Easter Mafia [GAME OVER]

[lapluie]

I think so too [mention]Dyslexicon[/mention] ....

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I want a trajectory laid out for my own reference.

Spoiler: show

If someone sees an error, lemme know.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Looks like it may be more strategic to lynch outside Marmot/Colin?

But I actually am not quite sure who I would prefer. I mean, I guess Quin?

I'm considering it, though I am inclined to believe that whichever one of Colin/Marmot is mafia is not Caerbannog (meaning if we successfully hit the teammate, it would be Caerbannog). My first guess on that front is Quin.

[Dyslexicon]

I forgive anyone for suspecting me btw. Cause I have a real hard time coming up with a clear cut this is the most suspicious outside of marmotcolincharlie salad.

[Scotty]

Guys i only have 3% on my phone and am in the woods for the night workig. I do have a charger but I can’t peomise I will locate an outlet in this building before EoD.

If we lynch off wagon I support Quin, if you guys think the math works best there. Lap sus he’s in the pool with Colin and marmot and the chlorine needs to come in on one of them I feel

[Dyslexicon]

Looks like it may be more strategic to lynch outside Marmot/Colin?

But I actually am not quite sure who I would prefer. I mean, I guess Quin?

I'm considering it, though I am inclined to believe that whichever one of Colin/Marmot is mafia is not Caerbannog (meaning if we successfully hit the teammate, it would be Caerbannog). My first guess on that front is Quin.

Oh, I assumed the opposite. That Caerbannog would be the one claiming. But thinking about it you may be right.

[Marmot]

GUYS what if Marmot left his breadcrumb trail for this very purpose for whichever power role seemed most appealing to claim as.

Think about it-

He claimed 20 minutes after lap claimed today, and the breadcrumbs he left were vague enough that it could have been for anything.

Also he claimed Gladys a while back, didn’t he? Why on earth would the doctor claim Gladys?

Wait when did marmot claimed gladys???

Unless I’m wrong and this isn’t actually a claim, this was day 2:

If I am Gladys Campbell, Colin is a dentist.

That was a response to Jay doing the same thing, I was only protecting the real cop.

[Dyslexicon]

Depending on if Charlie continues or not it may screw with the math though. Maybe just lynch Marmot and hope he flips scum. Passing up an opportunity to lynch lynchable mafia would be terrible. The benefits of a successful flip is great.

[Dyslexicon]

That was a response to Jay doing the same thing, I was only protecting the real cop.

Yes. The doctor works as an excellent shield.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Eat my hat if mafia tier: Scotty

You've done a great job to look the part if you're mafia tier: nutella

You've sold yourself well after a pressure-filled near-death experience tier: Quin

Despite my suspicions you look town as hell on day 4, and I don't think you kill nova/Kyle tier: Dizzy

[JaggedJimmyJay]

That was a response to Jay doing the same thing, I was only protecting the real cop.

What happens if your cover is successful, and the mafia team kills your ass? Then we're out a doctor.

[Dyslexicon]

Where is Quin anyway. Just noticed he has no vote.

[Dyslexicon]

I honestly just skimmed the part where Quin did the dramatic "lynch me". I don't think it particularly moved me though. Should revisit.

[Marmot]

That was a response to Jay doing the same thing, I was only protecting the real cop.

What happens if your cover is successful, and the mafia team kills your ass? Then we're out a doctor.

Then the cop is more likely to continue living and make more checks.

I dunno, I just responded immediately because it seemed like the right thing to do.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Scotty's observation is the most moving so far. I struggle to believe that one power role is going to provide cover for the other. The entire point of providing cover is to get shot.

[Scotty]

GUYS what if Marmot left his breadcrumb trail for this very purpose for whichever power role seemed most appealing to claim as.

Think about it-

He claimed 20 minutes after lap claimed today, and the breadcrumbs he left were vague enough that it could have been for anything.

Also he claimed Gladys a while back, didn’t he? Why on earth would the doctor claim Gladys?

Wait when did marmot claimed gladys???

Unless I’m wrong and this isn’t actually a claim, this was day 2:

If I am Gladys Campbell, Colin is a dentist.

That was a response to Jay doing the same thing, I was only protecting the real cop.

[VOTE: marmot] aubergine

The doctor protecting the cop is like paper beating scissors. It don’t make sense

[Scotty]

Scotty's observation is the most moving so far. I struggle to believe that one power role is going to provide cover for the other. The entire point of providing cover is to get shot.

The only possibility i can fathom is if he protected himself that day.

But at his own admission, he protected Kyle n2, so..,

[Marmot]

Guys... I'm not that good at doing things that make sense... I'm sorry that I've let you down.

[Dyslexicon]

Guys... I'm not that good at doing things that make sense... I'm sorry that I've let you down.

You play like me when scum.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Guys... I'm not that good at doing things that make sense... I'm sorry that I've let you down.

Do you believe Colin is Caerbannog?

[Dyslexicon]

Despite my suspicions you look town as hell on day 4, and I don't think you kill nova/Kyle tier: Dizzy

How have I looked town as hell this day compared to other days?

[lapluie]

GUYS what if Marmot left his breadcrumb trail for this very purpose for whichever power role seemed most appealing to claim as.

Think about it-

He claimed 20 minutes after lap claimed today, and the breadcrumbs he left were vague enough that it could have been for anything.

Also he claimed Gladys a while back, didn’t he? Why on earth would the doctor claim Gladys?

Wait when did marmot claimed gladys???

Unless I’m wrong and this isn’t actually a claim, this was day 2:

If I am Gladys Campbell, Colin is a dentist.

That was a response to Jay doing the same thing, I was only protecting the real cop.

[Quin]

i have literally never been so offended

i skimmed the suspicion of me. i'll go back and groin punch all of it individually. brb.

[Marmot]

Guys... I'm not that good at doing things that make sense... I'm sorry that I've let you down.

Do you believe Colin is Caerbannog?

I believe he claimed because he had 6 votes and it was the best thing he could do to survive, and that his actual role is irrelevant of that.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Despite my suspicions you look town as hell on day 4, and I don't think you kill nova/Kyle tier: Dizzy

How have I looked town as hell this day compared to other days?

Instead of telling me how I'm making no sense and from another planet, you're engaging a heated dialogue which will likely decide who wins the game with a believable fervor and tone.

[Dyslexicon]

i have literally never been so offended

i skimmed the suspicion of me. i'll go back and groin punch all of it individually. brb.

Don't bother. Find Marmot (Colin? Nah)'s teammate.

[lapluie]

[mention]Quin[/mention] well u think marmot is bad don't you? How about we lynch him

[JaggedJimmyJay]

i have literally never been so offended

i skimmed the suspicion of me. i'll go back and groin punch all of it individually. brb.

How are you even aware of it

[Marmot]

Guys... I'm not that good at doing things that make sense... I'm sorry that I've let you down.

You play like me when scum.

Lol, welcome to my playstyle in general.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Guys... I'm not that good at doing things that make sense... I'm sorry that I've let you down.

Do you believe Colin is Caerbannog?

I believe he claimed because he had 6 votes and it was the best thing he could do to survive, and that his actual role is irrelevant of that.

If he's Caerbannog, he doesn't need to do any of that to survive. So. ?

[Dyslexicon]

Instead of telling me how I'm making no sense and from another planet, you're engaging a heated dialogue which will likely decide who wins the game with a believable fervor and tone.

I spew town out of my ass all day every day when I'm town.

But ok.

[lapluie]

Voting quin bcos risking marmots life & or Colin if either of them is keith is conflicting tbh

[Marmot]

i have literally never been so offended

i skimmed the suspicion of me. i'll go back and groin punch all of it individually. brb.

Are you Colin's teammate?

[VOTE: Quin] aubergine

[Quin]

Let's say colin/marmot are keith
Then there's 3 vanilla civi - apart from keith
& 2 badies /non dentists
Marmot
Colin & quin are not dentists
what are the chances all of them are not bad & chances that they are.. either one imo would be good lynch, I think
But then what about quin?? There was a time when quin was ready to give up playing & had about 4 votes then suddenly we got a mis lynch directed to another player, anybody remember who voted who??

"There's a higher chance that any of the three of them could be town than mafia so they'd be a good lynch." Your words.

[lapluie]

Are u gonna vote for yourself like last time or

[Dyslexicon]

Quin, can you please try to spend less time defending yourself and more time figuring out the game? Cause that is were you could sway me if you're town.

[Quin]

yea

Please share.

something wrong if there isn't?

Yes.

lapluie is good and marmot is bad.

no there isn't. fight me.

Idk why he kept saying marmot is bad & hadn't voted for him that time, but stil... Quin is a suspect

You are obviously in a tunnel. Stop ignoring the fact that I can have multiple scum reads and have no obligation to lynch the first one I find.

[lapluie]

I'd like for a 3 way tie to happen but that's not possible

[Quin]

Quin, can you please try to spend less time defending yourself and more time figuring out the game? Cause that is were you could sway me if you're town.

No. I'm sick and should be working right now but instead I'm defending myself against a hot potato. I have nothing else for you right now.

[Quin]

Looks like it may be more strategic to lynch outside Marmot/Colin?

But I actually am not quite sure who I would prefer. I mean, I guess Quin?

I'm considering it, though I am inclined to believe that whichever one of Colin/Marmot is mafia is not Caerbannog (meaning if we successfully hit the teammate, it would be Caerbannog). My first guess on that front is Quin.

If you think this then you need to answer to my comment when you first pointed it out.

[Marmot]

Guys... I'm not that good at doing things that make sense... I'm sorry that I've let you down.

Do you believe Colin is Caerbannog?

I believe he claimed because he had 6 votes and it was the best thing he could do to survive, and that his actual role is irrelevant of that.

If he's Caerbannog, he doesn't need to do any of that to survive. So. ?

If he's lynched, successful or not, we go into Night 4 with two power roles alive, and both essentially confirmed (assuming lap is the cop).

If I'm lynched, we go into Night 4 with just a single cop who will be nightkilled. And we're still left wondering whether Colin is Cabernog or not.



It's a bold move, and it's clearly working.

[Dyslexicon]

Quin, can you please try to spend less time defending yourself and more time figuring out the game? Cause that is were you could sway me if you're town.

No. I'm sick and should be working right now but instead I'm defending myself against a hot potato. I have nothing else for you right now.

It's not a hot potato. It's a uncooked one, newly plucked from the ground, with dirt on it.

Marmot claimed Keith. Colin countered. That is where we lynch.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Looks like it may be more strategic to lynch outside Marmot/Colin?

But I actually am not quite sure who I would prefer. I mean, I guess Quin?

I'm considering it, though I am inclined to believe that whichever one of Colin/Marmot is mafia is not Caerbannog (meaning if we successfully hit the teammate, it would be Caerbannog). My first guess on that front is Quin.

If you think this then you need to answer to my comment when you first pointed it out.

I don't think you've done anything that is incompatible with a mafia alignment since the self-vote incident. If you disagree, show me.

[Marmot]

I do find it amazing that Quin skimmed and address the suspicions against him but had nothing to say about the Colin/Marmot debate.

[Dyslexicon]

Can we focus on getting it right between Marmot and Colin?

[Quin]

Looks like it may be more strategic to lynch outside Marmot/Colin?

But I actually am not quite sure who I would prefer. I mean, I guess Quin?

I'm considering it, though I am inclined to believe that whichever one of Colin/Marmot is mafia is not Caerbannog (meaning if we successfully hit the teammate, it would be Caerbannog). My first guess on that front is Quin.

If you think this then you need to answer to my comment when you first pointed it out.

I don't think you've done anything that is incompatible with a mafia alignment since the self-vote incident. If you disagree, show me.

Don't dodge the question. Answer me.

[Dyslexicon]

I do find it amazing that Quin skimmed and address the suspicions against him but had nothing to say about the Colin/Marmot debate.

So, now you're just as invested in lynching Quin as (from your supposed POV) a confirmed scum!Colin.

Pfffffffffffffffffffft.

[lapluie]

I do find it amazing that Quin skimmed and address the suspicions against him but had nothing to say about the Colin/Marmot debate.

Very true.. there's clearly more discussing to be brought up

[Quin]

I maintain my civ read on Marmot.
lapluie is a civ lost so deep in a tunnel I don't have the energy to bring her back out, nor would she ever agree to come out of.

These are lynches I won't vote self-preservation for.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Don't dodge the question. Answer me.

I just did. If that doesn't answer your question, then you're going to need to restate it.