Easter Mafia [GAME OVER]
Moderator: Community Team
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
The fact that Jay thinks there's such a thing as a "moronic" lynch candidate doesn't bode well either. If he didn't have information and was town, he'd realize that despite a Day 1 scumflip, it's possible for anyone to be bad.
He's not acting that way at all. He lacks the underlying paranoia and reassessment. It's all agenda.
He's not acting that way at all. He lacks the underlying paranoia and reassessment. It's all agenda.
- nutella
- hey kids, what's for dinner?
- Posts in topic: 383
- Posts: 24861
- Joined: Wed Jun 12, 2013 6:23 pm
- Location: Chicago
- Gender: Female
- Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
- Contact:
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]

M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 6:50 pm I'll try to illustrate what bothers me about Jay here in a bit. Most of his recent scum hunting is characterized by low-hanging fruit, WIFOM, etc. that town Jay would only give little consideration, or at least would realize the other point of view. The difference between town Jay and scum Jay is the agenda. Town Jay, despite speaking with confidence, is never really sure of anything; he's always trying to pressure and investigate from as many angles as possible. Scum Jay is trying to appear that way but really he's pushing an agenda. I really hate that Jay's actively engaging in WIFOM and pushing Marmot as a candidate based on such weak shit.
I'll ISO him when I'm less distracted to try to highlight what I mean.

well put.
avatar art credit to chardonnay! (colors added by me tho)
http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23 ~ http://feeling-diskinserted.tumblr.com ~ https://rateyourmusic.com/~nutella23
http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23 ~ http://feeling-diskinserted.tumblr.com ~ https://rateyourmusic.com/~nutella23
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Jay, your mistake was keeping me alive. 

- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I'm going to feel like such an asshole if I'm wrong, but dammit, that's mafia. Gotta take some risks sometime.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
nutella, your his teammate, aren't you? Bussing him early. 

- nutella
- hey kids, what's for dinner?
- Posts in topic: 383
- Posts: 24861
- Joined: Wed Jun 12, 2013 6:23 pm
- Location: Chicago
- Gender: Female
- Preferred Pronouns: she/her/hers
- Contact:
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
lol I wish
avatar art credit to chardonnay! (colors added by me tho)
http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23 ~ http://feeling-diskinserted.tumblr.com ~ https://rateyourmusic.com/~nutella23
http://www.last.fm/user/nutella23 ~ http://feeling-diskinserted.tumblr.com ~ https://rateyourmusic.com/~nutella23
- Scotty
- Jeff Probst
- Posts in topic: 405
- Posts: 17925
- Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 7:29 pm
- Location: New York City
- Gender: Male
- Preferred Pronouns: He/him
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
It seems to me like a team that’s active, but not entirely active. I probably would have killed jjj or Kyle N1 for instance. But then there’s the advent of the dentist doctor, so perhaps nova was a kill to clear the airwaves.M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 5:36 pm Kyle being killed is certainly interesting. I suck at NKA, and I typically don't like to employ it, but it seems the mafia team has switched strategies from "lol" to "kill the player least likely to be lynched".
I was the only player to suspect Kyle, let up on it even though I still had it on the back of my mind, so he was under no pressure.
I think this means the first kill was potentially meant to frame someone or get us looking in a specific direction. I'd be wary of people trying to steer that conversation. From what I recall, Jay did this.
That concerns me greatly.
In either case, I feel like it’s not indicative of a particular player to go that route. As Quin said, nova didn’t really have any big detractors. But all this leading to JJJ? Maybe, but not emphatically
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
not screaming like the people in his car
Spoiler: show
- Scotty
- Jeff Probst
- Posts in topic: 405
- Posts: 17925
- Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 7:29 pm
- Location: New York City
- Gender: Male
- Preferred Pronouns: He/him
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Why didn’t you trust Colin to begin with?M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 5:42 pm I'm not sure why I don't trust Colin, but I think I'm wrong in that. My gut tells me there is at least one scum who's been going without any pressure.
Even if I'm wrong, we need to pressure everyone. Please everyone, tell me why Jay is town. Because he led the wagon on Choutas? Choutas wasn't doing shit. Are we going to let a potentially scum Jay coast to victory on that?
Most of his scum hunting since then has been sporadic (I know this is ironic coming from me, but hear me out), and he's been engaging in an uncharacteristic amount of low hanging fruit, WIFOM, and NKA.
I don't like it. Town Jay would be looking at more angles. Jay keeps pushing easy suspects.
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
not screaming like the people in his car
Spoiler: show
- Scotty
- Jeff Probst
- Posts in topic: 405
- Posts: 17925
- Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 7:29 pm
- Location: New York City
- Gender: Male
- Preferred Pronouns: He/him
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
You’re being manic right now where your sock is about to unravel, and I like it.
[VOTE: Jay] aubergine
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
not screaming like the people in his car
Spoiler: show
- Scotty
- Jeff Probst
- Posts in topic: 405
- Posts: 17925
- Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 7:29 pm
- Location: New York City
- Gender: Male
- Preferred Pronouns: He/him
Re: Easter Mafia [NIGHT 2]
This has been my main concern with you- you did bus choutas if you are bad this game. This self proclamation of your baddie meta is what’s holding me back from giving you a green card.M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 6:35 pmI'm sorry, what I'm saying makes total sense to me, but that's probably only because I know my alignment and I understand the distinction between how I play when town and mafia, something I'm surprised more of you haven't picked up on.nutella wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 6:30 pmMeh, I won't pursue this anymore since I think you're town anyway and it doesn't seem worth the effort. I was just a little perplexed since it seemed to me that the "treatment" you were referring to was how you acted nonchalant about his lynch and eventually voted for him, when you also said at one point that you like to bus teammates as mafia. I just couldn't quite put together what you meant in a way that didn't seem like a contradiction.
I love bussing teammates when bad. I would have bussed Choutas the way Jay did if I was his teammate. Trust me.
Also I’m not going to marry you as another way to get it
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
not screaming like the people in his car
Spoiler: show
- Dyslexicon
- <3
- Posts in topic: 487
- Posts: 12805
- Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2016 2:12 am
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
K, I’m not buying the Jimmey case at all. Will come back to this later.
What was the last game lapluie was scum in?
What was the last game lapluie was scum in?
- JaggedJimmyJay
- The Brassiere of The Syndicate
- Posts in topic: 806
- Posts: 40022
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2015 11:42 pm
- Location: United States
- Gender: Man
- Preferred Pronouns: He/him/his/himself
- Aka: Jay | JJJ | J3 | 3J | jagged | Jimmy | KOFM
- Contact:
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I hate bussing my teammates and have never done it on Day 1 in my Mafia career. It “can” work, but on balance it’s a net negative. I don’t engage in foolery and tricks when there is no need. I lynch civilians and I win.
I cannot hunt without an opportunity to comb ISOs and discuss topics live. Ideally I’ll have my chance later, but if I do end up lynched I have a fucking demand.
If you’re a civilian and you lynched me, especially if your name is M Plus 7, you will follow these instructions:
1. You will not wallow in misery and frustration.
2. You will not lament your mistake.
3. You will not allow yourself to give anything away to the mafia team.
4. You will transform your bad feelings about murdering me into increased intensity and will to win.
5. You will hunt without mercy, and without regard for having been wrong about me.
6. You will lynch those who give you no inspiration.
7. You will not lynch those who do unless you have truly uncovered a sound and plausible case.
8. You will do this in my memory, for you will have ripped my control over ending my losing streak from my grasp and shouldered it yourself.
9. You will not let me down.
I cannot hunt without an opportunity to comb ISOs and discuss topics live. Ideally I’ll have my chance later, but if I do end up lynched I have a fucking demand.
If you’re a civilian and you lynched me, especially if your name is M Plus 7, you will follow these instructions:
1. You will not wallow in misery and frustration.
2. You will not lament your mistake.
3. You will not allow yourself to give anything away to the mafia team.
4. You will transform your bad feelings about murdering me into increased intensity and will to win.
5. You will hunt without mercy, and without regard for having been wrong about me.
6. You will lynch those who give you no inspiration.
7. You will not lynch those who do unless you have truly uncovered a sound and plausible case.
8. You will do this in my memory, for you will have ripped my control over ending my losing streak from my grasp and shouldered it yourself.
9. You will not let me down.
Spoiler: show
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I just think it's misguided to try to trace the kills back, especially this early in the game, in the attempt to clear someone based off of them.Scotty wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 7:26 pmIt seems to me like a team that’s active, but not entirely active. I probably would have killed jjj or Kyle N1 for instance. But then there’s the advent of the dentist doctor, so perhaps nova was a kill to clear the airwaves.M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 5:36 pm Kyle being killed is certainly interesting. I suck at NKA, and I typically don't like to employ it, but it seems the mafia team has switched strategies from "lol" to "kill the player least likely to be lynched".
I was the only player to suspect Kyle, let up on it even though I still had it on the back of my mind, so he was under no pressure.
I think this means the first kill was potentially meant to frame someone or get us looking in a specific direction. I'd be wary of people trying to steer that conversation. From what I recall, Jay did this.
That concerns me greatly.
In either case, I feel like it’s not indicative of a particular player to go that route. As Quin said, nova didn’t really have any big detractors. But all this leading to JJJ? Maybe, but not emphatically
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
It's mostly a gut thing.Scotty wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 7:27 pmWhy didn’t you trust Colin to begin with?M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 5:42 pm I'm not sure why I don't trust Colin, but I think I'm wrong in that. My gut tells me there is at least one scum who's been going without any pressure.
Even if I'm wrong, we need to pressure everyone. Please everyone, tell me why Jay is town. Because he led the wagon on Choutas? Choutas wasn't doing shit. Are we going to let a potentially scum Jay coast to victory on that?
Most of his scum hunting since then has been sporadic (I know this is ironic coming from me, but hear me out), and he's been engaging in an uncharacteristic amount of low hanging fruit, WIFOM, and NKA.
I don't like it. Town Jay would be looking at more angles. Jay keeps pushing easy suspects.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
- JaggedJimmyJay
- The Brassiere of The Syndicate
- Posts in topic: 806
- Posts: 40022
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2015 11:42 pm
- Location: United States
- Gender: Man
- Preferred Pronouns: He/him/his/himself
- Aka: Jay | JJJ | J3 | 3J | jagged | Jimmy | KOFM
- Contact:
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [NIGHT 2]
Lol, sure, that's true. It's not how I bus though. It's half-assed.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
What don't you buy specifically, and by not buying it does that mean you think it's fabricated or sincere?Dyslexicon wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 7:50 pm K, I’m not buying the Jimmey case at all. Will come back to this later.
What was the last game lapluie was scum in?
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Also, no idea re: lapluie.
- Scotty
- Jeff Probst
- Posts in topic: 405
- Posts: 17925
- Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 7:29 pm
- Location: New York City
- Gender: Male
- Preferred Pronouns: He/him
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I’d rsther do a Colin lynch today, but Mp is very convincing.
It’s not even what he’s saying, it’s how he’s saying it
It’s not even what he’s saying, it’s how he’s saying it
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
not screaming like the people in his car
Spoiler: show
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
That's all well and good, but I don't think just because you've never done it before means you'd never do it. I'm considering your defense though.JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 7:54 pm I hate bussing my teammates and have never done it on Day 1 in my Mafia career. It “can” work, but on balance it’s a net negative. I don’t engage in foolery and tricks when there is no need. I lynch civilians and I win.
I cannot hunt without an opportunity to comb ISOs and discuss topics live. Ideally I’ll have my chance later, but if I do end up lynched I have a fucking demand.
If you’re a civilian and you lynched me, especially if your name is M Plus 7, you will follow these instructions:
1. You will not wallow in misery and frustration.
2. You will not lament your mistake.
3. You will not allow yourself to give anything away to the mafia team.
4. You will transform your bad feelings about murdering me into increased intensity and will to win.
5. You will hunt without mercy, and without regard for having been wrong about me.
6. You will lynch those who give you no inspiration.
7. You will not lynch those who do unless you have truly uncovered a sound and plausible case.
8. You will do this in my memory, for you will have ripped my control over ending my losing streak from my grasp and shouldered it yourself.
9. You will not let me down.
I hate your bolded sentence. I can understand that being your preference (as it's mine as well), but surely you can hunt regardless.
- Scotty
- Jeff Probst
- Posts in topic: 405
- Posts: 17925
- Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 7:29 pm
- Location: New York City
- Gender: Male
- Preferred Pronouns: He/him
Re: Easter Mafia [NIGHT 2]
A brown cow is still a cow (hmmmm who have I said that one to this game

When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
not screaming like the people in his car
Spoiler: show
- Scotty
- Jeff Probst
- Posts in topic: 405
- Posts: 17925
- Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2015 7:29 pm
- Location: New York City
- Gender: Male
- Preferred Pronouns: He/him
Re: Easter Mafia [NIGHT 2]
Oh shut it was purple cow, now brown
When I die, I want to go peacefully in my sleep like my grandfather;
not screaming like the people in his car
not screaming like the people in his car
Spoiler: show
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Talk to me about Colin.
I've had a torn feeling all game that I can't trust the guy for some reason, but I also feel like he's on the level.
I didn't want to be at the computer all day today because that's literally every day of my life, but here we are, and I feel obligated to ISO some folks.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I'm paranoid as fuck about people thinking I'm making sense. How am I making sense?
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Why Elo exactly?
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Colin, I love your conclusion statements for your ISOs, especially the SECOND BASE for Charlie. Great stuff.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I'm going to do my own independent ISO of Jay now (god help me), so we'll see how I feel afterwards. I'll try to be as open-minded as possible.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
215 posts. Is this what it's like to ISO me? Goodness.
- Quin
- Indecent Bastard
- Posts in topic: 302
- Posts: 10900
- Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
- Location: The Future
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 2]
Literally has nothing to do with why I suspect you. I suspect you for what came after. This:Dyslexicon wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 8:12 am You haven't thooooo. I still don't know. Nobody else seems to know. So maybe you should take that into account? You literally said Nova was a smart kill (wen't back to look, cause I hadn't read the post since my initial impression). My point was exactly that you were the only one I perceived to not go "hm, that was a weird kill" but instead found a reason for it to be a good kill. That is not wrong. Not even objectively. And it can't be subjectively wrong. Why the fuck is this such a thing for you? What does it even mean for me to "shit on you analysis" lol. Anyway, have fun with thinking I'm scum, and please go look for my teammate so you're not wasting all the time in the case you are town. Please and thank you.
You suspect me for having a different opinion. I already find that disingenuous. "no but" implies that I did my analysis with the purpose of opposing what everyone else thought. You never explain why my reasons for thinking what I did was silly. My reasons were not silly. You just degraded them.I also don't like that he was the one to be like "no but the kill was actually clever come on guyezzz" for more or less silly reasons
What purpose does this question serve?Also, genuine question: Have you read the whole game?
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Quin, reads list?
- Quin
- Indecent Bastard
- Posts in topic: 302
- Posts: 10900
- Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
- Location: The Future
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
i'll be honest i haven't got a trucking clue what this expression means even after reading it 73 times
- Quin
- Indecent Bastard
- Posts in topic: 302
- Posts: 10900
- Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
- Location: The Future
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
GTH, sure.
colin - good
dizzy - bad
eloh - good
epi - good
3j - bad
lap - bad
MP - good
marmot - good
nutella - good
scotty - good
- ColinIsCool
- Hitman
- Posts in topic: 344
- Posts: 4804
- Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2018 12:33 pm
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
My problem in this game in general, it appears, is that I don’t know what “town Jay” would do versusM Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 5:42 pm I'm not sure why I don't trust Colin, but I think I'm wrong in that. My gut tells me there is at least one scum who's been going without any pressure.
Even if I'm wrong, we need to pressure everyone. Please everyone, tell me why Jay is town. Because he led the wagon on Choutas? Choutas wasn't doing shit. Are we going to let a potentially scum Jay coast to victory on that?
Most of his scum hunting since then has been sporadic (I know this is ironic coming from me, but hear me out), and he's been engaging in an uncharacteristic amount of low hanging fruit, WIFOM, and NKA.
I don't like it. Town Jay would be looking at more angles. Jay keeps pushing easy suspects.

- ColinIsCool
- Hitman
- Posts in topic: 344
- Posts: 4804
- Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2018 12:33 pm
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Yeah, for my own sanity, I won't get around to making a gigantic ISO analysis post here. I'll just throw out a few nuggets of particular note to back up my impressions.
- ColinIsCool
- Hitman
- Posts in topic: 344
- Posts: 4804
- Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2018 12:33 pm
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I don’t know about Jay you guys. Would he make a legacy post that long, for the second time in the game, if he were scum? My instinct and knowledge of him as a player tells me he’d put the effort to try to frame somebody else instead or something.

- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
It's difficult to suss out, I'll admit, but I'm trying to communicate at least what differences I've been able to pick out in my experiences with him.ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 8:30 pmMy problem in this game in general, it appears, is that I don’t know what “town Jay” would do versusM Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 5:42 pm I'm not sure why I don't trust Colin, but I think I'm wrong in that. My gut tells me there is at least one scum who's been going without any pressure.
Even if I'm wrong, we need to pressure everyone. Please everyone, tell me why Jay is town. Because he led the wagon on Choutas? Choutas wasn't doing shit. Are we going to let a potentially scum Jay coast to victory on that?
Most of his scum hunting since then has been sporadic (I know this is ironic coming from me, but hear me out), and he's been engaging in an uncharacteristic amount of low hanging fruit, WIFOM, and NKA.
I don't like it. Town Jay would be looking at more angles. Jay keeps pushing easy suspects.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
His inspirational posts are NAI in my experience. It could certainly be genuine, but it doesn't have to be.ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 8:36 pm I don’t know about Jay you guys. Would he make a legacy post that long, for the second time in the game, if he were scum? My instinct and knowledge of him as a player tells me he’d put the effort to try to frame somebody else instead or something.
- ColinIsCool
- Hitman
- Posts in topic: 344
- Posts: 4804
- Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2018 12:33 pm
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Okay. I mean, it’s possible I’ve been reverse tunneling him, but other than the few things in my ISO post, I didn’t see much.M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 8:40 pmHis inspirational posts are NAI in my experience. It could certainly be genuine, but it doesn't have to be.ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 8:36 pm I don’t know about Jay you guys. Would he make a legacy post that long, for the second time in the game, if he were scum? My instinct and knowledge of him as a player tells me he’d put the effort to try to frame somebody else instead or something.

- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I'll put up a post here soon and you can tell me what you think.ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 8:49 pmOkay. I mean, it’s possible I’ve been reverse tunneling him, but other than the few things in my ISO post, I didn’t see much.M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 8:40 pmHis inspirational posts are NAI in my experience. It could certainly be genuine, but it doesn't have to be.ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 8:36 pm I don’t know about Jay you guys. Would he make a legacy post that long, for the second time in the game, if he were scum? My instinct and knowledge of him as a player tells me he’d put the effort to try to frame somebody else instead or something.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Yeah, Jay is bad. I tried to see this otherwise as much as possible, but he's bad.
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
ISO of JaggedJimmyJay
I'll try to keep this as brief as possible for my own sanity.
Here is an example of a post in Jay's ISO I absolutely hate:
Just no. These are all low hanging fruit suspects, and I'd be OK if Jay wanted to lynch one or two of them maybe, but he's not even considering whether any of those weird or low-posting players are coming from a town or scum place, and we only have 2 scum left. It's like Jay is equating a player's effort with whether they are worthy of a lynch, despite the interactive analysis he previously conducted, and despite the fact that he knows that whether someone seems anti-town or low-effort does not mean they should be lynched. They're all low posters. This is the apathy of scum Jay.
I also hate this:
I asked Jay what he thought of it. He just said it shouldn't be discarded. He didn't tell me how he interpreted it, and he didn't seem to give thoughtful consideration to whether a town or scum Marmot would say that and why.
Somehow what's even worse is this D3 progression of posts:
This reads list is garbage. Epi and Elo are low hanging fruit, and Marmot's had a ton of heat on him off and on especially since his Choutas vote.
This is also garbage. We have a D1 scum flip, all those interactive analysis posts that Jay himself did, tons of other content, and he's relying on night kill analysis as the main basis for his reads and D3 vote? What the fuck?
The weakest possible shit.
This is also gross. Jay has made no indication previously in his ISO (other than the beef with Dizzy's vote on D1 which I already grilled him for) that he'd consider Dizzy. Even worse, he just says "I'm open." Vague. Keeping his voting options open.
Worst vote ever. Seriously. There's over 1,500 posts in this game and this is how Jay makes his vote?
It's autopilot. Jay doesn't care about the hunt.
Things I Like in Jay's ISO:
- vote for Choutas (objectively it looks solid, of course)
- effort put into interactive analysis ISOs on N1 after scum flip
Things I Don't Like in Jay's ISO:
- what I've already highlighted above as particularly egregious (going after low hanging fruit, relying way too much on NKA and WIFOM, and autopilot hunting)
- conversation with me on D1 re: Dizzy and how "looks bad" somehow means that's worthy of a vote (reference)
- along similar lines, Jay is voting for and/or going after low hanging fruit way too often for my comfort this game without making what I see as a fair attempt to determine whether the weird or inactive behavior is coming from a town or scum place (Dizzy on D1, Charlie on N1, Quin on D2, wolbre on D2 -- this one is the worst)
- vote for Choutas seems too clean (WIFOM)
- vote for wolbre (I don't buy that he actually assessed wolbre fairly)
- loaded language, especially in D1 interactions of Quin, that looks inauthentic
I'll try to keep this as brief as possible for my own sanity.
Here is an example of a post in Jay's ISO I absolutely hate:
Spoiler: show
I also hate this:
Spoiler: show
Somehow what's even worse is this D3 progression of posts:
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
The weakest possible shit.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
It's autopilot. Jay doesn't care about the hunt.
Things I Like in Jay's ISO:
- vote for Choutas (objectively it looks solid, of course)
- effort put into interactive analysis ISOs on N1 after scum flip
Things I Don't Like in Jay's ISO:
- what I've already highlighted above as particularly egregious (going after low hanging fruit, relying way too much on NKA and WIFOM, and autopilot hunting)
- conversation with me on D1 re: Dizzy and how "looks bad" somehow means that's worthy of a vote (reference)
- along similar lines, Jay is voting for and/or going after low hanging fruit way too often for my comfort this game without making what I see as a fair attempt to determine whether the weird or inactive behavior is coming from a town or scum place (Dizzy on D1, Charlie on N1, Quin on D2, wolbre on D2 -- this one is the worst)
- vote for Choutas seems too clean (WIFOM)
- vote for wolbre (I don't buy that he actually assessed wolbre fairly)
- loaded language, especially in D1 interactions of Quin, that looks inauthentic
- Tangrowth
- Don Emeritum
- Posts in topic: 450
- Posts: 33121
- Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2012 1:20 am
- Gender: genderfluid
- Preferred Pronouns: they/any
- Aka: tangy
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I could have made that look a lot better, sorry, but you all get the jist now of where I'm coming from anyway. Let me know whether it's an agreeable or disagreeable interpretation of Jay's behavior this game.
- Quin
- Indecent Bastard
- Posts in topic: 302
- Posts: 10900
- Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
- Location: The Future
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
He was lynched for this as town in FE.M Plus 7 wrote: ↑Sat May 26, 2018 9:03 pm ISO of JaggedJimmyJay
I'll try to keep this as brief as possible for my own sanity.
Here is an example of a post in Jay's ISO I absolutely hate:
Just no. These are all low hanging fruit suspects, and I'd be OK if Jay wanted to lynch one or two of them maybe, but he's not even considering whether any of those weird or low-posting players are coming from a town or scum place, and we only have 2 scum left. It's like Jay is equating a player's effort with whether they are worthy of a lynch, despite the interactive analysis he previously conducted, and despite the fact that he knows that whether someone seems anti-town or low-effort does not mean they should be lynched. They're all low posters. This is the apathy of scum Jay.Spoiler: show
I also hate this:
I asked Jay what he thought of it. He just said it shouldn't be discarded. He didn't tell me how he interpreted it, and he didn't seem to give thoughtful consideration to whether a town or scum Marmot would say that and why.Spoiler: show
Somehow what's even worse is this D3 progression of posts:
This reads list is garbage. Epi and Elo are low hanging fruit, and Marmot's had a ton of heat on him off and on especially since his Choutas vote.Spoiler: show
This is also garbage. We have a D1 scum flip, all those interactive analysis posts that Jay himself did, tons of other content, and he's relying on night kill analysis as the main basis for his reads and D3 vote? What the fuck?Spoiler: show
The weakest possible shit.
This is also gross. Jay has made no indication previously in his ISO (other than the beef with Dizzy's vote on D1 which I already grilled him for) that he'd consider Dizzy. Even worse, he just says "I'm open." Vague. Keeping his voting options open.Spoiler: show
Worst vote ever. Seriously. There's over 1,500 posts in this game and this is how Jay makes his vote?Spoiler: show
It's autopilot. Jay doesn't care about the hunt.
Things I Like in Jay's ISO:
- vote for Choutas (objectively it looks solid, of course)
- effort put into interactive analysis ISOs on N1 after scum flip
Things I Don't Like in Jay's ISO:
- what I've already highlighted above as particularly egregious (going after low hanging fruit, relying way too much on NKA and WIFOM, and autopilot hunting)
- conversation with me on D1 re: Dizzy and how "looks bad" somehow means that's worthy of a vote (reference)
- along similar lines, Jay is voting for and/or going after low hanging fruit way too often for my comfort this game without making what I see as a fair attempt to determine whether the weird or inactive behavior is coming from a town or scum place (Dizzy on D1, Charlie on N1, Quin on D2, wolbre on D2 -- this one is the worst)
- vote for Choutas seems too clean (WIFOM)
- vote for wolbre (I don't buy that he actually assessed wolbre fairly)
- loaded language, especially in D1 interactions of Quin, that looks inauthentic
- Quin
- Indecent Bastard
- Posts in topic: 302
- Posts: 10900
- Joined: Fri Feb 19, 2016 1:08 am
- Location: The Future
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
Also, saying he looks objectively good for his choutas vote and then adding in a tinfoil for the same thing later is fence-sitting. bbbbrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
- ColinIsCool
- Hitman
- Posts in topic: 344
- Posts: 4804
- Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2018 12:33 pm
Re: Easter Mafia [DAY 3]
I’m going to reply to you in greater detail when I can, but re: suspecting Dizzy. Doesn’t the quite right above where he says he’s tinfoiling count? This is in reference to the 5th quote you have.

- ColinIsCool
- Hitman
- Posts in topic: 344
- Posts: 4804
- Joined: Fri Jan 12, 2018 12:33 pm