Sloonei -- (#1 Very slight civilian read, #2 Very slight mafia read, #3 Very slight civilian read, #4 Moderate civilian read) -- As I said in #4, "His mafia hunting has been top notch and seems genuine. Up he goes. Don't feel confident enough to raise him above moderate though." This pretty much stands.
sanmateo -- (#1 Very slight mafia read, #2 Very slight civilian read, #3 no change, #4 Strong civilian read) -- DROP! Drops from my top town read to slight civilian read, due to lack of contributions during D2 thus far, more doubt surrounding him, and his quick Elo vote coupled with saying I'm "definitely bad" (yes, I realize I quickly voted for her as well). I also am looking for more detail regarding his reads on everyone at the moment, as he is only issuing opinions on a few players.
birdwithteeth11 -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2, #3 no change, #4 Very slight civilian read) -- I appreciate his contributions, though I want more. So far I feel relatively good about him, but anything is possible.
Dragon D. Luffy -- (#1 Slight civilian read, #2, #3 no change, #4 Very slight civilian read) -- As I said in #4: "Still think he reads genuine, but there's no denying that his vote makes him drop, and his fate could easily be mafia pending Epi's alignment. Appreciate that he ramped up the solid contributions though." I feel about the same, though I'm getting ready to drop him one more. I hope to hear more from him about players soon.
Turnip Head -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2 Very slight civilian read, #3 no change, #4 No read or unsure) -- ELEVATE! Back up to very slight civilian read. I feel just a little bit better about him than I did before, but still haven't been able to discern his intentions. His contributions today were insightful; assuming he continues, he may soon be in my slight civilian reads. Although I did get a bit paranoid of his discussion at times, I think it was coming more from a civilian perspective if I had to choose.
Black Rock -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2 Very slight mafia read, #3 Very slight civilian read, #4 no change) -- DROP! Since she is sick and some good points have been brought up during D2, I'm back to really having no idea whatsoever about BR. Hopefully she feels better and she can properly contribute soon.
Vompatti (Dom) -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2, #3, #4 no change) -- Same as before. POST MORE. Now that it's Vomps, I'm not sure I expect anything, but I've seen a civilian Vomps actually care, so I know it's possible. Let's please see that Vomps again if he is indeed civilian.
G-Man -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2, #3, #4 no change) -- Although it is pretty much certain to me that G-Man's posting is self-inflicted (though I suppose it could be a multi-period curse, but that seems so extremely unlikely), he has been contributing. I'm just unsure what to make of him still, completely.
acrosstheaether -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2, #3, #4 no change) -- DROP! Dropping her because she needs to contribute.
fingersplints -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2, #3 no change, #4 Very slight mafia read) -- As I said in #4: "Dropped her down to very slightly mafia read based on gut interpretation of her posts and her inability to fully substantiate reads, but I could be way off base. Having reevaluated, this is incredibly, incredibly slight." This pretty much still stands. When I asked her for a top read, she couldn't give me one, then she said she still really suspects BR. Seems odd to me. She needs to clarify her reads on players and contribute more or else I will drop her further. Just unsure what to make of her, but still leaning more mafia than not.
Roxy -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2 no change, #3 Very slight civilian read, #4 no change) -- DROP! Jay's ISO, in combination with Rox's low posting, have led me to drop her quite a bit. I really hope she comes back to the game to provide more clarification and respond to Jay's concerns.
TinyBubbles -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2 no change, #3 Very slight mafia read, #4 no change) -- Her vote for Elo is difficult to interpret, considering how new she is to the game. I really can't tell whether she is being genuine as a civilian or playing a new mafia game any better than I could before after her D2 behavior. As such, she stays in my very slightly leaning mafia read.
Bass_the_Clever -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2 Very slight mafia read, #3 Slight mafia read, #4 no change) -- In #3 and #4, I said: "And down he goes, but only to the "slight" read level, since I'm still far from sure we're seeing a baddie Bass here. That said, I'm really putting the pressure on him now by making him my top mafia read at the moment. Good points: I feel he engaged me and the thread in what he is thinking more than he has in recent games. I hope he continues this in the future. Bad points: His throwing out my behavior as something to keep an eye on, as if to bandwagon. Not having any suspects (though this is par for the course). He finally started throwing out slight pings but only after I prodded him considerably, which lines up with meta, but makes me feel as though he's hiding something from me. He could be a civilian hiding something, but he shouldn't be, and I really want him to engage more." These feelings still stand, pending his opinions as well as Elo and Epi's alignments. POST MORE.
Elohcin -- (#1 No read or unsure, #2 Slight civilian read, #3 no change, #4 Very strong mafia read) -- I've said a lot about this. Succinctly: She voted for Golden despite previously leaning civilian on him, both unexplained, and her behavior has been subsequently dismissive, emotionally-charged, and seems very fabricated to me. I've wavered a bit throughout Day 2 on my certainty level, but I'm standing by a strong mafia read, just a little bit less certain than I was feeling EoD D1, as some good points were made mostly by TH. I still strongly advocate her lynch, however.
For reference:
Very strong civilian read
Strong civilian read
Moderate civilian read
Slight civilian read
Very slight civilian read
No read or unsure
Very slight mafia read
Slight mafia read
Moderate mafia read
Strong mafia read
Very strong mafia read
Just a reminder: I have a lot of PhD stuff to do tomorrow, so I won't be around much at all (for real this time). Probably will pop in around EoD.
My main objective when I return is to sort through my very slight mafia reads since I'm having trouble discerning how I feel about them relative to each other.