Death Note Mafia [END]

#6001

FZ. wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
FZ. wrote: linki: Are you satisfied llama?
You told me who you are voting for, you didn't tell me who I should vote for, so no.
Haha, what? Are you looking for someone to place the blame on if she comes out good?

No, I am seeing how long it takes to get you to answer a very simple question.

#6002

FZ. wrote:I just saw that Mata had already voted for me. Very interesting in light of all her other votes where she was pondering and contemplating all the aspects of everything. Have you noticed that she hasn't even asked me one question since I claimed my lynch would be a waste? Wouldn't she at all try to understand where I'm coming from.

Like you did for MM on Day 6?

FZ. wrote:linki: I would have had more fun because I'd be sitting here pleased with myself for managing to confuse you all so much

#6003

thellama73 wrote:
FZ. wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
FZ. wrote: linki: Are you satisfied llama?
You told me who you are voting for, you didn't tell me who I should vote for, so no.
Haha, what? Are you looking for someone to place the blame on if she comes out good?
No, I am seeing how long it takes to get you to answer a very simple question.

You're not going to get anything more than me, so I'd put back the stopwatch. I'm not marching by your drum. I usually vote for the person I think should be voted. Apparently, that's not the case for you. You tell people to vote for one person and then go and vote for another?
Now get of my case.

linki: Did you notice what number I am among his voters or any voters for that matter. If I recall correctly, I think I gave it all the time I could before I went to bed

#6004

*get off my case

#6005

Flashbacks to Film Directors, where I spent two days trying to get Ricochet to say he wasn't bad. He wouldn't, and he was bad.

#6006

FZ. wrote:linki: Did you notice what number I am among his voters or any voters for that matter. If I recall correctly, I think I gave it all the time I could before I went to bed

Yes. Fourth.

You didn't ask him any questions. You just went with what other people said about him.

I think you knew he wouldn't get lynched.

#6007

Epignosis wrote:
FZ. wrote:I just saw that Mata had already voted for me. Very interesting in light of all her other votes where she was pondering and contemplating all the aspects of everything. Have you noticed that she hasn't even asked me one question since I claimed my lynch would be a waste? Wouldn't she at all try to understand where I'm coming from.
Like you did for MM on Day 6?

FZ. wrote:linki: I would have had more fun because I'd be sitting here pleased with myself for managing to confuse you all so much

More interestingly, I just went to look at the polls, and Mata never voted this early. Her earliest vote was 15 on the voters and most of the times she's later than that. In addition, Mata didn't vote when we all lynched Snowman. I can't find her name on the list

#6008

Epignosis wrote:
FZ. wrote:linki: Did you notice what number I am among his voters or any voters for that matter. If I recall correctly, I think I gave it all the time I could before I went to bed
Yes. Fourth.

You didn't ask him any questions. You just went with what other people said about him.

I think you knew he wouldn't get lynched.

Actually, I was fifth.
I had to go to sleep, I admitted to not having much on him, but that I trusted those who voted for him and that it was the best option for me that day. I didn't vote for Bea because she made it seem like she couldn't be lynched with voting for herself. I didn't know he wouldn't be lynched. If I had, I would have made sure to "build" a case on him, but of course I'm lying about that too

#6009

llama and Epi, you're not really trying to get to the bottom of things, you're trying to convince yourselves you're right. I see no point in discussing this further, because nothing I say will matter.

#6010

FZ. wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
FZ. wrote:linki: Did you notice what number I am among his voters or any voters for that matter. If I recall correctly, I think I gave it all the time I could before I went to bed
Yes. Fourth.

You didn't ask him any questions. You just went with what other people said about him.

I think you knew he wouldn't get lynched.
Actually, I was fifth.

Ahhhh! I was wrong! I'm melting! melting!

#6011

FZ. wrote:llama and Epi, you're not really trying to get to the bottom of things, you're trying to convince yourselves you're right. I see no point in discussing this further, because nothing I say will matter.

Actually, I'm trying to convince other people that I'm right. That's how this game works, if I'm not mistaken.

#6012

FZ, in Epi's latest long post he points out that if we lynch you and you are an unlynchable civ nothing will happen. If you're a Kira though the Death Note will be forced out of your hands. I know this seems like a dumb question but why fight so hard and make yourself miserable if the worst thing that can happen if you're civ is nothing?

#6013

juliets wrote:FZ, in Epi's latest long post he points out that if we lynch you and you are an unlynchable civ nothing will happen. If you're a Kira though the Death Note will be forced out of your hands. I know this seems like a dumb question but why fight so hard and make yourself miserable if the worst thing that can happen if you're civ is nothing?

That was exactly the point I made. But FZ got mad at me when I said it.

.

#6014

thellama73 wrote: There's no way you would be defending yourself this hard if you had an unlynchable role. No way. This smacks of desperation.

#6015

juliets wrote:FZ, in Epi's latest long post he points out that if we lynch you and you are an unlynchable civ nothing will happen. If you're a Kira though the Death Note will be forced out of your hands. I know this seems like a dumb question but why fight so hard and make yourself miserable if the worst thing that can happen if you're civ is nothing?

I don't want to fight it, they are just getting on my nerves because they think they are sooooooooooo clever when in fact, they couldn't be farther from the truth, so I find myself arguing with them. I'm sorry that other than fighting for them, I'm actually trying to lynch those I think are baddies. I think I've just said some very good things about Mata, but they're just foolishly ignoring it. A part of me wishes they do lynch me and will then have to face the truth. But the part of me that wants to win the game, doesn't want to wast another lynch. I thought that's how we're supposed to play the game.

linki: okay

#6016

FZ. wrote:
juliets wrote:FZ, in Epi's latest long post he points out that if we lynch you and you are an unlynchable civ nothing will happen. If you're a Kira though the Death Note will be forced out of your hands. I know this seems like a dumb question but why fight so hard and make yourself miserable if the worst thing that can happen if you're civ is nothing?
I don't want to fight it, they are just getting on my nerves because they think they are sooooooooooo clever when in fact, they couldn't be farther from the truth, so I find myself arguing with them. I'm sorry that other than fighting for them, I'm actually trying to lynch those I think are baddies. I think I've just said some very good things about Mata, but they're just foolishly ignoring it. A part of me wishes they do lynch me and will then have to face the truth. But the part of me that wants to win the game, doesn't want to wast another lynch. I thought that's how we're supposed to play the game.

linki: okay

I do think I'm really clever, but it has nothing to do with this game. That's a separate issue.

#6017

Okay, I'm going to step away from the game to breath...

#6018

juliets wrote:FZ, in Epi's latest long post he points out that if we lynch you and you are an unlynchable civ nothing will happen. If you're a Kira though the Death Note will be forced out of your hands. I know this seems like a dumb question but why fight so hard and make yourself miserable if the worst thing that can happen if you're civ is nothing?

What if she is a lynchable civ?

#6019

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
juliets wrote:FZ, in Epi's latest long post he points out that if we lynch you and you are an unlynchable civ nothing will happen. If you're a Kira though the Death Note will be forced out of your hands. I know this seems like a dumb question but why fight so hard and make yourself miserable if the worst thing that can happen if you're civ is nothing?
What if she is a lynchable civ?

Then she did herself no favors by claiming to be unlynchable.

#6020

thellama73 wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
juliets wrote:FZ, in Epi's latest long post he points out that if we lynch you and you are an unlynchable civ nothing will happen. If you're a Kira though the Death Note will be forced out of your hands. I know this seems like a dumb question but why fight so hard and make yourself miserable if the worst thing that can happen if you're civ is nothing?
What if she is a lynchable civ?
Then she did herself no favors by claiming to be unlynchable.

Ture. I've bluffed as a civ before over a similar idea. It backfired.

#6021

Whackadoo.

#6022

Gesundheit.

#6023

Perestroika.

#6024

Real talk I straight skipped the last two pages.

#6025

Epignosis wrote:
FZ. wrote:linki: Did you notice what number I am among his voters or any voters for that matter. If I recall correctly, I think I gave it all the time I could before I went to bed
Yes. Fourth.

You didn't ask him any questions. You just went with what other people said about him.

I think you knew he wouldn't get lynched.

Was there anybody who thought otherwise?

#6026

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
FZ. wrote:linki: Did you notice what number I am among his voters or any voters for that matter. If I recall correctly, I think I gave it all the time I could before I went to bed
Yes. Fourth.

You didn't ask him any questions. You just went with what other people said about him.

I think you knew he wouldn't get lynched.
Was there anybody who thought otherwise?

A number of people, apparently.

Anyway, thought and knew are two different things.

#6027

Hi FZ, I'm here. I've been following along. I was sick on Monday and busy yesterday and got distracted by the other game.

I don't think FZ is bad. I've been sitting on the fence trying to decide if I believe FZ or Epig. I believe FZ now. I don't think Epig is a detective and I don't believe he's even trying to pretend to be good. Is he a Kira? Maybe? I am going to vote Epig today. He's the one I feel the most strongly of right now.

I have been back and forth with Boo all game. Right now I don't trust him.

I'm taking my 5 year old out for a special dinner now, I'll be back later and I'll put some real time into this game tonight. I'm voting now though.

#6028

I have an OOP test. I think I'll agree with the Mata voters. Be back later.

#6029

I have been back and forth most of the day between FZ. and Mata. With Mata I feel she was inconsistent with her thoughts on whether she would discuss players she trusted in the thread. In the posts I read today, she didn't sound genuine and she didn't sound like a civ who needs people to vote elsewhere for her to be saved. Could be a lynch will not kill her, though how many of those people have we got...it can't be true for everyone. Then there are the points TH has made and even though i know TH may be bad most of his points sound good - logical and thoughtful. With FZ. I still just can't understand why she would let herself become so upset about a lynch that wouldn't happen if what she says is true. I guess her answer there is that she doesn't want to waste a civ lynch on someone who is a civ when we could lynch someone who is bad. Also with FZ there is still that weird feeling I get about her telling us all FU - why would she do that if civ, especially if the lynch would do nothing to her.

So I'm going to read a little more, think about it a little more, and then vote probably in about 30 more minutes.

#6030

Epignosis wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
FZ. wrote:linki: Did you notice what number I am among his voters or any voters for that matter. If I recall correctly, I think I gave it all the time I could before I went to bed
Yes. Fourth.

You didn't ask him any questions. You just went with what other people said about him.

I think you knew he wouldn't get lynched.
Was there anybody who thought otherwise?
A number of people, apparently.

Anyway, thought and knew are two different things.

I agree. I used 'thought' because it was more accurate.

I'm also glad you're not ignoring me.

#6031

Eh, the devil you know.

#6032

The "detectives" in this game:

"Well, my gut is telling me that the man who stole your TV..."

"It wasn't a man. It was a woman. I saw her-"

"Yes, but you see, my feelings indicate that this man came in through the window..."

"But the door is broken down."

"I understand that, but if I'm being true to myself- and I've seen many crimes committed in the past- your stolen sofa can only mean that..."

"It was the TV that was stolen. The TV. You even said so yourself."

"My instinct tells me YOU are the arsonist mister."

#6033

Eh, that was a nice catch up. Here's where I stand right now:

FZ - I'm kinda leaning toward lynching her purely because if she's telling the truth, nothing will happen anyway. I go back and forth on her and right now I'm leaning Epi and llama's way. Her actions just don't match her words. She's fighting so hard but has implied she's an unlynchable civ. I wouldn't really be that phased if I was unlynchable, but she clearly is.

boo - Maybe I'm biased but his case making is filled with assumptions and commentary that is patently made up. Speculation is one thing but he asks for more and then is not satisfied when he gets it. He simply then makes that the problem and procedes to make up more commentary to fit his preconceived notions. This stinks to me, but it's bound to as I've just been on the receiving end.

Mata - I'm not entirely sure of what the case is on him, outisde inconsistency and not seeming genuine, which I generally agree with. Am I missing something crucial? I don't know, I'll reread and see if it's enough to vote on as admittedly I skimmed a little bit as I was more interested in the FZ stuff.

#6034

They're all bad. Lynch 'em all.

#6035

heh, zeek screwed up Mata's gender. :P

#6036

I just saw the bit missed about Mata, TH and Rico making good points. Though I'm taking TH with a grain of salt. Spacedaisy as well with the buddying angle. Think I may have missed that page or something!

Not sure how to vote but I've just noticed Mata has 6 votes already. Why's everyone so confident?

linki - Oops. I did that last game with someone else

#6037

Ok my time is up, I have to go fix dinner. I'm going to vote for Mata this round for the reasons I explained in my last post. It was a very hard choice because there were good reasons for both but I have to pick one so it's Mata.

#6038

I am voting FZ.

#6039

zeek wrote:I just saw the bit missed about Mata, TH and Rico making good points. Though I'm taking TH with a grain of salt. Spacedaisy as well with the buddying angle. Think I may have missed that page or something!

Not sure how to vote but I've just noticed Mata has 6 votes already. Why's everyone so confident?

linki - Oops. I did that last game with someone else

Don't worry, I also did that a lot in my first game and actually got some heat for that, at least for a while. :P

Not sure where you saw me "making good points" about Mata, though. If it's that Misa BTSC I pointed out - again, it was only meant to clarify things.

#6040

Currently 40 minutes until lynch's end and I am missing 4 votes.

#6041

BR's reasoning caught my attention because I think she is the second (Spacedaisy too) to have said that she won't go with FZ. because she doesn't actually think Epig is a detective and therefore doesn't (or can't) trust any of his cases / agenda etc. Which in abstracto, is perfectly fine. But I haven't seen the same angle of trust taken from Russ' side (a very likely confirmed deceased civ) and his possible check & vote for FZ. Actually Spacedaisy did say she thinks there's too much assumption or guesswork in those math assumptions about Russ' check, any way you take it. But I don't think I noticed any reasoning from BR, instead. They've voted for Elo when L made the call for her (Spacedaisy in good faith, BR more reluctantly).

Still: 100% trust in L...ok, 0% trust in Epig...ok, but not addressing Russ' chance for a good call on FZ being bad (which the math, at least, could possibly be true that it was greater than 50-50) and expressing a degree of trust or not in that...

#6042

MovingPictures07 wrote:Currently 40 minutes until lynch's end and I am missing 4 votes.

I forgot the night was shorter and the deadline was moved two hours earlier.

#6043

Ricochet wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Currently 40 minutes until lynch's end and I am missing 4 votes.
I forgot the night was shorter and the deadline was moved two hours earlier.

No worries, my post is merely for informative reasons, especially due to the time switch. Every player has an opportunity to vote until the deadline is complete.

#6044

4 people haven't voted yet:
llama, Zeek, Rico and Bass.
I say at least one of them is bad. Bass is the natural option.
I also have to wonder why BR took the easy way out. If she really thinks both me and Mata are civvies, I'd get it, but she hasn't really stated that she feels that strongly about either of us, so I have to say I'm pinged by that vote.

#6045

Black Rock wrote:Hi FZ, I'm here. I've been following along. I was sick on Monday and busy yesterday and got distracted by the other game.

I don't think FZ is bad. I've been sitting on the fence trying to decide if I believe FZ or Epig. I believe FZ now. I don't think Epig is a detective and I don't believe he's even trying to pretend to be good. Is he a Kira? Maybe? I am going to vote Epig today. He's the one I feel the most strongly of right now.

I have been back and forth with Boo all game. Right now I don't trust him.

I'm taking my 5 year old out for a special dinner now, I'll be back later and I'll put some real time into this game tonight. I'm voting now though.

KNEW IT

#6046

DharmaHelper wrote:
Black Rock wrote:Hi FZ, I'm here. I've been following along. I was sick on Monday and busy yesterday and got distracted by the other game.

I don't think FZ is bad. I've been sitting on the fence trying to decide if I believe FZ or Epig. I believe FZ now. I don't think Epig is a detective and I don't believe he's even trying to pretend to be good. Is he a Kira? Maybe? I am going to vote Epig today. He's the one I feel the most strongly of right now.

I have been back and forth with Boo all game. Right now I don't trust him.

I'm taking my 5 year old out for a special dinner now, I'll be back later and I'll put some real time into this game tonight. I'm voting now though.
KNEW IT

What did you know?

#6047

Epignosis wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Black Rock wrote:Hi FZ, I'm here. I've been following along. I was sick on Monday and busy yesterday and got distracted by the other game.

I don't think FZ is bad. I've been sitting on the fence trying to decide if I believe FZ or Epig. I believe FZ now. I don't think Epig is a detective and I don't believe he's even trying to pretend to be good. Is he a Kira? Maybe? I am going to vote Epig today. He's the one I feel the most strongly of right now.

I have been back and forth with Boo all game. Right now I don't trust him.

I'm taking my 5 year old out for a special dinner now, I'll be back later and I'll put some real time into this game tonight. I'm voting now though.
KNEW IT
What did you know?

That Black Rock is full of poo,

#6048

Show me where Black Rock even REMOTELY brought up Epi as suspicious prior to today. Why throw a vote away so late in the game??

#6049

Where did her boo suspicion go? Where did her llama suspicion go? B-A-D-D-I-E

#6050

FZ., if I would have had more time than 30 minutes, I would have gone back extensively to your supposedly "insinuative" post.

You say that if Russ would have role checked and got a baddie role, his vote would have depended on whether that role could be lynched or not.

You say that if he got an unlynchable role, he'd have suggested perhaps he thinks you're bad, but he wouldn't have voted for you. (I can agree to this, btw)
You say that the only way he would have voted for you was if he actually got a "baddie role that can be lynched". (I can totally agree with this, btw)

That's two clear, opposite options.

But I think I asked you about a third option: if Russ would have voted you, if he actually got a baddie role that can in theory be lynched, but might turn into an unlynchable role under lynch pressure, namely Light or Misa.

You decided not to answer to this, saying you've said everything there is to say (or maybe you decided not to answer to another question of mine, because I can agree my posts was mixed with questionings, so idk).

Could still give me a quick view on this third option?

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous