Death Note Mafia [END]

#5301

Well if any baddies missed that, there you go.

#5302

Turnip Head wrote:Russ also made a pretty indepth case on Made a while back.

I'm not sure I'd agree with calling it in depth, it feels more to me like an "I've got my eye on you and here is why" post than a case, and I also think, based on the fact he didn't vote Made today, there must be a reason for that, that to him at least made FZ a more compelling choice.

But I'm still not really sure, because Russ himself hasn't seemed entirely convinced on either of them, he's just voiced suspicions, but not even in any great detail that makes me think he's entirely confident in them any more than any one else can be.

#5303

Good points, boo.

#5304

DharmaHelper wrote:Well if any baddies missed that, there you go.

I'm the baddie right? Anyway, I'm not the one who brought it to attention. Boo did. You can't all complain that we don't read the roles and then roll your eyes when we say the obvious.

I'm going with Bea, and fuck you all (and I rarely use that word).
Going to bed. I'm sick of this game

#5305

Because outing civvies in the thread is totally a civvie thing to do.

Lynch FZ.

#5306

Matahari wrote:Reading ppl's defenses have struck me oddly. FZ is defending hard, but somehow, I don't think a civ would go that hard. Made has brought up accusations but its too little, too late. And the part about Russ is making me He has had plenty of time to talk about Bass before now too, I think my vote is going to the greater of 2 evils. voting Made

FZ- I posted.

#5307

Also, for the record, I lied about my reasoning in thinking that Kira was not paying attention to the thread. In addition to the Black Rock stuff that I mentioned, that Kira hadn't killed Russ also struck me as odd, and indicated to me that Kira had not been paying attention to the thread. I just didn't want to say that. Until now.

#5308

DharmaHelper wrote:Also, for the record, I lied about my reasoning in thinking that Kira was not paying attention to the thread. In addition to the Black Rock stuff that I mentioned, that Kira hadn't killed Russ also struck me as odd, and indicated to me that Kira had not been paying attention to the thread. I just didn't want to say that. Until now.

I think several of us had the same thought.

#5309

I actually want people to vote for me. The satisfaction in the "I told you so" would be so much greater than the enjoyment I'm currently experiencing from this game. And is there a contra colour to Sarcastic orange? Because I really need it.

NIght

#5310

FZ. wrote:and fuck you all (and I rarely use that word).

#5311

yes DH that makes me very unhappy. Boo's post and FZ.'s subsequent post have turned me toward an FZ vote.

many linkis

#5312

DharmaHelper wrote:Also, for the record, I lied about my reasoning in thinking that Kira was not paying attention to the thread. In addition to the Black Rock stuff that I mentioned, that Kira hadn't killed Russ also struck me as odd, and indicated to me that Kira had not been paying attention to the thread. I just didn't want to say that. Until now.

Ya. I just didn't agree with you. I still think bea is Light, and I think she still has the kill. If Ryuk is any of the handful of people I think it is, there's no way that got missed, which means other kills were a higher priority (have you looked at Naomi's role? It has less certainty, but is more focused, and assuming Raye has the same ability and it just passes down, that's a very risky role for Light to leave standing).

#5313

juliets wrote:yes DH that makes me very unhappy. Boo's post and FZ.'s subsequent post have turned me toward an FZ vote.

many linkis

Could I convince you to vote Made? :P

#5314

boo wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Also, for the record, I lied about my reasoning in thinking that Kira was not paying attention to the thread. In addition to the Black Rock stuff that I mentioned, that Kira hadn't killed Russ also struck me as odd, and indicated to me that Kira had not been paying attention to the thread. I just didn't want to say that. Until now.
Ya. I just didn't agree with you. I still think bea is Light, and I think she still has the kill. If Ryuk is any of the handful of people I think it is, there's no way that got missed, which means other kills were a higher priority (have you looked at Naomi's role? It has less certainty, but is more focused, and assuming Raye has the same ability and it just passes down, that's a very risky role for Light to leave standing).

No doubt there are more dangerous roles out there, but it just strikes me as odd that Kira would pass up on a sure thing and risk taking out a Sympathizer or a Yotsuba in the process.

#5315

This is going to be a VERY interesting lynch result.

#5316

thellama73 wrote:This is going to be a VERY interesting lynch result.

What makes you say that?

#5317

DharmaHelper wrote:
boo wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:Also, for the record, I lied about my reasoning in thinking that Kira was not paying attention to the thread. In addition to the Black Rock stuff that I mentioned, that Kira hadn't killed Russ also struck me as odd, and indicated to me that Kira had not been paying attention to the thread. I just didn't want to say that. Until now.
Ya. I just didn't agree with you. I still think bea is Light, and I think she still has the kill. If Ryuk is any of the handful of people I think it is, there's no way that got missed, which means other kills were a higher priority (have you looked at Naomi's role? It has less certainty, but is more focused, and assuming Raye has the same ability and it just passes down, that's a very risky role for Light to leave standing).
No doubt there are more dangerous roles out there, but it just strikes me as odd that Kira would pass up on a sure thing and risk taking out a Sympathizer or a Yotsuba in the process.

Just more risk vs reward, lots of that built into the roles. Or a concern that he was protected. Or they really aren't paying attention, in which case, oops. But I doubt it, and I think that has to be part of the conversation in deciding between FZ and Made.

I think one of them is Mikami, and I think that's the priority Kira to get (unless Higuchi has started killing, which I don't think is the case. So Mikami would be the one we could actually lynch to try and box in Light to having to hold onto the note to make him lynchable), I'm just still not sure which one of them better fits. I'd lean towards Made for overall playstyle being more in line with my suspected Mikami style, but FZ for what she has said during this lynch.

#5318

DharmaHelper wrote:
juliets wrote:yes DH that makes me very unhappy. Boo's post and FZ.'s subsequent post have turned me toward an FZ vote.

many linkis
Could I convince you to vote Made? :P

OH MY GOD I'm so confused now. Ok, convince me.

#5319

And of course, they both voted bea, so maybe they're both bad, agree with me, and are attempting some distancing in case they go down. That they didn't vote for each other to try and save themself makes me think that. So maybe they're both Kira (Mikami and Misa), and the choice doesn't even matter.

#5320

Made wrote:
thellama73 wrote:This is going to be a VERY interesting lynch result.
What makes you say that?

Nothing makes me say anything. I have free will.

#5321

Oh wait DH - I forgot i already voted. So sorry.

#5322

boo wrote: I think one of them is Mikami, and I think that's the priority Kira to get (unless Higuchi has started killing, which I don't think is the case. So Mikami would be the one we could actually lynch to try and box in Light to having to hold onto the note to make him lynchable), I'm just still not sure which one of them better fits. I'd lean towards Made for overall playstyle being more in line with my suspected Mikami style, but FZ for what she has said during this lynch.

Well if it helps you make your decision, I'm Yotsuba.

#5323

KILL HIM MP DO IT

#5324

Made wrote:
boo wrote: I think one of them is Mikami, and I think that's the priority Kira to get (unless Higuchi has started killing, which I don't think is the case. So Mikami would be the one we could actually lynch to try and box in Light to having to hold onto the note to make him lynchable), I'm just still not sure which one of them better fits. I'd lean towards Made for overall playstyle being more in line with my suspected Mikami style, but FZ for what she has said during this lynch.
Well if it helps you make your decision, I'm Yotsuba.

I used to think so.

#5325

juliets wrote:Oh wait DH - I forgot i already voted. So sorry.

Crafty!

#5326

DharmaHelper wrote:KILL HIM MP DO IT

already cleared it with him, i'm in the clear.

#5327

Made wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:KILL HIM MP DO IT
already cleared it with him, i'm in the clear.

With him maybe.

#5328

boo wrote:And of course, they both voted bea, so maybe they're both bad, agree with me, and are attempting some distancing in case they go down. That they didn't vote for each other to try and save themself makes me think that. So maybe they're both Kira (Mikami and Misa), and the choice doesn't even matter.

#5329

You know what? That does help. I'm still ok with lynching Yotsuba, nothing has changed in that regard since BWT. That was a bad move Made. And I don't really believe it still, but if that's the alignment you're going to claim, and I think FZ would actually claim detective, if you're both telling the truth and this lynch was never going to go well, you're the far better choice.

Voting made.

#5330

Wait, Made just outted himself?? And that was ok??

#5331

Going into a further point, the majority of players in this game aren't detective, so why should everyone pretend they are anyways?

Detective's aren't even objectively civvies.
Re: JC, not an out. as my role is still secret.

#5332

I'm going to go with made. I for the life of me figure out why a civ made would work so hard to "trick" me then use it as a reason to call me bad.

#5333

Team claiming has never been against the rules. Team claiming is not role outing.

#5334

Alignment claiming is technically OK, since any time someone says "I'm not bad" or "I'm a civilian", that person is technically alignment claiming, and is stating a statement that may or may not be true. If a Kira Sympathizer is stupid enough to say "I'm Kira's best buddy", that's not against the rules.

Role claiming or outing is, however, forbidden.

#5335

I'm playing Death Note Mafia.

#5336

If what Made is claiming is true, than you people are 100% not lynching a Kira or a kira supporter

#5337

Made wrote:Going into a further point, the majority of players in this game aren't detective, so why should everyone pretend they are anyways?

Detective's aren't even objectively civvies.
Re: JC, not an out. as my role is still secret.

Yes they are, detectives need the killers dead to win. That's 1 Yotsuba and a bunch of people on an altered but still fairly recognizable baddie team. That's established. What it takes for the Yotsuba to win is not established, so whether their baddies, indies, or civvies, is only clear to them.

#5338

FZ. wrote:If what Made is claiming is true, than you people are 100% not lynching a Kira or a kira supporter

What do you mean you people?

#5339

DharmaHelper wrote:
FZ. wrote:If what Made is claiming is true, than you people are 100% not lynching a Kira or a kira supporter
What do you mean you people?

What do you mean you mean you people?

NOW TAKE A BIG STEP BACK, AND LITERALLY FUCK YOUR OWN FACE.

#5340

DharmaHelper wrote:
FZ. wrote:If what Made is claiming is true, than you people are 100% not lynching a Kira or a kira supporter
What do you mean you people?

I'm not the one voting for one of us

#5341

I think it's insane to vote for a confessed Yotsuba at this point in the game. We need to catch Kira, y'all.

#5342

thellama73 wrote:I think it's insane to vote for a confessed Yotsuba at this point in the game. We need to catch Kira, y'all.

Good job doing that

#5343

thellama73 wrote:I think it's insane to vote for a confessed Yotsuba at this point in the game. We need to catch Kira, y'all.

You are correct Marty! Great Scott! To the Delorean!

#5344

thellama73 wrote:I think it's insane to vote for a confessed Yotsuba at this point in the game. We need to catch Kira, y'all.

I mean it would make sense from a Kira perspective wouldn't it? It'd be stupid to claim that everyone who votes for me is kira, but at the same time, Kira would likely be more admimate because they have no reason to second guess how helpful knowing who yotsuba could be for their win condition.

When i thought about posting my alignment immediately I thought detective would be weary, and Kira would be 100% against it. I'm still at that place, but i dunno, it's still interesting.
Game mechanic/theory y'all

#5345

It adds another complexity to an already well made game that could be fun to play with especially as we get closer to late game.

#5346

So this took a weird turn...

#5347

Now the fun part where you all learn I lied

#5348

3 missing votes? You guys were doing so well before.

#5349

DAY 6

Who killed poor Zomberella12?

Poll ended at Thu Mar 05, 2015 7:14:14 pm

Bass_the_Clever
0
No votes
bea
3
Turnip Head (2), Made (13), FZ. (17) 15%
Black Rock
0
No votes
boo
0
No votes
Boomslang
0
No votes
DharmaHelper
0
No votes
DisgruntledPorcupine
0
No votes
Epignosis
1
Metalmarsh89 (9) 5%
FZ.
4
Russtifinko (5), Epignosis (6), thellama73 (8), juliets (18) 20%
juliets
0
No votes
Made
8
DharmaHelper (4), Spacedaisy (7), zeek (12), Bass_the_Clever (14), Boomslang (15), Matahari (16), boo (19), bea (20) 40%
Matahari
0
No votes
Metalmarsh89
0
No votes
Ricochet
0
No votes
Russtifinko
0
No votes
Spacedaisy
0
No votes
thellama73
0
No votes
Turnip Head
0
No votes
zeek
0
No votes
Kira killed during Night?!?! WTF?! (host, deadies, nons)
4
MovingPictures07 (1), birdwithteeth11 (3), S~V~S (10), AceofSpaces (11) 20%

Missing votes: Black Rock, DisgruntledPorcupine, Ricochet

#5350

Day 6: Orange Is the New Lynched

MADE: Thoughts on the above, everyone?

The players continued talking, failing to acknowledge Made's input. Sockface began writing Made's name in the Lynch Note.

MADE: This is an intimidating investigation, but I still have thoughts, even if no one understands them and I am really busy. Everyone?

Still no one talked to him.

MADE: Epi, you thought DH was a detective, right?
EPIGNOSIS: Why do I get the feeling that you aren't really reading the thread?
MADE: I am, so that's a good question.
TURNIP HEAD: You're bad, Made, as I expect so much more out of you. Even if I voted for bea right away.
DHARMAHELPER: I agree.
MADE: For real, I'm trying. Why isn't anyone listening to me?

Made figured he would have to try something desperate.

MADE: OK, I'm Yotsuba.
DHARMAHELPER: Kill him!
BOO: Ya, that's the nail in your coffin, Made.

Suddenly, Made collapsed, dying of a heart attack.

Made has been lynched. He was Masahiko Kida.

It is now Night 6.

You have 24 hours to send in your night actions.