U-Pick Mafia Vol 1 - Game Over

[Turnip Head]

nutella, Cbob, and Scotty are the current Eloh voters that I have my turnip eyes on

[ColinIsCool]

nutella, Cbob, and Scotty are the current Eloh voters that I have my turnip eyes on

Why cbob?

[Turnip Head]

nutella, Cbob, and Scotty are the current Eloh voters that I have my turnip eyes on

Why cbob?

Because he tried to take my beans.

[Zephyrus]

Okay. So this Eloh situation. Generally, when someone claims, I think that believing them is preferable to straight up lynching them so that you can give them a chance to prove their role, and, in this case, lynching Eloh is the only way to prove it. I personally buy the tardigrade story, but I don't understand the defeatist attitude. The whole point of defending, of convincing people not to lynch you, is stupid if you supposedly don't die. Yes, other people could be lynched instead, but we still get information from you not dying, so it's not completely useless. Overall, a scummy look to me.
That being said, I'm not going to switch over to her, because Colin still smells fishy to me.

Scum are going to have such an easy time bandwagoning on Eloh with a lead like that for now, no matter what her alignment is. We can do more.

I’m not saying Eloh directly picked her role. But her role had an obvious Mafia connotation, IF it is that. Certain roles in the game probably do. Mine does. So it’s possible she’s telling the truth. It doesn’t stop her from being scum, and I never said it did.

Eloh is very far away from a townread for me, so go ahead and lynch her. But let’s not just have 25 people on one wagon, right? That’s as much a wasted day as any.

[VOTE: ELOHCIN] aubergine

Character development at its finest.
1) "Scum can easily bandwagon Eloh, so try not to do it."
2) "She looks scum to me, but I'm not going to lynch her just yet."
3) "It appears this lynch is going to happen, better get on while I still can."
The use of stuff like "We can do more" and "That's as much a wasted day as any" to try and suggest that we aren't trying hard enough and that the lynch will not help us at all is really scummy to me, so I'm sticking with lynching Colin.

[ColinIsCool]

You can try to make my words look like other words as much as you want, but it won’t make that the case.

[wolbre04]

[mention]dunya[/mention] I saw ppl want to lynch you, destroy the haters like this

[ColinIsCool]

Show me where I changed my mind on Eloh between those 3 statements (or “developed my character” as you portray it) and I’ll PayPal you $10.

[Turnip Head]

Okay. So this Eloh situation. Generally, when someone claims, I think that believing them is preferable to straight up lynching them so that you can give them a chance to prove their role, and, in this case, lynching Eloh is the only way to prove it. I personally buy the tardigrade story, but I don't understand the defeatist attitude. The whole point of defending, of convincing people not to lynch you, is stupid if you supposedly don't die. Yes, other people could be lynched instead, but we still get information from you not dying, so it's not completely useless. Overall, a scummy look to me.
That being said, I'm not going to switch over to her, because Colin still smells fishy to me.

Scum are going to have such an easy time bandwagoning on Eloh with a lead like that for now, no matter what her alignment is. We can do more.

I’m not saying Eloh directly picked her role. But her role had an obvious Mafia connotation, IF it is that. Certain roles in the game probably do. Mine does. So it’s possible she’s telling the truth. It doesn’t stop her from being scum, and I never said it did.

Eloh is very far away from a townread for me, so go ahead and lynch her. But let’s not just have 25 people on one wagon, right? That’s as much a wasted day as any.

[VOTE: ELOHCIN] aubergine

Character development at its finest.
1) "Scum can easily bandwagon Eloh, so try not to do it."
2) "She looks scum to me, but I'm not going to lynch her just yet."
3) "It appears this lynch is going to happen, better get on while I still can."
The use of stuff like "We can do more" and "That's as much a wasted day as any" to try and suggest that we aren't trying hard enough and that the lynch will not help us at all is really scummy to me, so I'm sticking with lynching Colin.

[Turnip Head]

Zephyrus is officially in the smelly part of my rainbow

[dunya]

Hey [mention]Zephyrus[/mention] how was your final exam!? (:

[dunya]

Zephyrus is officially in the smelly part of my rainbow

[Zephyrus]

Hey @Zephyrus how was your final exam!? (:

Not too bad.
I've got some left to do after next week but I'm not worrying about them just yet.

[dunya]

Hey @Zephyrus how was your final exam!? (:

Not too bad.
I've got some left to do after next week but I'm not worrying about them just yet.

are you from the UK?

[Turnip Head]

Hey @Zephyrus how was your final exam!? (:

Not too bad.
I've got some left to do after next week but I'm not worrying about them just yet.

[dunya]

I like Zephyrus a lot. I'm giving him a green townie card. Yep. sorry sig, I know you're probably angry at me but...a girl's intuition is never to be ignored.

[dunya]

Hey @Zephyrus how was your final exam!? (:

Not too bad.
I've got some left to do after next week but I'm not worrying about them just yet.

Sloonei is hosting a Community game. I may or may not be playing. I may or may not see you there.

[Turnip Head]

Dunya and Zeph look like Troy and Abed from the Darkest Timeline tbh

[Turnip Head]

Sloonei is hosting a Community game. I may or may not be playing. I may or may not see you there.

It's my favorite show

[dunya]

Sloonei is hosting a Community game. I may or may not be playing. I may or may not see you there.

It's my favorite show

You sir have earned yourself a green townie card with Sloonei for the rest of the game, enjoy.

[dunya]

[mention]Zephyrus[/mention], my friend. Elochin has received some criticism beyond her roleclaim.

JaggedJimmyJay redirected any actions Elochin performed last night onto speedchuck (his 2 biggest scum reads at the time). Today, we learned that speedchuck is in a coma (I was in a coma for the duration of Day 2 and Night 2). speedchuck was a highly surprising choice, considering people were already suspicious of him and he wasn't really stepping on anyone's toes (except Scotty's maybe). Now, Elohcin denies that she is the person putting people in comas, and that her only role is to be unlynchable. It would make sense for Eloh to want to silence me after day 1/night 1, and with the evidence that JJJ has revealed, it also makes most sense she was caught silencing someone else who got redirected onto speedchuck.

What do you think of that?

[Turnip Head]

You can't say speedchuck was an odd choice for someone to target because obviously Jay targeted him, so then why couldn't somebody else have done the same? (A non-Elohcin coma-maker who picked chuck)

It doesn't seem like a stretch to me to view this as circumstancintial evidence at best and a meaningless councidence at worst, with respect to Eloh's civvieness.

[dunya]

see, I don't have a problem with Elohcin roleclaiming what she did, but I have a problem with her roleclaiming what she did and being caught as the coma-person and denying the latter completely. She could have come up with a stronger defence, imo. She was in the middle of giving us some reads (better lynched) in her catchup before she saw Jay's videos and then she just gave up. If she was town, she would have a stronger defence and she would have been more assertive in who she thought was scum. She didn't even call Jay's allegations bullshit, which is a thought I would certainly have had if I was innocent of the accusations he was throwing my way. Not once did she say that. It took Epi to connect some dots and question Jay's authenticity but not Eloh..who is the target of all of this. That's the problem I have with believing in Eloh's innocence.

[Zephyrus]

Show me where I changed my mind on Eloh between those 3 statements (or “developed my character” as you portray it) and I’ll PayPal you $10.

sure

I’m not saying Eloh directly picked her role. But her role had an obvious Mafia connotation, IF it is that. Certain roles in the game probably do. Mine does. So it’s possible she’s telling the truth. It doesn’t stop her from being scum, and I never said it did.

Eloh is very far away from a townread for me, so go ahead and lynch her. But let’s not just have 25 people on one wagon, right? That’s as much a wasted day as any.

[VOTE: ELOHCIN] aubergine

Talk about wasting a day.

My whole point is that you've maintained that you think that she's scum while you've tried to subtly urge people off the wagon, and then you suddenly decide to lynch her. It just looks odd to me.

[Turnip Head]

And I feel weird being the only person to apparently interpret it this way .

Linki I would give up too if I were in her shoes. No one is giving her the benefit of the doubt here.

[dunya]

You can't say speedchuck was an odd choice for someone to target because obviously Jay targeted him, so then why couldn't somebody else have done the same? (A non-Elohcin coma-maker who picked chuck)

It doesn't seem like a stretch to me to view this as circumstancintial evidence at best and a meaningless councidence at worst, with respect to Eloh's civvieness.

I believe Jay is civ. Jay redirected his top 2 scum picks onto each other. Hence, his choice of speedchuck (which I also questioned initially) makes sense.

Why would any member of the scumteam put speedchuck in a coma?

[Turnip Head]

IDK why someone would out speedchuck in a coma, it's not really relevant to me

[Turnip Head]

My point is that I don't think Elo did it. I think Elo has an unlynchable town role and is playing like it.

[dunya]

IDK why someone would out speedchuck in a coma, it's not really relevant to me

it's relevant to me, because I can't see a clear scum motive for it, hence the implication that Jay's redirect on Elohcin was the cause of it. How is this not relevant to you?

[ColinIsCool]

Show me where I changed my mind on Eloh between those 3 statements (or “developed my character” as you portray it) and I’ll PayPal you $10.

sure

I’m not saying Eloh directly picked her role. But her role had an obvious Mafia connotation, IF it is that. Certain roles in the game probably do. Mine does. So it’s possible she’s telling the truth. It doesn’t stop her from being scum, and I never said it did.

Eloh is very far away from a townread for me, so go ahead and lynch her. But let’s not just have 25 people on one wagon, right? That’s as much a wasted day as any.

[VOTE: ELOHCIN] aubergine

Talk about wasting a day.

My whole point is that you've maintained that you think that she's scum while you've tried to subtly urge people off the wagon, and then you suddenly decide to lynch her. It just looks odd to me.

Yeah, transparently no. I never said “get off Eloh’s wagon.” I said, let’s not let people blindly jump on. Let’s talk about other suspects. Let’s keep scumhunting. $10 is staying with me bucko.

[ColinIsCool]

And don’t you dare use Griffin McElroy against me!

[Zephyrus]

@Zephyrus, my friend. Elochin has received some criticism beyond her roleclaim.

JaggedJimmyJay redirected any actions Elochin performed last night onto speedchuck (his 2 biggest scum reads at the time). Today, we learned that speedchuck is in a coma (I was in a coma for the duration of Day 2 and Night 2). speedchuck was a highly surprising choice, considering people were already suspicious of him and he wasn't really stepping on anyone's toes (except Scotty's maybe). Now, Elohcin denies that she is the person putting people in comas, and that her only role is to be unlynchable. It would make sense for Eloh to want to silence me after day 1/night 1, and with the evidence that JJJ has revealed, it also makes most sense she was caught silencing someone else who got redirected onto speedchuck.

What do you think of that?

I'm assuming this is off the videos (which I haven't been able to watch). Do we know who he redirected on night one and onto who?
If this is true, it is certainly odd and a bit scummy to me. Denying evidence like that is definitely scummy.

[dunya]

My point is that I don't think Elo did it. I think Elo has an unlynchable town role and is playing like it.

k, let's lynch Colin instead.

[Turnip Head]

IDK why someone would out speedchuck in a coma, it's not really relevant to me

it's relevant to me, because I can't see a clear scum motive for it, hence the implication that Jay's redirect on Elohcin was the cause of it. How is this not relevant to you?

You're asking me to poke my turnip brain into a baddie chatzoid, see who's in there, see what powers they have, and then deduce why one or all of them would want to use some of those powers on speedchuck.

I can't do that... Mac didn't give me a role that cool

[dunya]

Zephyrus, my friend. Elochin has received some criticism beyond her roleclaim.

JaggedJimmyJay redirected any actions Elochin performed last night onto speedchuck (his 2 biggest scum reads at the time). Today, we learned that speedchuck is in a coma (I was in a coma for the duration of Day 2 and Night 2). speedchuck was a highly surprising choice, considering people were already suspicious of him and he wasn't really stepping on anyone's toes (except Scotty's maybe). Now, Elohcin denies that she is the person putting people in comas, and that her only role is to be unlynchable. It would make sense for Eloh to want to silence me after day 1/night 1, and with the evidence that JJJ has revealed, it also makes most sense she was caught silencing someone else who got redirected onto speedchuck.

What do you think of that?

I'm assuming this is off the videos (which I haven't been able to watch). Do we know who he redirected on night one and onto who?
If this is true, it is certainly odd and a bit scummy to me. Denying evidence like that is definitely scummy.

JaggedJimmyJay does not have a regular redirect role; he had to do something to earn that power. He got it for Night 2 and used it on Elohcin --> speedchuck.

[ColinIsCool]

Why are you so quick to believe Jay, dunya?

[dunya]

IDK why someone would out speedchuck in a coma, it's not really relevant to me

it's relevant to me, because I can't see a clear scum motive for it, hence the implication that Jay's redirect on Elohcin was the cause of it. How is this not relevant to you?

You're asking me to poke my turnip brain into a baddie chatzoid, see who's in there, see what powers they have, and then deduce why one or all of them would want to use some of those powers on speedchuck.

I can't do that... Mac didn't give me a role that cool

Mac clearly does not love you as much as he loves me.

[ColinIsCool]

HMMMMMMMM

I’ll roledump if people really don’t understand what I mean, but I think it’s in town’s best interest if I don’t.

you think we're believing everyone's claims?
cos we're not.

[Turnip Head]

Mac clearly does not love you as much as he loves me.

[dunya]

Why are you so quick to believe Jay, dunya?

Why would scum Jay make that up, and lie about it? Eloh had plenty of heat as it was.

things about Jay I am certain of:

1. as scum, in a game with 2 scum teams, he wouldn't out himself with his power role and make himself a target to being NKd if not absolutely necessary to share information with the rest of us.
2. he has no motive to lie about Eloh. Indeed, if we lynched her and she wasn't the coma inducer, Jay would look pretty bad.
3. Jay wouldn't fake role claim in a closed role madness game on Day 3 unless it was necessary. Did Jay have to post that video about Eloh?
4.

I have to go for a while can't continue. But youget the drift

[dunya]

HMMMMMMMM

I’ll roledump if people really don’t understand what I mean, but I think it’s in town’s best interest if I don’t.

you think we're believing everyone's claims?
cos we're not.

clearly because I townread him and scumread you. It doesn't take a scientist to figure that out.

[Zephyrus]

And don’t you dare use Griffin McElroy against me!

I only wanted the money, sometimes the big guns have to be used.

Zephyrus, my friend. Elochin has received some criticism beyond her roleclaim.

JaggedJimmyJay redirected any actions Elochin performed last night onto speedchuck (his 2 biggest scum reads at the time). Today, we learned that speedchuck is in a coma (I was in a coma for the duration of Day 2 and Night 2). speedchuck was a highly surprising choice, considering people were already suspicious of him and he wasn't really stepping on anyone's toes (except Scotty's maybe). Now, Elohcin denies that she is the person putting people in comas, and that her only role is to be unlynchable. It would make sense for Eloh to want to silence me after day 1/night 1, and with the evidence that JJJ has revealed, it also makes most sense she was caught silencing someone else who got redirected onto speedchuck.

What do you think of that?

I'm assuming this is off the videos (which I haven't been able to watch). Do we know who he redirected on night one and onto who?
If this is true, it is certainly odd and a bit scummy to me. Denying evidence like that is definitely scummy.

JaggedJimmyJay does not have a regular redirect role; he had to do something to earn that power. He got it for Night 2 and used it on Elohcin --> speedchuck.

What did he have to do? I'd find his claim easier to believe if I knew that.
I'm from the UK, yes.

[ColinIsCool]

HMMMMMMMM

I’ll roledump if people really don’t understand what I mean, but I think it’s in town’s best interest if I don’t.

you think we're believing everyone's claims?
cos we're not.

clearly because I townread him and scumread you. It doesn't take a scientist to figure that out.

I would like to call the Tunnel Victims Crisis Line, please

[dunya]

Spoiler: show

And don’t you dare use Griffin McElroy against me!

I only wanted the money, sometimes the big guns have to be used.

Zephyrus, my friend. Elochin has received some criticism beyond her roleclaim.

JaggedJimmyJay redirected any actions Elochin performed last night onto speedchuck (his 2 biggest scum reads at the time). Today, we learned that speedchuck is in a coma (I was in a coma for the duration of Day 2 and Night 2). speedchuck was a highly surprising choice, considering people were already suspicious of him and he wasn't really stepping on anyone's toes (except Scotty's maybe). Now, Elohcin denies that she is the person putting people in comas, and that her only role is to be unlynchable. It would make sense for Eloh to want to silence me after day 1/night 1, and with the evidence that JJJ has revealed, it also makes most sense she was caught silencing someone else who got redirected onto speedchuck.

What do you think of that?

I'm assuming this is off the videos (which I haven't been able to watch). Do we know who he redirected on night one and onto who?
If this is true, it is certainly odd and a bit scummy to me. Denying evidence like that is definitely scummy.

JaggedJimmyJay does not have a regular redirect role; he had to do something to earn that power. He got it for Night 2 and used it on Elohcin --> speedchuck.

What did he have to do? I'd find his claim easier to believe if I knew that.
I'm from the UK, yes.

I like your hesitation in believing his claim. Nice, very nice. You have earned more green townie points. Use them wisely.

[dunya]

HMMMMMMMM

I’ll roledump if people really don’t understand what I mean, but I think it’s in town’s best interest if I don’t.

you think we're believing everyone's claims?
cos we're not.

clearly because I townread him and scumread you. It doesn't take a scientist to figure that out.

I would like to call the Tunnel Victims Crisis Line, please

If I'm tunneling you, I'll owe you all the pizzas and all the beers. I'm sorry, I just can't unsee it.

[ColinIsCool]

I’ll PM you my address so you can FedEx them over, thanks

[wolbre04]

Sloonei is hosting a Community game. I may or may not be playing. I may or may not see you there.

It's my favorite show

Omg ima play that

[colonialbob]

Spoiler: show

And don’t you dare use Griffin McElroy against me!

I only wanted the money, sometimes the big guns have to be used.

Zephyrus, my friend. Elochin has received some criticism beyond her roleclaim.

JaggedJimmyJay redirected any actions Elochin performed last night onto speedchuck (his 2 biggest scum reads at the time). Today, we learned that speedchuck is in a coma (I was in a coma for the duration of Day 2 and Night 2). speedchuck was a highly surprising choice, considering people were already suspicious of him and he wasn't really stepping on anyone's toes (except Scotty's maybe). Now, Elohcin denies that she is the person putting people in comas, and that her only role is to be unlynchable. It would make sense for Eloh to want to silence me after day 1/night 1, and with the evidence that JJJ has revealed, it also makes most sense she was caught silencing someone else who got redirected onto speedchuck.

What do you think of that?

I'm assuming this is off the videos (which I haven't been able to watch). Do we know who he redirected on night one and onto who?
If this is true, it is certainly odd and a bit scummy to me. Denying evidence like that is definitely scummy.

JaggedJimmyJay does not have a regular redirect role; he had to do something to earn that power. He got it for Night 2 and used it on Elohcin --> speedchuck.

What did he have to do? I'd find his claim easier to believe if I knew that.
I'm from the UK, yes.

I like your hesitation in believing his claim. Nice, very nice. You have earned more green townie points. Use them wisely.

Vomit o'clock

[Turnip Head]

Spoiler: show

And don’t you dare use Griffin McElroy against me!

I only wanted the money, sometimes the big guns have to be used.

Zephyrus, my friend. Elochin has received some criticism beyond her roleclaim.

JaggedJimmyJay redirected any actions Elochin performed last night onto speedchuck (his 2 biggest scum reads at the time). Today, we learned that speedchuck is in a coma (I was in a coma for the duration of Day 2 and Night 2). speedchuck was a highly surprising choice, considering people were already suspicious of him and he wasn't really stepping on anyone's toes (except Scotty's maybe). Now, Elohcin denies that she is the person putting people in comas, and that her only role is to be unlynchable. It would make sense for Eloh to want to silence me after day 1/night 1, and with the evidence that JJJ has revealed, it also makes most sense she was caught silencing someone else who got redirected onto speedchuck.

What do you think of that?

I'm assuming this is off the videos (which I haven't been able to watch). Do we know who he redirected on night one and onto who?
If this is true, it is certainly odd and a bit scummy to me. Denying evidence like that is definitely scummy.

JaggedJimmyJay does not have a regular redirect role; he had to do something to earn that power. He got it for Night 2 and used it on Elohcin --> speedchuck.

What did he have to do? I'd find his claim easier to believe if I knew that.
I'm from the UK, yes.

I like your hesitation in believing his claim. Nice, very nice. You have earned more green townie points. Use them wisely.

Vomit o'clock

Me too thanks

[Marmot]

[Kites]

[VOTE: colin] aubergine

i dont trust all of them elo voters

offtopic
[mention]dunya[/mention] today was her bday and i made her so happy she full on started crying am i good or what