Harry Stephen Keeler [ENDGAME]

#3351

I didn't think he was tedious

Dearborn.

#3352

hey everyone sorry about missing the vote it was a busy Easter.

#3353

Dom wrote:i think the baddies put the safe up there to make us scared.

I think I agree with this because there really isn't a price for the safe. I would think they would want one of the five treasures that they need.

#3354

Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Dom wrote:i think the baddies put the safe up there to make us scared.
I think I agree with this because there really isn't a price for the safe. I would think they would want one of the five treasures that they need.

Exactly. There doesn't seem to be a logical reason for this tbh.

#3355

S~V~S wrote:I didn't think he was tedious

Dearborn.

I don't think he was either. Rereading him was though, and there were reasons for me rereading him which I won't share yet.

#3356

Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Dom wrote:i think the baddies put the safe up there to make us scared.
I think I agree with this because there really isn't a price for the safe. I would think they would want one of the five treasures that they need.

I feel more comfortable with this reasoning. However, I read it as the person who wants to trade the safe away offered not targetting Celestials as a prerequisite for trading, not as a bargaining chip. To the instigator, the safe is only for sale if the mafia will agree to terms.

#3357

Dearborn St.

#3358

Clark Street

#3359

I voted Clark St.

#3360

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Dom wrote:i think the baddies put the safe up there to make us scared.
I think I agree with this because there really isn't a price for the safe. I would think they would want one of the five treasures that they need.
I feel more comfortable with this reasoning. However, I read it as the person who wants to trade the safe away offered not targetting Celestials as a prerequisite for trading, not as a bargaining chip. To the instigator, the safe is only for sale if the mafia will agree to terms.

Or Dom is one of the Celestials and he is trying to play the civves...

#3361

Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Dom wrote:i think the baddies put the safe up there to make us scared.
I think I agree with this because there really isn't a price for the safe. I would think they would want one of the five treasures that they need.
I feel more comfortable with this reasoning. However, I read it as the person who wants to trade the safe away offered not targetting Celestials as a prerequisite for trading, not as a bargaining chip. To the instigator, the safe is only for sale if the mafia will agree to terms.
Or Dom is one of the Celestials and he is trying to play the civves...

But even if he is a celestial, and even if the celestials really did put that item up for sale (which I seriously doubt) there is no way the baddies can promise not to target a celestial. They don't know who is celestial and who is civ. I truly don't believe Dom is just trying to pull the wool over our eyes because the whole thing just doesn't make sense.

#3362

RIP Liz

#3363

Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Dom wrote:i think the baddies put the safe up there to make us scared.
I think I agree with this because there really isn't a price for the safe. I would think they would want one of the five treasures that they need.
I feel more comfortable with this reasoning. However, I read it as the person who wants to trade the safe away offered not targetting Celestials as a prerequisite for trading, not as a bargaining chip. To the instigator, the safe is only for sale if the mafia will agree to terms.
Or Dom is one of the Celestials and he is trying to play the civves...

Dom is not a Celestial, I can almost guarantee you that.

#3364

45 minutes to go, missing two PMs!

#3365

Where to, Charlie?

Poll runs till Mon Apr 06, 2015 6:00:55 pm

Archer Ave.
0
No votes

Clark St.
5
DFaraday (4), Metalmarsh89 (7), Turnip Head (13), Bass_the_Clever (14), rabbit8 (15)
31%

Dearborn St.
5
Dom (6), S~V~S (9), juliets (10), Bullzeye (12), Black Rock (16)
31%

Randolph St.
1
Canucklehead (11)
6%

22nd St.
2
Vompatti (2), Elohcin (3)
13%

Someplace I can get a deep dish pizza.(Host/Mod/Dead/NP)
3
thellama73 (1), Epignosis (5), LizKeen (8)
19%

Total votes : 16

#3366

DAY 7

#3367

Two deaths tonight? That's new... and unnerving.

#3368

juliets wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Dom wrote:i think the baddies put the safe up there to make us scared.
I think I agree with this because there really isn't a price for the safe. I would think they would want one of the five treasures that they need.
I feel more comfortable with this reasoning. However, I read it as the person who wants to trade the safe away offered not targetting Celestials as a prerequisite for trading, not as a bargaining chip. To the instigator, the safe is only for sale if the mafia will agree to terms.
Or Dom is one of the Celestials and he is trying to play the civves...
But even if he is a celestial, and even if the celestials really did put that item up for sale (which I seriously doubt) there is no way the baddies can promise not to target a celestial. They don't know who is celestial and who is civ. I truly don't believe Dom is just trying to pull the wool over our eyes because the whole thing just doesn't make sense.

this.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Dom wrote:i think the baddies put the safe up there to make us scared.
I think I agree with this because there really isn't a price for the safe. I would think they would want one of the five treasures that they need.
I feel more comfortable with this reasoning. However, I read it as the person who wants to trade the safe away offered not targetting Celestials as a prerequisite for trading, not as a bargaining chip. To the instigator, the safe is only for sale if the mafia will agree to terms.
Or Dom is one of the Celestials and he is trying to play the civves...
Dom is not a Celestial, I can almost guarantee you that.

that's a bold move.

#3369

Bullzeye wrote:Two deaths tonight? That's new... and unnerving.

tbh

#3370

RIP DF and Metalmarsh

and i agree I am most unnerved by this development.

#3371

tfw when you spend like 4 hours rereading everyone and find out you are dead.

#3372

RIP guys. Was he poisoned then? I didn't think there was a poisoner in this game.

#3373

He meaning DF.

#3374

I think there's a doctor on the baddie team that does vaguely worded baddie things.....which I would be very willing to interpret as poisoning and the like, given recent events.

#3375

Oh ok, that makes sense. Had to go back and read the role but that looks like what happened.

#3376

Canucklehead wrote:I think there's a doctor on the baddie team that does vaguely worded baddie things.....which I would be very willing to interpret as poisoning and the like, given recent events.

Canuck where are your thoughts right now?

#3377

Dom wrote:
Canucklehead wrote:I think there's a doctor on the baddie team that does vaguely worded baddie things.....which I would be very willing to interpret as poisoning and the like, given recent events.
Canuck where are your thoughts right now?

Baddie thought most likely.

#3378

I don't know about you guys, but I had an awesome weekend!

We had a big family party of Saturday for my sisters birthday

Then we had Easter with all the cousins & the cousins kids, so we had almost 25 kids egg hunting, then egg rolling. Plus tons of wine, snacks and good times

Then next weekend is Orthodox Easter, and I get to do it all again (with even MORE people) with the other side of the family

Squeeeee!!!!!

#3379

I have another idea. Remember how Sandringham takes on different roles and uses their powers? Could he have taken on the millionaire's power last night and killed DF thinking he was a baddie?

#3380

Rest in peace Marshy and DF

I agree it looks like a poisoning of some sort.

#3381

juliets wrote:I have another idea. Remember how Sandringham takes on different roles and uses their powers? Could he have taken on the millionaire's power last night and killed DF thinking he was a baddie?

I really like this idea. I didn't think of it. It could explain it... frankly I thought DF was a weird person for the baddies to target so this would make sense.

#3382

Also, rezz please. I don't care which one of me.

#3383

I guess we'll find out at the end of the game.

TH-- where you at?

#3384

AAAAA
EEEEE
IIIII
OOOOO
UUUUU
YYYYY

#3385

Dom wrote:I guess we'll find out at the end of the game.

TH-- where you at?

I'm going to reread Canuck and Elo when I get home. They are two players who I usually have some sort of opinion on by now, and both of them have evaded my radar so far. I thought that Elo's reactions during Epi's lynch felt a little out of character so I'm going to start my search there.

I had also planned to look into DF but that's moot now. I was also worried about Bass but MM said something re: Bass that made me take pause. Id'd like to know where Bass is looking for this lynch.

Where you at Dom?

#3386

Long Con wrote:AAAAA
EEEEE
IIIII
OOOOO
UUUUU
YYYYY

Eh?

#3387

Turnip Head wrote:
Dom wrote:I guess we'll find out at the end of the game.

TH-- where you at?
I'm going to reread Canuck and Elo when I get home. They are two players who I usually have some sort of opinion on by now, and both of them have evaded my radar so far. I thought that Elo's reactions during Epi's lynch felt a little out of character so I'm going to start my search there.

I had also planned to look into DF but that's moot now. I was also worried about Bass but MM said something re: Bass that made me take pause. Id'd like to know where Bass is looking for this lynch.

Where you at Dom?

I don't suspect Bass because LC was right that it's unlikely that if they switched roles that MM and Bass are on different alliances.

Elo-- I usually have no opinion on her. So, IDK about that.

Cancuk-- I usually have a read. A quick reread had nothing of substance tbqh. That concerns me.

I'm also suspicious of SVS.

#3388

I've reread early-game Canuck, and this is the only post that sticks out to me atm:

Canucklehead wrote:Sorry for not being around, my participation will increase as the game goes on and once RR is done...but you know me. I'm useless until I get my bearings and get drawn in to a game.

Canuck said she would get more talkative as the game went on, but the opposite has actually been true. In my estimation, Canuck had more posts and meatier posts during the first half of the game, and she has gradually dropped off since then. She posted four times on Day 5 and only once on Day 6.

That's not to say that Canuck hasn't made her opinions clearly known... I think that she has. She just doesn't seem as involved as I might expect her to be by now.

#3389

Turnip Head wrote:I've reread early-game Canuck, and this is the only post that sticks out to me atm:

Canucklehead wrote:Sorry for not being around, my participation will increase as the game goes on and once RR is done...but you know me. I'm useless until I get my bearings and get drawn in to a game.
Canuck said she would get more talkative as the game went on, but the opposite has actually been true. In my estimation, Canuck had more posts and meatier posts during the first half of the game, and she has gradually dropped off since then. She posted four times on Day 5 and only once on Day 6.

That's not to say that Canuck hasn't made her opinions clearly known... I think that she has. She just doesn't seem as involved as I might expect her to be by now.

Does that mean something to you though? I used to know Canuck's game much better than I do at this point.

#3390

No it doesn't mean anything to me yet, I'm more interested in hearing her response to it if anything. I've felt she's been rational and cautious this game; that is behavior that would benefit both civvies and baddies.

#3391

I think I've mentioned this before, but my prelims start in 6 days. The fact that I am posting at all is ridiculous, tbqh.
My posting rate will not increase. I will keep voting, and keep posting when I have a moment, but that's really all you should expect from me. I'm utterly useless other than as a civ number, but I'm definitely not a baddie.

#3392

All the snow finally melted

This has been a horrible winter (two in a row!) but it is finally over now

Have a fun day, catch you guys later

#3393

Convenient.

#3394

I'm all for voting Canuck and SVS.

Or Dom and TH. .........

#3395

ae iuo uyioa eaoiyuae aeeiuyo aoyoaeu aoiuaeya a iuyuiea oyaeu

#3396

rabbit8 wrote:I'm all for voting Canuck and SVS.

Or Dom and TH. .........

Hilarious, yes....but...

Why group me and TH?

#3397

Dom wrote:
rabbit8 wrote:I'm all for voting Canuck and SVS.

Or Dom and TH. .........
Hilarious, yes....but...

Why group me and TH?

Just an observation of the game. I could see you two being on one side of the coin if SVS and or Canuck are not bad.

#3398

So LC and SVS have a posting curse again?

I'm going to read over Canuck today. Make my own opinion on her.

#3399

what do people think of bwt?

#3400

I haven't suspected him at all.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who iced Dom?