Meta Mafia (day 4)

[Seanzie]

Idk why but I feel weirdest about Syn coming out of this. Gotta think about why that is

I was going to chime in and say that I feel similarly, but then everyone else was chiming in and saying they feel similarly, so instead of chiming in and feel similarly, I think I'm going to:

chime in and say I feel similarly.

[Dennis]

This game state is trash

Why

[falcon45ca]

Idk why but I feel weirdest about Syn coming out of this. Gotta think about why that is

I was going to chime in and say that I feel similarly, but then everyone else was chiming in and saying they feel similarly, so instead of chiming in and feel similarly, I think I'm going to:

chime in and say I feel similarly.

Seems redundant

[Seanzie]

Idk why but I feel weirdest about Syn coming out of this. Gotta think about why that is

I was going to chime in and say that I feel similarly, but then everyone else was chiming in and saying they feel similarly, so instead of chiming in and feel similarly, I think I'm going to:

chime in and say I feel similarly.

Seems redundant

I put the done 'dat in redundant.

[DrWilgy]

This game state is trash

Do you have nothing on my thoughts towards your point Neon?

[Syn]

Idk why but I feel weirdest about Syn coming out of this. Gotta think about why that is

Probably because they were like the start of this, and then they backed off just to try and throw shade at like everyone

I am generally asleep between the hours of 12 AM and 9 AM and have not yet mastered the art of sleep posting

[Syn]

Idk why but I feel weirdest about Syn coming out of this. Gotta think about why that is

I agree with this.

I'd really like to know what Syn thinks of the players they think are pocketing SVS, rather than just saying "wowee looky here"

@Syn?

ask me on D4

the point in my post seems fairly obvious and direct

[Syn]

Idk why but I feel weirdest about Syn coming out of this. Gotta think about why that is

I was going to chime in and say that I feel similarly, but then everyone else was chiming in and saying they feel similarly, so instead of chiming in and feel similarly, I think I'm going to:

chime in and say I feel similarly.

i too feel similarly

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

This game state is trash

Why

Because its stagnant and all anyone is doing is echoing the same points over and over

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

This game state is trash

Do you have nothing on my thoughts towards your point Neon?

Nope

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

As this point SVS is probably thread spewed town ig

Wilgz is town.

That's all. Cause this game state is awful.

[Dennis]

This game state is trash

Why

Because its stagnant and all anyone is doing is echoing the same points over and over

What do you think that suggests

[Dennis]

Idk why but I feel weirdest about Syn coming out of this. Gotta think about why that is

Probably because they were like the start of this, and then they backed off just to try and throw shade at like everyone

I am generally asleep between the hours of 12 AM and 9 AM and have not yet mastered the art of sleep posting

Smh get good maybe

Iunno I thought you were posting thru it all (and I don't know what timezone you're in ngl I assume everyone is EST for some reason)

[Dennis]

Hm what about lemonfairy

If everyone thinks syn felt weird, thoughts on lemon cuz I got some sorta funky vibes somewhere along the line

It felt like they might have been trying to cause some confusion because they didn't clarify for 100% certain about their joke solve, even after it was apparent svs thought they were being serious

[Dennis]

Hm what about lemonfairy

If everyone thinks syn felt weird, thoughts on lemon cuz I got some sorta funky vibes somewhere along the line

It felt like they might have been trying to cause some confusion because they didn't clarify for 100% certain about their joke solve, even after it was apparent svs thought they were being serious

Clarify without being prompted*

I had to ask, but they did clarify

[Syn]

imagine scum-reading someone because they got taken seriously by someone else

[Syn]

imagine scum-reading someone because they got taken seriously by someone else

this is me shading dennis

[Dennis]

imagine scum-reading someone because they got taken seriously by someone else

But then why wouldn't they clarify

[Dennis]

imagine scum-reading someone because they got taken seriously by someone else

this is me shading dennis

Oh thanks for letting me know

[Syn]

imagine scum-reading someone because they got taken seriously by someone else

But then why wouldn't they clarify

it's funnier not to

[SixStrings]

also this is irrelevant but people who are more resistant to being voted actually makes me want to push them more

so um
yeah

Maybe we just have a different approach, becasue I am always resistant to being voted

My very good friend is hosting her first game on this site, and i hope to be here for all of it, not be miselimmed on day one for a vague reason. Also, I was not 100% sure you really believed I was bad based on what *I think* was my reaction to a host post. I am a person who over thinks things and I am trying to be more spontaneous in Mafia games, but I'm not sure that's working out for me,

*Your* name is a good role, I'm not sure I'll ever get used to my name being a bad role, so expect more "um what?" from me in the future.

OK, still pretty new at all this but I will chime in. Seems too early to decide on a vote for wolf, however so far I am convinced S -V- S is town.

This is rather astute of you; may I ask why you think so? The other game we played, Muppets, I was in Crusader Rabbit mode, rather than defense mode, as I am here. And even though i do it myself, being defensive is pretty much generally viewed as kinda scummy. So not sure why you would have this thought.

Just a gut feel on you being town. Regarding your discussion on being defensive... Although I would agree that defensiveness can be construed as guilty or bad, it could easily be justified in many cases. Yours is one of them. Finally your reasoning seemed to be backed up by a third party in the thread.

[fingersplints]

Idk why but I feel weirdest about Syn coming out of this. Gotta think about why that is

I was going to chime in and say that I feel similarly, but then everyone else was chiming in and saying they feel similarly, so instead of chiming in and feel similarly, I think I'm going to:

chime in and say I feel similarly.

I’ve low posted for 15 years of everyone already having said all the thoughts, and for once I was in time for an original thought that everyone agreed with. Feel free to agree before it comes back and bites me in the butt lol

[fingersplints]

This game state is trash

Day 1 is trash a lot

[fingersplints]

also this is irrelevant but people who are more resistant to being voted actually makes me want to push them more

so um
yeah

Maybe we just have a different approach, becasue I am always resistant to being voted

My very good friend is hosting her first game on this site, and i hope to be here for all of it, not be miselimmed on day one for a vague reason. Also, I was not 100% sure you really believed I was bad based on what *I think* was my reaction to a host post. I am a person who over thinks things and I am trying to be more spontaneous in Mafia games, but I'm not sure that's working out for me,

*Your* name is a good role, I'm not sure I'll ever get used to my name being a bad role, so expect more "um what?" from me in the future.

OK, still pretty new at all this but I will chime in. Seems too early to decide on a vote for wolf, however so far I am convinced S -V- S is town.

This is rather astute of you; may I ask why you think so? The other game we played, Muppets, I was in Crusader Rabbit mode, rather than defense mode, as I am here. And even though i do it myself, being defensive is pretty much generally viewed as kinda scummy. So not sure why you would have this thought.

SixStrings seems very different from Muppet Mafia… is it because he is learning of affiliation change
(Not really asking, just noting I find his presence remarkably different)

[DrWilgy]

Epi
Splints
Neon
SVS
Seanzie

Mata
Six
Dennis
Roxy
Falcon

Syn
Lemon

Order is irrelevant.

This is the way.

[Dennis]

Splints is way more involved in this game than in tounge tied where we were baddies together and I distinctly remember she didn't want to be mafia then

Ergo townread for you

[Syn]

Epi
Splints
Neon
SVS
Seanzie

Mata
Six
Dennis
Roxy
Falcon

Syn
Lemon

Order is irrelevant.

This is the way.

poopy list my liege

[Syn]

replace syn and lemon with mata and six

and plummet epi from the top to the bottom

thanks love you

[falcon45ca]

This game state is trash

Why

Because its stagnant and all anyone is doing is echoing the same points over and over

Be the change you want to see in the game

[fingersplints]

Splints is way more involved in this game than in tounge tied where we were baddies together and I distinctly remember she didn't want to be mafia then

Ergo townread for you

I got some time today. I’d like the bar kept pretty low for my posting

[DrWilgy]

replace syn and lemon with mata and six

and plummet epi from the top to the bottom

thanks love you

I could replace you with a slanker, but it's just as likely that a slanker is a free space on the uno card of life.

Lemon isn't being replaced.

Talk to me about Epi.

[S~V~S]

I want to thank everyone for all the pocketing, and since almost everyone did it, I feel refreshingly uninfluenced by it.

Some things so far have not changed for me. I lean civ on Neon. I lean more wolfy on syn than I did this AM, mainly for the stated desire to go after low posters on Day One. Those folks have the same odds of randing civ as any of us, and if they're town, force the woofs to NK them if they want to win. Or sort them later in the POE.

Otherwise, my only experience with syn is Party Crasher, which is no experience at all. I'm sure they got a better look at my game than I got at theirs. So I'm more likely to rely on the opinions of others re syn.

I am going to reread Splints, her posts seem a bit ... I dunno, following the crowd a bit?

I always think Dennis is bad, lol, but I'm warming up to his game here. @Dennis , I saw you posted on Splints, on the fact that she is posting at all being AI. What do you think of what she is saying?

I saw Sixes reply, and I'm still processing it. It seemed sincere, but I'm not sure it answered my question. So not my likeliest vote as of now, but not my least likely either.

No real opinion on Falcon yet, I misread him alot when I first started playing with him so i'm fairly cautious about him, and i haven't found any hooks or tells that help me sort him as of yet.

I feel pretty good about Sean, mainly tone, no other reason. He seems very laid back, relaxed. Not the same as he felt in GOC where we were bad teammates.

Epi had zero reason as a baddie to point out what he did about my reaction to a host post. He can fool me better than most, but as of now, as I said, I don't see why he would bother making the post he did if he was bad.

Same for Wilgy, and his level of solve is good, and he isn't posting go along to get along opinions. I'm not as sure about Lemon as he is, I still think Lemon was sincere in his reasons for pushing me. Lemon doesn't know me, and in addition to being OG, I have always been a bit quixotic even back in the day. I learned my lesson about judging people based on stylistic differences in the Anni game.

Mata is incredibly insightful, and i hope she brings some of that. @Matahari come play with us.

Roxy is also a bit of a question mark for me; she graciously defended me, but I am looking forward to hearing her suspects, or her town, or her reads in general. I find she is very insightful and gets to the crux of the matter, without pulling any punches.

[Lemonfairy]

am back
will backread for a bit

[Lemonfairy]

I don't really want to read though

[Syn]

I lean more wolfy on syn than I did this AM, mainly for the stated desire to go after low posters on Day One.

I am voting for Epignosis, who is not a low poster

Those folks have the same odds of randing civ as any of us, and if they're town, force the woofs to NK them if they want to win. Or sort them later in the POE.

assuming that chopping into low posters is a thing that's going to happen (and I am not suggesting it should be, because it's lazy), you would sort low posters early on, not in the late game

and your argument that you "force the woofs to NK them" makes no logical sense in any way whatsoever. why would wolves NK low posters who aren't contributing or are likely to not be present enough to make an informed vote. no comprende

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

This game state is trash

Why

Because its stagnant and all anyone is doing is echoing the same points over and over

Be the change you want to see in the game

Nah that ain't me

[Lemonfairy]

wrong chat wrong chat

shitshitshit HI THReAD! I AM TOWN!!

Vote: Dennis

No.

Yes.

Maybe.

Progress

idk this is probably not w/w
weird convo

[Lemonfairy]

Maybe we just have a different approach, becasue I am always resistant to being voted

I do try to look past it if I think it's more likely NAI but it is more of a first reaction I have and sometimes I mess up and it overrides other stuff
eh we'll see

[Lemonfairy]

Feels weird ngl

what feels weird?

[Lemonfairy]

And I'll be damned if I give one care about being defensive when I get a suspicion/vote. I will *ALWAYS* defend as it is our duty as town to preserve/prove ourselves in order to be here another day helping/voting for the town.

it's good to try your best to not get elimmed but being defensive is imo not a great way to do it
and I'm not really trying to dissuade people from being defensive because at the end of the day, I can't control other people's reactions to being pushed - I just wanted to give a heads up on how I tend to react to defensiveness

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

Feels weird ngl

what feels weird?

SVS の動作

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

I'm bored

[Lemonfairy]

I think S~V~S looks slightly better than Neon in this exchange going on, but I could really see it being t/t. Neon is being a bit nitpicky and finding things in S~V~S posts that I don’t really agree with and am about seeing, but that points to maybe justified honest scumhunting. I think SVS being on the defensive this early also likely town trait for her. All in all, I’m ok with both of them for now

I didn't really feel Neon was being nitpicky?
felt like idk normal

[Seanzie]

Epi
Splints
Neon
SVS
Seanzie

Mata
Six
Dennis
Roxy
Falcon

Syn
Lemon

Order is irrelevant.

This is the way.

Tell me about Lemon.

[Lemonfairy]

I also don't think SVS's initial post is actually worth reading much into and it felt like a waste of time for so many people to comment on it
I liked their later posts though

[Epignosis]

Um what?

Mafia S~V~S wouldn't react this way.

um what?

My statement was unequivocal.

but why do you think scum SVS wouldn't react that way?

I've been reading along and I feel like this question has been addressed.

[Lemonfairy]

Um what?

Mafia S~V~S wouldn't react this way.

um what?

My statement was unequivocal.

but why do you think scum SVS wouldn't react that way?

I've been reading along and I feel like this question has been addressed.

yeah, it has
just skip it

[☆Princess Abigail☆]

Vote Lemon

[Lemonfairy]

Ooh like talk in baddie chat about already getting called out, I see

I only played with maf svs once and I don't remember a single thing so I'm gonna trust other people's meta reads, but I was already townleaning her so

this feels like town
and it's more specific than the "feelings" I had last game so hopefully it's right this time

[Lemonfairy]

Vote Lemon

are you telling me to vote or are you telling people to vote me?