Golden wrote:JJ, here is what I think.
I think if Bass didn't die, ninja did, and ninja is civ.
That could be. This isn't a 100% factual thing without a flip, but it could be.
Golden wrote:I think if hedge didn't die, probably DF did, and when I read DF back I don't agree with the case.
The tally does not reflect this statement.
Golden wrote:And I REALLY think I'm beginning to become suspicious of you for calling people anti-town just because they are involved in lynching civvies when there is literally no evidence that you have been voting for or casing people who are actually mafia either.
This is completely irrelevant. Even if I had taken part in all three of these lynches I would still view everyone else with some degree of suspicion. I would acknowledge that I was wrong, as anyone can be, and try to discern who among the
other voters was not merely
wrong. I'm not casting this suspicion upon people just because I wasn't involved with the lynches (indeed, I voted for Bass during the Cobalt lynch). I am casting suspicion because it is
inherently suspicious to lynch three straight townies. No matter what. And when that happens immediately after I join a game, don't you think it makes a lot of sense that my focus would be on that scenario?
Golden wrote:I personally think there is literally no case to be made that I am bad.
We'll see about that. I think there is
literally almost never a situation which satisfies this self-perception, but we'll see.
Golden wrote:I already responded to this last time. I also think if you read my post history carefully and thoroughly, someone as sharp as you can even figure out why...
So, put up or shut up. I don't want to hear you throw vague accusations around about me again until you have ISO'd and cased me, because you have now done it several days in a row...
I absolutely do not care what you want and do not want to hear from me. I care about trying to solve this game, which is always going to include looking into the player Golden. I have expressed some misgivings about you, but I have not voted for you or called for your lynch in any way. So your reaction to that is entirely nonsensical and frankly does not help you with me. You're going to have to calm down and give me an opportunity to investigate your content. Once I've done that I'll determine how I feel and you know very well that I'll post all of it. I don't care if it's the night phase.
It'll probably be later this evening when I can be here long enough to take on the workload. You
do have a lot of posts.
Golden wrote:Yesterday you got a, meh, can't expect JJ to have caught everything up, I can see why he isn't so ok with my last two days.
Today you get a full blown "I am now officially suspicious of you".
This progression is unfair at best and manipulative at worst. You can't expect me to just shrug at three town lynches in a row. I will never do that. It doesn't mean you're mafia, but it definitely means you're worth a reassessment.