U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[PunchyTheCat]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

I don't even know what I'm doing

just don't vote in his towncore except for eph tim and someone else i'm forgetting

i still want to vote xalt for voting me before i even posted and still voting me right now lmao

no i think he's town for a reason i forgot

[AWESOM-O]

woah manti is actually giving a shit about this game lmao

[sheepsaysmeep]

awesome is slightly villagery but not compellingly

wouldnt feel comfortable standing in the way if my villa reads want his death

[Sloonei]

Alright fine i’m a wolf you caught me, I couldn’t handle all this pressure of the Day 1 meme game.

[AWESOM-O]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

I don't even know what I'm doing

just don't vote in his towncore except for eph tim and someone else i'm forgetting

i still want to vote xalt for voting me before i even posted and still voting me right now lmao

no i think he's town for a reason i forgot

why are a bunch of others voting him then

[SilverKeith]

Someone who speaks spanish please explain

>>>>

[/quote]

just don't vote in his towncore except for eph tim and someone else i'm forgetting

[tedxtr]

Allowing sloonei votes to pass through seeing as he's struggling to be villagery

[PunchyTheCat]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

I don't even know what I'm doing

just don't vote in his towncore except for eph tim and someone else i'm forgetting

i still want to vote xalt for voting me before i even posted and still voting me right now lmao

no i think he's town for a reason i forgot

why are a bunch of others voting him then

idk they're bad

[AWESOM-O]

awesome is slightly villagery but not compellingly

wouldnt feel comfortable standing in the way if my villa reads want his death

wanted to point out that sheepsaysmeep is one of the people that actually can get a decent read on me pretty consistently

[Marcher Jovian]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

We require that you comply, citizen.

No.

No creo que creas que tu lista está 100% correcta.

Entiendo que creas que tu lista mayormente sea correcta (a pesar de que incluyas a alguien como a Tim), cosa que respeto, y que quieras resolver el juego en base a la misma.

Pero me da por las bolas que gente defienda a otras personas que yo legítimamente crea que son mafiosos y tengan razones de segunda para hacerlo. Así es como perdimos ani, porque cada vez que alguien quería poner a un mafioso en la mesa, siempre había otra persona (sea pueblerino o mafioso) que lo sacaba.

Entonces no, si me vas a venir con un post donde sacas a 10 personas de la mesa, discrepo.

Cómo alternativa, siempre me podrías vender uno de tus reads mafiosos. Lo que quizá estaría dispuesto a escuchar de no ser porque le disparaste a Daisy, quién muy probablemente sea pueblo. Ya tuviste tu chance de equivocarte, dejame la mía ahora, gracias.

The translator isn't doing very good work. Are you asking me to elaborate on specific reads? And you're saying that town-shielding is inherently anti-town citing anni?

tl;dr: I have legitimate reasons behind my scumreads (like the shot on daisy). I'm not gonna back down just because someone's getting townshielded and taken off the table. mafia talking each other off the table is how we lost anni. If you want me to change my vote sell me on your scumreads

[tedxtr]

Alright fine i’m a wolf you caught me, I couldn’t handle all this pressure of the Day 1 meme game.

sick xpost

[PunchyTheCat]

[mention]SilverKeith[/mention] readslist please

[sheepsaysmeep]

manti im hero peeking in your villa list pls forgive when it does actually end up being villa

[sheepsaysmeep]

awesome is slightly villagery but not compellingly

wouldnt feel comfortable standing in the way if my villa reads want his death

wanted to point out that sheepsaysmeep is one of the people that actually can get a decent read on me pretty consistently

ew no pressure get it away

[AWESOM-O]

manti im hero peeking in your villa list pls forgive when it does actually end up being villa

have you told me why you haven't made your avatar a more normal one?

[Hyena]

List of Vilagers/Vetoes

Spoiler: show

DaisyCloud
Shot a wolf. It's the type of role that wolves look at and say "yeah, this is our get deep for free card". Doming them, when funny was under 0 pressure and Daisy still had like 5 active shots in the air, is basically never a wolf. If they are, they're a godtier role, but we aren't getting into that for now.


DDL
Cool role, seems legit, prob village based on mechs. I don't feel like elaborating because I highly doubt anyone has their sites on him lol


NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
Claiming stumped, they also claim not to have a vote and all the other bullshit that makes a stump a stump. For now, gonna take their word for it and assume the slot is just a voice talking to us. I'll lol if they're like 3p executioner or some shit, that'd be hilarious


Ephemeral

LOCK OF THE WEEK. I can elaborate on why this guy is a villager if people really want me to, but as others have been saying basically all game, I'm the authority on Eph here. If anyone can read past this stupid bullshit, it's me. And my read is that this guy is a villager. I don't want to let him die this early, this easily, and for free. He's a 0 accountability wagon, and people like him dying this easily is how we lose. Don't let it happen


Hyena
Villagery ass MFer. After ISOing the guy, he's pure. I'd put this read on the same teir as Marcher. Towncore, listen to what he says, and if he has ultra strong feelings at ITAs consider what he's saying. I know sometimes hyena's good thoughts get ignored, and I don't want that happening here.


Marcher Jovian
Consistently villagery, protown, actually giving a shit. Seems to be a legit villager


nutella
After the fiasco that was last game, sort of have a grasp on how they play. Not really a meta read, more of a tonal/this is what I'd see a villager them be like


PunchyTheCat
SOULREAD PLEASE SHEEP, I UNDERSTAND WHY YOU MIGHT WANT TO KILL HIM BUT FAITH PLS TY


tedxtr
Early Denny's read, the guy stuck to his guns when pressured on it, but then backed off when new info came up and is giving the thread space rather than forcing through their own shit. This is always a villager.


ThisIsNotAceMarvel
Their ISO is legit. Not the most raw solving-power in there, but they come off as natural and their friendly/joky interactions with people comes off as genuine and unforced. Mix that with their solving, and they're probably a vilager.


Timsup2nothin
This guy feels like Phighter lol Abbrasive in unnecessary ways, and super tunneled on things that are pretty anti-town. But it isn't wolfy.


xalt
Guy has a pretty bad ISO. It's awkward, the jokes don't land, his posts are pretty bad. He isn't really all that pro-town, he doesn't really have a whole lot of good solving, and his reads are basic without much shown depth. This guy might as well be a wolf. However, deep in his heart, I see something. A kernal of villageriness. Something unshackably green at his core. Despite everything, he is a villager.


WerewolfHunter
Fix the broken OP lol anyway I didn't really like them when I was reading them live, but actually going through their posts independently they seems legit. Don't have a very detailed read idk lol


Jumpluff
I shouldn't have to explain this one my guys. I don't think anyone wants to kill them, so I'm not going to :hattip:



THESE READS ARE IN A RANDOM ORDER PLS SHEEP TY

I'm really vibing with this.

[Adam_]

im surprised that theres not a significantly larger wagon on me right now lmao

lol
[VOTE: sheepsaysmeep] aubergine
[VOTE: sloonei] aubergine

[SilverKeith]

Alright fuck it dropping the gimmick.

I actually gave like half a shit for this game so might as well

Originally I planned to take this in a low effort manner like rabbit suggested to me in the sign ups so I thought I'd rp and just don't care at all but whew I became invested in this siht earlier than I did in anni so fuck mafia I guess haha.

Also I feel bad that people are translating my post and shit my original idea was for people to ignore me more and me just being there screaming at stuff.

[Maple]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

We require that you comply, citizen.

No.

No creo que creas que tu lista está 100% correcta.

Entiendo que creas que tu lista mayormente sea correcta (a pesar de que incluyas a alguien como a Tim), cosa que respeto, y que quieras resolver el juego en base a la misma.

Pero me da por las bolas que gente defienda a otras personas que yo legítimamente crea que son mafiosos y tengan razones de segunda para hacerlo. Así es como perdimos ani, porque cada vez que alguien quería poner a un mafioso en la mesa, siempre había otra persona (sea pueblerino o mafioso) que lo sacaba.

Entonces no, si me vas a venir con un post donde sacas a 10 personas de la mesa, discrepo.

Cómo alternativa, siempre me podrías vender uno de tus reads mafiosos. Lo que quizá estaría dispuesto a escuchar de no ser porque le disparaste a Daisy, quién muy probablemente sea pueblo. Ya tuviste tu chance de equivocarte, dejame la mía ahora, gracias.

The translator isn't doing very good work. Are you asking me to elaborate on specific reads? And you're saying that town-shielding is inherently anti-town citing anni?

Estás sacando a muchas personas de la mesa en una etapa de juego muy temprano. No me gusta. Difiero.

Puedo escucharte en tus reads de mafiosos si quieres.

"Puedo escuchar en your reads by mobsters if you want."

I think you're saying you want to talk about mafia reads?

Regarding the first bit, it's more efficient to find a bunch of villagers early game, and kill other people. As the game goes on, you continually raise the bar and kill people who can't keep up, or who just aren't villagery. If I understand what you're saying right, I'll try to explain the folly of anni was that they failed to reevaluate reads as a collective, and allowed the wolves to pull the game into a series of "us vs them" disagreements.

There isn't anything inherently wrong with wanting to take people off the table early. What's wrong is not reevaluating later, and raising the bar. This isn't a mistake that I'll make.

[sheepsaysmeep]

manti im hero peeking in your villa list pls forgive when it does actually end up being villa

have you told me why you haven't made your avatar a more normal one?

theres no such thing as normal it's a social construct

[tedxtr]

awesome's avatar will make it harder for me to read him than it already was

i hope he gets shot in ita by some low poster

[Hyena]

Alright fine i’m a wolf you caught me, I couldn’t handle all this pressure of the Day 1 meme game.

[VOTE: Sloonei] aubergine

[ThisIsNotAceMarvel]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

We require that you comply, citizen.

No.

No creo que creas que tu lista está 100% correcta.

Entiendo que creas que tu lista mayormente sea correcta (a pesar de que incluyas a alguien como a Tim), cosa que respeto, y que quieras resolver el juego en base a la misma.

Pero me da por las bolas que gente defienda a otras personas que yo legítimamente crea que son mafiosos y tengan razones de segunda para hacerlo. Así es como perdimos ani, porque cada vez que alguien quería poner a un mafioso en la mesa, siempre había otra persona (sea pueblerino o mafioso) que lo sacaba.

Entonces no, si me vas a venir con un post donde sacas a 10 personas de la mesa, discrepo.

Cómo alternativa, siempre me podrías vender uno de tus reads mafiosos. Lo que quizá estaría dispuesto a escuchar de no ser porque le disparaste a Daisy, quién muy probablemente sea pueblo. Ya tuviste tu chance de equivocarte, dejame la mía ahora, gracias.

No

I don't think that your list is 100% correct

I understand you think that, even though you add someone like Tim, something I respect, because you want to solve the game based on this.

But I don't care that people defend others that I legit think are mafia, and have weak reasons to do so. Like we lost anni, because someone wanted to put a mafia on the table, there will always be another person that removed them.

So no, if you come telling me with a post removing 10 people, I disagree.

As an alternative, sell one of your mafia, I would be willing to listen, but you shot Daisy, who probably is town. You had your chance to be wrong, now let me have mine.

Tonal: sounds pretty firm and that SK won't budge.

[Maple]

Alright fuck it dropping the gimmick.

I actually gave like half a shit for this game so might as well

Originally I planned to take this in a low effort manner like rabbit suggested to me in the sign ups so I thought I'd rp and just don't care at all but whew I became invested in this siht earlier than I did in anni so fuck mafia I guess haha.

Also I feel bad that people are translating my post and shit my original idea was for people to ignore me more and me just being there screaming at stuff.

Good that was taking way too much brain effort lol

[AWESOM-O]

awesome's avatar will make it harder for me to read him than it already was

i hope he gets shot in ita by some low poster

wdym i'm literally eric cartman

[PunchyTheCat]

awesome is gut wolfy but i don't remember a single one of his posts and i'm not putting him on my wolflist

my wolflist is (unordered)

SilverKeith:
SilverKeith
Wolves:
112, Sloonei, cayvie, sheepsaysmeep, Tim, Ephemeral

[Maple]

@WerewolfHunter @Long Con, @iaafr, @Urist, @AWESOM-O
@DaisyCloud, @Dragon D. Luffy, @Logic, @colonialbob
@nutella, @Urist, @Timsup2nothin, @Adam_, @SilverKeith, @cayvie, @112
@sprityo

Hello, this is your captain speaking. I would like to ask that each of you please see this post, and change your votes.

Thank you for your cooperation.

No.

We require that you comply, citizen.

No.

No creo que creas que tu lista está 100% correcta.

Entiendo que creas que tu lista mayormente sea correcta (a pesar de que incluyas a alguien como a Tim), cosa que respeto, y que quieras resolver el juego en base a la misma.

Pero me da por las bolas que gente defienda a otras personas que yo legítimamente crea que son mafiosos y tengan razones de segunda para hacerlo. Así es como perdimos ani, porque cada vez que alguien quería poner a un mafioso en la mesa, siempre había otra persona (sea pueblerino o mafioso) que lo sacaba.

Entonces no, si me vas a venir con un post donde sacas a 10 personas de la mesa, discrepo.

Cómo alternativa, siempre me podrías vender uno de tus reads mafiosos. Lo que quizá estaría dispuesto a escuchar de no ser porque le disparaste a Daisy, quién muy probablemente sea pueblo. Ya tuviste tu chance de equivocarte, dejame la mía ahora, gracias.

No

I don't think that your list is 100% correct

I understand you think that, even though you add someone like Tim, something I respect, because you want to solve the game based on this.

But I don't care that people defend others that I legit think are mafia, and have weak reasons to do so. Like we lost anni, because someone wanted to put a mafia on the table, there will always be another person that removed them.

So no, if you come telling me with a post removing 10 people, I disagree.

As an alternative, sell one of your mafia, I would be willing to listen, but you shot Daisy, who probably is town. You had your chance to be wrong, now let me have mine.

Tonal: sounds pretty firm and that SK won't budge.

Thank you. In that case yes, I can discuss how I came to each read in a more specific way, rather than the "lol pls sheep" language I was using.

[Adam_]

sheep i would love to village with you again. you're way off right now. if you can start playing your normal game i think the wagon falls off of you. but this ain't right

[SilverKeith]

I think you're saying you want to talk about mafia reads?

Regarding the first bit, it's more efficient to find a bunch of villagers early game, and kill other people. As the game goes on, you continually raise the bar and kill people who can't keep up, or who just aren't villagery. If I understand what you're saying right, I'll try to explain the folly of anni was that they failed to reevaluate reads as a collective, and allowed the wolves to pull the game into a series of "us vs them" disagreements.

There isn't anything inherently wrong with wanting to take people off the table early. What's wrong is not reevaluating later, and raising the bar. This isn't a mistake that I'll make.

I'm saying that you're taking too many people off the table at this stage and I don't like it nor agree with it and if you want to actually get somewhere with me it would be best to try to sell me one of your scumreads.

Half of this is me strongly scumreading ephemeral

other half is salt based on me wanting to find a scum between the people who shot at daisy because you fucking know that daisy is the kind of POE shot that mafia loves to takes and would'nt you know half of those people are being shielded by you or are you.

[PunchyTheCat]

Alright fuck it dropping the gimmick.

I actually gave like half a shit for this game so might as well

Originally I planned to take this in a low effort manner like rabbit suggested to me in the sign ups so I thought I'd rp and just don't care at all but whew I became invested in this siht earlier than I did in anni so fuck mafia I guess haha.

Also I feel bad that people are translating my post and shit my original idea was for people to ignore me more and me just being there screaming at stuff.

thank you so much

[Adam_]

BUNNY GIF DISTRIBUTION

Thank you all for participating in the Bun to Heads read exercise!

There aren't any secret wolf reads buried in here, although I did actually comment on how it went. At the time, I think thread was fairly, though obviously not completely, pure. But mostly, I just wanted to reward people for participating, and relax after my appointment. So don't read it unless you're REALLY interested. But have a look at yours, and let me know if I missed you!

@Hyena @PunchyTheCat @Adam_ @NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME @DaisyCloud @MartinGG99 @SilverKeith @nutella @ThisIsNotAceMarvel @sabie12 pls don't be mad at me for pinging you for this lmao

Spoiler: show

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

1. nutella, with a lowercase n
2. YES

An eager and ready bun, with an appreciation for the tastier things in life. Knows what it wants.
Very interactive during the BUNBUN session, and even commenting on other participants! We note that even though this bunny is extremely focused on the banana, it has an alert and flexible focus.
We award Hyena 24/7 BUNBUN points. Of course, since all BUNs are 24/7, quantifying any extra BUNBUN points is impossible, but we are acknowledging that they have been earned with this Rabbit of Approval:

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

PunchyTheCat
YES

An enthusiastic and unorthodox response, with a reflexively egocentric nature. Drawn to the certainty of one's own perspective, which is perhaps to be commended when considering the fate of a bun.
Hyena correctly called this out as lazy, but it was a quick, natural, and unserious response, very in character, and somewhat consistent with the strength of Punchy's previously expressed reads. Hyena and Ace would have been fine names as well, but we think this is just Punchy being Punchy, and he would probably not try to ingratiate himself here. Lightly TOWN.
We award Punchy 24/7 BUNBUN points.

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

punchythecat
yes

(only 1 jumpluff allowed)

An affectionate and cooperative bun, aware of its role (to solve Punchy) and ready to prove itself (to me). An unsurprising but appreciated response.
Quick and natural response. Consistent with his approach to his rabbit's namesake - a good prognosis for bun ownership. Having talked to Adam a decent amount about PunchyTheCat reads since Anni, we are inclined to respect it. Since he and Punchy both submitted the same name, perhaps the fates have aligned with this v/v rand.
We award Adam 24/7 BUNBUN points. Treat your catbun well! (Buncat?)

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

I would name it Nanook, because I’m a narcissist

BUNBUN

A self-aware yet playful bun, unafraid to be the first purely frivolous responder. As my mason, he knows the most important quality is, of course, BUNBUN.
Self-evidently town. The self-BUNBUN is characteristic. We respect the style.
We award NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME 24/7 BUNBUN points.

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

does BUNBUN mean null?

it merely and completely means BUNBUN

it is a simple expression, and yet encompasses much; it is neither YES nor NO, but it is something much greater

oh okay thank you.

1. Maple. I think it's a good cute name for my pet rabbit.

2. BUNBUN

A thoughtful and pure bun, concerned only with the welfare of her pet rabbit. We should all aspire to be like DaisyCloud.
Tried her best to answer my question, which she took pretty seriously. An interesting look, but one that from DaisyCloud is certainly good. As a sidenote, I think DaisyCloud would be a really excellent name for a rabbit.
We award DaisyCloud 24/7 BUNBUN points and a Rabbit of Approval:

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

Hank
YES

A contemplative and considerate bun, bringing the spice and doing their best to bring others into the conversation. The most interesting response so far, even ignoring the thunderdome.
We do not claim to know the rationale behind this pick, but struggle to find a bad motivation behind using this as an opportunity to slap down an affirmative town read on a fairly UTR person. I would actually love to know why Marcher picked Hank, but it's a good name.
We award Marcher Jovian 24/7 BUNBUN points, and thank them for lending their name to our bun, who is helping me judge.

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

1) Apogee
2) YES (if not then BUNBUN)

from my PoV Apogee would be a good bunny name out of the selection here

A hedgey and maybe skittish bun, again with a non-consensus pick. Curiously, Apogee himself is a bit sceptical of early Apogee reads.
We see here that perhaps cautious overexplaining may be part of Martin's style. We wonder why their PoV makes Apogee a good bunny name, although we enjoy it, but we will not prod at it. It seems that they are new, also, and were a bit intimidated by the sheer bunnitude of the thread. So we are inclined to relent, as fellow hedgers (well, one of us is a fellow hedger; my pet bunny just eats them). We hope that Martin will feel more confident in the thread regardless.
We cautiously award MartinGG99 24/7 BUNBUN points, and thank them for going along with this despite their distrust of the BUNBUN BLOC.

sheepsaysmeep is a great name for a bunny

This is technically a reply, but it is not a BUN TO HEAD READ. Therefore, no bunny gif assignation will be done, which is a shame as I like sheep.
Oh, and we agree sheepsaysmeep is a fantastic name for a bunny.
At least say 'YES' or 'BUNBUN' like Nanook and Punchy :P What a dubious response.

We will address Trustworthy Liberal in a later post, but know that you are gone but not forgotten, 3p but still BUNBUN.

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

¿Cuál es la lógica/propósito de este ejercicio? Me interesa.

See sheepsaysmeep. However, as SilverKeith was actually re-enacting his role in the original BUN TO HEAD exercise here, which I failed to notice until he pointed it out to me for messing up my RP, we do not penalise this, but embrace it joyfully as an organic response.



A perceptive and humorous viscacha. Contributing great enjoyment to this game for me personally.
Maybe NAI really, but it feels good. Of course, I am confbiasing because I think SilverKeith is a villager regardless. There is, at least, an absence of wolfiness in the response. He was probably surprised to see anybody pasting that post into the game, so there is a wit to it. Also, he was unironically kinda solvy in the way he responded to the fact that I failed to react as cayvie did here.
We award SilverKeith 24/7 BUNBUN points, and a Delicious Treat.

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

I kinda did this back on page 1 but jumpluff and yes

A kind-hearted LOCK BUNBUN, eager to forge connections with rabbitkind. Generous and unselfconscious.
jumpluff, of course, would be a lovely and fluffy name for a bunny.
Also, nutella is like my favourite person ever for remembering BUN TO HEAD READS and even asked Jackofhearts2005 to do them before I ever made this post. That's like the purest flavour-inspired mindmeld ever.
We award nutella 24/7 BUNBUN points, and a Delicious Treat.

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN
this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
You, because Jumpluff have 3 giant cotton puffs, just like a fluffy bunny.
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN
I will say BUNBUN, because it sounds joyous.

EXTRA:

Spoiler: show

It will be like this bunny

A dedicated and sweet BUNBUN, who shares our appreciation for lops. 'Joyous' is the aura we would describe this village as possessing at the time, and this bun fit in it perfectly.
This is a very characteristic response, with extremely Ace reasoning that I found delightful immediately (because, wow, Jumpluff is a total bunny Pokémon). To me, Ace feels just like Anni, but without all the stress and overwhelmingness. So, like their Anni earlygame, somewhat.
I'd say I was pocketed by it, but I don't feel manipulated by it. My pet rabbit likes Ace immediately.
Also note that he calls me BUNBUN because it sounds joyous and doesn't say YES, so it's even better really.
Time taken to respond is even tempered by the effort here.
We award Ace Marvel 24/7 BUNBUN points, and a Rabbit of Joy.

ok im gonna run a lil exercise we do on my home forum if there's anyone currently in the thread

i call it BTH or Bun to Head reads

how it works is, answer these 2 questions.

1) if you had a pet rabbit, which player in this mash would you name it after?
2) is that player town? you have 3 possible responses to this question: YES, NO, BUNBUN

this is a serious exercise and i will be reading most of this game according to responses

Daisycloud sounds like a fluffy bun name I guess and yes.

Hm!



An inscrutable and laconic bun, drawn readily to the pure and fluffy.
I can't really describe the response I had to this post, sadly (my bunny disapproves). We were both amused that I had been thinking about what a good bun name DaisyCloud was and here we are. DaisyCloud was being villagery at the time, we think. And to me, they were an obvious villager. But others perceived them with great suspicion. That just might make sabie smart!
Perhaps there is dissonance between picking DaisyCloud for being a fluffy bun name and the tone of this post? It is all minute, and pales in the comparison to the respect shown for buns here by sabie's excellent choice. We appreciate the cooperation with our conversation starter.
We award sabie22 24/7 BUNBUN points.

bumping perfection. anyone who missed this is missing out. dig in before you forget

[sheepsaysmeep]

adam, apogee, awesome, bee, daisy, ddluffy, hyena, iaafr, jack, jump, maple, marcher, martin, nanook, nutella, poison, punchy, sheep, silverkeith, insomnia, tim, wwhunter, xalt


my villas

i think

[PunchyTheCat]

I think you're saying you want to talk about mafia reads?

Regarding the first bit, it's more efficient to find a bunch of villagers early game, and kill other people. As the game goes on, you continually raise the bar and kill people who can't keep up, or who just aren't villagery. If I understand what you're saying right, I'll try to explain the folly of anni was that they failed to reevaluate reads as a collective, and allowed the wolves to pull the game into a series of "us vs them" disagreements.

There isn't anything inherently wrong with wanting to take people off the table early. What's wrong is not reevaluating later, and raising the bar. This isn't a mistake that I'll make.

I'm saying that you're taking too many people off the table at this stage and I don't like it nor agree with it and if you want to actually get somewhere with me it would be best to try to sell me one of your scumreads.

Half of this is me strongly scumreading ephemeral

other half is salt based on me wanting to find a scum between the people who shot at daisy because you fucking know that daisy is the kind of POE shot that mafia loves to takes and would'nt you know half of those people are being shielded by you or are you.

me and ace are lock v never rescind

xalt and some other person i forgot shot at daisy (maybe apogee?)

and i v read xalt

[ColinIsCool]

What’s the 411 on 112?

[Adam_]

sheep, can you talk to me about beeboy v? what's the deal there?

[tedxtr]

ftr call me ted here, syndicate peeps will be confused

[Sloonei]

I signed up for this game to fart around and be goofy. If me doing that is going to make everyone lock me in as scum then we might as well just get my elimination over with. I did not sign up for the 50 player designated meme game 2 weeks before my semifinals game with the intention of going all out. So far I've been keeping my focus on activity that involves me. I am scrutinizing the players who have unconditionally and uncritically accepted the suspicion against me, so I would at least urge that we look at them once I'm dead and gone.

[Maple]

I think you're saying you want to talk about mafia reads?

Regarding the first bit, it's more efficient to find a bunch of villagers early game, and kill other people. As the game goes on, you continually raise the bar and kill people who can't keep up, or who just aren't villagery. If I understand what you're saying right, I'll try to explain the folly of anni was that they failed to reevaluate reads as a collective, and allowed the wolves to pull the game into a series of "us vs them" disagreements.

There isn't anything inherently wrong with wanting to take people off the table early. What's wrong is not reevaluating later, and raising the bar. This isn't a mistake that I'll make.

I'm saying that you're taking too many people off the table at this stage and I don't like it nor agree with it and if you want to actually get somewhere with me it would be best to try to sell me one of your scumreads.

Half of this is me strongly scumreading ephemeral

other half is salt based on me wanting to find a scum between the people who shot at daisy because you fucking know that daisy is the kind of POE shot that mafia loves to takes and would'nt you know half of those people are being shielded by you or are you.

I said early wrt this that I want to resolve JPIC ASAP for similar reasons to this. If the guy flips wolf, you're completely correct and we need to take a harder look at the people who shot at daisy, because a 2 person w/v list is a bit of a no-brainer decision for wolves to shoot.

That being said, typically when you have an unorganized ITA period wolves are more likely to be the guys taking orange-zone, kinda bad shots that have levels of plausible deniability, as per the Vigi Chart. I think looking into a combination of those two zones does sound quite sensible, and am down to discuss that.

[PunchyTheCat]

adam, apogee, awesome, bee, daisy, ddluffy, hyena, iaafr, jack, jump, maple, marcher, martin, nanook, nutella, poison, punchy, sheep, silverkeith, insomnia, tim, wwhunter, xalt

v idk idk idk v v v v idk v v v v v v v v you're a wolf idk v w v v

explain wwh and some of my idks

[sheepsaysmeep]

sheep i would love to village with you again. you're way off right now. if you can start playing your normal game i think the wagon falls off of you. but this ain't right

difficult to find the motivation for me right now entirely my fault

sorry

hopefully will be feeling better post-n1

[Maple]

tldr it sucks balls that we cant vote jpic today because he is by far the absolute best yeet possible today

[Marcher Jovian]

What’s the 411 on 112?

Claimed persuader (force one player to vote for another), which is historically a mafia role but as always could be setup WIFOM.
Apart from that kinda underwhelming.
Probs a good iso to poke through.

[Maple]

Anyway, continuing on that, all of my reads so far are on individuals. I'm not really going deep into atmospheric holistic reads yet, because that's typically a d2 thing.

That's why I want to focus on player-by-player discussion, rather than mechanical wolf boxing - which imo is worth a whole lot more later.

[SilverKeith]

I think you're saying you want to talk about mafia reads?

Regarding the first bit, it's more efficient to find a bunch of villagers early game, and kill other people. As the game goes on, you continually raise the bar and kill people who can't keep up, or who just aren't villagery. If I understand what you're saying right, I'll try to explain the folly of anni was that they failed to reevaluate reads as a collective, and allowed the wolves to pull the game into a series of "us vs them" disagreements.

There isn't anything inherently wrong with wanting to take people off the table early. What's wrong is not reevaluating later, and raising the bar. This isn't a mistake that I'll make.

I'm saying that you're taking too many people off the table at this stage and I don't like it nor agree with it and if you want to actually get somewhere with me it would be best to try to sell me one of your scumreads.

Half of this is me strongly scumreading ephemeral

other half is salt based on me wanting to find a scum between the people who shot at daisy because you fucking know that daisy is the kind of POE shot that mafia loves to takes and would'nt you know half of those people are being shielded by you or are you.

me and ace are lock v never rescind

xalt and some other person i forgot shot at daisy (maybe apogee?)

and i v read xalt

I think that you're the most likely villager out of there aside from ace and if we ignore like manti being cleared.

So we're left with... Ephemeral. And Xalt I suppose.

Maybe is the fact that some of you were scumreading daisy (or sheeped RAN on that 200iq read idk), but to me it was very clear that players like daisy are the type of players mafia love to shoot because no one is going to defend them and the way in which they defend themself is just weird or out there so they can use that plus general feelings to shot at it and come out clean. It's fucking textbook stuff.

[tedxtr]

I signed up for this game to fart around and be goofy. If me doing that is going to make everyone lock me in as scum then we might as well just get my elimination over with. I did not sign up for the 50 player designated meme game 2 weeks before my semifinals game with the intention of going all out. So far I've been keeping my focus on activity that involves me. I am scrutinizing the players who have unconditionally and uncritically accepted the suspicion against me, so I would at least urge that we look at them once I'm dead and gone.

you're just not being villagery sloonei ; i think you'd do more ground work or look into the votes on you - have a different reaction

I understand you have semis in 2 weeks - but it's not about you not going all out ; it's about you not going at all, if that makes sense.

[Sloonei]

Like, I'm fine with 112's suspicion of me. They were the first to say anything negative about me and I don't think they'd have done that as a wolf because at the time it was a risky move.
nutella is incapable of trusting me. I admire her for that, but it makes it difficult to take her suspicions too seriously. She could be putting it on for affect. I believe her so far.
Hyena to me feels to be reveling in the Sloonei suspicion.
After that I regard everyone as a follower and have not reviewed them all in any depth because that's something that Serious Sloonei would do, and that guy's not here.

[Maple]

Also Adam, I read your post at me earlier and I don't completely understand what you were trying to say to me. Something about wanting Jump to be alive (which shouldn't be an issue, no one wants to kill them).

[ColinIsCool]

What’s the 411 on 112?

Claimed persuader (force one player to vote for another), which is historically a mafia role but as always could be setup WIFOM.
Apart from that kinda underwhelming.
Probs a good iso to poke through.

Alright thanks

[PunchyTheCat]

I think you're saying you want to talk about mafia reads?

Regarding the first bit, it's more efficient to find a bunch of villagers early game, and kill other people. As the game goes on, you continually raise the bar and kill people who can't keep up, or who just aren't villagery. If I understand what you're saying right, I'll try to explain the folly of anni was that they failed to reevaluate reads as a collective, and allowed the wolves to pull the game into a series of "us vs them" disagreements.

There isn't anything inherently wrong with wanting to take people off the table early. What's wrong is not reevaluating later, and raising the bar. This isn't a mistake that I'll make.

I'm saying that you're taking too many people off the table at this stage and I don't like it nor agree with it and if you want to actually get somewhere with me it would be best to try to sell me one of your scumreads.

Half of this is me strongly scumreading ephemeral

other half is salt based on me wanting to find a scum between the people who shot at daisy because you fucking know that daisy is the kind of POE shot that mafia loves to takes and would'nt you know half of those people are being shielded by you or are you.

me and ace are lock v never rescind

xalt and some other person i forgot shot at daisy (maybe apogee?)

and i v read xalt

I think that you're the most likely villager out of there aside from ace and if we ignore like manti being cleared.

So we're left with... Ephemeral. And Xalt I suppose.

Maybe is the fact that some of you were scumreading daisy (or sheeped RAN on that 200iq read idk), but to me it was very clear that players like daisy are the type of players mafia love to shoot because no one is going to defend them and the way in which they defend themself is just weird or out there so they can use that plus general feelings to shot at it and come out clean. It's fucking textbook stuff.

hdgsgdjhgdgskjhd it was ephemeral

Punchy's suspicion on Ephemeral rises.

[Sloonei]

I signed up for this game to fart around and be goofy. If me doing that is going to make everyone lock me in as scum then we might as well just get my elimination over with. I did not sign up for the 50 player designated meme game 2 weeks before my semifinals game with the intention of going all out. So far I've been keeping my focus on activity that involves me. I am scrutinizing the players who have unconditionally and uncritically accepted the suspicion against me, so I would at least urge that we look at them once I'm dead and gone.

you're just not being villagery sloonei ; i think you'd do more ground work or look into the votes on you - have a different reaction

I understand you have semis in 2 weeks - but it's not about you not going all out ; it's about you not going at all, if that makes sense.

Yes, that is exactly my point. I'm not gonna do those things. I'm playing this game from the backseat.