JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Sun Feb 11, 2018 11:51 pm
ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Sun Feb 11, 2018 11:50 pm
Nope, not on RYM that I can recall, other games on other forums where I got my ass handed to me by some really manipulative “supertown” SOBs.
What are your reads on the four people in question?
dunya
Kylemii
Dragon D. Luffy
colonialbob
Dunya: mostly positive, actually, but strong players ought to be kept under scrutiny. Excitement scares me in Mafia because I know I’m always more excited when I get to lie. Then again she was excited enough to invite me before roles were called so it also seems genuine.
Kylemii: not a lot here for me, but I can’t agree with your read because it’s based on a meta I have no knowledge of. Nothing seems particularly scummy but nothing seems particularly towny.
DDL: I’m not sold on the case against Mac that people were all aboard for a little bit ago. The vote against him here struck me as capitalizing on his post with a rationale that looks good at first but not really under scrutiny. I don’t think a scum would offer himself up so easily on Day 1 as a sacrificial lamb when there’s slight momentum against him, but a townie might. I don’t also see anything in the hunting style that’s particularly better than anybody else’s.
Colonialbob: again, not a lot of feelings here but see the above re: hunting style
(In general the interactions between Mac and others are not adding up, including to Mac himself, and pursuing something there, between those players, might be the best route to go.)
The main theme here is that your rationale is based on intuitions I don’t share or information I don’t have access to, which isn’t your fault.
Also, I really want to know why Epignosis wants to know who we would pick?