Pyre Mafia [ENDGAME]

[Lissa]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

[Marcher Jovian]

Spoiler: show

So this day phase was shorter than I was thinking, my head is out of wack. Thought it ended more around 9:30pm EST and tried to post earlier and thread was locked. Would have voted for Master Radishes if I had posted prior to day end. Only had time to get through d0 for now, being slammed at work. Oh well, d1 is better in retrospect anyways and I have Sat night-Tuesday off. If you have no quotes under your name here that is generally a good thing.

bronana

im pretty sure outed, tony and bronan are all scum.

nutella is turning on jets in a towny way

i cant tell if you are going for TWTBAW here deliberately or what

cause it kinda feels like you're aiming for it

so this is the first time youve called me wolfy. and now not only am I wolfy, im OUTLANDISHLY wolfy.

sounds desperate

you seem intent on interpreting outed wolf's posts in the harshest light possible

Do you read that behavior by moth as towny or wolfy? That's what matters, not chastizing people for trying to get the ball rolling.



Carotenoid

How likely do you think it is that all the people that have posted so far are civilian?

This is such an empty kind of question. The townie version of this isn't usually framed as a question, but as a feeling that the thread is full of townies or wolves.


DrWilgy


dunya


KZA


Lissa


Long Con

i wonder if most of the mechanics of the game are already spelled out in the OP or if there are likely to be hidden ones coming up later

So, claiming vanilla?

How did you get that out of their post?


MacDougall


Marcher Jovian


Master Radishes

Okay serious question though.

Sloonei, if you're thinking nutella could be a wolf, are you going to stay in a triumvirate with her?

you could flip this and ask me the same thing but I wouldn't be sure tbh

kinda just inertia-stuck on the option I chose and I like it and I like LC so whatever maybe it'll be fun and interesting to be in a trio with a scumread (who also mutually scumreads me)

Is it weird I think you both could be right about each other but I'm not sure which one is yet?

If one is a wolf they're not right, they just have TMI. This is the wolfiest kind of both siding, where if both sides are town you can mislynch both, acting sad and swearing to lynch the other in their honor after the first flips town.


moth

argument for me being scum is that im frantic, ultra aggressive, abnormally desperate to prove myself, less funny than usual, and paranoid

You forgot to put overly self-conscious here.

everyone who has posted so far I could make an argument for being wolves

make the argument for moth

it was asked for

Doesn't mean it has to be answered, especially given the question asked doesn’t warrant a response.

So I dunno what to do about that. I suspect lissa could easily be a lazy wolf who doesnt see any better targets here. but that seems pretty amatuer for someone like lissa

Lissa struggle wolfed in the Mountainous Arson game which was a star studded roster. They can be a lazy wolf.


motobot


NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME


nutella


outed wolf

Oh and sloonei is already there. Hell yeah.

But why, sloonei did you state your vote/anything really so far? Why should I wanna be on your triumvirate?

wolfy post

boom roasted.

why

Sloonei has made a couple posts and isn't projecting town yet and if he doesn't start doing so soon I will be very concerned

i assume this is sarcasm/joke of some kind?

also nice, thx jjj

Overly cautious here in trying to get a sense of standing before saying anything else.

[VOTE: Nutella] aubergine

I am thunderously calm.

Did nutella being serious make them suspicious to you here?

upon isoing him. idk how sloonei plays but uh. i suppose there is not much of anything there. could just be playstyle for now i guess.

not that im expecting much at all, but its just 5 word questions.

maybe you're right nutella!

This is some strange backing of nutella given earlier posts.

im pretty sure outed, tony and bronan are all scum.

nutella is turning on jets in a towny way

i cant tell if you are going for TWTBAW here deliberately or what

cause it kinda feels like you're aiming for it

so this is the first time youve called me wolfy. and now not only am I wolfy, im OUTLANDISHLY wolfy.

sounds desperate

no i said you're aiming for "Too Wolfy To Be A Wolf"

your post about me/TSP/bronana is silly.

The only ones who would set out with a goal of seeming TWTBAW...are wolves.



Sloonei

tedxtr


TonyStarkPrime

Turnip Head


tutuu

I just noticed soneji shaded the banish lol

[Marcher Jovian]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

[Long Con]

My friend, I would be the player to do it. I am probably responsible for each of the Top 5 scumslips on the site.

Lmao I was thinking this was a derpclear/angleshooty clear but you are also kind of the master of fake derpclears

I think most of my derpclears have been as legit as my scumslips... but I don't think this qualifies either way.

Alright so we should leave LC alive, one of us can push that scumslip angle tomorrow.

Magnifique.

[Lissa]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

[Marcher Jovian]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

this reasoning is meh.

[Soneji]

i wonder if most of the mechanics of the game are already spelled out in the OP

So, claiming vanilla?

How did you get that out of their post?

Ennnh, upon reread, I was confusing "game mechanics" with "ability mechanics". I realized that soon after, but decided to leave it in case anything shook loose somehow.
[/quote]


I guess at the least there's an angle to your question where if they're actually vanilla that likely confirms them town.

Spoiler: show

So this day phase was shorter than I was thinking, my head is out of wack. Thought it ended more around 9:30pm EST and tried to post earlier and thread was locked. Would have voted for Master Radishes if I had posted prior to day end. Only had time to get through d0 for now, being slammed at work. Oh well, d1 is better in retrospect anyways and I have Sat night-Tuesday off. If you have no quotes under your name here that is generally a good thing.

bronana

im pretty sure outed, tony and bronan are all scum.

nutella is turning on jets in a towny way

i cant tell if you are going for TWTBAW here deliberately or what

cause it kinda feels like you're aiming for it

so this is the first time youve called me wolfy. and now not only am I wolfy, im OUTLANDISHLY wolfy.

sounds desperate

you seem intent on interpreting outed wolf's posts in the harshest light possible

Do you read that behavior by moth as towny or wolfy? That's what matters, not chastizing people for trying to get the ball rolling.



Carotenoid

How likely do you think it is that all the people that have posted so far are civilian?

This is such an empty kind of question. The townie version of this isn't usually framed as a question, but as a feeling that the thread is full of townies or wolves.


DrWilgy


dunya


KZA


Lissa


Long Con

i wonder if most of the mechanics of the game are already spelled out in the OP or if there are likely to be hidden ones coming up later

So, claiming vanilla?

How did you get that out of their post?


MacDougall


Marcher Jovian


Master Radishes

Okay serious question though.

Sloonei, if you're thinking nutella could be a wolf, are you going to stay in a triumvirate with her?

you could flip this and ask me the same thing but I wouldn't be sure tbh

kinda just inertia-stuck on the option I chose and I like it and I like LC so whatever maybe it'll be fun and interesting to be in a trio with a scumread (who also mutually scumreads me)

Is it weird I think you both could be right about each other but I'm not sure which one is yet?

If one is a wolf they're not right, they just have TMI. This is the wolfiest kind of both siding, where if both sides are town you can mislynch both, acting sad and swearing to lynch the other in their honor after the first flips town.


moth

argument for me being scum is that im frantic, ultra aggressive, abnormally desperate to prove myself, less funny than usual, and paranoid

You forgot to put overly self-conscious here.

everyone who has posted so far I could make an argument for being wolves

make the argument for moth

it was asked for

Doesn't mean it has to be answered, especially given the question asked doesn’t warrant a response.

So I dunno what to do about that. I suspect lissa could easily be a lazy wolf who doesnt see any better targets here. but that seems pretty amatuer for someone like lissa

Lissa struggle wolfed in the Mountainous Arson game which was a star studded roster. They can be a lazy wolf.


motobot


NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME


nutella


outed wolf

Oh and sloonei is already there. Hell yeah.

But why, sloonei did you state your vote/anything really so far? Why should I wanna be on your triumvirate?

wolfy post

boom roasted.

why

Sloonei has made a couple posts and isn't projecting town yet and if he doesn't start doing so soon I will be very concerned

i assume this is sarcasm/joke of some kind?

also nice, thx jjj

Overly cautious here in trying to get a sense of standing before saying anything else.

[VOTE: Nutella] aubergine

I am thunderously calm.

Did nutella being serious make them suspicious to you here?

upon isoing him. idk how sloonei plays but uh. i suppose there is not much of anything there. could just be playstyle for now i guess.

not that im expecting much at all, but its just 5 word questions.

maybe you're right nutella!

This is some strange backing of nutella given earlier posts.

im pretty sure outed, tony and bronan are all scum.

nutella is turning on jets in a towny way

i cant tell if you are going for TWTBAW here deliberately or what

cause it kinda feels like you're aiming for it

so this is the first time youve called me wolfy. and now not only am I wolfy, im OUTLANDISHLY wolfy.

sounds desperate

no i said you're aiming for "Too Wolfy To Be A Wolf"

your post about me/TSP/bronana is silly.

The only ones who would set out with a goal of seeming TWTBAW...are wolves.



Sloonei

tedxtr


TonyStarkPrime

Turnip Head


tutuu

How the double hockey sticks do you not have a quote on me
[/quote]
Your d0 posts didn't stick out to me

I do plan to comb over it again as most of that read came in small bursts between stuff at work, and while exhausted.

Lissa struggle wolfed in the Mountainous Arson game which was a star studded roster. They can be a lazy wolf.

why can i never escape people bringing up marson

i wasn't lazy, i had no time and played bad as a related result

It's my only non-mash experience with you so it's the best meta I got

Spoiler: show

So this day phase was shorter than I was thinking, my head is out of wack. Thought it ended more around 9:30pm EST and tried to post earlier and thread was locked. Would have voted for Master Radishes if I had posted prior to day end. Only had time to get through d0 for now, being slammed at work. Oh well, d1 is better in retrospect anyways and I have Sat night-Tuesday off. If you have no quotes under your name here that is generally a good thing.

bronana

im pretty sure outed, tony and bronan are all scum.

nutella is turning on jets in a towny way

i cant tell if you are going for TWTBAW here deliberately or what

cause it kinda feels like you're aiming for it

so this is the first time youve called me wolfy. and now not only am I wolfy, im OUTLANDISHLY wolfy.

sounds desperate

you seem intent on interpreting outed wolf's posts in the harshest light possible

Do you read that behavior by moth as towny or wolfy? That's what matters, not chastizing people for trying to get the ball rolling.



Carotenoid

How likely do you think it is that all the people that have posted so far are civilian?

This is such an empty kind of question. The townie version of this isn't usually framed as a question, but as a feeling that the thread is full of townies or wolves.


DrWilgy


dunya


KZA


Lissa


Long Con

i wonder if most of the mechanics of the game are already spelled out in the OP or if there are likely to be hidden ones coming up later

So, claiming vanilla?

How did you get that out of their post?


MacDougall


Marcher Jovian


Master Radishes

Okay serious question though.

Sloonei, if you're thinking nutella could be a wolf, are you going to stay in a triumvirate with her?

you could flip this and ask me the same thing but I wouldn't be sure tbh

kinda just inertia-stuck on the option I chose and I like it and I like LC so whatever maybe it'll be fun and interesting to be in a trio with a scumread (who also mutually scumreads me)

Is it weird I think you both could be right about each other but I'm not sure which one is yet?

If one is a wolf they're not right, they just have TMI. This is the wolfiest kind of both siding, where if both sides are town you can mislynch both, acting sad and swearing to lynch the other in their honor after the first flips town.


moth

argument for me being scum is that im frantic, ultra aggressive, abnormally desperate to prove myself, less funny than usual, and paranoid

You forgot to put overly self-conscious here.

everyone who has posted so far I could make an argument for being wolves

make the argument for moth

it was asked for

Doesn't mean it has to be answered, especially given the question asked doesn’t warrant a response.

So I dunno what to do about that. I suspect lissa could easily be a lazy wolf who doesnt see any better targets here. but that seems pretty amatuer for someone like lissa

Lissa struggle wolfed in the Mountainous Arson game which was a star studded roster. They can be a lazy wolf.


motobot


NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME


nutella


outed wolf

Oh and sloonei is already there. Hell yeah.

But why, sloonei did you state your vote/anything really so far? Why should I wanna be on your triumvirate?

wolfy post

boom roasted.

why

Sloonei has made a couple posts and isn't projecting town yet and if he doesn't start doing so soon I will be very concerned

i assume this is sarcasm/joke of some kind?

also nice, thx jjj

Overly cautious here in trying to get a sense of standing before saying anything else.

[VOTE: Nutella] aubergine

I am thunderously calm.

Did nutella being serious make them suspicious to you here?

upon isoing him. idk how sloonei plays but uh. i suppose there is not much of anything there. could just be playstyle for now i guess.

not that im expecting much at all, but its just 5 word questions.

maybe you're right nutella!

This is some strange backing of nutella given earlier posts.

im pretty sure outed, tony and bronan are all scum.

nutella is turning on jets in a towny way

i cant tell if you are going for TWTBAW here deliberately or what

cause it kinda feels like you're aiming for it

so this is the first time youve called me wolfy. and now not only am I wolfy, im OUTLANDISHLY wolfy.

sounds desperate

no i said you're aiming for "Too Wolfy To Be A Wolf"

your post about me/TSP/bronana is silly.

The only ones who would set out with a goal of seeming TWTBAW...are wolves.



Sloonei

tedxtr


TonyStarkPrime

Turnip Head


tutuu

I just noticed soneji shaded the banish lol

If you had read the top part of the post, you'd realize that was all written prior to the banish.

[KZA]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

this reasoning is meh.

So what does that tell you

[Marcher Jovian]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

this reasoning is meh.

So what does that tell you

I dislike Lissa more

[Marcher Jovian]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

this reasoning is meh.

So what does that tell you

I dislike Lissa more

What kind of answer did you even expect from that question? If you’d thought about it for half a second you’d have known what I’d say

[KZA]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

this reasoning is meh.

So what does that tell you

I dislike Lissa more

What kind of answer did you even expect from that question? If you’d thought about it for half a second you’d have known what I’d say

lol

weak shade

[Marcher Jovian]

why

just felt pure and real

this reasoning is meh.

So what does that tell you

I dislike Lissa more

What kind of answer did you even expect from that question? If you’d thought about it for half a second you’d have known what I’d say

lol

weak shade

right back at you lol

[Lissa]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

this reasoning is meh.

what is the problem with it exactly

[Lissa]

It's my only non-mash experience with you so it's the best meta I got

sorry i'm like

it's probably one of the worst possible examples of my average wolf game and i kind of have a pride thing about being at least marginally better than it so i really hate people using it as a yardstick of my wolf game

lol

[Marcher Jovian]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

this reasoning is meh.

what is the problem with it exactly

It is meh.

[Lissa]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

this reasoning is meh.

what is the problem with it exactly

It is meh.

aight then

[nutella]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

I had the same thought tbh

[Marcher Jovian]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

I had the same thought tbh

[nutella]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

I had the same thought tbh

what does that mean

[Marcher Jovian]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

I had the same thought tbh

what does that mean

means . is the total of all emotions conveyed when one sees and experiences . Look into your heart. Ask your heart, “Hey what does mean?” and your heart shall guide you true.

[Long Con]

Full disclosure, I just had illegal BTSC with Moth.

Here is a picture of him on my workshop doorframe as proof.


We chatted it up.

[Long Con]

Dammit

https://photos.app.goo.gl/9uT6pLr3pyTDSrmt5 just click it

[bronana]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

i thought it seemed kinda fake tbh

marcher never answered me on why they had such a strong townread there afaik, lmk if i missed it. if not explain it to me, i'm not seeing it

[KZA]

I like Bronana more after EoD

Jovan still scum

Dunya scum

Should ISO nutella but I'm too drunk

[bronana]

I can't figure out how to a non-tedious way to multi-quote posts from someone's iso, but Radishes was VERY insistent on nutella being a wolf. I've had some light concerns there, and I def give Radishes' read some weight. The way she moved from Sloonei --> ted --> MR, expressing such confidence that person was a wolf each time, it just feels wrong. Especially since they're all probably villagers. Like she was looking to park a vote and bury a villa, then moved on to the next target when the previous wagon lost traction. Her read on ted stayed the same even while his posting got much more villagy.

moth has had a massive drop-off since that d0.

Gonna look at Marcher next.

[bronana]

looked at a town and wolf game from marcher on cfc. They did the endless questions thing in the wolf game that they've been criticized for here, while the town game seemed to not have that at all, much more direct.

i'm totally trustworthy, but if you want to double check my work:

https://forums.civfanatics.com/threads/ ... ry.657987/
https://forums.civfanatics.com/threads/ ... ry.659154/

[bronana]

How likely do you think it is that all the people that have posted so far are civilian?

...this was an opener.

I'm here if you wanna talk! I'm catching up on another tab but I'm easily distracted lol

Hey Carotenoid what do you think about tedxtr's response to your entrance? (and also like tedxtr's thing in general of making a quick retrospective on the first pages and establishing slank cover)

Now that's a w/w post.

The whole interaction from here feels suspiciously light, maybe an excuse to try and establish a townread there and try to steer the thread away.

Looking at Carot's iso again, I don't know how you could possibly have a strong townread on this person? Very dubious.

Nevermind, apparently Marcher had an issue with my interpretation of Carote’s opening?

I don’t see what the problem is there. “Hey guys, how many civillians have posted?” seems like about a pretty wolfy post, for an opener.

@Marcher Jovian Why do you like that particular post??

It feels like the kind of weird mindset post that comes from >rand town. Like mafia already know everyone's alignment. They know exactly who's posted and what their alignments are. It feels like the sort of random thoughts that town sometimes has that are hard to think of when you're mafia.

tl;dr lack of tmi

This is kinda grasping at straws as a reasoning.

Who the hell comes into an eod, sees a strong villager was misyeeted, and gets mad about people voting the counterwagon? how did lissa think that was "pure and real" wtf

[bronana]

@bronana
you wanna walk me through the tedxtr read

he seems very snappy/obnoxious/arrogant like in that way villagers tend to get when they think they are gods gift to mankind. you said he was much more reasonable in the game you played with him

i dont really think hes a wolf i just wanna get a better understanding

I said he was competent, which isnt quite the same

at the time i made that post, he was basically a slanker who hadnt done anything except pop in to make what i perceived as bad, narrow-minded pushes and seemed to be avoiding having to make wider reads on the thread. Now they have a million posts, expanded well past that, and are pretty villagy, so my perspective there might seem weird even if it was perfectly cromulent at the time.

[nutella]

Who the hell comes into an eod, sees a strong villager was misyeeted, and gets mad about people voting the counterwagon? how did lissa think that was "pure and real" wtf

what kind of wolf does that though.

[nutella]

Like I think it's possible Jovian is wolf and had TMI on carotte town, but I don't think they ever do that as w/w? And I suspect carotte more than jovian anyway

[bronana]

Who the hell comes into an eod, sees a strong villager was misyeeted, and gets mad about people voting the counterwagon? how did lissa think that was "pure and real" wtf

what kind of wolf does that though.

That phrase is one of my all time pet peeves in games. It's so often applied incorrectly.

It was obviously done to look villagy. See Lissa's reaction to it.

[nutella]

Who the hell comes into an eod, sees a strong villager was misyeeted, and gets mad about people voting the counterwagon? how did lissa think that was "pure and real" wtf

what kind of wolf does that though.

That phrase is one of my all time pet peeves in games. It's so often applied incorrectly.

It was obviously done to look villagy. See Lissa's reaction to it.

and yet you, and jovian themself, were baffled at lissa townreading it


???

[bronana]

Just an FYI, I do intend to play this game seriously. Some day. Just...not right now. Busy drowning in work. (I didn't think the game would start so soon.)

I can do lazy GTH reads if anyone wants, but they'd be kind of worthless at this point.

Lay it on me brother.

Without double checking things, just impressions:

Townie:
Moth - because he just doesn't seem to care how he comes across
tedxtr - being insightful yet a bit cautious (in a good way) in his outlook on the people he's interacted with
KZA - meta read; we've played together plenty and he sounds comfortable here
tutuu - perhaps mistaking 'fun' for 'townie' but I like them so far

Townie I guess?
bronana - mainly based on presence; not sure I've yet seen anything that makes me slot you higher than this
Nook - slanking D1 is his MO; when I scummed with him he was in the background but always nudging things in certain directions on D1, and he's not doing that here
TSP - responding to a big post with just 'bad' is vintage TSP
Mac - seems jovial enough to be town, but nothing that isn't fakeable tbh

Hmmmmm:
Nutella & Sloonei - tbh I kind of want to agree with both of them; meta-wise, neither has yet convinced me I'm seeing the town version of themselves (but I'm not calling this w/w) - needs further observation
Marcher - seems to be forcing things
Carotenoid - seems a bit hesitant, like putting a toe in the water but not fully committing yet


Not going to force anyone into a scum read.

Not going to comment on anyone else even though I've noticed them post a few times, e.g. Lissa, Turnip Head, etc. If I don't have solid meta I'm not going to hedge a read until I think about it properly.

Sick post. It lines up with my current opinions, therefore I like it. Feel like a dummy for sussing you about this. I tried to switch people to Carot but I'm still at fault for being partly responsible for getting the ball rolling on you. Sorry

I'll take that KZA read, and note the TSP + Nanook ones as well.

[bronana]

Who the hell comes into an eod, sees a strong villager was misyeeted, and gets mad about people voting the counterwagon? how did lissa think that was "pure and real" wtf

what kind of wolf does that though.

That phrase is one of my all time pet peeves in games. It's so often applied incorrectly.

It was obviously done to look villagy. See Lissa's reaction to it.

and yet you, and jovian themself, were baffled at lissa townreading it


???

Why would ted keep digging his heels about the marcher thing when it was obviously garnering massive pushback? what kind of wolf does that? Yet you wolfread him all the way.

Wolves do all kind of shit. I am looking for the villagy spirit behind Marcher's posts, and I don't see it. Getting increasingly confident Marcher/Carot is w/w but holding myself back from prematurely bringin out the finger guns.

[Lissa]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

i thought it seemed kinda fake tbh

marcher never answered me on why they had such a strong townread there afaik, lmk if i missed it. if not explain it to me, i'm not seeing it

they didn't that i can see

i agree i found it baffling and still don't really get it

just think the way they came into the thread about it felt like they believed it

[bronana]

Now we're at the stage of the game where I have eighty tabs open.

[Lissa]

looked at a town and wolf game from marcher on cfc. They did the endless questions thing in the wolf game that they've been criticized for here, while the town game seemed to not have that at all, much more direct.

i'm totally trustworthy, but if you want to double check my work:

https://forums.civfanatics.com/threads/ ... ry.657987/
https://forums.civfanatics.com/threads/ ... ry.659154/

that sounds fairly notable

i'll take a look

[KZA]

feeling pretty solid about that post eod sequence of jovian posts

why

just felt pure and real

i thought it seemed kinda fake tbh

marcher never answered me on why they had such a strong townread there afaik, lmk if i missed it. if not explain it to me, i'm not seeing it

they didn't that i can see

i agree i found it baffling and still don't really get it

just think the way they came into the thread about it felt like they believed it

Interesting I felt it looked planned

[bronana]

KZA

lettuce alliance

[Lissa]

Who the hell comes into an eod, sees a strong villager was misyeeted, and gets mad about people voting the counterwagon? how did lissa think that was "pure and real" wtf

what kind of wolf does that though.

That phrase is one of my all time pet peeves in games. It's so often applied incorrectly.

It was obviously done to look villagy. See Lissa's reaction to it.

suppose i may have focused so much on the feel and tone of it i didn't think about whether it actually made sense

hm

[Lissa]

are these... isoable

[KZA]

KZA

lettuce alliance

Sure

I have no personal preference so I'll let you decide who's power Rangers and who's turtles

[nutella]

hmmm. yeah marcher really never did explain why they townread carotte so confidently, I was hoping they'd go back and find the specific posts that gave them that feeling

[mention]Marcher Jovian[/mention] can you do so


still think it's more likely TMIing/whiteknighting a townie but I also suspect carotte independently and maybe they just would hard defend a teammate idfk

[bronana]

Where I'm at right now. Order in tiers purely alphabetical.


Villagy

bronana
KZA
tedxtr
tutuu

dunya
Lissa

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
TonyStarkPrime


Sort Pile

DrWilgy
Long Con
MacDougall
moth
motobot
outed wolf
Soneji
Turnip Head


Wolfy

nutella

Carotenoid
Marcher Jovian

[bronana]

hmmm. yeah marcher really never did explain why they townread carotte so confidently, I was hoping they'd go back and find the specific posts that gave them that feeling

@Marcher Jovian can you do so


still think it's more likely TMIing/whiteknighting a townie but I also suspect carotte independently and maybe they just would hard defend a teammate idfk

how is it TMIing a villager when you suspect carot and are hesitant on suspecting marcher

that sentence is breaking my brain

[bronana]

are these... isoable

In the search box, put in the username under "Posted by member" and check "search this thread only"

For catan, I manually ctrl+f'd the first few pages because marcher had too many posts for the search function apparently.

[nutella]

hmmm. yeah marcher really never did explain why they townread carotte so confidently, I was hoping they'd go back and find the specific posts that gave them that feeling

@Marcher Jovian can you do so


still think it's more likely TMIing/whiteknighting a townie but I also suspect carotte independently and maybe they just would hard defend a teammate idfk

how is it TMIing a villager when you suspect carot and are hesitant on suspecting marcher

that sentence is breaking my brain

I just don't see it as w/w, I think it is w/v or v/w (or v/v I guess but meh)
I'm open to your view of it though, maybe they are just teammates but I really don't feel it and I don't have the energy to dig into marcher's meta

[nutella]

are these... isoable

In the search box, put in the username under "Posted by member" and check "search this thread only"

For catan, I manually ctrl+f'd the first few pages because marcher had too many posts for the search function apparently.

dude the site has iso buttons on desktop, and if you're on mobile and they dont show up the host provided the links in the OP for convenience

[bronana]

hmmm. yeah marcher really never did explain why they townread carotte so confidently, I was hoping they'd go back and find the specific posts that gave them that feeling

@Marcher Jovian can you do so


still think it's more likely TMIing/whiteknighting a townie but I also suspect carotte independently and maybe they just would hard defend a teammate idfk

how is it TMIing a villager when you suspect carot and are hesitant on suspecting marcher

that sentence is breaking my brain

I just don't see it as w/w, I think it is w/v or v/w (or v/v I guess but meh)
I'm open to your view of it though, maybe they are just teammates but I really don't feel it and I don't have the energy to dig into marcher's meta

idgi, why can't it be w/w?

[nutella]

are these... isoable

In the search box, put in the username under "Posted by member" and check "search this thread only"

For catan, I manually ctrl+f'd the first few pages because marcher had too many posts for the search function apparently.

oh wait youre talking about a different site huh
nvm im dumb