Easter Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Dyslexicon]

Well that was time well spent doing ISO >_>

[Epignosis]

But like, what? Last time I looked at the rules, claiming was legal. Why can some people claim and others can't?

[Marmot]

What?

Well, I guess I just saved myself a bunch of time instead. Have fun.

After the power roles claimed, we got a ruling from G-Man, and he said that faction-claiming for the sake of PoE is forbidden (basically what you did).

I doubt you're in trouble in it, but we'll see I guess.

[Epignosis]

I can't keep up with this and the other thing at the same time. I'm sorry everybody. I can't do it and work and everything else I have to do. It's too much for me.

Alright. I get it. But don't be surprised that people suspect you. It's not unfair. it's the game.

I'll be however I want to be.

[Epignosis]

Well that was time well spent doing ISO >_>

Or you could wait until you get a bad guy identified for sure before acting like you've figured everything out.

[Marmot]

[mention]Dyslexicon[/mention] [mention]lapluie[/mention] why do you believe Colin's claim over mine?

Also, if I was mafia, why would I fake-attempt to protect Kyle and kill him in the same night?

[Scotty]

Ok all caught up. Had to keep reading between work breaks.

This is bullshit. I believe lap is telling the truth, and unfortunately that means both Colin and marmot could be bad, but only one of Colin and marmot is bad, but I ALREADY FIGURED THAT. My initial thought as I was reading everything in succession that Colin is just peddling bullshit because he knew he was caught but I can also see why marmot could be vomiting feces and Colin was just holding back to claim so that he didn’t have to. Marmot coming out as the doctor at a 4 v 2 vote with like 9 hours before EoD is definitely a questionable move.

I hate this. I still lean Colin

[Dyslexicon]

Well that was time well spent doing ISO >_>

Or you could wait until you get a bad guy identified for sure before acting like you've figured everything out.

Nah, I had sugar energy. Plus, I was LOOKING, not acting like I had figured something out. Next game, have more time and figure more things out kthx. I'll hold your hand and encourage you. : p

[Dyslexicon]

@Dyslexicon @lapluie why do you believe Colin's claim over mine?

Also, if I was mafia, why would I fake-attempt to protect Kyle and kill him in the same night?

Why would you breadcrumb as doctor? I've never ever seen that before.
It is true that you only mentioned rabbits directly those two times though.

To the last question - Why not?

I don't knooooow.

[lapluie]

Let's say colin/marmot are keith
Then there's 3 vanilla civi - apart from keith
& 2 badies /non dentists
Marmot
Colin & quin are not dentists
what are the chances all of them are not bad & chances that they are.. either one imo would be good lynch, I think
But then what about quin?? There was a time when quin was ready to give up playing & had about 4 votes then suddenly we got a mis lynch directed to another player, anybody remember who voted who??

[Marmot]

@Dyslexicon @lapluie why do you believe Colin's claim over mine?

Also, if I was mafia, why would I fake-attempt to protect Kyle and kill him in the same night?

Why would you breadcrumb as doctor? I've never ever seen that before.
It is true that you only mentioned rabbits directly those two times though.

To the last question - Why not?

I don't knooooow.

I breadcrumbed so y'all would believe me, but clearly it was fruitless.

[Scotty]

fuck why couldn’t it have been nutella or even Epi to come out as Keith

[Dyslexicon]

I breadcrumbed so y'all would believe me, but clearly it was fruitless.

Cause you knew this day would come? : p

[Dyslexicon]

fuck why couldn’t it have been nutella or even Epi to come out as Keith

Yeah, could the two players I've had the worst gut feeling about not do this plz. I haven't even made up my mind. (Interesting that PT and scum both looks off so much of the time).

[Dyslexicon]

I dislike Colin claiming and disappearing btw.

Ugh. Scum the lot of you.

[lapluie]

@Dyslexicon @lapluie why do you believe Colin's claim over mine?

Also, if I was mafia, why would I fake-attempt to protect Kyle and kill him in the same night?

Why else would anyone be as furious as colin when you supposedly claimed keith? His reasoning makes sense kiND of but, even still his frustrations to your claim sounds sincerely genuine on his behalf, I believe he was shocked how his role got stolen & needed a reason to support himself with 6 votes.. Idunno ok???

If you protected Kyl & it failed then someone targeted you for misdirect or block any night actions, if that's a power role in this game idunno

[Dyslexicon]

@Dyslexicon @lapluie why do you believe Colin's claim over mine?

Also, if I was mafia, why would I fake-attempt to protect Kyle and kill him in the same night?

Why else would anyone be as furious as colin when you supposedly claimed keith? His reasoning makes sense kiND of but, even still his frustrations to your claim sounds sincerely genuine on his behalf, I believe he was shocked how his role got stolen & needed a reason to support himself with 6 votes.. Idunno ok???

If you protected Kyl & it failed then someone targeted you for misdirect or block any night actions, if that's a power role in this game idunno

Yes. This is true. He did seem actually upset.

[Marmot]

Anyway, if you really must lynch me first, then lynch Colin tomorrow.

Day 4 ---> 9 players alive now, 7 civ, 2 mafia

Day 5 ---> 7 players alive, 5 civ, 2 mafia

Day 6 (Option 1) ---> 5 players left alive, 4 civ, 1 mafia
Day 6 (Option 2) ---> 6 players left alive, 4 civ, 2 mafia (with a confirmed Cabernog)



It's not the end of the world if you lynch me today, but if you lynch Colin tomorrow and he's Cabernog, that puts you in LYLO where you have to find 1 scum among 5 players, a less than ideal situation.

[Dyslexicon]

I am at the gym. If I come back to find myself lynched, tomorrow I will bench press 275 lbs. out of Mafia-inspired rage. I’ll try to be home in time to reply to messages but I can’t guarantee it.

Oh, it's explained.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I breadcrumbed so y'all would believe me, but clearly it was fruitless.

This is one of my concerns. Bread crumbs for protection shots don't really serve a purpose other than this, which means they can be prepared in advance for a mafioso who wants to fake claim. FZ prepared herself throughout Currents for her eventual fake cop claim.

Who is Colin's teammate?

[Dyslexicon]

Nice touch with the breadcrumbs though, Marmot. You are charismatic and clever. <3

[lapluie]

[mention]nutella[/mention] What do you think of all this??

[Marmot]

@Dyslexicon @lapluie why do you believe Colin's claim over mine?

Also, if I was mafia, why would I fake-attempt to protect Kyle and kill him in the same night?

Why else would anyone be as furious as colin when you supposedly claimed keith? His reasoning makes sense kiND of but, even still his frustrations to your claim sounds sincerely genuine on his behalf, I believe he was shocked how his role got stolen & needed a reason to support himself with 6 votes.. Idunno ok???

If you protected Kyl & it failed then someone targeted you for misdirect or block any night actions, if that's a power role in this game idunno

The votes piled onto him after I claimed, and really his frustration didn't build until after the votes moved. And again, waiting 5 hours to counter-claim, only to disappear immediately after? He's lying, and that's evidence against him.


There's only two power roles this game, you and I. The only thing that could block my attempt to protect Kyle is his role, something that would be silly of me to risk if I'm mafia.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Charlie Baseball:

It's clear now that either Marmot or Colin is a bad guy. Which one is it?

[Dyslexicon]

Suddenly I find myself singing musical classics, but changing the name to "nutella".

Nuteeeellaaa, I just met a girl named Nuteeeellaaaa.

[Marmot]

I breadcrumbed so y'all would believe me, but clearly it was fruitless.

This is one of my concerns. Bread crumbs for protection shots don't really serve a purpose other than this, which means they can be prepared in advance for a mafioso who wants to fake claim. FZ prepared herself throughout Currents for her eventual fake cop claim.

Who is Colin's teammate?

With Epignosis's claim, I'm not entirely ruling him out, but my first thought is Quin. He defended me unnecessarily yesterday. But I also want to see what he has to say to all this.

[nutella]

@Dyslexicon @lapluie why do you believe Colin's claim over mine?

Also, if I was mafia, why would I fake-attempt to protect Kyle and kill him in the same night?

I don't know why you think this is supposed to be convincing. You chose Kyle after the fact as an easy fake claim because you know now he wasn't a christian.

[Dyslexicon]

There's only two power roles this game, you and I. The only thing that could block my attempt to protect Kyle is his role, something that would be silly of me to risk if I'm mafia.

Like what?

Oh. Because you crumbed N2 BEFORE Kyle died.

Fucking fuck.

Maybe you didn't think it through, but got lucky?

[Dyslexicon]

Lol. Couldn't you two just have been teammates? Would've been so much easier.

[Scotty]

GUYS what if Marmot left his breadcrumb trail for this very purpose for whichever power role seemed most appealing to claim as.

Think about it-

He claimed 20 minutes after lap claimed today, and the breadcrumbs he left were vague enough that it could have been for anything.

Also he claimed Gladys a while back, didn’t he? Why on earth would the doctor claim Gladys?

[lapluie]

Can we just lynch quin

[lapluie]

GUYS what if Marmot left his breadcrumb trail for this very purpose for whichever power role seemed most appealing to claim as.

Think about it-

He claimed 20 minutes after lap claimed today, and the breadcrumbs he left were vague enough that it could have been for anything.

Also he claimed Gladys a while back, didn’t he? Why on earth would the doctor claim Gladys?

Wait when did marmot claimed gladys???

[Marmot]

@Dyslexicon @lapluie why do you believe Colin's claim over mine?

Also, if I was mafia, why would I fake-attempt to protect Kyle and kill him in the same night?

I don't know why you think this is supposed to be convincing. You chose Kyle after the fact as an easy fake claim because you know now he wasn't a christian.

No I didn't I made the post that I linked Night 2, before his death. :/

[Dyslexicon]

GUYS what if Marmot left his breadcrumb trail for this very purpose for whichever power role seemed most appealing to claim as.

Think about it-

He claimed 20 minutes after lap claimed today, and the breadcrumbs he left were vague enough that it could have been for anything.

Also he claimed Gladys a while back, didn’t he? Why on earth would the doctor claim Gladys?

Yeah. Thanks!

I feel like MP:

Are any of us decisive? : p

I said before this whole mess that I decided on Marmot. So I'm keeping that.

[Dyslexicon]

Marmot plays scum like I play scum.

[lapluie]

Colin & marmot r bad

No u

This is when I checked colin after

[Dyslexicon]

Except he probably has more fun doing it. : p

[Scotty]

GUYS what if Marmot left his breadcrumb trail for this very purpose for whichever power role seemed most appealing to claim as.

Think about it-

He claimed 20 minutes after lap claimed today, and the breadcrumbs he left were vague enough that it could have been for anything.

Also he claimed Gladys a while back, didn’t he? Why on earth would the doctor claim Gladys?

Wait when did marmot claimed gladys???

Unless I’m wrong and this isn’t actually a claim, this was day 2:

If I am Gladys Campbell, Colin is a dentist.

[Scotty]

Can we just lynch quin

Fuck it.

Maybe.

I don’t wanna lose the doc at this point in the game

[Dyslexicon]

GUYS what if Marmot left his breadcrumb trail for this very purpose for whichever power role seemed most appealing to claim as.

Think about it-

He claimed 20 minutes after lap claimed today, and the breadcrumbs he left were vague enough that it could have been for anything.

Also he claimed Gladys a while back, didn’t he? Why on earth would the doctor claim Gladys?

Wait when did marmot claimed gladys???

Unless I’m wrong and this isn’t actually a claim, this was day 2:

If I am Gladys Campbell, Colin is a dentist.

Yeah, so that would fit with the crumbing, right.

Busted.

Marmot, you devil you. I do love you a lot.

[Scotty]

No, one of Colin and marmot need to die today and we need to be right about it.

Someone give me tweezers and a strawberry dacquiri

[lapluie]

First instinct is to ask whoever jumped Choutas wagon super late, why?

I hopped on Choutas because I saw nothing town-indicative from him, and my vote on lapluie wasn't doing much.

Eye me all you want. But I don't see why my vote would be suspicious. Choutas was likely lynched whether I switched or not.

Hmmmm true....but.... why do you think you *needed* to vote for him anyway even if he's already in a lynch lead? You seemed hesitant & worried for him to be bad but he was already gonna die anyway

should we actually lynch marmot today because im feeling it

Yes I'll make the first contribution to my vote

Quin wanted to lynch marmot but didnt.. after saying he was feeling it twice but still did not.

[lapluie]

Marmot lied, Colin isn't a dentist

[nutella]

@Dyslexicon @lapluie why do you believe Colin's claim over mine?

Also, if I was mafia, why would I fake-attempt to protect Kyle and kill him in the same night?

I don't know why you think this is supposed to be convincing. You chose Kyle after the fact as an easy fake claim because you know now he wasn't a christian.

No I didn't I made the post that I linked Night 2, before his death. :/

Asmultiple people have already said, you could have planned that. Doesn't really do much for me

[lapluie]

No, one of Colin and marmot need to die today and we need to be right about it.

Someone give me tweezers and a strawberry dacquiri

I got you sweetie

[Dyslexicon]

7 town, 2 scum.

If we lynch the unlynchable -

6 town, 1 unknown scum, 1 known scum - would give us only 1 mislynch (because 2-2 would be a loss).

---

If we lynch outside Marmot/Colin

This gives us 2 mislynches. (5/2 and 3/2). This is assuming the unlynchable isn't outside of Marmot/Colin.

[Epignosis]

Charlie Baseball:

It's clear now that either Marmot or Colin is a bad guy. Which one is it?

I don't know if it's fair that I continue to participate, given what happened.

I'm sorry G-Man, if I ruined anything.

And holy crap, I even asked about this in the thread and lapluie encouraged me. What the heck?

I'm going to cook now.

[lapluie]

yea

Please share.

something wrong if there isn't?

Yes.

lapluie is good and marmot is bad.

no there isn't. fight me.

Idk why he kept saying marmot is bad & hadn't voted for him that time, but stil... Quin is a suspect

[lapluie]

Charlie Baseball:

It's clear now that either Marmot or Colin is a bad guy. Which one is it?

I don't know if it's fair that I continue to participate, given what happened.

I'm sorry G-Man, if I ruined anything.

And holy crap, I even asked about this in the thread and lapluie encouraged me. What the heck?

I'm going to cook now.

pls be accountable for ur own actions thx

[Dyslexicon]

Looks like it may be more strategic to lynch outside Marmot/Colin?

But I actually am not quite sure who I would prefer. I mean, I guess Quin?