Easter Mafia [GAME OVER]

[nutella]

Whoever it is, you've played your ass off and I salute you. Whatever happens, the loser of this game will have done everything they can to win.

It's shit like this that makes me want to vote for you again. This sounds like Bravo. This isn't your civ persistence.

[Dyslexicon]

I don't understand what motivation Scotty has for playing dumb here. [mention]Scotty[/mention], Do you think the lynch should definitely be between me and you?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Whoever it is, you've played your ass off and I salute you. Whatever happens, the loser of this game will have done everything they can to win.

It's shit like this that makes me want to vote for you again. This sounds like Bravo. This isn't your civ persistence.

Then calm down. If there's one thing about me in Mafia that transcends alignment, it's my appreciation for a hard-fought game.

[Dyslexicon]

Nut is using all different and more emojis in FE. Like, I think that's my only observation at this point. >_>

[Dyslexicon]

ColinIsCool
Kylemii
M Plus 7
novaselinenever
Scotty

Dyslexicon
TheFloyd73

wolbre04
Quin
MacDougall
lapluie
Elohcin
Choutas

One teammate at the top.

One teammate at the bottom.

lol I noticed that too

Seems like something you would bring up in that case actually.

I read through some of Phenon. It was a short game. Jimmey did the "why is this player town?" in Ass Class as well though. I don't feel particularly compelled to lynch Jimmey for this.

[Dyslexicon]

Dizzy are you caught up? What are your thoughts? Are you reconsidering Jay or am I crazy? Tell me if I'm crazy. I can always move back to Scotty.

I'm considering you way more than Jimmey.

[nutella]

Dizzy are you caught up? What are your thoughts? Are you reconsidering Jay or am I crazy? Tell me if I'm crazy. I can always move back to Scotty.

I'm considering you way more than Jimmey.

Oh? Why's that?

[Dyslexicon]

If I don't think anyone is scum, should I just vote for Colin again?

I was thinking of voting there today if we don’t find a consensus.

But to not think anyone is scum? That’s quite the statement. Why is your vote on me then

I was joking.

[Dyslexicon]

Dizzy are you caught up? What are your thoughts? Are you reconsidering Jay or am I crazy? Tell me if I'm crazy. I can always move back to Scotty.

I'm considering you way more than Jimmey.

Oh? Why's that?

[Dyslexicon]

The notion of exaggerating the Colin read and then placing him in a rainbow with seven reds below him is among Dizzy's worst looks.

I know you don't think I'm scum, but I still find this ironic, cause it should be one of the most obvious signs I'm town. xD

[nutella]

The notion of exaggerating the Colin read and then placing him in a rainbow with seven reds below him is among Dizzy's worst looks.

I know you don't think I'm scum, but I still find this ironic, cause it should be one of the most obvious signs I'm town. xD

Is that so?

[Dyslexicon]

Rezz please

Rezz please

This never gets old

:3

Where the fuck are you in all of this? Like, we’re almost 6 hours before deadline and you haven’t weighed in on anything yet

Are you fucking kidding me?
This sequence happens, and you say you don't know Marmot is dead? Are you paying ANY attention to the game at all?

If you're town I'm going to need to lay down after this.

[Dyslexicon]

The notion of exaggerating the Colin read and then placing him in a rainbow with seven reds below him is among Dizzy's worst looks.

I know you don't think I'm scum, but I still find this ironic, cause it should be one of the most obvious signs I'm town. xD

Is that so?

This is the Nut I saw in FE : p

What do you think of Quin's and Jimmey's theory btw? You haven't commented on it I think.

[nutella]

The notion of exaggerating the Colin read and then placing him in a rainbow with seven reds below him is among Dizzy's worst looks.

I know you don't think I'm scum, but I still find this ironic, cause it should be one of the most obvious signs I'm town. xD

Is that so?

This is the Nut I saw in FE : p

What do you think of Quin's and Jimmey's theory btw? You haven't commented on it I think.

I mentioned it on passing as one of the things that strongly leads me to believe you are town

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I mentioned it on passing as one of the things that strongly leads me to believe you are town

Not strongly enough to spare Dizzy a emoji?

[nutella]

I mentioned it on passing as one of the things that strongly leads me to believe you are town

Not strongly enough to spare Dizzy a emoji?

That was a joke mostly. But I'm still not sure how strong it is because of how Scotty has responded/not responded to it.

[Dyslexicon]

Colin and nutella are chattering away in BTSC right now.

I lol'd. But that was because I read "Scotty and Nutella".

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I mentioned it on passing as one of the things that strongly leads me to believe you are town

Not strongly enough to spare Dizzy a emoji?

That was a joke mostly. But I'm still not sure how strong it is because of how Scotty has responded/not responded to it.

How does that make you feel about Scotty?

[Dyslexicon]

I mentioned it on passing as one of the things that strongly leads me to believe you are town

Not strongly enough to spare Dizzy a emoji?

That was a joke mostly. But I'm still not sure how strong it is because of how Scotty has responded/not responded to it.

Oh. You think he has responded to hit. Cause I think he's pretending to be dumb or just actually not paying attention or thinking straight at all. Is my theory.

[Dyslexicon]

[mention]Scotty[/mention], You really need to answer this shit. Cause this here is what will have you lynched. And if you're actually town, that's just too lame. Do you get it?

[nutella]

I mentioned it on passing as one of the things that strongly leads me to believe you are town

Not strongly enough to spare Dizzy a emoji?

That was a joke mostly. But I'm still not sure how strong it is because of how Scotty has responded/not responded to it.

How does that make you feel about Scotty?

Concerned but I can't blame him for not knowing what to say and even if he does say something I won't know whether to believe it at this point.

[nutella]

Dizzy, do you think there is a way he could respond to it that would make him town in your eyes?

[nutella]

I feel like we're playing taboo lol this is so roundabout

[Scotty]

I don’t think the theory is valid- it’s pure speculation: that no one has protested it also means nothing. Was it a claim?

Nobody claimed anything and nobody will. Rules must be followed.

What is invalid about the theory?

Because it’s the same scenario as a mafia member claiming civ, and people not refuting that specifically. Because it’s heresay and isn’t something that can be verified in a game that forbids faction claims

It's not the same as that. Nobody claimed anything.

A more pointed question for you: Dizzy can be said to have embraced the theory. Nobody else in this game faults them for that. Do you? And as such, do you suspect anyone other than Dizzy at all?

Jay, dizzy can say she’s fucking Chris Kringle and I still wouldn’t believe it. That goes for anyone here too.
And no, I also don’t fault her for embracing it either- it makes her look better. I’m a goddamned leprechaun, just don’t ask to see my pot of gold

[Dyslexicon]

One thing I think is good for Dizzy is that Quin and I both speculated about them being the last dentist, and I don't recall anyone opposing that notion. Dizzy's fiercest enemy has been Scotty, but that relates to other points.

Why would anyone oppose that? We can’t faction claim anyway

Hypothetical situations:

If I'm a Christian in this game and highly suspects someone is the last dentist for something they wrote early in the game, and they don't seem to deny it or even nudge a denial in front of them, then I would find no reason to vote that person because I would know that it was not me and nobody else seems to mind so the theory must be correct.

If I'm a Dentist in this game and there is a theory that someone else is the last dentist for something they wrote early in the game, and they don't seem to deny it or even nudge a denial in front of them, then I would vote that person with fire and dragons and insist on their lynch so hard their computer would get hot.

Do you see what I'm saying?

What are you doing?

[Scotty]

Scotty, You really need to answer this shit. Cause this here is what will have you lynched. And if you're actually town, that's just too lame. Do you get it?

Actually no, if this is the shit that gets me lynched then the town is playing themselves.

I don’t suspect you any less or more because of this “theory” based on the current rules of claiming

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Jay, dizzy can say she’s fucking Chris Kringle and I still wouldn’t believe it. That goes for anyone here too.
And no, I also don’t fault her for embracing it either- it makes her look better. I’m a goddamned leprechaun, just don’t ask to see my pot of gold

Your perspective here makes Dizzy a very likely civilian unless there is something I am just completely missing.

[Dyslexicon]

Scotty, You really need to answer this shit. Cause this here is what will have you lynched. And if you're actually town, that's just too lame. Do you get it?

Actually no, if this is the shit that gets me lynched then the town is playing themselves.

I don’t suspect you any less or more because of this “theory” based on the current rules of claiming

The theory was based on stuff that happened before the rules of claiming. All information is still alive in the thread.

You can't touch me. U mad?

[Dyslexicon]

It just has to be Scotty. I'm done.

[nutella]

Scotty, You really need to answer this shit. Cause this here is what will have you lynched. And if you're actually town, that's just too lame. Do you get it?

Actually no, if this is the shit that gets me lynched then the town is playing themselves.

I don’t suspect you any less or more because of this “theory” based on the current rules of claiming

Oh they are, are they?

Lynch this man

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Scotty, You really need to answer this shit. Cause this here is what will have you lynched. And if you're actually town, that's just too lame. Do you get it?

Actually no, if this is the shit that gets me lynched then the town is playing themselves.

I don’t suspect you any less or more because of this “theory” based on the current rules of claiming

Oh they are, are they?

Lynch this man

This is the shit that makes me want to vote for you again. Playing the slip game at LyLo with something like this is gross.

[Scotty]

Here’s where I’m at: I’m not giving any more attention to the dentist thing- it’s not helping at all.

I came into the day with my main suspects nutella and dys. I don’t like how Dys is now using that as a crutch and is refusing to look seriously at nut today. Epi and nut brought about some tinfoil on JJJ, and I have given that thought as I read it, but I don’t see it, and I’m experiencig a bit of stubborn exhaustion with him as Mafia. I don’t think he would do the bussing he would have done just for civ cred. And that is exactly the narrative that Is being pushed. I need to make the strongest decision I can and nutella’s Roundabout ride is proving to make my thoughts very muddy, when it should be getting clearer. Both are making it exceedingly hard for me to narrow down the field.

But jay is very defensive of Dys, and maybe I’m just wrongzilla

[nutella]

Scotty, You really need to answer this shit. Cause this here is what will have you lynched. And if you're actually town, that's just too lame. Do you get it?

Actually no, if this is the shit that gets me lynched then the town is playing themselves.

I don’t suspect you any less or more because of this “theory” based on the current rules of claiming

Oh they are, are they?

Lynch this man

This is the shit that makes me want to vote for you again. Playing the slip game at LyLo with something like this is gross.

I don't think so. If something makes me confident I've found the last baddie at lylo it's not gross.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Here’s where I’m at: I’m not giving any more attention to the dentist thing- it’s not helping at all.

I came into the day with my main suspects nutella and dys. I don’t like how Dys is now using that as a crutch and is refusing to look seriously at nut today. Epi and nut brought about some tinfoil on JJJ, and I have given that thought as I read it, but I don’t see it, and I’m experiencig a bit of stubborn exhaustion with him as Mafia. I don’t think he would do the bussing he would have done just for civ cred. And that is exactly the narrative that Is being pushed. I need to make the strongest decision I can and nutella’s Roundabout ride is proving to make my thoughts very muddy, when it should be getting clearer. Both are making it exceedingly hard for me to narrow down the field.

But jay is very defensive of Dys, and maybe I’m just wrongzilla

My concern is that given your read on me as you've described it above, your decision should then be pretty simple: nutella. The end. It makes little sense for Dizzy to be mafia if nobody in this game stands against that theory, particularly when the last bastion of relative opposition (you) just said Dizzy looks better for having embraced the theory.

[Scotty]

I would like to add that if I were bad, it would have been easy to piece together a suspicion of JjJ and latch onto that tinfoil case that was being made.

I am starting to think that nutella slept on it and discovered that in a 48 hour period, she may have needed more potential suspects to lean on to distance herself from the fray. The more confusion in a thread like this, the better at lylo

[nutella]

Seriously I actually believe that was a slip. Scotty is under a lot of pressure and that phrasing came from a place of frustration and does not sound like a townie talking about the town. Maybe I'm wrong but I believe that shit happens.

[Dyslexicon]

Here’s where I’m at: I’m not giving any more attention to the dentist thing- it’s not helping at all.

The speculation is extremely helpful if you are town. That is not rocket science, Scotty. It's simple logic. It's pretty detrimental if you're scum. Unfair, maybe, but that's the way the cookie crumbles with a rule change mid game and a numbers game with factioned town.

I'm not moving my vote off you. I have considered Nut. I have considered Jimmey.

[nutella]

I'm not bad. If it's not Scotty it's Jay and that's that.

[Scotty]

Scotty, You really need to answer this shit. Cause this here is what will have you lynched. And if you're actually town, that's just too lame. Do you get it?

Actually no, if this is the shit that gets me lynched then the town is playing themselves.

I don’t suspect you any less or more because of this “theory” based on the current rules of claiming

Oh they are, are they?

Lynch this man

Yes, THEY. As in THE PEOPLE THAT ARE USING THIS AS A BASIS FOR POE

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Seriously I actually believe that was a slip. Scotty is under a lot of pressure and that phrasing came from a place of frustration and does not sound like a townie talking about the town. Maybe I'm wrong but I believe that shit happens.

In this scenario, is Scotty playing himself?

[Dyslexicon]

I was right about something this game. Yay.
Actually, I wasn't half bad.

[Scotty]

Jay, dizzy can say she’s fucking Chris Kringle and I still wouldn’t believe it. That goes for anyone here too.
And no, I also don’t fault her for embracing it either- it makes her look better. I’m a goddamned leprechaun, just don’t ask to see my pot of gold

Your perspective here makes Dizzy a very likely civilian unless there is something I am just completely missing.

From her perspective, it makes her look better

Ok now people are putting words in my mouth

STOP TRYING TO FIND SCUMSLIPS THAT ARENT THERE

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Jay, dizzy can say she’s fucking Chris Kringle and I still wouldn’t believe it. That goes for anyone here too.
And no, I also don’t fault her for embracing it either- it makes her look better. I’m a goddamned leprechaun, just don’t ask to see my pot of gold

Your perspective here makes Dizzy a very likely civilian unless there is something I am just completely missing.

From her perspective, it makes her look better

Ok now people are putting words in my mouth

STOP TRYING TO FIND SCUMSLIPS THAT ARENT THERE

I misunderstood you. What do YOU think of Dizzy embracing the theory? Does it make Dizzy look better or worse or neither?

[Dyslexicon]

[mention]Charlie Blackmon[/mention], Will you be around to strenghten the town consensus with your vote? Just in case.

[nutella]

Seriously I actually believe that was a slip. Scotty is under a lot of pressure and that phrasing came from a place of frustration and does not sound like a townie talking about the town. Maybe I'm wrong but I believe that shit happens.

In this scenario, is Scotty playing himself?

What?

[Scotty]

Here’s where I’m at: I’m not giving any more attention to the dentist thing- it’s not helping at all.

I came into the day with my main suspects nutella and dys. I don’t like how Dys is now using that as a crutch and is refusing to look seriously at nut today. Epi and nut brought about some tinfoil on JJJ, and I have given that thought as I read it, but I don’t see it, and I’m experiencig a bit of stubborn exhaustion with him as Mafia. I don’t think he would do the bussing he would have done just for civ cred. And that is exactly the narrative that Is being pushed. I need to make the strongest decision I can and nutella’s Roundabout ride is proving to make my thoughts very muddy, when it should be getting clearer. Both are making it exceedingly hard for me to narrow down the field.

But jay is very defensive of Dys, and maybe I’m just wrongzilla

My concern is that given your read on me as you've described it above, your decision should then be pretty simple: nutella. The end. It makes little sense for Dizzy to be mafia if nobody in this game stands against that theory, particularly when the last bastion of relative opposition (you) just said Dizzy looks better for having embraced the theory.

No, that’s based on YOUR read of dizzy. I don’t think that absolves dizzy. That you are so deadset on fizzy is something that I must acknowledge tho

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I'm still not 100% on Scotty.

[nutella]

I'm still not 100% on Scotty.

I'm not either until he answers your last question

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Seriously I actually believe that was a slip. Scotty is under a lot of pressure and that phrasing came from a place of frustration and does not sound like a townie talking about the town. Maybe I'm wrong but I believe that shit happens.

In this scenario, is Scotty playing himself?

What?

Scotty has no reason to say "ourselves" or some such in a scenario where he feels other people are screwing the pooch. I hate that you're ignoring the obvious.

[Scotty]

Seriously I actually believe that was a slip. Scotty is under a lot of pressure and that phrasing came from a place of frustration and does not sound like a townie talking about the town. Maybe I'm wrong but I believe that shit happens.

It would be THEY always; in that situation, I am not part of the WE making boneheaded decisions.

[VOTE: nutella] aubergine