fingersplints wrote:If Elo doesn't want to play she should be replaced. It's only Day 1. I don't want to risk losing a valuable civvie role. I think it would have been more fair to the host for him to have cut a role then to lose a more important role for this reason.
I'm considering voting Epi now. I don't like that he is pushing this.
It's Mafia. You always risk losing a valuable civilian role when you vote. Nature of the beast.
Do you think Elohcin has a valuable civilian role?
S~V~S wrote:I just looked, this thread was opened Sunday at 7:45, Timmer tried to sign up Sunday at 3:48. There was a willing replacement if Epi wanted to play so bad, and Elo did not.
I kinda am not as sure I buy that story anymore. Splints is right; this seems like a desperation play to me.
It's the truth.
It's why I mentioned reading between the lines.
Little while... (Replacement)
4
bea (4), MovingPictures07 (16), nijuukyugou (18), DisgruntledPorcupine (33)
12%
There were four people who signed up to be replacements. Evidently, Eloh didn't asked to be replaced. Unless I'm on a team with an inactive, I don't ask the host to replace other people.
FZ. wrote:I just read Epi's post and all those following. I too wonder why not just let Timmer replace her, or anyone for that matter. Also, since he admitted that he doesn't necessarily think she's bad, would civvie Epi really let a non baddie die just like that? Also, like SVS and Splints said, I can see him using this as a manipulation, because if he's a baddie and is taking her down in a lynch, he can then kill someone else during the night, if he even has a NK. Maybe that's his was of making her think he isn't bad.
I'm not sold on this theory, but the fact that he's willing to let someone who he doesn't know is bad, die, makes me think he doesn't really care if the civvies win.
Epi, can you please explain why you have no problem getting a possible non baddie lynched, instead of trying to replace Eloh?
Between llama and Epi, I'm still more worried about llama, but I have about 2 more hours to decide.
linki: BF, he was wording it to make it look like a brilliant discovery. No, I don't buy it. Sorry
Uh, no- I didn't "admit that I don't necessarily think she's bad." What I said was that I think it's highly unlikely she's an Old Rogue, making it more likely that she's a New Rogue. That's manipulating what I said.
Tell me, do you KNOW if someone is bad right now?
Roxy wrote:FZ - Tbh when Epi hosts he never mk's non players and instead replaces them as soon as he is asked to otherwise they roll along without doing anything. I do not understand why heis so willing to lead a lynch on Elo (who by his words does not want to play) instead of getting her replaced. It goes against everything I Know about Epi inre: to replacements/nonplayers.
Eloh is the one who needs to asked to be replaced. I don't asked to replace other players.
++++
Consider this: Eloh practically admitted that she doesn't have BTSC, meaning my assumption about her is true. If my math is correct, then she is unlikely to be an Old Rogue.