Hogwarts Mafia - END

[DharmaHelper]

Right now everyone, Colin included has a strong case for being a civ when you just look at broad strokes. The fact is that cannot be true.

That means we have gone beyond POE.

So...

Who is faking their game?

I think it's DH. I have also explained why.

Great question, from the guy whose "strong case" for being civ includes..

The guy who died conveniently after "clearing" you on the night you believed he could be killed.

[juliets]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What's so ironic is if he's right, you are a very smart and gutsy player which is what you are saying about your civilian play.

[nutella]

Mac r u seriously doubing DH's townieness?

Absolutely. All of you are suspects as far as I'm concerned. This game is in the balance right now and if DH is Mafia he is coasting and I am not about that life.

If only someone here were a cop and able to check his alignment.

If only cop checks were infallible.

[nutella]

Luna if you are voting for Colin you should be willing to question your cop checks too.

The double standards....

[DharmaHelper]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What's so ironic is if he's right, you are a very smart and gutsy player which is what you are saying about your civilian play.

[MacDougall]

I believe that Poutanko is civ because she is evidenced as being WRONG with her cop claim. Mafia do not let this happen. Way too bold.

I believe Luna is a civilian because she has been skeptical of things in a civ way. She has not shown evidence of TMI and her claim is bold.

I believe nutella is a civ because she has shown civilian tendency to backflip on her own points and we have mindmelded a fair bit.

Colin is playing like a townie trapped in POE but he has a green peek too which is more than can be said for several others.

Juliets ... we are going back to the Glorfindel near lynch resulting in a scum lynch instead right? It's pretty goofy reasoning for excluding her from POE.

DharmaHelper has led the town on two lynches and has a green peek. He is also incredulous and dismissive in his townie way.

[MacDougall]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What a shit thing to say.

[MacDougall]

The mafia have imperio. No cop checks are trustworthy really. So the fact that you are being sarcastaluna over my DH push is illogical.

[DharmaHelper]

Juliets ... we are going back to the Glorfindel near lynch resulting in a scum lynch instead right? It's pretty goofy reasoning for excluding her from POE.

Glorf claimed town, which everyone here (Myself excluded) Cares so deeply about as to the truth meta thing.

[DharmaHelper]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What a shit thing to say.

You're whole thing has been like... "DH must have bussed two teammates because there's no way he caught two baddies and is civ" Which is like, in its own way, kinda shitty.

[MacDougall]

DH also got mad when I initially suggested we reveal our roles. Quin and Sloonei were keen and are dead civs fwiw but DH led us away from that. And still hasn't revealed his night actions.

[DharmaHelper]

DH also got mad when I initially suggested we reveal our roles. Quin and Sloonei were keen and are dead civs fwiw but DH led us away from that. And still hasn't revealed his night actions.

No I haven't good point lol.

[MacDougall]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What a shit thing to say.

You're whole thing has been like... "DH must have bussed two teammates because there's no way he caught two baddies and is civ" Which is like, in its own way, kinda shitty.

I have been giving you the credit of believing you capable of something amazing and you just said I suck at Mafia.

Thanks guy. Cool.

[DharmaHelper]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What a shit thing to say.

You're whole thing has been like... "DH must have bussed two teammates because there's no way he caught two baddies and is civ" Which is like, in its own way, kinda shitty.

I have been giving you the credit of believing you capable of something amazing and you just said I suck at Mafia.

Thanks guy. Cool.

I didn't say you suck at mafia

[MacDougall]

Is DH the only one we don't know the abilities of?

[Jackofhearts2005]

DH also got mad when I initially suggested we reveal our roles. Quin and Sloonei were keen and are dead civs fwiw but DH led us away from that. And still hasn't revealed his night actions.

Cause then you’d know who was in his cult.

[DharmaHelper]

Is DH the only one we don't know the abilities of?

IDK good question.

[MacDougall]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What a shit thing to say.

You're whole thing has been like... "DH must have bussed two teammates because there's no way he caught two baddies and is civ" Which is like, in its own way, kinda shitty.

I have been giving you the credit of believing you capable of something amazing and you just said I suck at Mafia.

Thanks guy. Cool.

I didn't say you suck at mafia

I am just doing your thing where you re explain sentences to suit your point.

[nutella]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What a shit thing to say.

You're whole thing has been like... "DH must have bussed two teammates because there's no way he caught two baddies and is civ" Which is like, in its own way, kinda shitty.

I have been giving you the credit of believing you capable of something amazing and you just said I suck at Mafia.

Thanks guy. Cool.

Yeah still gotta side with Mac here. What you said about mac was uncalled for.

[DharmaHelper]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What a shit thing to say.

You're whole thing has been like... "DH must have bussed two teammates because there's no way he caught two baddies and is civ" Which is like, in its own way, kinda shitty.

I have been giving you the credit of believing you capable of something amazing and you just said I suck at Mafia.

Thanks guy. Cool.

Yeah still gotta side with Mac here. What you said about mac was uncalled for.

I didn't say anything about Mac. He's been saying that I must be faking being this good at catching baddies this whole time.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I think we can all agree Colin is the best mislynch option today so let’s just agree to disagree on DH’s alignment.

[nutella]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What a shit thing to say.

You're whole thing has been like... "DH must have bussed two teammates because there's no way he caught two baddies and is civ" Which is like, in its own way, kinda shitty.

I have been giving you the credit of believing you capable of something amazing and you just said I suck at Mafia.

Thanks guy. Cool.

Yeah still gotta side with Mac here. What you said about mac was uncalled for.

I didn't say anything about Mac. He's been saying that I must be faking being this good at catching baddies this whole time.

He's not saying you must be. He's saying you could be, and if you are it's very impressive.

You said that he can't imagine a civ playing mafia well, which implies he can't play well as a civ, which is just mean.

[juliets]

I believe that Poutanko is civ because she is evidenced as being WRONG with her cop claim. Mafia do not let this happen. Way too bold.

I believe Luna is a civilian because she has been skeptical of things in a civ way. She has not shown evidence of TMI and her claim is bold.

I believe nutella is a civ because she has shown civilian tendency to backflip on her own points and we have mindmelded a fair bit.

Colin is playing like a townie trapped in POE but he has a green peek too which is more than can be said for several others.

Juliets ... we are going back to the Glorfindel near lynch resulting in a scum lynch instead right? It's pretty goofy reasoning for excluding her from POE.

DharmaHelper has led the town on two lynches and has a green peek. He is also incredulous and dismissive in his townie way.

I think we're going back to Glorfs claim that he was town, which may be stronger evidence than his being a near lynch in a scum lynch. Though this could be the one time he lied .

[DharmaHelper]

Look all fun and jokes aside I know it's super hard for Mac to think that a civilian knows how to play this game and is good at it so I'm gonna cut him some slack.

What a shit thing to say.

You're whole thing has been like... "DH must have bussed two teammates because there's no way he caught two baddies and is civ" Which is like, in its own way, kinda shitty.

I have been giving you the credit of believing you capable of something amazing and you just said I suck at Mafia.

Thanks guy. Cool.

Yeah still gotta side with Mac here. What you said about mac was uncalled for.

I didn't say anything about Mac. He's been saying that I must be faking being this good at catching baddies this whole time.

He's not saying you must be. He's saying you could be, and if you are it's very impressive.

You said that he can't imagine a civ playing mafia well, which implies he can't play well as a civ, which is just mean.

If he took it tat way that would be mean. That's not what I meant.

[nutella]

I believe that Poutanko is civ because she is evidenced as being WRONG with her cop claim. Mafia do not let this happen. Way too bold.

I believe Luna is a civilian because she has been skeptical of things in a civ way. She has not shown evidence of TMI and her claim is bold.

I believe nutella is a civ because she has shown civilian tendency to backflip on her own points and we have mindmelded a fair bit.

Colin is playing like a townie trapped in POE but he has a green peek too which is more than can be said for several others.

Juliets ... we are going back to the Glorfindel near lynch resulting in a scum lynch instead right? It's pretty goofy reasoning for excluding her from POE.

DharmaHelper has led the town on two lynches and has a green peek. He is also incredulous and dismissive in his townie way.

I think we're going back to Glorfs claim that he was town, which may be stronger evidence than his being a near lynch in a scum lynch. Though this could be the one time he lied .

........eh?

[nutella]

tfw juliets gets too drunk and outs herself as scum

[DharmaHelper]

I believe that Poutanko is civ because she is evidenced as being WRONG with her cop claim. Mafia do not let this happen. Way too bold.

I believe Luna is a civilian because she has been skeptical of things in a civ way. She has not shown evidence of TMI and her claim is bold.

I believe nutella is a civ because she has shown civilian tendency to backflip on her own points and we have mindmelded a fair bit.

Colin is playing like a townie trapped in POE but he has a green peek too which is more than can be said for several others.

Juliets ... we are going back to the Glorfindel near lynch resulting in a scum lynch instead right? It's pretty goofy reasoning for excluding her from POE.

DharmaHelper has led the town on two lynches and has a green peek. He is also incredulous and dismissive in his townie way.

I think we're going back to Glorfs claim that he was town, which may be stronger evidence than his being a near lynch in a scum lynch. Though this could be the one time he lied .

Cool. Cool and good.

[juliets]

Is DH the only one we don't know the abilities of?

IDK good question.

No, I haven't said anything about my abilities other than the Phoenix.

[DharmaHelper]

I should have said "A civilian DharmaHelper knows how to..." etc etc and so on.

[juliets]

tfw juliets gets too drunk and outs herself as scum

lol no that was Saturday night.

[DharmaHelper]

tfw juliets gets too drunk and outs herself as scum

lol no that was Saturday night.

You outted yourself as Scum on Saturday night?

[Jackofhearts2005]

tfw juliets gets too drunk and outs herself as scum

lol no that was Saturday night.

Tell me this happened.

[juliets]

tfw juliets gets too drunk and outs herself as scum

lol no that was Saturday night.

Tell me this happened.

well I wasn't drunk but I was drinking a good bit of wine on discord

[juliets]

tfw juliets gets too drunk and outs herself as scum

lol no that was Saturday night.

You outted yourself as Scum on Saturday night?

oops missed this - no, I was drinking wine and on discord - I wasn't talking about the game, I was talking about wine.

[nutella]

tfw juliets gets too drunk and outs herself as scum

lol no that was Saturday night.

You outted yourself as Scum on Saturday night?

God this game is a trip I love you all

[nutella]

tfw juliets gets too drunk and outs herself as scum

lol no that was Saturday night.

You outted yourself as Scum on Saturday night?

oops missed this - no, I was drinking wine and on discord - I wasn't talking about the game, I was talking about wine.

Classic scumslip right here

[MacDougall]

Have you read your role card juliets?

[juliets]

tfw juliets gets too drunk and outs herself as scum

lol no that was Saturday night.

You outted yourself as Scum on Saturday night?

oops missed this - no, I was drinking wine and on discord - I wasn't talking about the game, I was talking about wine.

Classic scumslip right here

Maybe, but not likely

[juliets]

Have you read your role card juliets?

lol yes, I'm just having some fun. It's late and you made my mind overflow by trying to see DH as scum.

[MacDougall]

Can someone show me where Glorf said he was town?

[DharmaHelper]

Glorf: "dont rezz me"
Also Glorf: *votes Long Con because he doesn't want to be lynched

I’m Town and you damn well know it.

As Town, it’s my job to try to stay alive - God knows why, I’d be quite happy to be out of this mess

[juliets]

Ok, Mac anything else before I go to bed? And thanks DH, I couldn't get to it that quick.

[MacDougall]

Thanks.

I am back at my laptop now so I'm gonna do a little sleuthing. DH if you would be ever so kind as to share your roles now that it's day 7 I think we're beyond the point of it being a dumb idea. Sharing what we all did each night is the last piece of the POE puzzle here imo.

[juliets]

Night Actions -

N3 - Phoenix
N4 - made a potion
N5 - sent it to DH - you're welcome DH
N6 - made a potion

Is that enough or do you need more?

[DharmaHelper]

I mean I guess I could but no one would believe me if I did :P

Well except maybe Juliets.

And mafia have Hogwarts abilities so that means nothing POE-wise.

[DharmaHelper]

Also I don't like outing myself/my actions even in open set ups which I find silly.

[DharmaHelper]

Night Actions -

N3 - Phoenix
N4 - made a potion
N5 - sent it to DH - you're welcome DH
N6 - made a potion

Is that enough or do you need more?

Oh hey thanks it was delish.

[juliets]

OK, I'm gone

[DharmaHelper]

OK, I'm gone

Awe dang I was gonna post my thing and have you confirm it and triple-double-super-extra-plus clear me but if you're going to bed there's no point lol.


Have a good night!

[MacDougall]

I mean I guess I could but no one would believe me if I did :P

Well except maybe Juliets.

And mafia have Hogwarts abilities so that means nothing POE-wise.

This isn't making me feel any less suspicious of you dude.