Other people pointed out later that it wasn't. Someone moved a vote iirc after she voted.Quin wrote:If this is true then this looks bad for Eloh. A BWT wagon would be a lot less likely to take off than a Mac wagon since only one of them was actually around. It doesn't make sense for a self-preservation vote.S~V~S wrote:But MacDougall had more votes than BWT when Eloh voted, yes?Sloonei wrote:birdwithteeth has not posted in this game yet. That is the entirety of the case against him. Scotty always votes a no-show or low poster on Day 1. Elohcin voted purely out of self-preservation.
I only skimmed this AM, I will read back to when I told Rico I was going to step back when I get home in about 1.5 hours.
Search found 41 matches
Return to “MAD MAX: GAME OVER”
- Fri Oct 21, 2016 6:20 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
- Thu Oct 20, 2016 9:33 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Night 2
Well if you're gonna lynch a civvie that's a good one to lynch. Sorry Rico, glad your secrets dies with you 

- Thu Oct 20, 2016 9:28 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
I am flipping between this and the Al Smith dinner.
- Thu Oct 20, 2016 9:06 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
I tend/try to blow off emotional content. I found that based on the person making it, it either makes me trust them OR (and this is more likely) makes me think they are being manipulative. So it was not my intent to dismiss your opening up. It is just how I tend to read things.MovingPictures07 wrote:That's all well and good, but it just appeared to me like you didn't even read what I said, especially given I sort of emotionally opened myself up there, so it bugged me a bit. Sorry.S~V~S wrote:A tie is a no lynch, right? So we are one vote from that now.
Linki @MP, with all due respect, my opinion is still my opinion. You knowing him better does not make it invalid.
- Thu Oct 20, 2016 9:01 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
A tie is a no lynch, right? So we are one vote from that now.
Linki @MP, with all due respect, my opinion is still my opinion. You knowing him better does not make it invalid.
Linki @MP, with all due respect, my opinion is still my opinion. You knowing him better does not make it invalid.
- Thu Oct 20, 2016 8:55 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
When I asked HER who she thought might kill Epi night one, Jay answered me this:a2thezebra wrote:I brought this up earlier. JJJ and MP were the ones to point out that she would benefit from Epi being dead Night 1, and I think that's worth noting.S~V~S wrote:My only worry re Eloh is that it would be easy to set her up as a fall guy with an Epi NK. Super easy.
So yeah.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:He reads Elohcin herself particularly well, or so the reputation goes. He had her on his hypothetical baddie team.
I think my opinions all around will fallout more on when I finish reading (and tomorrow at work I will have time as my boss is going to a conference in Vegas) AND on how todays lynch falls out. I think his discussion to/about her may have been Epi trying to feel her out.
Linki, Alex you are not Rico. I am almost NEVER rational, lol. I am comparing Rico to Rico.
- Thu Oct 20, 2016 8:46 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
I see Sloonei voted Eloh day one. He goes on my reading list with Epi.
Linki, I did not play that. And the totality of my experience negates one game where he was aberrant to my mind. Did he win that?
Linki, I did not play that. And the totality of my experience negates one game where he was aberrant to my mind. Did he win that?
- Thu Oct 20, 2016 8:43 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
My only worry re Eloh is that it would be easy to set her up as a fall guy with an Epi NK. Super easy.
- Thu Oct 20, 2016 8:41 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
insertnamehere wrote:People think I'm parroting others opinions and avoiding having actual thoughts on the game.S~V~S wrote:And looking at the poll, why is INH taking all of those votes? Can I get a Cliffs notes?
Here's an actual thought and opinion: Those people are dum dums.
Thank you & Thank you.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:I'll try to summarize for Sloonei while he isn't here (I might not have a full grasp).S~V~S wrote:And looking at the poll, why is INH taking all of those votes? Can I get a Cliffs notes?
He felt INH was being disingenuous in his treatment of Ricochet and his interactions with motel room and Sloonei himself. LoRab seemed to agree, I don't quite remember exactly her reasoning though. Rico's vote is self-pres.
Since based on Day 1 (i am not caught up enough to go any farther) I would be putting Sloonei in the orange if I were a rainbow lister, which I emphatically am NOT. So I won't be replacing my feelings about INH with Slooneis.
I am OK leaving my vote where it is. I feel bad about both Rico & Eloh tbh.
But you can reconcile that irrational mindset he clung to on day one with civ Rico, who is not irrational, like, at all?MovingPictures07 wrote:INH and zebra (and Mac for that matter as well), thanks for trying to elaborate further on your views regarding Rico and others, even though I know you've spoken on this stuff to some degree earlier too. It's helpful that you all seem committed to hunting and engaging with me and others on your perceptions of the thread. I think we have some really good baddie hunting going around this thread, even if there's a lot of disagreement going around. There's a lot to be proud of with respect to effort too.
Yeah, same here. I guess I can see that perspective, but I don't even remotely agree with it, and I think Rico's done plenty that is easily compatible with a town-minded outlook, even if initially a very salty one.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:I feel like we're reading different threads.insertnamehere wrote:It feels like he decided to back away from his initial "FUCK MAC" stance only after others called him out on it.
- Thu Oct 20, 2016 8:26 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
And looking at the poll, why is INH taking all of those votes? Can I get a Cliffs notes?
- Thu Oct 20, 2016 8:25 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
Me for one. I got wrapped up in politics last night, and just got home from work, so I did not have the chance to read back on Epi as I would have liked.MovingPictures07 wrote:Who hasn't voted, anyone know?
For now I am going to dropmy vote on Eloh and try to read back for at least a bit. So it might change. But at this point I could not find where she addressed this:
I am still up in the air about Rico & Sloonei.S~V~S wrote:That is possible, but if they had killed him, he would be gone & Mac would be sitting on those votes. PLUS THE LULZ. That is just as valid a reason for NKing someone as irrational paranoia is for wanting to lynch them
I am not sure if I am tunnelling though, so I plan to go over Epis post with a fine tooth to see what got him killed. Does he read anyone particularly well? Eloh, who do you think may have wanted to kill Epi on Day One?
But seriously when you're evil killing for the lulz is the best. Unless your name is Metalmarsh & you're killing me mid afternoon. Then not so much
Linki @INH,I kinda feel like that too. The people who I would expect to see the same things I see re Rico aren't seeing those things, so i am not sure if it is becasue I am out of practice, or becasue they are protecting him. So that could be why I am shying away from Rico vote. The people actively protecting him hard are making me second guess my gut.
- Wed Oct 19, 2016 7:29 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
That is possible, but if they had killed him, he would be gone & Mac would be sitting on those votes. PLUS THE LULZ. That is just as valid a reason for NKing someone as irrational paranoia is for wanting to lynch them 
I am not sure if I am tunnelling though, so I plan to go over Epis post with a fine tooth to see what got him killed. Does he read anyone particularly well? Eloh, who do you think may have wanted to kill Epi on Day One?
But seriously when you're evil killing for the lulz is the best. Unless your name is Metalmarsh & you're killing me mid afternoon. Then not so much

I am not sure if I am tunnelling though, so I plan to go over Epis post with a fine tooth to see what got him killed. Does he read anyone particularly well? Eloh, who do you think may have wanted to kill Epi on Day One?
But seriously when you're evil killing for the lulz is the best. Unless your name is Metalmarsh & you're killing me mid afternoon. Then not so much

- Wed Oct 19, 2016 6:13 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Spoiler: show
I know what he said. My point was that he implied that he thinks Mac is killing.
- Wed Oct 19, 2016 6:12 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
P.s. Rico~ I think ANY baddie team EXCEPT one that included you or Mac would have killed you for the lulz as well as the chance to frame Mac. To me the NK of someone other than you implies a team with either you or Mac on it.
- Wed Oct 19, 2016 6:06 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 2
So you DO think he's bad? Since you think he's killing people.Ricochet wrote:Did I say I am?
You've got nothing to fret about anymore, you can kill whomever you like now, nobody gives a damn.
What a hollow finger-waggy statement to make, right after the very post in which I clearly stated I would focus on proper leads.
Epi was an odd choice for an NK with the end of the lynch going down as it did. Time to reread him.
- Tue Oct 18, 2016 6:47 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Night 1
Glad to hear that my break hasn't made me lose my edge. I would be worried if you did not think me utterly bizarrea2thezebra wrote:That's utterly bizarre to me, if Scotty flipped bad I wouldn't be nearly as suspicious of Epi if he had changed his vote last-minute.S~V~S wrote:I would be with you on this if Scotty flipped bad. I sat and kept refreshing waiting for the hammer to drop & lynch someone else after Epi switched his vote. But Scotty wasn't bad. And even with Epi switching his vote at the last minute, we're all smart folk, and would remember that Epi pushed the Scotty suspish fairly strongly. Scotty flipping civ made me feel better about Epi, not worse.a2thezebra wrote:The answer is literally one post above the one you're quoting. You won't have to dig too deep.Epignosis wrote:Why?a2thezebra wrote:I thought I would have more to offer but most of that territory that I caught up with is well-covered. The only update for me as far as reads go (besides Scotty of course) is Epignosis. I don't read him as a baddie yet but removing his vote from Scotty near the end bumped him down from my civ reads.

- Tue Oct 18, 2016 6:17 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Night 1
I would be with you on this if Scotty flipped bad. I sat and kept refreshing waiting for the hammer to drop & lynch someone else after Epi switched his vote. But Scotty wasn't bad. And even with Epi switching his vote at the last minute, we're all smart folk, and would remember that Epi pushed the Scotty suspish fairly strongly. Scotty flipping civ made me feel better about Epi, not worse.a2thezebra wrote:The answer is literally one post above the one you're quoting. You won't have to dig too deep.Epignosis wrote:Why?a2thezebra wrote:I thought I would have more to offer but most of that territory that I caught up with is well-covered. The only update for me as far as reads go (besides Scotty of course) is Epignosis. I don't read him as a baddie yet but removing his vote from Scotty near the end bumped him down from my civ reads.
- Tue Oct 18, 2016 7:25 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Night 1
This is what the light background looks like. When you quote the yellow against the beige, especially, it is almost impossible to see especially on phone or tablet. You have to quote it to see it since highlighting is harder on phone.
The darker brights are good, the lighter ones not so much.


The darker brights are good, the lighter ones not so much.


- Tue Oct 18, 2016 6:12 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Night 1
Just an FYI anyone using light background can't read that yellow. And I use light background cause its work safe.
RIP Scotty.
RIP Scotty.
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 8:59 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
You were on Scotty, right?
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 8:56 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
Facts have a time requirement?motel room wrote:This is so early for Facts.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Expanding on this parallel:JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Actually now that I think of it, this incident is rather similar to what happened in Red vs. Blue -- Scotty made a misstep on Day 1 by providing an inconsistent read relative to Epignosis (either his own votes or someone's votes for him, I can't recall exactly), and Epignosis (his partner) helped lynch him for it. I'm not saying this is necessarily a bus job, but rather that there's a recent precedent for a baddie Scotty to do something like this.
The following post is from Red vs. Blue, not Mad Max:
Scotty goofed in that game by putting two reads together that weren't very compatible (he liked Metalmarsh, but not the votes on Epignosis, one of which was Metalmarsh). In this game he seems to have done something similar: he doesn't like Elohcin or Rico as much, but thinks Epignosis is steering the thread the wrong direction for suspecting the same two people. Incompatible.Spoiler: show
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 6:46 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
Also Scotty, that, what JimmyNeil said.
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 6:43 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
So the only person you suspect is Mac? And you have said you don't actually suspect him, iirc.Ricochet wrote:Myes, if only the implication of his actions wouldn't extend beyond one game.Epignosis wrote:I just want to say that voting for MacDougall for whatever he did in a completely different game is lousy.
You put the blame on me for not writing something substantial in a post that started with "dunno" to your earlier inquiry on whether I have leads.S~V~S wrote:
Generically. You answered and at length, but you really did not say anything. You feel better about one person who had a discussion than the other, but you are not saying you suspect her, either. You have the third most posts in the thread, but are claiming "too busy" and seem to have plenty of defense time.
If you did not have to vote to defend, who would you vote for?![]()
The posting has all to do with having to expand on my policy. I posted exactly as many times as said work and other online activities have permitted.
I am not voting to defend, my vote was among the first in the phase. I am perfectly fine with my vote.
I am going to vote for you now; a friend is coming over to watch Westworld. I will pop back before deadline to see if there were any new developments.
Voting *RICO*
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 6:28 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
Generically. You answered and at length, but you really did not say anything. You feel better about one person who had a discussion than the other, but you are not saying you suspect her, either. You have the third most posts in the thread, but are claiming "too busy" and seem to have plenty of defense time.Ricochet wrote:How so and for what?S~V~S wrote:You know what? You sound just like bad me here. Identical. Had to look out the window to make sure I am not in Nauru.Ricochet wrote:sup
Dunno. From my experience, mafia can punch a free lunch ticket on cray Rico; not all of them, but some could. Of my current voters, I feel better about the logic brought by INH in his questioning than with zebra's. Of the other players I'm tied (or nearly tied) with right now, not named MacDougall, I've been swamped with classes today and another online activity to follow up properly. BWT is having half a policy lynch of his own, right? Not going to flip a coin on what the inactive might prove, tbh. What's the summary on Elohcin and Scotty?S~V~S wrote:Not even a ping?
If you did not have to vote to defend, who would you vote for?
Linki, yeah agreed re both points, w/Mac & BWT. For me it is between Rico for being irrational (IMO, against norm) or Scotty for fancy straw grasping.
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 6:18 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
You know what? You sound just like bad me here. Identical. Had to look out the window to make sure I am not in Nauru.Ricochet wrote:sup
Dunno. From my experience, mafia can punch a free lunch ticket on cray Rico; not all of them, but some could. Of my current voters, I feel better about the logic brought by INH in his questioning than with zebra's. Of the other players I'm tied (or nearly tied) with right now, not named MacDougall, I've been swamped with classes today and another online activity to follow up properly. BWT is having half a policy lynch of his own, right? Not going to flip a coin on what the inactive might prove, tbh. What's the summary on Elohcin and Scotty?S~V~S wrote:Not even a ping?
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 6:11 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
As someone who everyone always thinks is Mafia when I am not, I hate it. Plus "virtually" townesque? Doesn't virtually mean "almost"?MovingPictures07 wrote:GTH reaction: What do people think of this bolded/underlined set of statements?Ricochet wrote:No, I don't. That's not the point of a policy lynch. That's not the point of my policy lynch. That's not the point of self-preservation.S~V~S wrote:Do you have any reason to actually think he is bad?Ricochet wrote:Don't get what's confusing about that, S~V~S. Self-preservation goal implies to prevent something for your own good. What better way to counter the odds of Mac being bad and getting even to Night 1 and try to make his team eliminate me, because I'm one of the players he doesn't like playing against?
And that Day Zero comment of mine was by far the jokey one, due to context of G-Man calling out to those who haven't even read their PMs. I would have started Day One the same way, regardless of any Day Zero chatter or banter.
Both you & Mac posted after me, yet neither of you addressed the "throwing each other under a bus" aspect of my post, which tbh is the thing I most expected a reaction to. The main thing that is making me think I could be seriously wrong is that everyone else is sitting back and letting me run with this wacky theory.
What do you think of MP?
Linki, I am a very nice lady
I don't know what to say about your bussing theory. It's certainly the third perspective that can be developed. It's the third perspective that can be developed about any hissing between players. The questions here would be: Do you think I'd do something as aggressive as this on Day One (or even Zero, if you will)? Do you think I'd gain something / expect to attain a goal by doing something as aggressive as this? Do you think I'd choose a policy lynch to craft a bus? Bussing usually require more skill, time and finesse than any of this, I'd argue.
Besides, my distress is virtually townesque. I don't know what Mac is. I don't know if he's mafia. I fear he could be. And I'd like to prevent the chance of him being mafia and getting to pull again his own declared policy of nightkilling me.
Thank You. The trouble with changeable votes (although I still love them for the most part). It was important to me becasue if she was voting to save herself, why not vote for the person with the most votes? But apparently at the time she did vote, she did do that. The votes in the poll did not reflect that at the time I looked at it.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:S~V~S: if I recall correctly, when Elohcin placed her vote for BWT, BWT had 2 votes and Mac had 2 votes. So she essentially broke that tie which also included herself. I'm not sure I feel this is an indictment against her or a positive for her, but it's a detail that seems important to you. I don't think Mac had more votes than BWT.
If anyone remembers differently by all means speak up.
And @Epi, OK, I kept reading and now see that you DID put money where mouth is.
Right now I am vacillating between Rico & Scotty. I have to reread Scotty again.
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 5:57 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
This is where I am in my catch up, breaking it up into a few posts. I have a lot of heebie jeebies from certain people, but nothing I can quantify, so not saying until I do have something to quantify. It's day one. Heebies to the left ofme, jeebies to the right of me.
Also this:
Do you know his role, Glorfindel?
Linki @Neil, thank you, I will say Sloonei was one of my heebie jeebies, but so far I feel OK about you, and trust your judgment on Sloonei. But I still want to keep an eye on him.
Linki @Epi, you KNOW I hate vagueness & innuendo in Mafia. Just come out & say it if you have a reason to suspect him, or why bother? xoxoxox
This sounds like normal Eloh to me. Default for Eloh "normal" being civ. If you still feel otherwise Epi, I would like to know why.Elohcin wrote:Then I'm even more confused. Posting on my phone and have no clue how to so multiple quotesMovingPictures07 wrote:The "trying too hard" argument bothers me, but I'm not sure I find you suspicious for it. I just don't agree. Also, Neil Hartley has nothing to do with Mad Max.Elohcin wrote:I know nothing of this show, so JJJ is confusing me a bit. I may vote him. It seems a little 'trying too hard' to come in here role play like that right off the bat. Like he is trying to win us over. What do y'all think? And this is not WIFOM talking...whatever that is. I never understood that term completely. but you all seem to use it for when you go after someone who has gone after you? I don't know.
I'll hold off on voting for now.
..so posting this now and will most likely post again.
Also this:
This doesn't fee like bad Eloh to me. BUT BUT her vote... She voted BWT to self preserve but someone else already had more votes.Elohcin wrote:
Why is agreeing/disagreeing with you an indicator of alignment? I thought the same thing Zeebs did before I read Glorfindels post about his Mom. But if all the civvies agreed, there would be no point in playing this game. Why do you think someone is bad for not agreeing with you?Sloonei wrote:I have not seen a committed and engaged MP in a long long time, so I don't know quite how to read him at this time, but a few of his posts did have me scratching my chin a little.
This one, for instance:Polar opposite response to mine. I see no reason why zebra throwing minimal-effort poo at Scotty on Day is a town-tell.MovingPictures07 wrote:Oh, and I'm tentatively feeling good about zebra as well. Her willingness to throw a vote on Scotty for a perceivedmoment seemed natural and not forced.
Not feeling those bad vibes from anyone just yet, but I'm sure they will come.
We're all good players. Lynching someone for being a good player is fairly crappy. So far he has not pinged me whatsoever. Although I don't think he is someone I read well if at all. If someone who DOES read him well gives me reason, I will take that more seriously.Glorfindel wrote:Thank you to everyone who wished my Mum a speedy recovery - we think she's on her way to one so for now, I'm good to go with this game. I sincerely appreciate the support you gave me
Jay, I'm looking at it this way; a random lynching of any player has (by my calculations) a 21% chance of success. It is Day 1 and we have nothing concrete so far to suggest that anyone is necessarily more suspect than anyone else (in my opinion at least) - a fact borne out by the badly fragmented voting sheet we have right now. Mac is a very good player and we witnessed the damage of which he was capable as Mafia last game. I voted for him the Day phase before he NK'd me then and I'm voting for him again now. Certainly, I'm happy to (and will certainly continue to) consider other options before the end of this Day phase but for now, I'm satisfied to leave my vote where it is.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Glorfindel, how do you feel about MacDougall now that he has provided a number of posts?
Do you know his role, Glorfindel?
Not even a ping?Ricochet wrote:But it's how I feel. Paranoia isn't exactly a logical act.a2thezebra wrote:Or more specifically, your willingness to acknowledge that that is indeed your fringe opinion and still act like it's in any way logical.
@SVS: Can't say that I do atm. Who should I look into?
Linki @Neil, thank you, I will say Sloonei was one of my heebie jeebies, but so far I feel OK about you, and trust your judgment on Sloonei. But I still want to keep an eye on him.
Linki @Epi, you KNOW I hate vagueness & innuendo in Mafia. Just come out & say it if you have a reason to suspect him, or why bother? xoxoxox
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 5:32 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
There is a possibility anyone is bad.Epignosis wrote:There's a possibility Scotty is bad.
MacDougall, based on this:
I am thinking YOU think Rico is bad? Am I correct there?MacDougall wrote:Any kind of human interaction comforts me.Sloonei wrote:Would it confort you to know I have no idea what you're talking about?MacDougall wrote:He pinged me. I called him bad. He ignored it.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:WhyMacDougall wrote:I already said Sloonei was bad.
Insertnamehere is bad. Well played Ricochet.
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 3:35 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
@ JimmyNeil~ I know you read Sloonei well. What is your opinion of him so far this game?
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 3:34 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
But MacDougall had more votes than BWT when Eloh voted, yes?Sloonei wrote:birdwithteeth has not posted in this game yet. That is the entirety of the case against him. Scotty always votes a no-show or low poster on Day 1. Elohcin voted purely out of self-preservation.
I only skimmed this AM, I will read back to when I told Rico I was going to step back when I get home in about 1.5 hours.
- Mon Oct 17, 2016 7:28 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
The reason I am resistant to this idea from you is that it is irrational. I would not blink an eye to see other people behave irrationallyRicochet wrote:So I can't have my policy lynch for once, got it.Glad it's been a non-issue in the past when players pull it for truly shallow/salty reasons, but when I do it out of principle and self-prez, stop the presses.
Damn if I play serious and, as far as recent stats have shown, get remove before seeing another daylight, damn if I don't.![]()
I agree with Epig and INH thoughts that this matter is also Catch22ish, since it's something the mafia could weave, but hopefully the mafia will seek its own agenda after how D1 events shape up, in case Mac's not a part of it, or even if he is, they might choose not to follow his disdain-filled agenda. So projecting how the Mafia will behave is as loose as ever, at this point.
Yes, there's no high degree of helpfulness to this method. It's a declared policy lynch, which is never as substantiated as squuezing neurons to read into a player for mafia tells. And it's personal, which I also never denied.
One thing I can disagree with is that this crayons me bad in any way. If I were part of the mafia team, I'd have nothing to fear about getting killed... by the mafia. If I were mafia and lnew Mac is town, my retribution could easily take another form, without any mention in the thread obviously. As for the ideas of either framing or bussing Mac, they'd seem highly ineffectual as long-term plotting. And I'm a long-term kind of strategist.
So yeah, one could say this basically clears me as town. You're welcome, PoE makers.

So do you have any actual suspicions? If you already posted them, I missed them, I just did a quick skim before running out the door.
- Sun Oct 16, 2016 6:43 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
I am going to sit back for now and let other people talk. I hope they do talk. But I may be reading into things. I may not. But I want to hear from others.
- Sun Oct 16, 2016 6:24 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
Do you have any reason to actually think he is bad?Ricochet wrote:Don't get what's confusing about that, S~V~S. Self-preservation goal implies to prevent something for your own good. What better way to counter the odds of Mac being bad and getting even to Night 1 and try to make his team eliminate me, because I'm one of the players he doesn't like playing against?
And that Day Zero comment of mine was by far the jokey one, due to context of G-Man calling out to those who haven't even read their PMs. I would have started Day One the same way, regardless of any Day Zero chatter or banter.
Both you & Mac posted after me, yet neither of you addressed the "throwing each other under a bus" aspect of my post, which tbh is the thing I most expected a reaction to. The main thing that is making me think I could be seriously wrong is that everyone else is sitting back and letting me run with this wacky theory.
What do you think of MP?
Linki, I am a very nice lady

- Sun Oct 16, 2016 6:08 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
On Day One with no indication of alignment? On Day Zero?Ricochet wrote:Yes.MovingPictures07 wrote:Oh, I see. Clearly I was missing some important context here. So the basis for your policy lynch vote is essentially self-preservation, am I right?Ricochet wrote:"I'm killing the people who I hate playing against.'MovingPictures07 wrote:
What's the profile exactly? I must have missed something here.
You know how to Mafia, Rico. I am not liking this, you are not a fear based player. Not sure if it makes you bad, but I am still not liking this. The fact that you were trying to get rid of him before the game even really got going is giving me the heebies. The first thing that comes to mind is you are teamies and you threw him under the bus in case he did not show. And when he did, you had to keep it going. As a matter of fact the first thing that came to my mind was that all the Mac votes were his teammates.Ricochet wrote:Modkill MacDougall, send reminders to the others.
Wrench in that theory is that Mac has not said much that makes me think he is actually bad. So I could be reading into it, I am rusty.
- Sun Oct 16, 2016 4:14 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
So you are saying that he makes you so paranoid that you cannot deal with him being alive without factual knowledge that he is a civ?
- Sun Oct 16, 2016 3:45 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
Regardless of affiliation?Ricochet wrote:As long as Mac lives, yes.MovingPictures07 wrote:You're scared.Ricochet wrote:I'll let the others. Mac is top priority afaic.MovingPictures07 wrote:Go for it.Ricochet wrote:Oh so you're applying the Scotty philosophy this game.MovingPictures07 wrote:
Well, you're here now, so I'm switching to BWT.![]()
We can lynch you D1 instead of Scotty, then.
- Sun Oct 16, 2016 10:28 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 1
JJNeil, what is your opinion on policy lynching Mac?
- Sun Oct 16, 2016 9:02 am
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 0
To be fair,he said this before Glorfindel said is Mom was sick. I had the same thought, too, until I read Glorfindels post.a2thezebra wrote:Scotty wrote:Suspicious of Glorf for voting in the poll but not commenting.
Glorfindel? More like Skaglorfindel.
Epi & JaggedJimmyNeil, you are making me nervous saying this kind of thing, lol.JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Give yourself a hand, gentleman. You and Neil see eye to eye.Epignosis wrote:I view S~V~S as good.
I don't love policy lynches, but I don't love low posters either. I would rather give the Host a cycle to see if he can get a replacement if it is known that Mac is not coming back.
Hope it all works out for your family, Glorfindel

- Fri Oct 14, 2016 9:32 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 0
OK, just saw you were in here and I know how you feel that 48 hour days are a waste, so was surprised when I started a post, went & got a drink, went to the bathroom, and you still had not voted.Epignosis wrote:I'm voting for winning money in NBA tonight.S~V~S wrote:Epi, y u no vote for 24 yet?
- Fri Oct 14, 2016 9:23 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 0
Epi, y u no vote for 24 yet?
- Fri Oct 14, 2016 9:18 pm
- Forum: Previous Side Missions
- Topic: MAD MAX: GAME OVER
- Replies: 4518
- Views: 141414
Re: MAD MAX: Day 0
I am out of the habit of being here & checking in so the more time the better. But tbh, I always like longer days cause it's easier to immerse if I have more time due to my work hours.
So I voted 48.
So I voted 48.