U-Pick Mafia Vol 1 - Game Over

[ColinIsCool]

Cbob, care to explain your role further or no?

Literally explained all of it

What that's not true, I can't target myself.

There that's all

One-shot or what?

[colonialbob]

Cbob, care to explain your role further or no?

Literally explained all of it

What that's not true, I can't target myself.

There that's all

One-shot or what?

...... no?

[sig]

Scotty died on Night 3

Lets just pretend for a bit that every time I said Odd I meant Even and vice verse and I didn't switch around which numbers where which okay?

[sig]

I promise I'm not a total moron I'm still on the deans list. (Though it would explain my bad math grades)

[ColinIsCool]

Scotty died on Night 3

Lets just pretend for a bit that every time I said Odd I meant Even and vice verse and I didn't switch around which numbers where which okay?

[sig]

Scotty died on Night 3

Lets just pretend for a bit that every time I said Odd I meant Even and vice verse and I didn't switch around which numbers where which okay?

[ColinIsCool]

[ColinIsCool]

Unless somebody comes up with something better I’m driving 300 miles across state lines going 80 mph the whole way at 3:30 in the morning just so I can lynch sig as of RIGHT NOW

[sig]

Unless somebody comes up with something better I’m driving 300 miles across state lines going 80 mph the whole way at 3:30 in the morning just so I can lynch sig as of RIGHT NOW

No bad colins bad boy.

[sig]

My civ minded speak for myself, I called out not only nova, but was the main reason LC got lynched since it was my alignment check passed through to DDL that let the train get rolling.

I won't go so far to NO U colin, but him going after me makes me very iffy of him.
I'd also keep in mind the whole reason I backed off of him was because Juliet vouched for him and she was a solid civ read, BUT she could've been co-opted/recruited when she escaped so we can't say for sure she still is a civ. I'll need to reread her actions since her reemergence and look over Colin as well. Though he's probably just a confused civ.

[sig]

civ minded record*

[sig]

[mention]Turnip Head[/mention] Who would you like to lynch next phase and why?

[Kylemii]

imbuing someone with two votes, which sounds like what his power is isn't inherently good, but also not bad.

@Kylemii Does his role check out?

it does, he told me his power was to +1 a vote to another player's vote

[Quin]

I was online the other day and noticed I was the only registered user viewing the thread with 93 guests and thought it was weird. Then I realised this thread is full of the word ISIS. LOL. Hello feds! I promise we're just playing a friendly game and was just making a pun.

i swear if you get this site shut down i'll never forgive you

[MacDougall]

I was online the other day and noticed I was the only registered user viewing the thread with 93 guests and thought it was weird. Then I realised this thread is full of the word ISIS. LOL. Hello feds! I promise we're just playing a friendly game and was just making a pun.

i swear if you get this site shut down i'll never forgive you

That would not be my fault. That would be the fault of a very over zealous government agent no?

[sig]

I was online the other day and noticed I was the only registered user viewing the thread with 93 guests and thought it was weird. Then I realised this thread is full of the word ISIS. LOL. Hello feds! I promise we're just playing a friendly game and was just making a pun.

i swear if you get this site shut down i'll never forgive you

That would not be my fault. That would be the fault of a very over zealous government agent no?

[Kylemii]

[mention]Turnip Head[/mention] did you still want to play a snake game

[juliets]

Holy moly - so, INH did the exact same thing as he did in Ass Class and tried to say it was NAI, hahaha. And who got after me for letting dunya's read of Kites sway me against voting for him early in the phase? I should have listened to her.

I will be driving home today so after a little while I won't be in the thread anymore until late if at all.

[juliets]

Wait, I'm looking at the poll and the vote was 5-4. How did we end up lynching both INH and Kites?

[colonialbob]

Wait, I'm looking at the poll and the vote was 5-4. How did we end up lynching both INH and Kites?

I gave Kyle a double vote.

Which should also prove my power, although that doesn't prove I'm civ.

[juliets]

Wait, I'm looking at the poll and the vote was 5-4. How did we end up lynching both INH and Kites?

I gave Kyle a double vote.

Which should also prove my power, although that doesn't prove I'm civ.

So c-bob, the poll I'm looking at which is on the previous page, doesn't show that Kyle has a double vote. Or did you mean Kites? That would make more sense given my question.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I was online the other day and noticed I was the only registered user viewing the thread with 93 guests and thought it was weird. Then I realised this thread is full of the word ISIS. LOL. Hello feds! I promise we're just playing a friendly game and was just making a pun.

Don't worry, this site is usually being swarmed by a bunch of bots, and it has been like that for years. Some of them try to create accounts sometimes.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Voted DougMacall. Sounds like a trustworthy fella.

[colonialbob]

Wait, I'm looking at the poll and the vote was 5-4. How did we end up lynching both INH and Kites?

I gave Kyle a double vote.

Which should also prove my power, although that doesn't prove I'm civ.

So c-bob, the poll I'm looking at which is on the previous page, doesn't show that Kyle has a double vote. Or did you mean Kites? That would make more sense given my question.

Why would the poll show Kyle has a double vote? He's still just one person.

(Double vote = his vote counts as 2, apparently the double vote terminology means something different to some people here?)

[juliets]

Wait, I'm looking at the poll and the vote was 5-4. How did we end up lynching both INH and Kites?

I gave Kyle a double vote.

Which should also prove my power, although that doesn't prove I'm civ.

So c-bob, the poll I'm looking at which is on the previous page, doesn't show that Kyle has a double vote. Or did you mean Kites? That would make more sense given my question.

Why would the poll show Kyle has a double vote? He's still just one person.

(Double vote = his vote counts as 2, apparently the double vote terminology means something different to some people here?)

OOOOOHHHHHH I see. I interpreted that as you gave Kyle two votes. I understand now, thanks.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Bob and TH are the two people I'm least confident in atm.

linki:
Since it was ISIS kill wasn't it.

No, look at when Scotty died. I’m fairly certain Pieda kills on odd nights.

Didn't he die on n3 though?

linki: Psh please daddy?

Yes, he was ISIS. As was Luna on Night 5. So there’s no real reason to assume Luna was vig killed over the Pieda kill.

But even if she was also a Pieda kill it would mean they killed on even nights?

Well either way i guess we'll see when the phase ends.

I don’t understand what you mean here.

Honestly neither do I.

I'll just say I've been assuming ISIS kills on Odd nights And Pieda on Even. This is based off of Scotty dying on an Even night.

And I assumed the second kill last night was a vig shot and that the vig wouldn't shoot dunya since she was mostly being civ read while Luna was getting some pressure.

I've been assuming both mafias kill every night. Because thats how you make a 31 player game not last forever.

[ColinIsCool]

We’ve had 3 nights where only one kill was clearly attributable to the night kill so I think they must alternate.

[ColinIsCool]

Someone read that exchange between sig and I and tell me what you think.

[ColinIsCool]

My civ minded speak for myself, I called out not only nova, but was the main reason LC got lynched since it was my alignment check passed through to DDL that let the train get rolling.

I won't go so far to NO U colin, but him going after me makes me very iffy of him.
I'd also keep in mind the whole reason I backed off of him was because Juliet vouched for him and she was a solid civ read, BUT she could've been co-opted/recruited when she escaped so we can't say for sure she still is a civ. I'll need to reread her actions since her reemergence and look over Colin as well. Though he's probably just a confused civ.

I’m at work and unable to ISO completely, but if you can provide posts justifying these claims re: Nova and Long Con it’d be for your benefit. I don’t think your “calling out” of nova as I saw it looks good at all, but maybe I missed the post you refer to.

[ColinIsCool]

For example:

Spoiler: show

This is a prewritten message recorded during the unfortunate time period where I should’ve been engaging in a hot orgy, but instead was just kinda hanging out chained to a wall and having my plane delayed by many many many hours. (3ish to be exact) HOWEVER, I will use this time to record some thoughts I’ve had throughout the phase.
1. I believe DDL, especially since I’m very confident I’ll be returning soon to the land of the living, I’m very much against lynching him at all and can confirm 100% that he had nothing to do with my abduction. Also screw you boyfriend (figuratively not literally, bet I’ll be tired from my time in the sex cave) letting me get kidnapped gotta say can’t see this relationship lasting long.
I do see the game theory logic that Jack presented however, I think Jack was also using this game theory to stir up paranoia on DDL which is a bad look for him.

2. I’ve really disliked Nutella’s tone this phase it rubs me all the wrong ways. I’d be shocked if she was civ.

3. Golden is creeping me out.

4. But, not as much as goats, goats are creepy man. Its like they know I love lamb and plan to rise up and kill me

5. LC is being too nice

6. But, not as nice as like Bill Cosby so I think we’re safe for now ( My mind is still in the sex dungeon :P )

7. Dunya is gone, anybody make progress on saving her if she needs to be saved or what?

8. Why has nobody questioned DDL about Juliets? She’s slipped through the cracks for sure. Can he bring her back or was I the only option and
why.

9. @Daisy were you punished for breaking a rule or was your time out an ability?

10. Lilifer/Lochlan has been very inactive this I dislike, I also disagree that he’d post more with a cooler role, while he’d most likely post a bit
more we wouldn’t see a massive movement.

11. What happened to Scotty? He was looking great than dropped off the map

12. Dogs are pretty crummy personally but I do find cats amazing

13. Sloonie should be getting some pressure votes until he starts giving more content, RP is fun and all but it doesn’t win mafia games.

14. Sig is amazing and super tired, so ignore spelling/grammar errors.

15. Elo is also rubbing me the wrong way, I could see her being mafia.

16. Yes I’m adding extra shit just to see if y’all are bothering to read it if you are than howdy what’s up how ya doing yadyadyad.

17. Bren’s posting a lot for being dead I suggest we ignore him in case it triggers some sorta role thing.

18. I literally have no real civ reads atm. I confident DDL is being honest therefore I’d rather not lynch him, Epi is obvs a civ, and I don’t want to lynch Daisy. Her frustration seemed to genuine. I won’t be lynching Lap or Luna both are playing within civ meta.

19. Nova has been flying under the radar I suggest a vig hit seeing how good they are at coasting to end game as mafia.

20. Vig Hit a new and improved item take one shot and your shooting like a vig! Saving town from evils both large and small. WARNING: may cause the death of all allies, hair loss, total disgrace and exile from the forum, and a mafia victory. 70% of people who have used Vig Hit have reported feeling like morons after killing an important civ role and giving the game to the mafia. Try today for a limited time only. Vig hit a killer you can trust.

21. Where in the world is Motel and Kites? Neither have really contributed much that I can remember

22. Someone mentioned Kyle not joking as much? I think this is NAI some games I joke more others I joke less ect.

23. INH and Zeph has very few posts don’t like this at all

24. Yes I’m very bored in case you couldn’t tell

25. TH looks good, but I don’t remember his scum/civ meta. He wants me to frolic though so he can stay alive ( Unless that was another game than lets lynch the bastard)

26. Haven’t read any of Bobs posts and don’t plan to I’ll put him as a light civ read for the effort he’s putting forth

27. Colins is looking good nice activity

28. Cats are amazing

29. Juliets and I were abducted by different people, with I’d assume different agendas. I believe her abduction might be a more basic silenced/jailkept type thing while mine isn’t.

30. Any medics or protector roles should make DDL a priority as long as he can return vanished players he’s needed.

31. I doubt Zeph is mafia I think he was just guessing re Lochlan.

32. Mars bars are amazing for more information log onto discord RIGHT NOW (7:54 Am UTC 0) to learn more or just come and chat since I’m bored this is a limited time offer and won’t last long so make good use of its.


Very disappointed with thhe fact we got stuck with this poll btw, I much preferred the 3 lynches. And I REAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAALY like Luna calling out Golden on his post. Even if he did make the poll that doesn’t mean he’s a civ at all it could be a mafia power.

That’s all I’ve got atm, I basically spun my wheels and did nothing of major value this phase, so oh well, if anyone wants my input let me know preferable through a mention and I’ll get back to ya. I do plan to jump on and post this as soon as I can, but It’ll be 12:30 am I believe when the day ends so I highly doubt this post will be up until noon. (I’ve got no clue when Day ends ignore this) God speed good townies, screw you mafia, and Indies keep being the selfish bastards that you are.


Continuing on starting at page 67ish


33. Kites is talking to a girl and girls are gross ergo Kites is gross.

34. Disagree with Dunya’s “Girls before mafia” we’re all bros here and following the bro code its mafiabeforehoes :P

35. Hate Eloh’s refusal to contribute, if someone could give me some insight into whether this is a more civ thing or not that would be great, but
atm this seems like a way for mafia to avoid breaking a tie/getting looked at.

36. Love scotty thoughts on current lynches

37. I see Juliet’s reading the thread, howdy Juliet’s! What are your current thoughts.

38. I see where Nutella is coming from with the Zeph thing, I don’t necessarily think she’s right, but it does make her look more civvie in my eyes.

39. Luna’s looking good, I agree with her on Jack’s post. I also dislike his reactions on DDL, which I already mentioned. I could see him being one
the abductors, I’d suggest we knock out Jack.

40. So Nutella posts are coming across and a combination of cocky and aggressive, but she also seems like she’s trying really hard to be helpful by suggesting things to Mac and playing a consoling role in game. So like she’s trying to be helpful, but it’s so over the top that I feel like she isn’t serious about it?

41. I’ve changed my mind on Eloh she seems more civ minded.


P.S. I wasn’t tecruited by a cult or mafia last night, try harder cult/mafia. My loose streak is directly tied to me being a civ I need an epic win.

Last thoughts. I said something about Golden being weird earlier his response was to turn it into a joke about him lynching me last game. I didn’t think that was odd until right now, but I believe it could’ve been an attempt to disvalue my gut read.

Here's a slightly better spaced out format of my post.

This is not calling out Nova. It’s not even a good suspicion. It’s a random throwaway comment that nobody would take seriously.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

We’ve had 3 nights where only one kill was clearly attributable to the night kill so I think they must alternate.

What does "clearly" even mean?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Just saying in places not called Mafia Syndicate, having both mafias kill at once is the norm. Alternating kills is something I only see here. So maybe you guys are taking for granted that kills alternate, while I'm taking the opposite for granted.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

But if we get two kills every night, chances are both mafias are killing at once, rather than that we have a vig that hasn't missed a single kill.

[ColinIsCool]

We’ve had 3 nights where only one kill was clearly attributable to the night kill so I think they must alternate.

What does "clearly" even mean?

I suppose it’s not clear since theoretically any kill could come from anywhere. So I am wrong to call it that, but my point was about numbers:

Night 1: 3
Night 2: 1
Night 3: 4 (3 being Luna)
Night 4: 1
Night 5: 2

There are 3 Nights there that seem to discount the possibility of two teams killing per night, or else there’d just be a higher toll. It’s possible that kills are getting blocked in some way, but on 3 out of 5 nights? I dunno about that.

[colonialbob]

just fyi my work recently moved locations and the reception here is even worse than it was previously (plus we have lower cube walls. So I probably won't be around much if at all during the day anymore.

[Long Con]

As a host, I always love all my roles too much. I want to see each of them flourish and reach their full potential, and increasing the number of kill per night just cuts short more beautiful lives. My role-children are more important to me than ensuring a quick game. I understand some prefer a fast game. That's why I make Jobs, not Heists.

[Turnip Head]

That's why I make Jobs, not Heists.

L O N G C O N 2 0 2 0

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Eh I like to think game length is already covered by the fact it's 48h instead of 24h, and that we shouldn't make it artificially longer.

Besides civ chance of victory increases with every day phase you add. I mean look at GoC. Mafia didn't have a chance of standing up against 15 polls of teammate analysis.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Like imagine hosting a 60p game and still applying alternated kills.

-> But DDL 60p games don't exist.

They exist in other places and they only work because there are 4-5 people deing every night.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

That said this game has been quite generous in terms of deaths. If it does have alternated kills then Mac has managed to compensate with other abilities.

[Epignosis]

DDL is talking about mafia found in other places and mechanics that have no bearing on this one. He is not a civilian.

[juliets]

DDL is talking about mafia found in other places and mechanics that have no bearing on this one. He is not a civilian.

Right, he told us he's 3p. Or are you just joking around. I'm tired so it's hard to tell.

[Epignosis]

DDL is talking about mafia found in other places and mechanics that have no bearing on this one. He is not a civilian.

Right, he told us he's 3p. Or are you just joking around. I'm tired so it's hard to tell.

I gave him a beer. You tell me.

[juliets]

DDL is talking about mafia found in other places and mechanics that have no bearing on this one. He is not a civilian.

Right, he told us he's 3p. Or are you just joking around. I'm tired so it's hard to tell.

I gave him a beer. You tell me.

Seems like you like him then.

[nutella]

As a host, I always love all my roles too much. I want to see each of them flourish and reach their full potential, and increasing the number of kill per night just cuts short more beautiful lives. My role-children are more important to me than ensuring a quick game. I understand some prefer a fast game. That's why I make Jobs, not Heists.

That's why I make Jobs, not Heists.

L O N G C O N 2 0 2 0

*wipes tear*

[Epignosis]

DDL is talking about mafia found in other places and mechanics that have no bearing on this one. He is not a civilian.

Right, he told us he's 3p. Or are you just joking around. I'm tired so it's hard to tell.

I gave him a beer. You tell me.

Seems like you like him then.

He made the team, didn't he?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Someone has just accused me of the same thing in another game.

I just like to chatter, people.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Oh nvm it's jest.

[MacDougall]

Omar was on day 1879 of the much anticipated Sonemic build. Beta 46 has been taking forever and he was very frustrated. Cornering a small innocent creature he decided to take his frustrations out on it. He kicked and stomped on the poor thing until it stopped moving. Lord knows why he decided to do it in the middle of the town though. For repercussions there would surely be.

ColinIsCool has been killed.

He was

Spoiler: show

Fergus, Son of Shrek, Civilian. You are an adorable baby ogre. If someone kills you they will be brutally murdered for justice.

Sloonei has been hanged by the townsfolk for an unspeakable crime.

He was

Spoiler: show

Sharifi, Al-Pieda. Each night you can target an RYMer and share a BTSC with them.

It is now day 7, and on we go.

[ColinIsCool]

My work here is done. Good luck guys, this has been a blast.