Pyre Mafia [ENDGAME]

[Sloonei]

TonyStarkPrime
Turnip Head
tutuu

[Sloonei]

TonyStarkPrime - TOWN
Turnip Head - TOWN
tutuu - TOWN

[dunya]

Sloonei
Soneji
tedxtr

town
town
town

[nutella]

TonyStarkPrime
Turnip Head
tutuu

Scum
Town
Town

[Master Radishes]

TonyStarkPrime
Turnip Head
tutuu

Town
Town
Town

[bronana]

i've been nodding along to almost all of nutella's g2h reads

[Lissa]

TonyStarkPrime
Turnip Head
tutuu

w
w
v

[dunya]

TonyStarkPrime
Turnip Head
tutuu

town
town
town

[dunya]

i could have really gone wolf on turnip tbh but hit send before i did it lol

[bronana]

gun to bronana's head

V
bronana
DrWilgy
dunya
KZA
Lissa
Long Con
Marcher Jovian
motobot
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
nutella
outed wolf
Sloonei
tedxtr
Turnip Head
tutuu


W
Carotenoid
MacDougall
Master Radishes
moth
Soneji
TonyStarkPrime

-----

wavered most on: long con, outed wolf, turnip head, carotenoid, macdougall, moth

[Sloonei]

thanks for indulging me, folks. I'm making a CHART, which as we all know, will solve the game in an instant. Carry on with life, please and thanks.

[Lissa]

could probably have gone w on soneji

meh

[Long Con]

Finally, a chart to show us the way!

[Long Con]

(dammit, how did I not go with "chart our way"...? )

[dunya]

I don’t even know what people’s gripes are with my approach on Marcher, maybe you can like mediate instead of going “ah you’re outed suck my ass”

Because I see both a contradiction and also mental inconsistencies from Marcher that honestly just hard pins him wolf to me

I asked what he thought was “nervous” about moth and whatever words he pulled out of the scumtionary in order to sweep it under the rug and he didn’t reply at all.

Maybe you can look through moth’s ISO and tell me where he’s being nervous

it seemed super nitpicky and blown way out of proportion, and you focused on it to the exclusion of all else. your pushes have felt more like looking for something to pounce and hyper-aggro on than genuine attempts at solving

marcher's been villagy imo. i still dont really understand anyone's problem with them tbh

what does your villa circle look like rn?

can you off the top of your head cite who he was super aggressive towards? i mean, his iso is still fresh in my mind so i would like to engage with that.

its baffling to me that you read his iso and aren't sure who he was aggro towards

marcher jovian, and me earlier in the game on d0

well i did say apart from jovian, and you have been pretty aggressive with him along with the whole everyone else who won't give him room to breathe.

i disagree that his progression on marcher did not contain genuine townie waffling at the beginning there when he was sussing carot instead. i see town frustration and not mafia in his dealing with the thread rn.

ted is town.

.

is what I was responding to

yes, for context: sloonei had just asked me this and i had read nothing of the developments:

down with ketchup?

let's hop in with both feet

tedxtr is tunneling hard on a case that nobody else agrees with. What is your gut response to that?

and i read ted's (passionate) iso and during the time i was responding, ted was literally not breathing as he hammered away on his keyboard very angrily, smacking suspicions from a lot of people. sorry if i exaggerated the events, but it's the impression i got from ted's reactions in his iso rather than the actual events happening itt if that makes sense.

[Turnip Head]

i could have really gone wolf on turnip tbh but hit send before i did it lol

[Lissa]

aight, that makes more sense from an iso pov

wasn't massively concerned regardless, mostly pulled up to clarify what i'd been referring to

[Turnip Head]

Master Radishes is 100% guaranteed bad.

[dunya]

i guess pickled turnips trump radishes in this forum.

[bronana]

Master Radishes is 100% guaranteed bad.

is this confidence based on meta? can you expand at all plz

[Turnip Head]

In case anyone cares, I caught Master Radishes being bad on Day 1 in the very first game we played together., and I'm 100% at reading him in every game we've played since then.

[bronana]

In case anyone cares, I caught Master Radishes being bad on Day 1 in the very first game we played together., and I'm 100% at reading him in every game we've played since then.

whats the sample size

[Turnip Head]

In case anyone cares, I caught Master Radishes being bad on Day 1 in the very first game we played together., and I'm 100% at reading him in every game we've played since then.

whats the sample size

Like 2... I'm still building my portfolio

[dunya]

In case anyone cares, I caught Master Radishes being bad on Day 1 in the very first game we played together., and I'm 100% at reading him in every game we've played since then.

whats the sample size

Like 2... I'm still building my portfolio

2/2 is strong.

[VOTE: Radishes] aubergine

[Sloonei]

GTH results:

Spoiler: show

Notes and things:
bronana's results were contributed after the rest of us had done them rapid fire, but I included them anyway.
ted started and stopped because he didn't believe there would be prizes.
Radishes named the fewest suspects. That has been the supposed tell with this exercise in the past. Juicy.
nutella named the most suspects, but she's also aware of the supposed tell.
Radishes and Carotenoid were the top suspects. Mac and KZA were surprisingly popular suspects as well.
bronana, lissa, nanook, myself, and tutuu were universal town reads.

Let's explore why Radishes, Carot, Mac, and KZA were the preferred suspects.

[tedxtr]

stonks

[tutuu]

GTH results:

Spoiler: show

Notes and things:
bronana's results were contributed after the rest of us had done them rapid fire, but I included them anyway.
ted started and stopped because he didn't believe there would be prizes.
Radishes named the fewest suspects. That has been the supposed tell with this exercise in the past. Juicy.
nutella named the most suspects, but she's also aware of the supposed tell.
Radishes and Carotenoid were the top suspects. Mac and KZA were surprisingly popular suspects as well.
bronana, lissa, nanook, myself, and tutuu were universal town reads.

Let's explore why Radishes, Carot, Mac, and KZA were the preferred suspects.

[dunya]

Radishes named the fewest suspects. That has been the supposed tell with this exercise in the past. Juicy.

my mouth is watering...feed me radishes

[nutella]

what do you think of monsieur radishes

Him town reading me is bad but other than that I don’t have much to add

don't like this

[tedxtr]

what do you think of monsieur radishes

Him town reading me is bad but other than that I don’t have much to add

don't like this

Ok

[dunya]

what do you think of monsieur radishes

Him town reading me is bad but other than that I don’t have much to add

oh so you suspect me cos i townread u too?

[nutella]

[VOTE: master radishes] aubergine


I think he and ted are compatible but I'm feeling slightly more forgiving to ted atm

The continued rl excuses/slank cover feels simultaneously like it should be NAI and yet also guilt-trip/"just give me another couple phases to skate by" in a slimy way.

My one reservation is I worry he'd have put in more effort to look legitimately solvey if scum (based on how he successfully pocketed me in the Covid game by looking supertownish) but if he doesn't have the availability to do so regardless I can't just give him a pass.

He has given very limited content and what he has given in the way of reads feel forced imo. My gut says this is a hit.

[Sloonei]

[mention]dunya[/mention] [mention]Lissa[/mention] why did you GTH KZA as scum?

[Master Radishes]

Like how come no one sees nutella howling?

[tedxtr]

what do you think of monsieur radishes

Him town reading me is bad but other than that I don’t have much to add

oh so you suspect me cos i townread u too?

Being weary of pockets, I expect wolves to either side with me or ignore the whole deal

W/r/t MR it wasn’t about this though, he has a history of tunneling me when he’s town so his town read on me, especially that early and for reasons that I already forgot was kind of bad

It’s different from my assessment of you

It’s not even a hard scum read I just wanna keep myself in check to actually read you for stuff other than your defence of me

I have read approximately 4 slots, which I’ve given my reads on already.

[Master Radishes]

what do you think of monsieur radishes

Him town reading me is bad but other than that I don’t have much to add

oh so you suspect me cos i townread u too?

Being weary of pockets, I expect wolves to either side with me or ignore the whole deal

W/r/t MR it wasn’t about this though, he has a history of tunneling me when he’s town so his town read on me, especially that early and for reasons that I already forgot was kind of bad

It’s different from my assessment of you

It’s not even a hard scum read I just wanna keep myself in check to actually read you for stuff other than your defence of me

I have read approximately 4 slots, which I’ve given my reads on already.

'History' is a strong word. It was one game.

[tutuu]

(townreads listed in order of confidence)
tutuu
sloonei
dunya
moth
tedxtr
bronana
nutella
TonyStarkPrime
MacDougall
Lissa

[dunya]

@dunya @Lissa why did you GTH KZA as scum?

i dunno, i only read like 4 posts of theirs before the GTH and they were all made yesterday at around 5am my time? they said it was their weekend and they're ready for action, but i feel like they're still slanking. haven't seen a post that screams town to me yet

[Master Radishes]

[VOTE: master radishes] aubergine


I think he and ted are compatible but I'm feeling slightly more forgiving to ted atm

The continued rl excuses/slank cover feels simultaneously like it should be NAI and yet also guilt-trip/"just give me another couple phases to skate by" in a slimy way.

My one reservation is I worry he'd have put in more effort to look legitimately solvey if scum (based on how he successfully pocketed me in the Covid game by looking supertownish) but if he doesn't have the availability to do so regardless I can't just give him a pass.

He has given very limited content and what he has given in the way of reads feel forced imo. My gut says this is a hit.

This took 100 words to justify a vote on me for 'being not very present'. It's OTT.

The last line is particularly smelly.

[tedxtr]

what do you think of monsieur radishes

Him town reading me is bad but other than that I don’t have much to add

oh so you suspect me cos i townread u too?

Being weary of pockets, I expect wolves to either side with me or ignore the whole deal

W/r/t MR it wasn’t about this though, he has a history of tunneling me when he’s town so his town read on me, especially that early and for reasons that I already forgot was kind of bad

It’s different from my assessment of you

It’s not even a hard scum read I just wanna keep myself in check to actually read you for stuff other than your defence of me

I have read approximately 4 slots, which I’ve given my reads on already.

'History' is a strong word. It was one game.

We had like 3 games here + 1 offsite

And in that one you town read me early as well iirc and you were scum

[dunya]

also i feel like the reads KZA did provide were sorta safe ones. "TSP/moth/tutuu town" "the guy who was fighting with ted not town"

[Sloonei]

am i supposed to be pronouncing Lissa as Lisa or Melissa? Or maybe Lizza?

[dunya]

Like how come no one sees nutella howling?

i do tbh

maybe she's bussing you now cos you're too busy irl

[tedxtr]

It’s not like it would move the needle on you though, I actually want you to live because part of me asks why you would think the thread was headed in your direction, which is pretty much the only reason you’d pull the last long post you had a few hours ago or something.

I think there’s a decent chance you’re just town that finds it hard to find the motivation, although that isn’t clearing on its own, because you didn’t have the drive as a mafia either.

If you’re town, you’re just burying yourself here. I would want to keep you alive. You just set up high expectations and if you won’t achieve them, then you probably are scum.

[nutella]

am i supposed to be pronouncing Lissa as Lisa or Melissa? Or maybe Lizza?

Second one

[nutella]

[VOTE: master radishes] aubergine


I think he and ted are compatible but I'm feeling slightly more forgiving to ted atm

The continued rl excuses/slank cover feels simultaneously like it should be NAI and yet also guilt-trip/"just give me another couple phases to skate by" in a slimy way.

My one reservation is I worry he'd have put in more effort to look legitimately solvey if scum (based on how he successfully pocketed me in the Covid game by looking supertownish) but if he doesn't have the availability to do so regardless I can't just give him a pass.

He has given very limited content and what he has given in the way of reads feel forced imo. My gut says this is a hit.

This took 100 words to justify a vote on me for 'being not very present'. It's OTT.

The last line is particularly smelly.

No u.

stream of consciousness man

[nutella]

Your read on me was the fakest of all tbh and you doubled down on it for no justifiable reason

[Lissa]

@dunya @Lissa why did you GTH KZA as scum?

I followed his champs game (well, d1, but that was all he was alive for anyway) and he was... hm. Cutting and self assured, and I don't think hipfirey is quite the word but something in that vein?

Feels a bit limp here in comparison and his main reads are really easy.

[nutella]

I could vote for Lissa. I don't think Ted is bad I think he's just tilted and needs to regain perspective.

Ehhhhhhh could be.

Should I trust you tho

Tell me about your bronana vote

and any other strong feelings you have

My instant reaction is I don't like this post.

Nutella we mindmelded last we played - what happened?

(Like, okay, I was scum in that one, but the reads we shared were ones I felt were legit and would make anyway if I had been town.)

This concerns me.

Yes thanks for understanding, I hate being a push and hate being the D1 push, leave me alone please and thank you

I'm very much tilted that I got piled on without being offered anything remotely close to an explanation as to why I'm wrong even though Marcher clearly bullshited the read there but I guess that's okay

still, the idea that someone could contain their nervousness in a wolf chat for a town read is pretty damn silly for a villager to make and reeks of TMI

You've been offered explanations you're just refusing to see it another way from how you tunnel-interpreted it

Are you still scum reading me?

on balance yes

you could be a tunneled townie but like. try to be helpful. your continued refusal to talk about anything else is anti-town

nutella town from this post tbh. and the one above that was @ master radishes

towny frustration. at least imo its pure

Nah I'm going the opposite direction. She's putting it on a bit. I just haven't decided if it's because she's probably a wolf or because she's definitely a wolf.

Yeah, okay, [VOTE: nutella] aubergine then.

This entire progression is just so fake

[Lissa]

In case anyone cares, I caught Master Radishes being bad on Day 1 in the very first game we played together., and I'm 100% at reading him in every game we've played since then.

whats the sample size

Like 2... I'm still building my portfolio

I'm not super compelled by a sample size of 2

Prolly villagery conviction though