weird, because it was the exact same thing as what I said about DF: 'the game's over, so why would he still be making accusations if he was town?'

Still an impressive game on your part. It was only when I subbed out that I started suspecting you (and that's likely pretty biased...)

Golden wrote:
Quin wrote:I could have put more effort into this game, I admit. Sorry for that Golden - I'd just hit sort of a mafia slump of sorts.
Everyone agreed to vomp it lol. That's going to lead to town losses.

Everyone needs games where they don't play as hard though. I tend to get lynched when I have mine.

Also, another note. Dom had no warning that I was going to do what I did with DF. It was only briefly and was just fun on my part. So good on him for running with it.

I'm sure it isn't fun having lots of people approach your game that way, so I'm sorry for the subpar performance. Although, I did make the decision to play a more gut-based game after a little bit and it did pretty well in catching DF.

Golden wrote:
speedchuck wrote:
Quin wrote:
speedchuck wrote:I do want to know who was revealed accidentally and who would have died D1 if Llama hadn't messed up the tie.
Golden lied with that one. He actually revealed Dom and SVS as DF's teammates in the role reveal, so he had to sub me out to cover it up.
I mean... that is an accidental reveal.
Yes... it just wasn't the 'wrong role'. It was the entire mafia team.

Also, Quin is fast. I edited it as soon as I posted it, quite literally.

I was refreshing like crazy

I'm surprised that Dom wasn't lynched today after his vote at EoD. Maybe I'm speaking with a bias, but that vote looked really bad for him.

Congrats to the baddies, you did well to win.

I could have put more effort into this game, I admit. Sorry for that Golden - I'd just hit sort of a mafia slump of sorts.

speedchuck wrote:I do want to know who was revealed accidentally and who would have died D1 if Llama hadn't messed up the tie.

Golden lied with that one. He actually revealed Dom and SVS as DF's teammates in the role reveal, so he had to sub me out to cover it up.

bzzzzzzzzzzt

intense

Epignosis wrote:
speedchuck wrote:I don't drink coffee.
Then shame on you.

speedchuck wrote:I can see why you are top FEB, Epi

You play a bad guy like I do.
*scans for your name in the hall of fame*

Uh...

No I don't. I'm good at it.

yeah but where's your socky?

noice

Finally, I've made it off the island!

Tell that to my replacement.

whistles

No I don't.

DFaraday wrote:Baddies are Quin, SVS, and either Chuck or Dom. *is strangled*

If you're town then the game is over so there was no need to say this. Eagerly awaiting a baddie flip.

i feel bad things right now

MAYDAY

Epignosis wrote:Well, right not DF is getting the lynch (or maybe not).

Might as well not even vote.

I do think DF is a sure thing, and I'd rather guarantee a Day 5 than take a risk and mislynch now.

G-Man, you're dying tonight. Try your best to get everything you can possibly think of into the thread, and we'll get you that win.

Epignosis wrote:Let's assume this: G-Man, Quin, Epignosis, and S~V~S are good. That's a nice crew that leaves Dom, Sorsha, and speedchuck.

Two out of three ain't bad.

But two are.

C I V I L I A N C O R E

S~V~S wrote:It's based on phoning it in mainly. Also Dom backed off of me too easily when he poked me and I poked back re my misinformed suspish of G Man. I don't expect either of them to totally phone it in.

Also Sorsha seeming to think I was defending her when I was actually questioning why she had votes at all was a bit odd.

Linki, good point.

Why is this indicative of a bad Sorsha?

Epignosis wrote:
Quin wrote:Can you explain them then? I think that Dom would come out looking good from a DF baddie flip.
If DF can survive a lynch, nobody looks good regardless of him being bad.

Fair cop. His early picking at DF at least looked genuine, though. The only person to point at him before then was sawyer, who was one of the most suspected at the time.

Can you explain them then? I think that Dom would come out looking good from a DF baddie flip.

S~V~S wrote:Probably Sorsha or Dom. I still doubt Speed is bad. He acts too bad, if you know what I mean. He doesnt care how he looks.

Have you talked about the first two before? I need to read.

SVS, who is on your shortlist for a vote assuming DF flips bad? Why?

i post good

For reasons I said in a post on this page.

Epignosis wrote:I would like everyone to pretend DF is gone. It's Day 4. Who gets your vote and why?

speedchuck.

I'm leaning town on both Epi and Dom. I don't think Dom and DF are teammates (famous last words), and I'm pretty much just letting intuition guide my read on Epi.

G-Man wrote:Following me isn't the goal. Keeping our options open is. Tell me what you guys think about speedchuck.

G-Man wrote:Five Reasons Speedchuck Might Be Mafia:
1) He spent most of Day 1 posting but adding nothing of substance.

2) He mentions he'd almost rather force a tie than lynch either notsawyer or nutella on Day 2. Perhaps he knew and this was him playing 'uncertain civvie' as little too loosely?

3) The top half of his colorless rainbow was pretty spot-on.

4) He's tightened up his game the longer the game has progressed.

5) There's a lot of posts expressing his thoughts on the thoughts and theories of others but I feel like there's not enough expressing his own thoughts.

Five Reasons Speedchuck Might Be Civvie:
1) He's newer here and still trying to get used to all of our varying personalities.

2) I feel inclined to give a new guy the benefit of the doubt. Sometimes to a fault though.

3) He had a good, pointed question to S~V~S regarding her "second silly vote looks worse than the third" bit.

4) He's tightened up his game the longer the game has progressed.

5) n/a

#3- My initial coward threat and the first time I called Golden a coward.

On the wind that lifts her perfume through the air...

I've had pangs of suspicion. He was quick to accept me as town even when it'd been made clear that in a balanced setup either DF or I must be bad. I get that he town read me anyway, but at Lylo I'd have expected it to be debated more. He was also the third to jump on my Sorsha vote.

Fun fact - he claims he was town-reading me, but tried to lynch me when he realised I was still alive. What's up with that... chucky boy?

I'm hesitant to assume that DF is unlynchable because that would be a parallel to G-Man's role. INH's and G-Man's roles already go hand in hand in that respect, although INH was lacking a power.

Epignosis wrote:
Quin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Quin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:If DF is a traditional Mafia godfather, and he gets the most votes, the game is over, and the civilians don't win.
What's your definition of a traditional mafia godfather?
Perhaps "traditional" is a poor word choice. I simply mean if DF cannot be lynched until his goons are taken out first, trying to lynch him today gets the mafia the win.
If I recall, (I might be mistaking him for Rico or llama) Golden criticised my having a role of that sort in my burglary. I don't think that would be the case here based on that.
The fact remains that DF received the most votes and there was no lynch. How do you account for that?

That specific role is one option. It's also possible that DF just has the counter to my role.

Epignosis wrote:
Quin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:If DF is a traditional Mafia godfather, and he gets the most votes, the game is over, and the civilians don't win.
What's your definition of a traditional mafia godfather?
Perhaps "traditional" is a poor word choice. I simply mean if DF cannot be lynched until his goons are taken out first, trying to lynch him today gets the mafia the win.

If I recall, (I might be mistaking him for Rico or llama) Golden criticised my having a role of that sort in my burglary. I don't think that would be the case here based on that.

Epignosis wrote:If DF is a traditional Mafia godfather, and he gets the most votes, the game is over, and the civilians don't win.

What's your definition of a traditional mafia godfather?

Dom wrote:i don't get what is going on with quin at all

neither do i, sometimes.

I don't believe that a completely vanilla baddie team is balanced against three roles which can survive attempts on their life AND can kill. One of us is bad. G-Man is confirmed (and untouchable, anyway) which leaves me and DF.

So, go nuts.

G-Man wrote:
Quin wrote:Tell me why killing Spacedaisy is helpful.
Felt worse about her than Epi and speedchuck. I'm still mulling you all everybody over in my head. This is LYLO after all.

Something that I hope is a point in my favour -

Take a look at Zodiac, Mad Max, Monkey Island and GoC. All of which are my baddie (and indy variant) games here, and in all of them I gave a shit. That's not to say I don't give one as a civ, but still

Here, I faked being dead for an entire day phase for fun. pls.

Tell me why killing Spacedaisy is helpful.

I agree.

DFaraday wrote:
Quin wrote:
DFaraday wrote:
Quin wrote:
DFaraday wrote:
Quin wrote:Given G-Man and I have a power role of some sort each, DF's survival has a connection to the mafia.
No it doesn't. Besides, how do we know you're civ?
My role card says so.
That same post also said you're dead, and yet here you are.
Surely this answers to that query:

Quin wrote:
G-Man wrote:
Quin wrote:According to Lostpedia they had one 'centric' episode, but like 7 overall.

I don't know if you're trying to guess or if I should just tell you
From your description of one centric episode and seven total, coupled with this being Season 3, I'd venture to guess that you are Nikki and/or Paulo. I'd have to check but that sounds about right, as Rose and Bernard had their centric episode in Season 2.

If Nikki, your catch phrase is: "Razzle dazzle!"

If Paulo, you just stand there looking like a lost but devoted puppy dog until your better half shows her true colors and chucks a paralyzing spider on you out of greed.

Either way, you got the short end of the stick this game, unless you've got crazy awesome powrs.

"Acting like you're stupid people..."
Razzle dazzle!
So you're saying that you're Nikki AND Paulo? And that you had a kill even though your role card said you're a vanilla civ? At the very least, the role card was leaving out an incredible amount of information about you; at worst, it was actively misleading. I don't see why I should believe anything about your role card, or that you're civ.

Short answer: That's not my full role card. It's half.

DFaraday wrote:
Quin wrote:
DFaraday wrote:
Quin wrote:Given G-Man and I have a power role of some sort each, DF's survival has a connection to the mafia.
No it doesn't. Besides, how do we know you're civ?
My role card says so.
That same post also said you're dead, and yet here you are.

Surely this answers to that query:

Quin wrote:
G-Man wrote:
Quin wrote:According to Lostpedia they had one 'centric' episode, but like 7 overall.

I don't know if you're trying to guess or if I should just tell you
From your description of one centric episode and seven total, coupled with this being Season 3, I'd venture to guess that you are Nikki and/or Paulo. I'd have to check but that sounds about right, as Rose and Bernard had their centric episode in Season 2.

If Nikki, your catch phrase is: "Razzle dazzle!"

If Paulo, you just stand there looking like a lost but devoted puppy dog until your better half shows her true colors and chucks a paralyzing spider on you out of greed.

Either way, you got the short end of the stick this game, unless you've got crazy awesome powrs.

"Acting like you're stupid people..."
Razzle dazzle!

DFaraday wrote:
Quin wrote:Given G-Man and I have a power role of some sort each, DF's survival has a connection to the mafia.
No it doesn't. Besides, how do we know you're civ?

My role card says so.

A+ role description. Voted DFaraday.

G-Man wrote:For what reason? Couldn't the baddies all be vanilla? They were in my games. Honestly, I thought Widmore would have counted as a non-vanilla role but I can't recall what the final determination on wincons was when it was hashed out. INH didn't have an active power but he also wasn't a regular civvie. Curiouser and curiouser. I hesitate to trust anyone rushing to judgement at this point.

I don't consider INH to have had a power role. I also think the balance would be way off if civilians had a unkillable confirmed townie, a bulletproof vig, and a lynch-proof role and mafia had nothing but vanillas.

Given G-Man and I have a power role of some sort each, DF's survival has a connection to the mafia.

I goofed.

I shot nutella. Sorry if I goofed.

DFaraday wrote:If someone could outline the case on me, that'd be great.

I think you were buddying my sawyer case yesterday.

nutella wrote:
G-Man wrote:
speedchuck wrote:
nutella wrote:I could probably just as well vote for speed since he has the same problems as llama. And his only attempt at hinting has been multiple references to the smoke monster. Not sure what's going on there.
Me neither. Should I claim my character?

Sorsha wrote:
speedchuck wrote:
Sorsha wrote:Put my vote on llama for now. I'll change it later if saving myself is a possibility.
Where would you change it to?
Wherever I'd be able to tie or put someone else in the lead
Ah, so you'd change your vote to save yourself.

Okay then.
From your comment about spitting up sand, my thoughts are you could be Paulo or Vincent. I don't recall anyone else being around sand to the point it was in their mouth.

You all... You all- You all, everybody...
Lol, nice.

If he's Paulo and Quin is Nikki it feels somehow fitting that both of those characters were given to players who haven't watched the show Filthy redshirts

if speedchuck hinted at being Paulo, that's a problem. I know he outright claimed Sun, but that was after I claimed both losers. I'm not familiar enough with the show to make proper sense of it.

Search found 116 matches