U-Pick Mafia Vol 1 - Game Over

[Quin]

I'd like to see a past scum Golden's reaction to getting heat from anyone.

I can’t channel my past self.

Economics, Montreal, syndicate 1, haiku, I can’t think of all my scum games off the top of my head.

Phenon. AKA my lesser known best mafia performance.

I wasn’t lynched there either.

yeah. i exposed this fucking guy and he managed to convince everyone the doctor was a scum role and got me lynched. fuck that.

[dunya]

i'm breaking my own rule. i will not discuss this ridiculous theory again for the rest of day 1.

What did Golden accuse you of?

"trying to control the narrative."

[Golden]

I'd like to see a past scum Golden's reaction to getting heat from anyone.

I can’t channel my past self.

Economics, Montreal, syndicate 1, haiku, I can’t think of all my scum games off the top of my head.

Phenon. AKA my lesser known best mafia performance.

I wasn’t lynched there either.

yeah. i exposed this fucking guy and he managed to convince everyone the doctor was a scum role and got me lynched. fuck that.

I thought we exploded together? Am I misremembering?

You were scum tho

[Quin]

I'd like to see a past scum Golden's reaction to getting heat from anyone.

I can’t channel my past self.

Economics, Montreal, syndicate 1, haiku, I can’t think of all my scum games off the top of my head.

Phenon. AKA my lesser known best mafia performance.

I wasn’t lynched there either.

yeah. i exposed this fucking guy and he managed to convince everyone the doctor was a scum role and got me lynched. fuck that.

I thought we exploded together? Am I misremembering?

You were scum tho

we did. my last act of resistance. or speedchucks, whatever.

[Golden]

i'm breaking my own rule. i will not discuss this ridiculous theory again for the rest of day 1.

What did Golden accuse you of?

"trying to control the narrative."

Specifically through the use of discrediting through dismissive terms that generally stated an emotion or motive to my posts.

[Golden]

The only others I can think of when looking through the hall of fame are world reborn and guess who. Didn’t get lynched in those either.

[dunya]

i'm breaking my own rule. i will not discuss this ridiculous theory again for the rest of day 1.

What did Golden accuse you of?

"trying to control the narrative."

Specifically through the use of discrediting through dismissive terms that generally stated an emotion or motive to my posts.

[dunya]

Out of baseless expectation, yes. "It should be, therefore it is." dunya is not being unreasonable. And from her posts she's not stopping you from pushing the alternative either.

I don't care about any alternative being pushed or not pushed. I just care about a player knowing more than she should. She knew way more than she should about the Hellenic League and nobody called it out. I'm here to fix that this time.

actually, I knew that we knew nova was aligned with us right after Colin was lynched. I also knew that nova didn't know any of us. I pushed out the concept that members of the hellinic league don't know us AND we don't know them, because in the OP it states they won't be informed (although it doesn't say the Persians don't know who is aligned with them). so if you want to get technical, I was bullshitting and not using my TMI, to debunk the theory that 3ps knew the scum team if they were aligned with them--which was really in the OP written by you. I just made the OP look like the team leaders also wouldn't be informed, although you didn't specifically imply that in your post, but you didn't say anything to contradict that either so...it worked.

and also, why don't you direct some of that mighty heat and passion onto Golden? Here's a scenario. He has the towniest townie role in all of Towndom, and he drew a scum card. he comes in here to theorize based on that TMI and I discredit him immediately off the bat because things like that are wrong based on ethics, and he doesn't like that (ohhhhhhhh lala I'm projecting more on Golden, take my projections, they are you, become them, YOU ARE ONE).

JJJ, here's what I think (time for more projecting!): you're upset I was scum in FE. You just witnessed my Ancient Greece game at the vantage point of a host who can see everything as it happens. You literally told me yesterday you have new scumtells on me based on those games. You're trying to look for reasons why I'm scum, which is fine, that's scumhunting. But you're building theories and reasons to try and convince yourself I'm scum because you want me to be scum and you want to be right about me being scum. the fact you still haven't made a read on me despite me making up like 99% of your posts (wow see I'm so good with numbers like you) is more proof of that. ugh, I'm gonna throw up from all this projecting. How's that for a kick-ass theory?

[Golden]

None of your kick-ass theories are about you not being bad. They're just about others not really believing in their suspicions.

In a two scum game, why would any suspicion of you be a lie?

[dunya]

dunya, I'd like to refresh myself on civ dunya to make sure what I remember is accurate and to contrast that with what I am learning about bad dunya. What are your two most recent civ games?

Mountain Mafia, Mortal Kombat, Vocaroo 2, Seinfeld, The Search for Quin

[dunya]

None of your kick-ass theories are about you not being bad. They're just about others not really believing in their suspicions.

In a two scum game, why would any suspicion of you be a lie?

wow you're putting words in my mouth. are you...projecting? don't do that, it's bad.

I never said Jay was lying. I'm saying he wants me to be scum and he's seeing stuff in a negative light. I have him a firm civ read and he'll come around.

[Golden]

Here's a scenario. He has the towniest townie role in all of Towndom, and he drew a scum card. he comes in here to theorize based on that TMI and I discredit him immediately off the bat because things like that are wrong based on ethics, and he doesn't like that (ohhhhhhhh lala I'm projecting more on Golden, take my projections, they are you, become them, YOU ARE ONE).

Why does it make sense for a scum to come in making untrue noise? It's a zero merit strategy.

[dunya]

Here's a scenario. He has the towniest townie role in all of Towndom, and he drew a scum card. he comes in here to theorize based on that TMI and I discredit him immediately off the bat because things like that are wrong based on ethics, and he doesn't like that (ohhhhhhhh lala I'm projecting more on Golden, take my projections, they are you, become them, YOU ARE ONE).

Why does it make sense for a scum to come in making untrue noise? It's a zero merit strategy.

why does it make sense when it applies to me? why didn't i humor your theory if i had tmi?

[Golden]

None of your kick-ass theories are about you not being bad. They're just about others not really believing in their suspicions.

In a two scum game, why would any suspicion of you be a lie?

wow you're putting words in my mouth. are you...projecting? don't do that, it's bad.

I never said Jay was lying. I'm saying he wants me to be scum and he's seeing stuff in a negative light. I have him a firm civ read and he'll come around.

I didn't put any words in your mouth. Your mouth is nowhere near my post.

[Golden]

Here's a scenario. He has the towniest townie role in all of Towndom, and he drew a scum card. he comes in here to theorize based on that TMI and I discredit him immediately off the bat because things like that are wrong based on ethics, and he doesn't like that (ohhhhhhhh lala I'm projecting more on Golden, take my projections, they are you, become them, YOU ARE ONE).

Why does it make sense for a scum to come in making untrue noise? It's a zero merit strategy.

why does it make sense when it applies to me? why didn't i humor your theory if i had tmi?

When what applies to you?

[dunya]

Here's a scenario. He has the towniest townie role in all of Towndom, and he drew a scum card. he comes in here to theorize based on that TMI and I discredit him immediately off the bat because things like that are wrong based on ethics, and he doesn't like that (ohhhhhhhh lala I'm projecting more on Golden, take my projections, they are you, become them, YOU ARE ONE).

Why does it make sense for a scum to come in making untrue noise? It's a zero merit strategy.

why does it make sense when it applies to me? why didn't i humor your theory if i had tmi?

When what applies to you?

"making noise"

[dunya]

when are you gonna post about anything unrelated to me, Golden? there's 2 scum teams. chop chop.

[Golden]

I've never said anything about you having TMI. I see no reason to agree with that aspect of Jay's case. Your passionate belief in ethics is sincere but entirely irrelevant - a nice side show. The only relevance to the whole thing about me claiming that I may have influenced myself into a town role was that you preferred to discredit me rather than engage with it in any meaningful way, which I don't buy - no matter how passionate about ethics you are.

linki - I said 'making untrue noise'. Which is what you're accusing me of.

linki 2 - On my own schedule. I don't care how many scum teams there are. You keep hoping I'll get off your back, because you're feeling the heat. I'm not going to be at all influenced by what others tell me I should be looking at or not looking at.

[dunya]

Apparently Mac is a predictable host. He falls into obvious cookie-cutter tendencies.

yea, my human slave has known mac for 8 years and she says he's batshit crazy so it actually sounds like something he could do...

Er.

Okay.

taken out of context. I was talking about weird role stipulations, not handpicking players into teams. your inability to see why i would assume there's a big fat red line to draw there is exhausting.

[colonialbob]

I found a cool thing.

No us central time

(I mean it's easy enough to extrapolate)

[colonialbob]

He buys himself a mansiere.

I think you mean the "Bro"

Have you ever considered something for support?

that football looks sick. It's swollen and weird colors. I hope it's ok

[colonialbob]

Im with the missus now, gonna be social. Comradebob is my pick for quiet scum thus far.

Wat

[Jackofhearts2005]

I've never played a bastard game before to my knowledge so I really don't know what goes and what doesn't in them, btw.

Basically, roles that could be called “bullshit.”

Vig that can take out three players in a night, goon that’s part of a mason team, cops that only get “mafia” results, etc.

Civ/mafia BTSC is one of my favorite things

You saw I snuck into a civ btsc in Greece, right? So ticked they killed my mason partner.


The Hogwarts Chainsaw Massacre was before your time, right? Four person Death Eater Mafia but two players were polyjuiced members of the opposing Order of Phoenix mafia. The Order of Phoenix was similarly half Death Eaters. Then there were the three serial killers...

My own bastard game had a 3 player mason team with no townies in it.

[Jackofhearts2005]

yawn im still alive. why?

Cause I haven’t killed you yet, mongrel.

[colonialbob]

Jack let's hunt.

How do you see dunya/golden?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Hi folks

Damn 18 pages?

[colonialbob]

I've never played a bastard game before to my knowledge so I really don't know what goes and what doesn't in them, btw.

Basically, roles that could be called “bullshit.”

Vig that can take out three players in a night, goon that’s part of a mason team, cops that only get “mafia” results, etc.

Civ/mafia BTSC is one of my favorite things

You saw I snuck into a civ btsc in Greece, right? So ticked they killed my mason partner.


The Hogwarts Chainsaw Massacre was before your time, right? Four person Death Eater Mafia but two players were polyjuiced members of the opposing Order of Phoenix mafia. The Order of Phoenix was similarly half Death Eaters. Then there were the three serial killers...

My own bastard game had a 3 player mason team with no townies in it.

My favorite was one of IR's games (don't remember if it was history or lit or the combo) where every townie had a mason partner, and adamical (?) and I were the only pair in the game that didn't trust each other right off the bat. Shows you my default assumptions I guess.

[Golden]

Jack let's hunt.

How do you see dunya/golden?

Reading glasses.

Or, given you’re asking jack, perhaps reading asses.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Join me my brothers and sisters

I’m more of an ass, man.

Spoiler: show

Fixed it.

You dare!

Spoiler: show

[colonialbob]

Hi folks

Damn 18 pages?

A lot of it is memes, a lot of it is dunya and Golden fighting.

Why shouldn't we lynch you?

[Jackofhearts2005]

Jack let's hunt.

How do you see dunya/golden?

Bad/good.

Why don’t I lynch Dunya?

After all, a king controls the lynch.

[Golden]

Hi folks

Damn 18 pages?

A lot of it is memes, a lot of it is dunya and Golden fighting.

Why shouldn't we lynch you?

Fair question

[colonialbob]

Jack let's hunt.

How do you see dunya/golden?

Bad/good.

Why don’t I lynch Dunya?

After all, a king controls the lynch.

Ok, so do you know any kings?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Cuz you can't.

[Golden]

Cuz you can't.

That’s inconvenient

[Dragon D. Luffy]

It sure is.

Also Mac banned me from posting during day 0 for some reason.

No I don't know what reason it is.

[Golden]

It sure is.

Also Mac banned me from posting during day 0 for some reason.

No I don't know what reason it is.

Are you actually on the player list?

[Jackofhearts2005]

Jack let's hunt.

How do you see dunya/golden?

Bad/good.

Why don’t I lynch Dunya?

After all, a king controls the lynch.

Ok, so do you know any kings?

Filthy mongrel! Your insolent tongue will be your death!

[colonialbob]

Jack let's hunt.

How do you see dunya/golden?

Bad/good.

Why don’t I lynch Dunya?

After all, a king controls the lynch.

Ok, so do you know any kings?

Filthy mongrel! Your insolent tongue will be your death!

Too easy

[juliets]

Ok, so many posts overnight. I dread what I will find when I get home from work today.

dunya, I like your nutella case. I noted in my last post her turnaround on you - dunya is bad, dunya is good, dunya is bad - which made me suspicious. nutella if there were reasons you can point to for your change of opinion twice please do. Also thanks dunya for pointing me to those civ games. I hope to look at a couple this afternoon if I can tear myself away from this thread long enough.

I don't get the colonial bob scum theory so motel room could you please tell us what you are seeing?

[Jackofhearts2005]

I need someone to be my Rider. Someone worthy of a king’s respect. Not Bob, obviously.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

It sure is.

Also Mac banned me from posting during day 0 for some reason.

No I don't know what reason it is.

Are you actually on the player list?

Apparently I wasn't on day 0 but should have been included when day 1 started.

[mention]MacDougall[/mention]

[Turnip Head]

I need someone to be my Rider. Someone worthy of a king’s respect. Not Bob, obviously.

ummmmmmmm hi. do I have the right address my liege?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

It seems so cruel to lynch people, and yet if morality is relative then the universe won’t care. Any action is unpunished by all but the arbitrary confines of society.

Holy shit guys.

I think I broke Jay.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I need someone to be my Rider. Someone worthy of a king’s respect. Not Bob, obviously.

ummmmmmmm hi. do I have the right address my liege?

You amuse me, balloon. Speak your mind.

[dunya]

It seems so cruel to lynch people, and yet if morality is relative then the universe won’t care. Any action is unpunished by all but the arbitrary confines of society.

Holy shit guys.

I think I broke Jay.

Don't worry, I superglued him back together. Kinda wish I'd left him to stay a broken record tho.

[colonialbob]

I need someone to be my Rider. Someone worthy of a king’s respect. Not Bob, obviously.

From what I remember of Fate/Zero this offer is a trap

[Jackofhearts2005]

I need someone to be my Rider. Someone worthy of a king’s respect. Not Bob, obviously.

From what I remember of Fate/Zero this offer is a trap

There is only need for one king.

[Long Con]

Logging off for the night, so I'm looking forward to reading 35 pages about completely different players tomorrow! Please engage the Boobquest queries I've made!

I believe in the boobquest. So long as the info wolbre has given is generally accurate, I support the theory that a play is the Right Boob without knowing it. Like, you could be Eclectic Conjuring Guitar and also Right Boob without knowing it. Functionally, the concept is identical to the Right Boob being an item that one of us doesn't know they have. Or they do, and they have an impetus to find wolbre or keep it out of his grabby hands. WHO KNOWS? What I don't think is that he's lying about it. IF it's a lie, and he's covering the fact that his role is the Grim Reaper, then I am already enjoying the audacious fun of it.

As for singing... I'm hesitant to comply with any requests, out of fear that the role might collect my soul or something equally nefarious.

I skipped the Golden-Colin-dunya thing but read the fallout.I believe Golden comes out of it looking worse... like, I get that you didn't get emotional about it, but you can overreact in a really calm way. I think you accused dunya of falsely applying an emotional lean to posts of yours that you found dispassionate, but I think that the emotional indicators she was seeing weren't what you think they should have been.

What I mean is, if you overreact to something, even calmly, the level of - defensiveness, I guess? - can be described as emotional. Calmly and dispassionately triggered. These are the thoughts I recall from last night, reading up (though I got too tired before I fully caught up).

Linki: Now I see Jack requesting shit from people. Instantly my suspicion goes up that it's a trap.

[Scotty]

yawn im still alive. why?

Good question