Part II
The following only applies if we assume that a) No mafia member had the ability to kill on a tribe he or she was not on, and b) No mafia member, intentionally or inadvertently, killed one of their own. If either of these are true, especially the former, then all of this can go out the window.
Pikachu:
colonialbob
Dragon D Luffy - Killed Night 14 by the Evens, so his first life was not Even.
Dharmahelper
dom
Epignosis
Long Con - Evil Even
nutella - Evil Even
Quin - Killed Night 12 by the Evens, so his first life was not Even.
speedchuck
sprityo
S~V~S - Killed Night 6 by the Evens, so her first life was not Even.
Cerberus:
Boomslang
DrWilgy - Strex
insertnamehere
JackofHearts2005
Kylemii
LoRab - Strex
Marmot - Strex
Ninja
Scotty - Killed Night 2 by Strex, so his first life was not Strex.
sig
Sloonei
Spacedaisy
Strex conducted no kills against Pikachu until Jack, but the kill could have been submitted before the switch, and Wilgy and Marmot were both switched over with Jack. This somewhat implies that all of Strex was on Cerberus from the beginning.
If that's true, then it means Strex had no idea what was going on in Pikachu before Day 8.
The Evil Evens killed people on both tribes. Scotty was killed Night 2, which implies that at least one Evil Even is among the original Cerberus population. That's Boomslang, insertnamehere, Kylemii, Scotty, Sloonei, and Spacedaisy.
Scotty was killed by a Cerberus Evil Even Night 2. That would mean Scotty did not come to Pikachu and kill sprityo. Scotty and Sloonei both argued over which Strex members to kill first.
This clears Scotty, and he should not be lynched today (unless you believe he turned or is a malevolent independent). I note that at this moment, both S~V~S and Kylemii are parked on Scotty.
Sloonei's first role was one that could steal powers and use them on other people, and there was no limit on how many times he could use the ability. If you believe Sloonei is an Evil Even, then it means he could have eventually copied LC and nutella's very powerful roles multiple times and caused wicked chaos. I understand Sloonei was on a different tribe than both of them and this opportunity never presented itself, but all that would have had to have happened was Lorab pushing the button Night 1, potentially putting Sloonei in the same tribe as Long Con and nutella, and he would have had a field day copying their vote manipulations and fake revelations.
I have a hard damn time believing that role existed on a team with Long Con and nutella. A hard damn time. Unless you believe he turned or is a malevolent independent,
Sloonei should not be lynched today. I'm marking Sloonei off the list.
That leaves Kylemii and Spacedaisy, neither of whom voted for sig Day 6 when sig was tied up for Long Con on the other tribe.
This will require further investigation.
Pikachu 2:
Epignosis
Kylemii
Scotty
Sloonei
Spacedaisy
Cerberus 2:
Boomslang
colonialbob
dom
Dragon D. Luffy
insertnamehere
Quin
S~V~S
If you believe that Strex was limited to Cerberus until Day 8, then there is less reason to suspect those who migrated from Pikachu to Cerberus. That would be colonialbob, Dom, DDL, Quin, and S~V~S. If I had to name one of these as Strex, it would be colonialbob for the same reasons I gave Day 13 in my big damn post. Boomslang and insertnamehere remain secondary suspects at this time.