Dom wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 12:56 am
A post I wanted to make last night.
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Tue Aug 06, 2019 9:32 pm
Okay Dom in the other game which we can now talk about you were town and pursued a case about another townie aggressively. Here you "lead" the case against Nutella except that was basically an ISO and a vote; you put more substance into the case here but to me it seemed like it lacked the same passion. Maybe I'm wrong. Obviously different circumstances and all that, but someone said something I think in this game that gave me the impression that you are in fact generally a very aggressive player and that is not the impression I've gotten so far. Again, maybe I'm wrong.
I think its fairly aggressively to pursue a player for several days and then create a massive iso which results in their lynch.
Who else got nutella lynched?
You?
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Tue Aug 06, 2019 9:32 pm
On the "vague case" thing. Yes it's vague. Oh well. I think you're scum. I don't have a wall of evidence. Most good players aren't going to leave behind a wall of evidence. Also Nutella would still have full interest in hunting scum given her role; the fact that she was neutral doesn't make that case any less viable.
"Most good players aren't going to leave behind a wall of evidence" doesn't quite square with "Basically an iso and a vote"
Which is it? Am I a bad player or a good player? Am I bad because I didn't try enough or am I bad because I left behind a wall of evidence? Why is your standard different than mine?
You're not just not throwing strikes, bro. You're pelting the batter.
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Tue Aug 06, 2019 9:32 pmOn the "whatever to whoever" thing. Fair I guess. I tried to define "off" but it didn't really go so well. To clear things up I didn't intend for equal opportunity attacker to be negative and when I reviewed some of your games I saw a lot of posts of the same style so I'm going to call it NAI.
But you didn't say that. And you spent the day trying to lynch me.
So... what does "off" mean? It didn't go well, you're right. Why? Let's unpack that.
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Tue Aug 06, 2019 9:32 pmOn the salad thing (which I'm getting very defensive about and if when the game is over I was in fact correct you guys are gonna be hearing about it): it's not? I don't think? I don't see the connection between my attempt to generate discussion on mafia teams and me giving any sort of non-committal preferences on lynches, which is what I thought salad is. Please enlighten me if I am in fact wrong.
Weird that I didn't accuse you of salad-ing, but rather, Jack.
Any reason why you're defensive on that?
Okay fine. You lynched Nutella. Here’s a star. I’m sorry for attacking you for not adequately lynching Nutella. (Yes you actually did do a lot of effort to the end of lynching Nutella I’m not going to dispute that and there’s a chance that I have a distorted hindsight view which is leading me to believe that you didn’t actually care).
You’re a good player that’s why I wouldn’t expect to find a lot of information that would clue me into your affiliation.
It didn’t go well because maybe I was wrong is probably the correct assessment. Or else no one who’s better at articulating these things picked up on the same vibes that I did. I don’t know.
I’m defensive cause I thought it was a good idea and no one else liked it and I was sad.
I voted sabie last lynch and I preferred her to Creature... I was pretty meh on the Creature lynch. His constant complaining about how we play Mafia grated on me enough that I didn't give a damn. He was great for the mafia.
Right now I'm totally down with Dom over Tony for the Civ side of things. That is to say Dom has impressed me in the Civ fashion. Whereas Tony is alluding to scumminess because of my invisible, plus he did engage in the Chess, which could have been a scum distraction on his end somehow.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:17 am
Right now I'm totally down with Dom over Tony for the Civ side of things. That is to say Dom has impressed me in the Civ fashion. Whereas Tony is alluding to scumminess because of my invisible, plus he did engage in the Chess, which could have been a scum distraction on his end somehow.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:12 am
I voted sabie last lynch and I preferred her to Creature... I was pretty meh on the Creature lynch. His constant complaining about how we play Mafia grated on me enough that I didn't give a damn. He was great for the mafia.
I do not like these situations we’re in where all of the lynched are “meh”.
Um, what else? Dyslexicon and Epignosis, I don't see them both being baddies and putting on this big show or something. I am concerned about one of them being bad. Of course my mind puts Epignosis there... it could be such a smooth plan to sub in for a baddie role to berate the Civvies for low-posting and keep the posting engine generally revved up enough that it's very difficult to find reason to lynch him. Paranoid? Maybe. Or maybe not. We'll see at endgame.
Dizzy, Epi, Jack, and Dom are all good in my books, for reasons and maybe optimism?
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:17 am
Right now I'm totally down with Dom over Tony for the Civ side of things. That is to say Dom has impressed me in the Civ fashion. Whereas Tony is alluding to scumminess because of my invisible, plus he did engage in the Chess, which could have been a scum distraction on his end somehow.
Yeah Dom is winning the war I know when I’m beat.
It's a taste of peak Mafia virtuosity that I'm glad to see Dom displaying. Dom, don't stop playing Mafia when you can make posts like that, you are lifeblood.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:12 am
I voted sabie last lynch and I preferred her to Creature... I was pretty meh on the Creature lynch. His constant complaining about how we play Mafia grated on me enough that I didn't give a damn. He was great for the mafia.
I do not like these situations we’re in where all of the lynched are “meh”.
All the lynched were "meh"? Is that the situation we're in? Help an old man out here.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:17 am
Right now I'm totally down with Dom over Tony for the Civ side of things. That is to say Dom has impressed me in the Civ fashion. Whereas Tony is alluding to scumminess because of my invisible, plus he did engage in the Chess, which could have been a scum distraction on his end somehow.
Yeah Dom is winning the war I know when I’m beat.
It's a taste of peak Mafia virtuosity that I'm glad to see Dom displaying. Dom, don't stop playing Mafia when you can make posts like that, you are lifeblood.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:12 am
I voted sabie last lynch and I preferred her to Creature... I was pretty meh on the Creature lynch. His constant complaining about how we play Mafia grated on me enough that I didn't give a damn. He was great for the mafia.
I do not like these situations we’re in where all of the lynched are “meh”.
All the lynched were "meh"? Is that the situation we're in? Help an old man out here.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:25 am
Um, what else? Dyslexicon and Epignosis, I don't see them both being baddies and putting on this big show or something. I am concerned about one of them being bad. Of course my mind puts Epignosis there... it could be such a smooth plan to sub in for a baddie role to berate the Civvies for low-posting and keep the posting engine generally revved up enough that it's very difficult to find reason to lynch him. Paranoid? Maybe. Or maybe not. We'll see at endgame.
Dizzy, Epi, Jack, and Dom are all good in my books, for reasons and maybe optimism?
My paranoia is still on Dizzy of those two; I’m not willing to clear Dom out of some whimpering sense of pride but I think he’s probably fine; Jack posted something yesterday that made me think he was town for a really weird reason but outside of that I have no reason to let him go.
I am rarely in this position but I just need someone to be a voice of reason and tell me what to do.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:12 am
I voted sabie last lynch and I preferred her to Creature... I was pretty meh on the Creature lynch. His constant complaining about how we play Mafia grated on me enough that I didn't give a damn. He was great for the mafia.
I do not like these situations we’re in where all of the lynched are “meh”.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:17 am
Right now I'm totally down with Dom over Tony for the Civ side of things. That is to say Dom has impressed me in the Civ fashion. Whereas Tony is alluding to scumminess because of my invisible, plus he did engage in the Chess, which could have been a scum distraction on his end somehow.
Yeah Dom is winning the war I know when I’m beat.
It's a taste of peak Mafia virtuosity that I'm glad to see Dom displaying. Dom, don't stop playing Mafia when you can make posts like that, you are lifeblood.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:12 am
I voted sabie last lynch and I preferred her to Creature... I was pretty meh on the Creature lynch. His constant complaining about how we play Mafia grated on me enough that I didn't give a damn. He was great for the mafia.
I do not like these situations we’re in where all of the lynched are “meh”.
All the lynched were "meh"? Is that the situation we're in? Help an old man out here.
Hey LC--
I appreciate the nice words.
But... uhh... this post didn't do you any favors in my book.
I guess I'm debating if dizzy 2.0 is in your scum range or not. Cause your scum range play is less active than your town play.
You also didn't die or don't remember you getting voted aside from what Epi 2.0 said today. I guess him having thoughts to vote for you might lean you townish, but l'm not sure if I like all of Sloonei's posts.
I think Sloonei was the one you replaced...right?!?!?
Derps for Juliets and Timmer:
juliets wrote: ↑Wed Jul 31, 2019 6:35 pm
This whole time I thought we lynched Luna, lol.
Juliets is only mafia if the whole team didn't know the lynch was Nut and not Luna (or they didn't talk about it at all), or if this is fake, but I don't think it is.
timmer wrote: ↑Mon Aug 05, 2019 6:07 pm
Fuck, I had a whole thing about how it seemed like juliets and Luna were linked but that's because I thought Luna was on the baddie team but now I see she was an indy so it makes no sense.
This is Timmer's derp, and looking at it now I don't like it as much. Cause how do you not know Luna was not mafia. Also Timmer straight out tells me that he could pull out fake derps so yay all the wifom. I don't know
I guess I'm debating if dizzy 2.0 is in your scum range or not. Cause your scum range play is less active than your town play.
You also didn't die or don't remember you getting voted aside from what Epi 2.0 said today. I guess him having thoughts to vote for you might lean you townish, but l'm not sure if I like all of Sloonei's posts.
I think Sloonei was the one you replaced...right?!?!?
And LC and Jack are more gut town than anything. I don't think I can read Jack very well tbh, but I haven't had negative reactions to their post. Not sure I would do if they were scum. LC I think I have been ok at reading in the past, I feel their reaction to being voted seemed town. Just the "lay off take a break" attitude.
I replaced Sloonmeister and I'm town, so there's that. I don't get scum roles Owner =p Also I thought you were town ever since you posted that suspicion on Tony D1 tbh. I still think you've posted like your town self, but please post more.
Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 1:25 am
Um, what else? Dyslexicon and Epignosis, I don't see them both being baddies and putting on this big show or something. I am concerned about one of them being bad. Of course my mind puts Epignosis there... it could be such a smooth plan to sub in for a baddie role to berate the Civvies for low-posting and keep the posting engine generally revved up enough that it's very difficult to find reason to lynch him. Paranoid? Maybe. Or maybe not. We'll see at endgame.
Dizzy, Epi, Jack, and Dom are all good in my books, for reasons and maybe optimism?
Actually I have a thought about Epi:
Epignosis wrote: ↑Wed Aug 07, 2019 10:11 pm
The good news is the mafia whiffed on this. I don't know why Quin is more of a threat than I am, but there are you are.
Would Epi say this as mafia? I read the "haha I'm alive" as a town thing to say
juliets wrote: ↑Wed Aug 07, 2019 10:19 pm
Well, the post says he was a hero so I guess RIP Quin. Also apologies to you Creature, I won't try to meta read you again.
I will start my day with a vote for sabie12
And goodnight!
Why though+ Because of the "slip" that still may or may not be a slip?
sabie has really done nothing except for that one post that you quoted. Other than that post when she's been here she's just been telling us why she can't post instead of taking those opportunities to give us some content. I especially hate that she told us she was on her way home from vacation and would be in a place where she had internet and then didn't post for 3 whole days.
The one post where she had content had that statement about nutella being wrong about her reads. I admit that still bothers me given nutella had indeed given 9+ reads prior to her statement. I know you disagree with the way I am looking at that and I will go back and re-read your concerns.
I will still be looking at others during the day. I see you've voted Michelle so I will look at her for example along with some others.
Dom wrote: ↑Thu Aug 08, 2019 8:06 am
You have a history of flattering me when bad.
This is not as bad as suspecting me for an RIP post, but it's down there. Leave this one in the trash; it's not a real tell.
Doesn't mean my vote will end up there.
That doesn't worry me much. I'm just saying, I'm Civ this time, you will know I'm Civ at the end of the game, you shouldn't try to make this into a tell in the future. I was just impressed, that's all. And a little drunk.
[mention]Dyslexicon[/mention] I read through Michelle's posts and though there aren't a lot of them I see a difference between her behavior and Sable's. As an example, Michelle took a pretty strong stand on timmer and had one post where she had several posts from him and gave her thoughts on those posts. I wish she would post more but at least I saw more meat on her posts. I will stay with sabie for now, but I would like to hear what others think of Michelle.
Aaaand I see you have changed to sabie so this probably doesn't matter anymore.
Also, sprityo. He only has maybe 3 posts so I don't know what to think about him. I have voted to lynch him for lurking or low posting in other games and have been wrong more than right. What is everyone else thinking about him?
linki, ok I see what you are thinking Jack and I had forgotten you took issue with her sheep post. I'd like to hear her answer as well.
