Gossip Girl Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Mongoose]

I don't like your empty day 0 reads. They seem baseless, and just throw suspicion on random people. Why?

Hol' up, hol' up.

Why?

Why?

How many games have we played together at this point?

Okay, but that aside, why are you so adamant that your day 0 reads are correct? You've only voted Indiglo and myself today. Do you not have any other suspects?

I’m not adamant about anything. I don’t even remember some of my Day 0 reads. Matahari is a suspect. Why is your vote on Mongoose?

Mongoose's tone is overall timid, questioning, and her posts don't hold a lot of content. It doesn't look like a strong town play to me. Which is why she's on my watch list.

A lot of that could be in the eye of the beholder. I chuckled at timid though. I’ve been trying to clock my Aries aggression this game.

I don’t remember if No U is what I think it is, but it was a vote to save myself, and some of the accusations against me were dilute at best. Explanation Salad? Is that the best you got? Even on Day 1?

(Also I don’t want to miss the vote if I make it to yoga because then I won’t be back until after 730pm EST)

[Mongoose]

If you and MacD were in a city together, would it be called Cahoots? Asking for a friend.

You are one strange maphier

That's literally the first correct thing you've surmised about me all day.

This just seems like a funny thing to say if you're actually really scum. If you're town, what's the motive?

Just for clarity: are you asking me the motive behind that one statement or a more general query about my play style?

[Lunalee]

I don't like your empty day 0 reads. They seem baseless, and just throw suspicion on random people. Why?

Hol' up, hol' up.

Why?

Why?

How many games have we played together at this point?

Okay, but that aside, why are you so adamant that your day 0 reads are correct? You've only voted Indiglo and myself today. Do you not have any other suspects?

I’m not adamant about anything. I don’t even remember some of my Day 0 reads. Matahari is a suspect. Why is your vote on Mongoose?

Mongoose's tone is overall timid, questioning, and her posts don't hold a lot of content. It doesn't look like a strong town play to me. Which is why she's on my watch list.

A lot of that could be in the eye of the beholder. I chuckled at timid though. I’ve been trying to clock my Aries aggression this game.

I don’t remember if No U is what I think it is, but it was a vote to save myself, and some of the accusations against me were dilute at best. Explanation Salad? Is that the best you got? Even on Day 1?

(Also I don’t want to miss the vote if I make it to yoga because then I won’t be back until after 730pm EST)

I'm not set on having you lynched, just so you know. If you could move your "SOS" vote anywhere, who would you move it to?

[Lunalee]

If you and MacD were in a city together, would it be called Cahoots? Asking for a friend.

You are one strange maphier

That's literally the first correct thing you've surmised about me all day.

This just seems like a funny thing to say if you're actually really scum. If you're town, what's the motive?

Just for clarity: are you asking me the motive behind that one statement or a more general query about my play style?

you could answer both if you have time!

[Mongoose]

@Lunalee

1. Specifically that statement - just a slight sardonic jab after I felt he had been wrong about me from out of the gate. And a slight attempt at humor.

2. I don’t know if I have a play style, I’m just a more exaggerated version of myself (the offline me isn’t as easily frustrated or gets defensive or aggressive). I’m not sure if you’ve ever played with thellama73 but he also has a sort of whimsical, bananapants Loki play style that’s an exaggeration of his own real persona.

[Mongoose]

Now commuting

[Lunalee]

@Lunalee

1. Specifically that statement - just a slight sardonic jab after I felt he had been wrong about me from out of the gate. And a slight attempt at humor.

2. I don’t know if I have a play style, I’m just a more exaggerated version of myself (the offline me isn’t as easily frustrated or gets defensive or aggressive). I’m not sure if you’ve ever played with thellama73 but he also has a sort of whimsical, bananapants Loki play style that’s an exaggeration of his own real persona.

Hey, thanks. How would you feel about switching to Jay with me? He's my next vote choice. I find it strange he wants me lynched this early in the game when we've played before and is used to my play style (or lack thereof).

[Lunalee]

I'm about to be away and won't be able to change my vote 30 minutes before EOD. I'm feeling more and more that this is a town tie, and I don't like it. But I'm not 100% sure who I should switch to.

[juliets]

I'm about to be away and won't be able to change my vote 30 minutes before EOD. I'm feeling more and more that this is a town tie, and I don't like it. But I'm not 100% sure who I should switch to.

I'm a little concerned it's a town tie too and could be convinced to change my vote but not to jay. To who though.

[Matahari]

I'm about to be away and won't be able to change my vote 30 minutes before EOD. I'm feeling more and more that this is a town tie, and I don't like it. But I'm not 100% sure who I should switch to.

I'm a little concerned it's a town tie too and could be convinced to change my vote but not to jay. To who though.

What has convinced you that the two are town? I remember that people used to become suspicious of the people who switched votes close to the end, or people who waited till the end of day to vote, if the person lynched flipped civ. I’m going to place my vote on Luna, and I am wondering now before I vote, whether she has said anything that makes her look civ to you.

[nutella]

I don't like your empty day 0 reads. They seem baseless, and just throw suspicion on random people. Why?

Hol' up, hol' up.

Why?

Why?

How many games have we played together at this point?

Okay, but that aside, why are you so adamant that your day 0 reads are correct? You've only voted Indiglo and myself today. Do you not have any other suspects?

I’m not adamant about anything. I don’t even remember some of my Day 0 reads. Matahari is a suspect. Why is your vote on Mongoose?

Sure.

[VOTE: jaggedjimmyjay] aubergine

[Owner of a Lonely Heart]

I'm not set on having you lynched, just so you know. If you could move your "SOS" vote anywhere, who would you move it to?

Hold the phone. So you are saying you're not set on voting for Mongoose, but you are still leaving your vote there?!?!? [VOTE: Lunalee] aubergine

Coming from that, I guess I'm just speechless.

[nutella]

Jay and Mongoose are teammates

Intriguing.

If I have to choose between Luna and mongoose I'd definitely vote mongoose. I'll wait a bit closer to end

[nutella]

I'm not set on having you lynched, just so you know. If you could move your "SOS" vote anywhere, who would you move it to?

Hold the phone. So you are saying you're not set on voting for Mongoose, but you are still leaving your vote there?!?!? [VOTE: Lunalee] aubergine

Coming from that, I guess I'm just speechless.

Uh, given the current poll state that is perfectly normal and expected.

[nutella]

Now I think owner is mongoose's teammate lol.

[nutella]

But then mongoose would have been faking not knowing who she was. Hmm

[MacDougall]

I'm not set on having you lynched, just so you know. If you could move your "SOS" vote anywhere, who would you move it to?

Hold the phone. So you are saying you're not set on voting for Mongoose, but you are still leaving your vote there?!?!? [VOTE: Lunalee] aubergine

Coming from that, I guess I'm just speechless.

Nooo that is such a townie post how can you not see that. Scum would never make that post.

[MacDougall]

Lunalee is a civ ffs

[nutella]

Yeah im going to go ahead and [VOTE: mongoose] aubergine bc I think Luna is town. I don't feel great about lynching mongoose yet, I'd prefer Jay mata or owner, but some of them look sorta compatible with her anyway so if she's what's on the table I'll take it. Sorry if you're town.

[juliets]

I'm about to be away and won't be able to change my vote 30 minutes before EOD. I'm feeling more and more that this is a town tie, and I don't like it. But I'm not 100% sure who I should switch to.

I'm a little concerned it's a town tie too and could be convinced to change my vote but not to jay. To who though.

What has convinced you that the two are town? I remember that people used to become suspicious of the people who switched votes close to the end, or people who waited till the end of day to vote, if the person lynched flipped civ. I’m going to place my vote on Luna, and I am wondering now before I vote, whether she has said anything that makes her look civ to you.

It's more that she gives me pause in that she listened to Mongoose and was willing to move her vote so it makes me question my read of her. Day 1 is always a hard read for me, I doubt myself a lot. And Mac is so adamant.

[Lunalee]

I'm about to be away and won't be able to change my vote 30 minutes before EOD. I'm feeling more and more that this is a town tie, and I don't like it. But I'm not 100% sure who I should switch to.

I'm a little concerned it's a town tie too and could be convinced to change my vote but not to jay. To who though.

mathari? though it looks like nutella has switched off of them

[Lunalee]

I'm not set on having you lynched, just so you know. If you could move your "SOS" vote anywhere, who would you move it to?

Hold the phone. So you are saying you're not set on voting for Mongoose, but you are still leaving your vote there?!?!? [VOTE: Lunalee] aubergine

Coming from that, I guess I'm just speechless.

I'm actually very open to moving my vote.

[Matahari]

I'm about to be away and won't be able to change my vote 30 minutes before EOD. I'm feeling more and more that this is a town tie, and I don't like it. But I'm not 100% sure who I should switch to.

I'm a little concerned it's a town tie too and could be convinced to change my vote but not to jay. To who though.

What has convinced you that the two are town? I remember that people used to become suspicious of the people who switched votes close to the end, or people who waited till the end of day to vote, if the person lynched flipped civ. I’m going to place my vote on Luna, and I am wondering now before I vote, whether she has said anything that makes her look civ to you.

It's more that she gives me pause in that she listened to Mongoose and was willing to move her vote so it makes me question my read of her. Day 1 is always a hard read for me, I doubt myself a lot. And Mac is so adamant.

Based on very recent posts, I’m beginning to believe I should not be voting Luna. You’re right, day one is hard.

[Lunalee]

I think everyone here is more than capable of keeping myself from getting lynched if that's what they want. And I have to leave now, so I'm switching my vote to Jay. Good luck.

[nutella]

I'll move to Jay if two more people move off Luna.

[Elohcin]

And I guess you did clear it up in the previous post in response to Jay, but the original post just sounded so enthusiastic about it. Idk it was weird.

That’s okay, I don’t mind getting voted. It’s been a long time since I played, but you might remember me as someone who never explains things well, that hasn’t changed lol.
I remember you as someone who was always on the offense early in games, and it was never indicative of being town or mafia.
Can you tell me what you think about JJJ? His making snap decisions, and naming off a variety of players, is that a diversionary tactic that mafia would use? Or is it him just being silly?

I can talk to this if you don't mind. I think Jay likes to stir the pot and see what kind of responses he gets. It helps him come to conclusions on his thoughts of people.

Good morning @Elohcin , I checked the votes and was surprised to see you voted for Mac. I also checked your ISO but didn't see a reason. Can you explain your thoughts there?

And good morning @Owner of a Lonely Heart I also don't mind your small posts. It's easier for me to digest someone's thoughts when they are given a bit at a time.

I feel like he is hiding behind his words and I like the way mongoose called him out about perhaps something he didn't say in the thread but in btsc.

I suspect indiglo but I don't wanna lynch her in her first game back in a long time.

What is your exact reason for suspecting me? Because I make jokes?

He is just poking you to see what kind of reaction he can get out of you. This reaction doesn't make me think good of you.

However, your next post eases my mind a bit.

For the good of the group: don’t you think such unbridled frustration tends to read/skew more civ? When someone believes something about you that is so patently untrue, the frustration becomes palpable.

Apologies for the leading question, but I really want to know the veracity of my (foregone?) conclusion.

A warning. The syndicate and how people play has changed immensely since you last played. It's a whole new vibe that will take some getting used to, I'm sure.

And yes, I do suspect you Jay.

k, y

I don't like your empty day 0 reads. They seem baseless, and just throw suspicion on random people. Why?

I've come to accept that nutella is a a hound at sniffing out scum. Also, her back-and-forth with you leaves her looking a bit better than you in my opinion.

I might understand throwing out reads like you did on day 0 to get people talking. But you actually stuck with them into day 1. You say you suspect Indiglo and myself, then later on day 1, you still suspect us but "feel bad" lynching either of us. Day 1 is a time to build a case on those suspects if you were serious about them, or drop them if you weren't. Instead you're trying to look like you're staying "consistent," but you still just have no real reason for the suspicions.

I respect Jay and his playstyle. I think it gets people talking and I understand his point of view. But Luna, here, hits the nail on the head. If Jay still suspects indiglo and Luna, he should not "feel bad" lynching them whatsoever. And then, I see he actually did vote indiglo and then Luna. I am not used to this wishy washy Jay. But I have a hard time saying I think he is bad still b/c I respect his process. And I feel like I am seeing Jay's civ process here. @Jay - explain your wishywashyness

Masculine maleness flows through my male body and into my male genitals.

I just want to say that I think you are funny even if no one else does. I feel like you may be intimidated by all these women playing. It's okay to actually PLAY the game.

okay, I may not catch up before the end of the day. So, I think I am going to change my vote to Luna. I will continue to read, however in case I can change my mind beofre the end. Luna has made some posts I agree with, but mafia is not that black and white. Of course, we are either civ or bad, but that doesn't mean even a baddie can't help catch another baddie (for example when there are two baddie teams) and it doesn't mean that a civ can't ever agree with something a baddie says. So...even though Luna says some things that I want to say, "you go girl!" to, I still see her as a bit off and probably bad, especially in her conversations with Jay.

And....I am calling it now, Mata sounds town. I don't usually feel strong enough about a player so early in the game.

Also, I am going to go out on a limb and say Juliets is good. I can never read her, but I am seeing civ here.

oh my goodness the link. and for the record, I still suspect Mac. But my vote there will do nothing so I feel weird keeping it there.

[Elohcin]

Jay and Mongoose are teammates

Are they your teammates?

[nutella]

Nooooo eloh no

[juliets]

I'll move to Jay if two more people move off Luna.

I can move to Reywas, I didn't like his reason for voting for you. But I'm worried about condemning Mongoose to a Lynch. I'm not reading her as bad.

[nutella]

Don't vote for Luna please she put her trust in the thread to love off of her while she's gone bc she moved off of self pres.

[nutella]

Move*off of her

[Elohcin]

I don't like your empty day 0 reads. They seem baseless, and just throw suspicion on random people. Why?

Hol' up, hol' up.

Why?

Why?

How many games have we played together at this point?

Okay, but that aside, why are you so adamant that your day 0 reads are correct? You've only voted Indiglo and myself today. Do you not have any other suspects?

I’m not adamant about anything. I don’t even remember some of my Day 0 reads. Matahari is a suspect. Why is your vote on Mongoose?

Mongoose's tone is overall timid, questioning, and her posts don't hold a lot of content. It doesn't look like a strong town play to me. Which is why she's on my watch list.

she is on my watchlist too which makes me question my thoughts of you. *scratches head*

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I am stuck in a meeting after class. Give me a brief bulleted argument against Mongoose or something, please.

[Mongoose]

okay, I will switch off Luna but not to vote Jay. I'm surprised we've not talked about Mac since I called him out. I was wondering if it really happened until nutella brought it up (catching up and will be right with you again shortly).

[nutella]

I am stuck in a meeting after class. Give me a brief bulleted argument against Mongoose or something, please.

She's not Luna
Her teammates are eloh and owner
GG

[nutella]

okay, I will switch off Luna but not to vote Jay. I'm surprised we've not talked about Mac since I called him out. I was wondering if it really happened until nutella brought it up (catching up and will be right with you again shortly).

Wait what?

[Mongoose]

I am stuck in a meeting after class. Give me a brief bulleted argument against Mongoose or something, please.

The summary is that I'm playing like a relic that know one remembers but Eloh and Juliets and maybe nutella, so everyone is super suspish but I know you'll see through it.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]Elohcin[/mention], I do feel bad for lynching people the people I named. Feeling bad never stopped me before.

[Owner of a Lonely Heart]

I'm not set on having you lynched, just so you know. If you could move your "SOS" vote anywhere, who would you move it to?

Hold the phone. So you are saying you're not set on voting for Mongoose, but you are still leaving your vote there?!?!? [VOTE: Lunalee] aubergine

Coming from that, I guess I'm just speechless.

Nooo that is such a townie post how can you not see that. Scum would never make that post.

If you are not set on the lynch, you should change it. Keeping the vote where it is is not helping the odds of getting a more favorable lynch. Sorry, dinner got called right after I posted.

It's not necessarily townie to self-pres vote, especially if you are half-heartly not wanting to lynch them in the mean time.

[Mongoose]

okay, I will switch off Luna but not to vote Jay. I'm surprised we've not talked about Mac since I called him out. I was wondering if it really happened until nutella brought it up (catching up and will be right with you again shortly).

Wait what?

If I misattributed that you referenced it, my apologies.

[juliets]

I think you're wrong nutella about Mongoose being bad. She says she's switching off Luna. We have this lynch wrong imo.

[nutella]

I'm not set on having you lynched, just so you know. If you could move your "SOS" vote anywhere, who would you move it to?

Hold the phone. So you are saying you're not set on voting for Mongoose, but you are still leaving your vote there?!?!? [VOTE: Lunalee] aubergine

Coming from that, I guess I'm just speechless.

Nooo that is such a townie post how can you not see that. Scum would never make that post.

If you are not set on the lynch, you should change it. Keeping the vote where it is is not helping the odds of getting a more favorable lynch. Sorry, dinner got called right after I posted.

It's not necessarily townie to self-pres vote, especially if you are half-heartly not wanting to lynch them in the mean time.

I disagree but also right after this she moved her vote and left entrusting us not to lynch her.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[mention]Mongoose[/mention] who is bad? Gimme two names. Who is good? Gimme two names?

My advisor is literally talking next to me; I will try my best to be present over the next 18 minutes.

[nutella]

I think you're wrong nutella about Mongoose being bad. She says she's switching off Luna. We have this lynch wrong imo.

I am moving back to Jay. He just really isn't sitting right.

[Owner of a Lonely Heart]

I'll move to Jay if two more people move off Luna.

What's scummy about Jay?

[Elohcin]

But then mongoose would have been faking not knowing who she was. Hmm

tbh, it DID sound fake to me. And I feel like you are civ which is throwing me way off

omg, I cannot even post. I am getting so much linki. 8th time's the charm

[JaggedJimmyJay]

[VOTE: Owner] aubergine because her explanation for voting Luna seemed quite exaggerated.

[Mongoose]

@Mongoose who is bad? Gimme two names. Who is good? Gimme two names?

My advisor is literally talking next to me; I will try my best to be present over the next 18 minutes.

We never really excavated into Mac's slip (or was it?) Why didn't we? Whether or not that was a slip, it's super weird to me that something so succulent just slipped on by last passing by a traffic sign.

[Elohcin]

Yeah im going to go ahead and [VOTE: mongoose] aubergine bc I think Luna is town. I don't feel great about lynching mongoose yet, I'd prefer Jay mata or owner, but some of them look sorta compatible with her anyway so if she's what's on the table I'll take it. Sorry if you're town.

I'm going to do this as well. I have a BAD gut feeling about mongoose. Sorry, girl.

[Mongoose]

But then mongoose would have been faking not knowing who she was. Hmm

tbh, it DID sound fake to me. And I feel like you are civ which is throwing me way off

omg, I cannot even post. I am getting so much linki. 8th time's the charm

I can't see folks' names on my phone, which makes playing from work extremely difficult. Going back and forth between pages is also nigh impossible.