The Game of Champions 2024 [ENDGAME]

[Cape90]

ok i have read eod, main takeaway is it feels like something is fishy about the roxy/sprityo interaction in some direction, also don't like tsp's vibe so far

town
svs
michelle
abbi
cape

town?
thunal
porscha
scotty
long con

meh
pyxxy
sig
wilgy

bleh
tsp
darling
roxy
sprityo

You’re a wolf

Do you expect Nutella to be a person that's good at reading you?

[Cape90]

@Cape90

welcome to playing with porscha, who rarely outright states reads

what do you want to know

I get it, but I also don't really know what specifically to ask you at the same time lol

[Cape90]

I guess for starters where would you vote in the group that's in the poll right now Porscha if you had to vote now?

[Porscha]

I guess for starters where would you vote in the group that's in the poll right now Porscha if you had to vote now?

Mmm probably Roxy but it's also kind of a lazy answer lol

Legitimately like it would sbpc

(Tho I didnt love her post where she referred to my energy as chaotic and said she would vote me cuz it implies I'm wolfy without outright saying it, but merh)

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

Who's first?

DarlingMonroe

Voters: sprityo

Lime Coke

Voters: S~V~S, TonyStarkPrime, Long Con, Michelle

Michelle

Voters: DrWilgy

Porscha

Voters: falcon45ca

☆Princess Abigail☆

Voters: pyxxy

Roxy

Voters: ☆Princess Abigail☆, Cape90, Scotty

Sig

Voters: Thunal33

sprityo

Voters: Roxy

Not voting:

porscha, sig, darlingMonroe, Lime Coke, Daisy/Nutella

EOD1, Readable version

Without the number of votes is not readable.

I started Brad's wagon. A quiet Brad is not town Brad. I was afraid he tried to pocket me by that read and I was waiting all day for him to come and play.
I thought he's a wolf.

Catching up

[Michelle]

I am not a fan of colouring stuff with someone else's reads, why did you do that @sprityo?

This post doesn't show your thoughts about the game at all.

[Michelle]

VC

Spoiler: show

Who tried but nobody died?
Poll runs till Wed Mar 12, 2025 2:00 am
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


pyxxy
0
No votes
Voters: None
Roxy
0
No votes
Voters: None
S~V~S
0
No votes
Voters: None
Thunal33
1
33%
Voters: TonyStarkPrime
Chicken Masks FTW (The Host, the Non, the Dead)
2
67%
Voters: Syn, Epignosis
Total votes: 3

The lack of interest in voting is concerning.

[S~V~S]

I am not a fan of colouring stuff with someone else's reads, why did you do that @sprityo?

This post doesn't show your thoughts about the game at all.

It actually does, it's a theory about what happened with the poll (and being on it, I find it super relevant).

When I saw it last night, I assumed it was a role mechanic, probably town. I kind of assumed YOU did it since I'm on there, and I know I'm your POE (not the gestalt POE (I don't think), as you implied in an earlier post, "the POE").

In any case I kinda just skimmed, and stopped at Sprits color post speculating i did it. *IF* I did do it, I was not aware of it, and am not sure how or whatever, but it is possible I guess.

Spoiler: show

Who's first?

DarlingMonroe

Voters: sprityo

Lime Coke

Voters: S~V~S, TonyStarkPrime, Long Con, Michelle

Michelle

Voters: DrWilgy

Porscha

Voters: falcon45ca

☆Princess Abigail☆

Voters: pyxxy

Roxy

Voters: ☆Princess Abigail☆, Cape90, Scotty

Sig

Voters: Thunal33

sprityo

Voters: Roxy

Not voting:

porscha, sig, darlingMonroe, Lime Coke, Daisy/Nutella

EOD1, Readable version

Spoiler: show

I tried to take everyone but low/no content posters out of null.


People I'm pretty comfy thinking of as town, unlikely to vote today, there would have to be a slip or something major.

Scotty, not too grinchy
Long Con, he's doing things and saying things I don't think he'd do or say if bad.
Abbi, she feels like she believes what she's saying, Like I said last list, she feels like she laughing with you not at you. Her sideeye at me re how I'm posting differently felt genuine.
Falcon, he's on topic asking pointed questions, and on topic more than off. Day one baseline town Falcon for me.
Cape, he sounds *reasonable* he's making reads without seeming to be worried about ruffling people. Can anyone tell me if bad Cape does anything different? I mean, if this was my first time seeing him, I'd think town. He's evolving while he reads which is a good look.

People I feel mostly towny on, but not "supatown" but also not likely to vote today

Roxy. Not seeing why she's taking sus. Not immensely on topic, but that's fairly typical of her. I considered putting her in the null reads, but tone wise I think she feels open and townish. I personally need to see reads to feel 100% putting her in this group, but I feel OK in general.
Michelle, she has that slightly srs bsns feel I get from town Michelle. We don't seem to be on the same page alot here, but we often aren't, especially early. The only thing keeping her out of straight up town is her not wanting to tell me what bad vibes I have without looking up an iso. I recall her doing something similar when bad, avoiding a question she didn't want to answer.
pyxxy is kind of enigmatic to me in general. I think he approaches the game from a totally different place to myself, and I don't always see his perspective right away. More than anyone, he reminds me of Matahari, and even having played with her for years, I would still have to work at seeing her perspective for the most part. So while not agreeing with some things he's saying, I like the way he's saying it if that makes sense.
Thunal I was a bit worried about her yesterday, while I didn't think bad Thunal would lead with a story about dreaming she was bad, other than that she was not how I tend to think of town Thunal. Today she came in and is closer to what I think of as towny for her. But she can 100% percent fool me.

People I could vote for; I have no real reason to think they're town. These are fairly tentative, I'm seeing more town than bad as of now.

Lime for me town Lime may not he a high poster, but he's a quality poster. He comes in, throws out some off the cuff reads, leaves. Not seeing that here. Least likely of the "I could vote for him", but not towny either.
sig I had him null leaning green last list, seeing other peoples opinions led me to reread, and it feels looking for a reason to vote for a person, rather than finding something that leads to a vote.
Sprit I don't love his Wilgy vote, and am still not sure if it's serious or not. He was here, made some vaguely on topic posts, but not really. Without that vote, he'd be a null.
Porscha even without the feel she was kissing up to Scotty, I'm also not loving how she's pushing at Falcon. More than half of his Day 1 posts are on topic, he's made lists and engaged with suspicions. I don't ever recall seeing bad Falcon do so on Day 1.

Complete Nulls. They haven't had enough on topic content to have an opinion, I don't love yeeting low posters Day 1

Darling, one "Yay game" post
Daisy isn't feeling well
TSP mostly Eraserhead
Wilgy mostly shitposting as far as I can tell

And I'm pretty sure that's everybody.

Now including SVS’ colors from 7 hours before EOD1 (so this might not reflect her current feelings) but look at the pretty colors! I used them for convenience, interesting no?

Not sure if I'm being a dummy here by telling this, but this isn't against the rules, and I'm not sure how this could get me in trouble saying it. Worst case is I get NK for it, I guess. And if so the town gets info, and a role that potentially limits the poll kinda randomly is gone ( if that's what I'm doing here).

Part of my role is that I have to send a number in at night. Not sure how this would even remotely correlate to a list I posted in thread, but very weirdly, I guess it might.

Last night I sent in "8", and my orange group would correspond to 6, 7, 8 & 9 (minus Michelle, plus me). So I sent one number, not a range or not 4 numbers, just one. The number 8.

This could be a coincidence. But it is very very weird that it corresponds to my list. It's a good theory, it is possible. But if i did do it, I am not aware of it.

[S~V~S]

Just being open here.

Now gonna really read, not just skim.

[S~V~S]

OK, also quick impressions from EOD 1, I was gonna do this before bed last night, but then Cape pointed out the poll which I hadn't even noticed.

Most sus person coming out of EOD 1 to me was Wilgy. I would have prolly voted for him already had he been on the poll. He came in to say, "Why does Porscha have votes", and left without changing his obvs joke vote for Michelle.

Also initially found TSP kinda sus for similar reasons, came in "Why Porscha?" voted Lime and left. Then when Michelle suggested the flashwagon on Brad, i went with it since I was not a fan of the Roxy wagon becasue I had not seen anything sus from her, just null typical Roxy stuff. Rox doesn't go with wagonomics, she'll vote how she feels regardless of other wagons, it's how she rolls, and it's NAI as far as I'm concerned.

I had found Brad sus anyhow, he was in my red group so i went with it. When I thought he was bad till Epi clarified, that put TSP much more towny for me, it put Abbi lower on my list since she had voted for Brad, then voted off right around/after the time I voted, I thought maybe it had been a distancing vote (when I thought Brad was bad) that no longer worked once I moved my vote to him. Like w/TSP, that changed when Epi clarified Brads role. My initial thought was also that perhaps instead of what I had thought (a 3 person mafia, and 2 indies) about composition, maybe it was two 2 person Mafias since Limes role said "Workout Mafia", I thought that was a team name.

And now I won't have much time to finish reading back, so will likely do it from work, may or may not comment. Bye.

[S~V~S]

@Cape90

welcome to playing with porscha, who rarely outright states reads

what do you want to know

Do you have thoughts on Wilgy and TSP? If you said them and I missed them, sorry, I'm chronological right now, not in ISO's.

[Michelle]

I am not a fan of colouring stuff with someone else's reads, why did you do that @sprityo?

This post doesn't show your thoughts about the game at all.

It actually does, it's a theory about what happened with the poll (and being on it, I find it super relevant).

Are we talking about the same thing?
He is taking your reads colouring the poll accordingly but I don't see his own reads

When I saw it last night, I assumed it was a role mechanic, probably town. I kind of assumed YOU did it since I'm on there, and I know I'm your POE (not the gestalt POE (I don't think), as you implied in an earlier post, "the POE").

It's not my action.
I play deck mafia and I have a card who can choose the poll without putting myself on it. I used it as town and choose only townies in it, and that taught me I don't have always good reads in the first day of the game

You are in my POE but I am not willing to tunnel you in the possibility I am wrong and I am waiting for the read to be confirmed or infirmed by your play or mechs.

The lack of interest on the chop at EOD gave me the desire to CFD and I choose Brad for the reason I explained.

In any case I kinda just skimmed, and stopped at Sprits color post speculating i did it. *IF* I did do it, I was not aware of it, and am not sure how or whatever, but it is possible I guess.

Spoiler: show

Who's first?

DarlingMonroe

Voters: sprityo

Lime Coke

Voters: S~V~S, TonyStarkPrime, Long Con, Michelle

Michelle

Voters: DrWilgy

Porscha

Voters: falcon45ca

☆Princess Abigail☆

Voters: pyxxy

Roxy

Voters: ☆Princess Abigail☆, Cape90, Scotty

Sig

Voters: Thunal33

sprityo

Voters: Roxy

Not voting:

porscha, sig, darlingMonroe, Lime Coke, Daisy/Nutella

EOD1, Readable version

Spoiler: show

I tried to take everyone but low/no content posters out of null.


People I'm pretty comfy thinking of as town, unlikely to vote today, there would have to be a slip or something major.

Scotty, not too grinchy
Long Con, he's doing things and saying things I don't think he'd do or say if bad.
Abbi, she feels like she believes what she's saying, Like I said last list, she feels like she laughing with you not at you. Her sideeye at me re how I'm posting differently felt genuine.
Falcon, he's on topic asking pointed questions, and on topic more than off. Day one baseline town Falcon for me.
Cape, he sounds *reasonable* he's making reads without seeming to be worried about ruffling people. Can anyone tell me if bad Cape does anything different? I mean, if this was my first time seeing him, I'd think town. He's evolving while he reads which is a good look.

People I feel mostly towny on, but not "supatown" but also not likely to vote today

Roxy. Not seeing why she's taking sus. Not immensely on topic, but that's fairly typical of her. I considered putting her in the null reads, but tone wise I think she feels open and townish. I personally need to see reads to feel 100% putting her in this group, but I feel OK in general.
Michelle, she has that slightly srs bsns feel I get from town Michelle. We don't seem to be on the same page alot here, but we often aren't, especially early. The only thing keeping her out of straight up town is her not wanting to tell me what bad vibes I have without looking up an iso. I recall her doing something similar when bad, avoiding a question she didn't want to answer.
pyxxy is kind of enigmatic to me in general. I think he approaches the game from a totally different place to myself, and I don't always see his perspective right away. More than anyone, he reminds me of Matahari, and even having played with her for years, I would still have to work at seeing her perspective for the most part. So while not agreeing with some things he's saying, I like the way he's saying it if that makes sense.
Thunal I was a bit worried about her yesterday, while I didn't think bad Thunal would lead with a story about dreaming she was bad, other than that she was not how I tend to think of town Thunal. Today she came in and is closer to what I think of as towny for her. But she can 100% percent fool me.

People I could vote for; I have no real reason to think they're town. These are fairly tentative, I'm seeing more town than bad as of now.

Lime for me town Lime may not he a high poster, but he's a quality poster. He comes in, throws out some off the cuff reads, leaves. Not seeing that here. Least likely of the "I could vote for him", but not towny either.
sig I had him null leaning green last list, seeing other peoples opinions led me to reread, and it feels looking for a reason to vote for a person, rather than finding something that leads to a vote.
Sprit I don't love his Wilgy vote, and am still not sure if it's serious or not. He was here, made some vaguely on topic posts, but not really. Without that vote, he'd be a null.
Porscha even without the feel she was kissing up to Scotty, I'm also not loving how she's pushing at Falcon. More than half of his Day 1 posts are on topic, he's made lists and engaged with suspicions. I don't ever recall seeing bad Falcon do so on Day 1.

Complete Nulls. They haven't had enough on topic content to have an opinion, I don't love yeeting low posters Day 1

Darling, one "Yay game" post
Daisy isn't feeling well
TSP mostly Eraserhead
Wilgy mostly shitposting as far as I can tell

And I'm pretty sure that's everybody.

Now including SVS’ colors from 7 hours before EOD1 (so this might not reflect her current feelings) but look at the pretty colors! I used them for convenience, interesting no?

Not sure if I'm being a dummy here by telling this, but this isn't against the rules, and I'm not sure how this could get me in trouble saying it. Worst case is I get NK for it, I guess. And if so the town gets info, and a role that potentially limits the poll kinda randomly is gone ( if that's what I'm doing here).

Part of my role is that I have to send a number in at night. Not sure how this would even remotely correlate to a list I posted in thread, but very weirdly, I guess it might.

Last night I sent in "8", and my orange group would correspond to 6, 7, 8 & 9 (minus Michelle, plus me). So I sent one number, not a range or not 4 numbers, just one. The number 8.

This could be a coincidence. But it is very very weird that it corresponds to my list. It's a good theory, it is possible. But if i did do it, I am not aware of it.

Interesting role, I remembered the GoC thing who's choosing from all the year games a role flavour and idk where this thing can come.
Coincidentally, I played the workout mafia so I could understand Brad's role when I read it but I wasn't active enough in the last year to know more games.

Anyway the flavour stuff is not AI so it doesn't really matter.

From the poll, you are the player I wouldn't vote with the current impression I have on the game.

[Michelle]

@pyxxy is too quiet and also I need @Thunal33 to talk more.

[Michelle]

Overnight I suspected TSP for the vote but thinking better I don't know if his play matches scum!TSP behaviour.

[Michelle]

Overnight I suspected TSP for the vote but thinking better I don't know if his play matches scum!TSP behaviour.

I expect scum to be more manipulative about their play, but TSP is just vibing imo.

What everyone thinks?

[Porscha]

@Cape90

welcome to playing with porscha, who rarely outright states reads

what do you want to know

Do you have thoughts on Wilgy and TSP? If you said them and I missed them, sorry, I'm chronological right now, not in ISO's.

I haven't seen wilgy for like 3 irl days so not much from him, I just remember getting shit on for commenting on his posts around scotty and Michelle

Tsp uuuuuh idk i always sorta townread tsp lol, I liked thay he called nutella a wolf teehee

[Porscha]

Kinda feel like ur read of me @S~V~S is bad lol

Not accurate at all

[sig]

Not caught up, the weekend got away from me unfortunately, but plan to catch up today.

Rip Lime Coke, but a third party going down isn’t a bad thing so meh.

No death plus a limited poll is interesting. I’m assuming we had some role action last night for both.

[S~V~S]

Kinda feel like ur read of me @S~V~S is bad lol

Not accurate at all

Youre in my POE to be sure, and while at one point you were most sus to me, I never actually voted for you, even when you were a viable wagon and Scotty poked me about why I hadn’t. I was on the sig wagon.

I’m a bit botd here since I went and looked at Hod Dog fingers, and it wasn’t as overt as I recalled it being.

I ask about Wilgy and TSP since they both came in when you had a lot of votes and questioned why YOU had votes, but not anyone else who had votes.

I seriously doubt that a team consisting of you, TSP and Wilgy would act that way lol, but I had to ask your thoughts on it.

[sig]

Does anyone remember if mafia Roxy is more likely to post emoji?

Or was she less likely?

I know it was one or the other but can’t remember which.

Maybe don't use that tell then.

Psh I’ll use all the nonsensical tells tyvm

[sig]

I'm officially so bored of this game I'm gonna go cook

And making me want to cook is really hard

You’re not gonna believe this, I just made some eggs and toast

It was very yummy

I got a nice breakfast today. 2 eggs, 2 toast, 3 bacon, and homefries: $6.99!

Wanna adopt me? Cheap breakfast and a pathway into Canada win win

[S~V~S]

@Michelle

You seem to know what your role does, I don’t. I roll dice and get a number. Can’t get the same # twice.

The relation of my roll and the color ranks on my list could totally be coincidence. But still my guess is we have a lot of poll manips so it might be smart to avoid ties and too much vote spreading if possible when voting.

[Thunal33]

Anyways, I uh... am noticing the poll

oh. what's the determining factor between all of them

That’s really our big mystery for today. Is this a town/mafia/indy role mechanic?

I definitely feel like it’s mafia related, maaayybbee indy. Or it’s neither and it’s just game related, but in cases of mafia or game mechanics, there’s no way all 4 people in the poll today are town

I'd be careful about assuming there's at least 1 mafia in that group. I think it's more likely a town role than a mafia role because why do it day 2 if it's a mafia role? It would be way more powerful late game.

There's also the possibility it is mafia and they just put 4 townies up for elimination.

[Thunal33]

@Michelle

You seem to know what your role does, I don’t. I roll dice and get a number. Can’t get the same # twice.

The relation of my roll and the color ranks on my list could totally be coincidence. But still my guess is we have a lot of poll manips so it might be smart to avoid ties and too much vote spreading if possible when voting.

Probably a good idea, there were a few vote manip roles in Napoleon Dynamite. I don't think I've ever seen someone's readslist have mechanical importance? (except for Roxy's tiebreak lists, but she knew what she was doing with those)

[Thunal33]

@TonyStarkPrime why did you vote Lime Coke? Because it's bugging me that there wasn't any reason I could see that you voted him for.

Because it seemed like Porscha was trying the ol “vote lime coke and get him to break rules in a vaguely out of line manner” strategy which hasn’t worked in like 3-4 years and I wanted to help out

People don't really do that anymore and Lime is better at not breaking rules so no, I wasn't thinking of that.

[Michelle]

@Michelle

You seem to know what your role does, I don’t. I roll dice and get a number. Can’t get the same # twice.

The relation of my roll and the color ranks on my list could totally be coincidence. But still my guess is we have a lot of poll manips so it might be smart to avoid ties and too much vote spreading if possible when voting.

I have no idea what your role does. It just seems interesting and connected with other role in an unknown way (that's just a speculation)

I think the reduced poll it's enough by itself, votes manipulations would be too much imo, but to not be sorry we should take this advice

[Thunal33]

@Michelle

You seem to know what your role does, I don’t. I roll dice and get a number. Can’t get the same # twice.

The relation of my roll and the color ranks on my list could totally be coincidence. But still my guess is we have a lot of poll manips so it might be smart to avoid ties and too much vote spreading if possible when voting.

Do you pick a target as well as your number? (It's okay if you don't feel like answering)

[Thunal33]

The only odd one out on the poll is thunal

how am I odd?

[TonyStarkPrime]

I am not a fan of colouring stuff with someone else's reads, why did you do that @sprityo?

This post doesn't show your thoughts about the game at all.

It actually does, it's a theory about what happened with the poll (and being on it, I find it super relevant).

When I saw it last night, I assumed it was a role mechanic, probably town. I kind of assumed YOU did it since I'm on there, and I know I'm your POE (not the gestalt POE (I don't think), as you implied in an earlier post, "the POE").

In any case I kinda just skimmed, and stopped at Sprits color post speculating i did it. *IF* I did do it, I was not aware of it, and am not sure how or whatever, but it is possible I guess.

Spoiler: show

Who's first?

DarlingMonroe

Voters: sprityo

Lime Coke

Voters: S~V~S, TonyStarkPrime, Long Con, Michelle

Michelle

Voters: DrWilgy

Porscha

Voters: falcon45ca

☆Princess Abigail☆

Voters: pyxxy

Roxy

Voters: ☆Princess Abigail☆, Cape90, Scotty

Sig

Voters: Thunal33

sprityo

Voters: Roxy

Not voting:

porscha, sig, darlingMonroe, Lime Coke, Daisy/Nutella

EOD1, Readable version

Spoiler: show

I tried to take everyone but low/no content posters out of null.


People I'm pretty comfy thinking of as town, unlikely to vote today, there would have to be a slip or something major.

Scotty, not too grinchy
Long Con, he's doing things and saying things I don't think he'd do or say if bad.
Abbi, she feels like she believes what she's saying, Like I said last list, she feels like she laughing with you not at you. Her sideeye at me re how I'm posting differently felt genuine.
Falcon, he's on topic asking pointed questions, and on topic more than off. Day one baseline town Falcon for me.
Cape, he sounds *reasonable* he's making reads without seeming to be worried about ruffling people. Can anyone tell me if bad Cape does anything different? I mean, if this was my first time seeing him, I'd think town. He's evolving while he reads which is a good look.

People I feel mostly towny on, but not "supatown" but also not likely to vote today

Roxy. Not seeing why she's taking sus. Not immensely on topic, but that's fairly typical of her. I considered putting her in the null reads, but tone wise I think she feels open and townish. I personally need to see reads to feel 100% putting her in this group, but I feel OK in general.
Michelle, she has that slightly srs bsns feel I get from town Michelle. We don't seem to be on the same page alot here, but we often aren't, especially early. The only thing keeping her out of straight up town is her not wanting to tell me what bad vibes I have without looking up an iso. I recall her doing something similar when bad, avoiding a question she didn't want to answer.
pyxxy is kind of enigmatic to me in general. I think he approaches the game from a totally different place to myself, and I don't always see his perspective right away. More than anyone, he reminds me of Matahari, and even having played with her for years, I would still have to work at seeing her perspective for the most part. So while not agreeing with some things he's saying, I like the way he's saying it if that makes sense.
Thunal I was a bit worried about her yesterday, while I didn't think bad Thunal would lead with a story about dreaming she was bad, other than that she was not how I tend to think of town Thunal. Today she came in and is closer to what I think of as towny for her. But she can 100% percent fool me.

People I could vote for; I have no real reason to think they're town. These are fairly tentative, I'm seeing more town than bad as of now.

Lime for me town Lime may not he a high poster, but he's a quality poster. He comes in, throws out some off the cuff reads, leaves. Not seeing that here. Least likely of the "I could vote for him", but not towny either.
sig I had him null leaning green last list, seeing other peoples opinions led me to reread, and it feels looking for a reason to vote for a person, rather than finding something that leads to a vote.
Sprit I don't love his Wilgy vote, and am still not sure if it's serious or not. He was here, made some vaguely on topic posts, but not really. Without that vote, he'd be a null.
Porscha even without the feel she was kissing up to Scotty, I'm also not loving how she's pushing at Falcon. More than half of his Day 1 posts are on topic, he's made lists and engaged with suspicions. I don't ever recall seeing bad Falcon do so on Day 1.

Complete Nulls. They haven't had enough on topic content to have an opinion, I don't love yeeting low posters Day 1

Darling, one "Yay game" post
Daisy isn't feeling well
TSP mostly Eraserhead
Wilgy mostly shitposting as far as I can tell

And I'm pretty sure that's everybody.

Now including SVS’ colors from 7 hours before EOD1 (so this might not reflect her current feelings) but look at the pretty colors! I used them for convenience, interesting no?

Not sure if I'm being a dummy here by telling this, but this isn't against the rules, and I'm not sure how this could get me in trouble saying it. Worst case is I get NK for it, I guess. And if so the town gets info, and a role that potentially limits the poll kinda randomly is gone ( if that's what I'm doing here).

Part of my role is that I have to send a number in at night. Not sure how this would even remotely correlate to a list I posted in thread, but very weirdly, I guess it might.

Last night I sent in "8", and my orange group would correspond to 6, 7, 8 & 9 (minus Michelle, plus me). So I sent one number, not a range or not 4 numbers, just one. The number 8.

This could be a coincidence. But it is very very weird that it corresponds to my list. It's a good theory, it is possible. But if i did do it, I am not aware of it.

This is the kind of posting which the rational side of me has seen mafia do a million times but the irrational side of me just wants to lock town because it’s so wild

[Thunal33]

Overnight I suspected TSP for the vote but thinking better I don't know if his play matches scum!TSP behaviour.

I expect scum to be more manipulative about their play, but TSP is just vibing imo.

What everyone thinks?

Unsure. I very slight towned him for his comments on Porscha and doing what he thought was helping her reaction test Lime Coke. But then he voted me today "mostly just for mech" and I have no idea what mech he could possibly be talking about. Probably still just above null.

[TonyStarkPrime]

@TonyStarkPrime why did you vote Lime Coke? Because it's bugging me that there wasn't any reason I could see that you voted him for.

Because it seemed like Porscha was trying the ol “vote lime coke and get him to break rules in a vaguely out of line manner” strategy which hasn’t worked in like 3-4 years and I wanted to help out

People don't really do that anymore and Lime is better at not breaking rules so no, I wasn't thinking of that.

Well yeah I know that’s what I said in my post

[TonyStarkPrime]

The only odd one out on the poll is thunal

how am I odd?

going to hold off so we can wait for a claim or anyone else to share some wild theories but I think this is pretty level 1.

do you have any theories?

[Thunal33]

Caught up but it isn't sticking, probs due to the fact I am a 4 year Olds best friend and I thoroughly enjoy every minute.

W hile I an unsure of sig I have a vibe he is probs town poss 3p but unlikely. He should however know (bc we have played many times) I post however I want to as town or bad. The noble smiley is one of my faves. Reminds me of my old dog Bear. Not voting sig.

Thunal feels different tone wise to me. I have gotten her wrong before but I have also been right. I want to just give her time bc it feels like she hardly plays anymore.

Porscha wow. You are all over the map. You have sussed people then cleared them, buddying up the thread. I've missed you and your energy in games I have played but I could vote here.

Sprityo your Darling vote is a cop out with all that is in the thread. I despise D1 low poster votes just bc they cba'ed to have opinions on things that are in the thread. I am also 98% sure low poster votes d 1 lead to much towny sadness whenI have seen them. Voting here vote sprityo

Also decided not to really comment on Capes vote for me bc he really does not know me plus the fact I really don't give a care bc Ariya is here

this pop in feels very phoned in. Like a collect call. I get you're busy with fam, just calling this post out like I see it, and I see a bit of player salad. Especially considering you said of porscha, who is leading, 'i could vote there' and then heading straight to sprityo, a vanity wagon.

[VOTE: Roxy] aubergine

feeeeeeels off

very torn between agreeing with this read and calling it fake lol

Hi Nut! I kind of agree with it but I also don't know if Roxy just really dislikes d1 low poster votes. Sometimes her reasons for voting feel completely different from what I would vote for.

[Thunal33]

The only odd one out on the poll is thunal

how am I odd?

going to hold off so we can wait for a claim or anyone else to share some wild theories but I think this is pretty level 1.

do you have any theories?

I have a wild theory that it could have to do with who we targeted at night.

Or it's just a 1-shot town role who can pick 4 people.

[Thunal33]

The only odd one out on the poll is thunal

how am I odd?

going to hold off so we can wait for a claim or anyone else to share some wild theories but I think this is pretty level 1.

do you have any theories?

Oh yeah I just saw how I'm different from the others.

Maybe just a coincidence?

[Michelle]

The only odd one out on the poll is thunal

how am I odd?

going to hold off so we can wait for a claim or anyone else to share some wild theories but I think this is pretty level 1.

do you have any theories?

Oh yeah I just saw how I'm different from the others.

Maybe just a coincidence?

What's the difference?

[Roxy]

My townreads in order are

Michelle
Long Con
Princess Abigail
Porscha
Scotty
SVS
Thunal?

I think my strongest wolf lean is Roxy with like 0% confidence

Ok so only daisy and pyx have not posted yet. Hopefully Epi is prodding them but I am unsure bc of Porcha's intro post.

Not seeing anything wrong with Scotty and his questioning/posting.

Not seeing sig as sk at all.

Actually it's very early for me to mention anything so I am done now.

like there is something a bit strange and awkward with the things i highlighted

Anyways rn I could move around the top TRs like:
Michelle
PA
Scotty
Long Con
Porscha

but i guess that's kind of arbitrary

[VOTE: Roxy] aubergine

I just feel like Roxy is pretending to be inquisitive here

First how was I inquisitive when I was giving opinions and not asking questions? Wouldn't inquisitive imply questions?

Second Scotty was being talked about (started by SVS) so hence my opinion
Third Wigly came in and called sig a sk then PA agreed so hence my opinion again.
Fourth this post was for me to know who had not yet posted.

Explain how it was pretending to be inquisitive.

[Roxy]

My townreads in order are

Michelle
Long Con
Princess Abigail
Porscha
Scotty
SVS
Thunal?

I think my strongest wolf lean is Roxy with like 0% confidence

Ok so only daisy and pyx have not posted yet. Hopefully Epi is prodding them but I am unsure bc of Porcha's intro post.

Not seeing anything wrong with Scotty and his questioning/posting.

Not seeing sig as sk at all.

Actually it's very early for me to mention anything so I am done now.

like there is something a bit strange and awkward with the things i highlighted

Anyways rn I could move around the top TRs like:
Michelle
PA
Scotty
Long Con
Porscha

but i guess that's kind of arbitrary

[VOTE: Roxy] aubergine

I just feel like Roxy is pretending to be inquisitive here

First how was I inquisitive when I was giving opinions and not asking questions? Wouldn't inquisitive imply questions?

Second Scotty was being talked about (started by SVS) so hence my opinion
Third Wigly came in and called sig a sk then PA agreed so hence my opinion again.
Fourth this post was for me to know who had not yet posted.

Explain how it was pretending to be inquisitive.

[Roxy]

One last post before work for you @Roxy

Not a cop out, genuinely want to play the game with you all and day 1 (in my opinion) is the most inconsequential day to vote off someone who isnt even here. Especially someone who literally checked in to confirm playing and had this far been away. In either case, I’d rather the people with the time and are invested in doing their day 1 sleuthing take the reins. My vote stays, I’ll check back with yall after work

I guess everyone has their own way of playing but BE SURE to remember this about me:

I will always defend low/no poster especially D 1. I detest lhf votes D 1. Useless and info void bc they were low/no posters.

[Roxy]

One last post before work for you @Roxy

Not a cop out, genuinely want to play the game with you all and day 1 (in my opinion) is the most inconsequential day to vote off someone who isnt even here. Especially someone who literally checked in to confirm playing and had this far been away. In either case, I’d rather the people with the time and are invested in doing their day 1 sleuthing take the reins. My vote stays, I’ll check back with yall after work

Isn't Darling Monroe in this situation?

exactly my point I just made ---but Michelle sprit had actually voted Darling.

[Thunal33]

The only odd one out on the poll is thunal

how am I odd?

going to hold off so we can wait for a claim or anyone else to share some wild theories but I think this is pretty level 1.

do you have any theories?

Oh yeah I just saw how I'm different from the others.

Maybe just a coincidence?

What's the difference?

The other three are next to each other on the playerlist.

[Thunal33]

I'd be really careful about determining the alignment of the people in the poll just from them being on the poll or not. I wouldn't rule out any combination of town and mafia in the poll names (other than 4 mafia because I'm town).

[Roxy]

Caught up but it isn't sticking, probs due to the fact I am a 4 year Olds best friend and I thoroughly enjoy every minute.

W hile I an unsure of sig I have a vibe he is probs town poss 3p but unlikely. He should however know (bc we have played many times) I post however I want to as town or bad. The noble smiley is one of my faves. Reminds me of my old dog Bear. Not voting sig.

Thunal feels different tone wise to me. I have gotten her wrong before but I have also been right. I want to just give her time bc it feels like she hardly plays anymore.

Porscha wow. You are all over the map. You have sussed people then cleared them, buddying up the thread. I've missed you and your energy in games I have played but I could vote here.

Sprityo your Darling vote is a cop out with all that is in the thread. I despise D1 low poster votes just bc they cba'ed to have opinions on things that are in the thread. I am also 98% sure low poster votes d 1 lead to much towny sadness whenI have seen them. Voting here vote sprityo

Also decided not to really comment on Capes vote for me bc he really does not know me plus the fact I really don't give a care bc Ariya is here

this pop in feels very phoned in. Like a collect call. I get you're busy with fam, just calling this post out like I see it, and I see a bit of player salad. Especially considering you said of porscha, who is leading, 'i could vote there' and then heading straight to sprityo, a vanity wagon.

[VOTE: Roxy] aubergine

feeeeeeels off

Player salad?? I guess that's your opinion.

These are the things that were stuck in my craw after my catch up so I commented on them. I guess when I catch up *I* am not allowed to comment on anything - noted.

I voted what I felt I really like to follow my own gut when it comes to *my* vote. You do you let me be me.

I am gonna do what I want to do bc I let others do what they want so it seems fair to me. Sorry if you disagree with my strategy for playing mafia.

[Roxy]

I actually don't want to vote Porscha anymore.

[VOTE: sig] aubergine

Could vote Sig or Roxy.

First time you even mention my name without any sort of why.

So why?

Why did I suddenly get included into your posts?
Why did you suddenly not want to vote Porscha anymore?

[Roxy]

Atm my PoE is kind of boring. Sig, Roxy, Lime, Wilgy, and DM I'd consider PoE.

Yeah really boring imo, all low posters. With zero reasons attached.

[Roxy]

The vote up there that looks baddiest to me is Wilgys.

Had he not been in since he made it it would be NAI to me. But he was here and left it. That’s bothersome to me.

Yeah.

And hey, while you're here. What's your current take on Roxy?

She hasn’t said anything overtly towny, but I’m not seeing anything bad there, either. I am not surprised by her vote for Sprit based on the reasons she made it. That vote might alarm me day 3 maybe, it is pretty NAI to me Day 1, wagon or off wagon isn’t something she much cares about I think as opposed to what she thinks is right.

I think it's bad the fact she didn't say a thing about you and LC

Sorry i fell asleep again and I can't stay much

Sorry I did not conform to *your* timeline with my response.

If you have played with me before than you would know/remember that I don't give reads on LC and SVS on D1's - this would also apply to anybody I find hard to read tbh.

I will say both feel towny to me as of this moment in time.

[nutella]

Caught up but it isn't sticking, probs due to the fact I am a 4 year Olds best friend and I thoroughly enjoy every minute.

W hile I an unsure of sig I have a vibe he is probs town poss 3p but unlikely. He should however know (bc we have played many times) I post however I want to as town or bad. The noble smiley is one of my faves. Reminds me of my old dog Bear. Not voting sig.

Thunal feels different tone wise to me. I have gotten her wrong before but I have also been right. I want to just give her time bc it feels like she hardly plays anymore.

Porscha wow. You are all over the map. You have sussed people then cleared them, buddying up the thread. I've missed you and your energy in games I have played but I could vote here.

Sprityo your Darling vote is a cop out with all that is in the thread. I despise D1 low poster votes just bc they cba'ed to have opinions on things that are in the thread. I am also 98% sure low poster votes d 1 lead to much towny sadness whenI have seen them. Voting here vote sprityo

Also decided not to really comment on Capes vote for me bc he really does not know me plus the fact I really don't give a care bc Ariya is here

this pop in feels very phoned in. Like a collect call. I get you're busy with fam, just calling this post out like I see it, and I see a bit of player salad. Especially considering you said of porscha, who is leading, 'i could vote there' and then heading straight to sprityo, a vanity wagon.

[VOTE: Roxy] aubergine

feeeeeeels off

very torn between agreeing with this read and calling it fake lol

Hi Nutella, welcome!
you’ve read day 1, right?

A) so after everything I’ve written on Day 1, this is the post that you start to wonder if I’m faking it?

B) what about this post do you find fake? Do you not agree that it’s player salad?

I mean... unironically kind of yes lol
full disclosure, I casually followed along with a lot of day 1 before I knew I was subbing in and haven't really had time to reread with actual read-forming in mind. I sort of loosely thought you had a townish swagger but I have a harder time confidently calling your trains of thought definitely well-intentioned than I have for say SVS or even Cape this game so far

and for this post specifically, idk i do lean more on agreeing with it but I have mixed feelings on whether roxy's waffleyness in it is actually scum indicative

[Thunal33]

Atm my PoE is kind of boring. Sig, Roxy, Lime, Wilgy, and DM I'd consider PoE.

Yeah really boring imo, all low posters. With zero reasons attached.

That's pretty much it, yeah. I'm not going to say otherwise. I haven't caught anyone who isn't a low poster doing anything I find wolfy other than Porscha who I meta checked and realized she wasn't wolfy.

I thought your catch up post was kind of a nothing post and didn't think voting Sprityo for voting DM there made a lot of sense so I had you as just below null, but I also preferred a Sig vote over you.

[nutella]

Caught up but it isn't sticking, probs due to the fact I am a 4 year Olds best friend and I thoroughly enjoy every minute.

W hile I an unsure of sig I have a vibe he is probs town poss 3p but unlikely. He should however know (bc we have played many times) I post however I want to as town or bad. The noble smiley is one of my faves. Reminds me of my old dog Bear. Not voting sig.

Thunal feels different tone wise to me. I have gotten her wrong before but I have also been right. I want to just give her time bc it feels like she hardly plays anymore.

Porscha wow. You are all over the map. You have sussed people then cleared them, buddying up the thread. I've missed you and your energy in games I have played but I could vote here.

Sprityo your Darling vote is a cop out with all that is in the thread. I despise D1 low poster votes just bc they cba'ed to have opinions on things that are in the thread. I am also 98% sure low poster votes d 1 lead to much towny sadness whenI have seen them. Voting here vote sprityo

Also decided not to really comment on Capes vote for me bc he really does not know me plus the fact I really don't give a care bc Ariya is here

this pop in feels very phoned in. Like a collect call. I get you're busy with fam, just calling this post out like I see it, and I see a bit of player salad. Especially considering you said of porscha, who is leading, 'i could vote there' and then heading straight to sprityo, a vanity wagon.

[VOTE: Roxy] aubergine

feeeeeeels off

very torn between agreeing with this read and calling it fake lol

crazy how you just sub in and instantly clear yourself with 1 post lol

How is that clearing?

I changed my mind after I said it and she didn't respond to it but still suggested I was wolfing lol

wat
I put you in light town pile

[nutella]

ok i have read eod, main takeaway is it feels like something is fishy about the roxy/sprityo interaction in some direction, also don't like tsp's vibe so far

town
svs
michelle
abbi
cape

town?
thunal
porscha
scotty
long con

meh
pyxxy
sig
wilgy

bleh
tsp
darling
roxy
sprityo

You’re a wolf

No u