U-Pick Anything Volume 2 Game Thread (Day 4 )

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We could try to get someone scummy to shoot at maple

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

How exactly does his thing claim to work again? Idk if I’ll have time to search it out before ITAs lol

[Timsup2nothin]

Working backwards the town (or townie enough to live today anyways) are like

Apogee
Cayvie
Daisy
DDL*
Hyena
Rabbit
Logic
Long Con
NANOOK HELL YEAH BABAY
Poison
Punchy
Sabie
Sheep
Tim
WWH

We can set aside JPIC too, I guess

So really pretty much any shots outside of that group are fine I think?





*spec chat is scum is a thought I had ngl, but DDL can still be town for today

I think it is less confusing to provide a clear shooting list. Anyone who just can't resist a hero shot is doubly warned not to shoot into this veto list though.

Well yeah I’m gonna get to that, but I start from who shouldn’t be on it and work that way

But yeah I’m gonna post a shot list assuming no complaints with the removals

It's already made and you had major input. We are gonna have people popping in and having to shoot quickly...let's make it as easy as possible so the wolves can'y shoot whoever they want in the confusion, eh?

[DaisyCloud]

I'm thinking Mafia kill Ace, Jack, and Urist.

Serial Killer killed speedchuck/ted and vig got the other.

Speedchuck's revenge kill autoresolved last and it was on Awesome-O who by the way had just won the popcorn

My experience is that faction NK is usually at the end of order of operations. Awesome-O was lock town and had destroyed the wolf plan almost single handed. I figure him for the NK. Speedchuck was a claimed vig shot. Ted maybe SK, maybe vig. No clue on all the janitored kills but probably mafia vigs. Same with Ace, Jack, and Urist.

Well if someone is poisoned tomorrow, then we'll know for sure.

what if they are only odd nite?

sorry I could be wrong. idk but your theory is good and so is tim's and it be hard to resolve.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

So shot list is currently

Beeboy
Colin
Bob
Wilgy
Epi
Iwan
10k

??

Low key want to take Epi off tbh but idk if that’s a good idea or not

[Timsup2nothin]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Beeboy
DrWigly
Iwan
TenThousandCalories

IF AND ONLY IF THOSE FOUR ARE ALL DEAD:

Colin
ColonialBob

IF THOSE TWO ARE ALSO DEAD AND BY SOME MIRACLE YOU STILL HAVE BULLETS YOU CAN SHOOT:

Logic

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

HOLDING YOUR FIRE WILL BE FROWNED UPON

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Just take logic off entirely plz

[Timsup2nothin]

So shot list is currently

Beeboy
Colin
Bob
Wilgy
Epi
Iwan
10k

??

Low key want to take Epi off tbh but idk if that’s a good idea or not

Epi is off, lock full stop, I'll explain later

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’d like him to not get hero vigged with the excuse of “it was heat of the moment and I thought he was on the list”

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

So shot list is currently

Beeboy
Colin
Bob
Wilgy
Epi
Iwan
10k

??

Low key want to take Epi off tbh but idk if that’s a good idea or not

Epi is off, lock full stop, I'll explain later

Good enough for me

[Timsup2nothin]

Just take logic off entirely plz

We are never going to get six kills, but if by some weird quirk we do I don't want some last shooting wolf to say "no more list, guess I can shoot Tim no questions asked."

[Timsup2nothin]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Beeboy
DrWigly
Iwan
TenThousandCalories

IF AND ONLY IF THOSE FOUR ARE ALL DEAD:

Spoiler: show

Colin
ColonialBob

IF THOSE TWO ARE ALSO DEAD AND BY SOME MIRACLE YOU STILL HAVE BULLETS YOU CAN SHOOT:

Spoiler: show

Logic

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

HOLDING YOUR FIRE WILL BE FROWNED UPON

[iaafr]

Just take logic off entirely plz

We are never going to get six kills, but if by some weird quirk we do I don't want some last shooting wolf to say "no more list, guess I can shoot Tim no questions asked."

any wolf could theoretically out to shoot you even with the full list alive lol

doing it with the list alive vs dead doesnt change how outing it is

[Timsup2nothin]

I’d like him to not get hero vigged with the excuse of “it was heat of the moment and I thought he was on the list”

This was a good point and I have reformatted.

[DaisyCloud]

Spoiler: show

[color= green]punchy going camping and having fun in rl is nice and all but wish they can clone themselves and be in game too.

I'm a selfish person. sorry but I felt compelled to say this.

part of this is probably me in rl dealing with power outages and heat and sweat and storms and blah blah blah. this is off topic and idk how to change color.[/color]

I put off topic in spoilers because idk how to color text

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I’d like him to not get hero vigged with the excuse of “it was heat of the moment and I thought he was on the list”

This was a good point and I have reformatted.

Thanks

Also seconding rabbit’s point

[Timsup2nothin]

Just take logic off entirely plz

We are never going to get six kills, but if by some weird quirk we do I don't want some last shooting wolf to say "no more list, guess I can shoot Tim no questions asked."

any wolf could theoretically out to shoot you even with the full list alive lol

doing it with the list alive vs dead doesnt change how outing it is

I'm just being thorough...it's my nature

[DaisyCloud]

I'm an un cc'ed vig, I shot a wolf, and an investigator targeted me last night and said I was v

this was information I needed like 40 mills hours ago.

[DaisyCloud]

I'm sorry guys just having some personal drama

self care boss ♡♡

take care and hope everything resolves well for you ♡♡

[DaisyCloud]

can I be done playing catch up or??

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Ngl I am SUPER tempted to shoot maple and see what happens

[iaafr]

I'm an un cc'ed vig, I shot a wolf, and an investigator targeted me last night and said I was v

this was information I needed like 40 mills hours ago.

thats like the third time she claimed it and you couldve isoed her at any point

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

It’s fine, claims are really easy to miss still

[DaisyCloud]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Beeboy
DrWigly
Iwan
TenThousandCalories

IF AND ONLY IF THOSE FOUR ARE ALL DEAD:

Colin
ColonialBob
Logic

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

HOLDING YOUR FIRE WILL BE FROWNED UPON

Logic shouldn’t be on that list unless you’re scumreading myself and/or poison

wheres that same check

Poison claimed it, ISO her and search logic’s name, should come up

wut? poison claimed what? how is logic involved. im on mobile.

[Timsup2nothin]

Any wolf that wants to out by taking a shot at me...you know I will flip green and as of this moment the town looks like they would be unforgiving if you actually killed me...but in the 85% chance that you missed and out yourself for nothing I will be down your throat with a chainsaw finding out who all your little playmates are.

[iaafr]

Ngl I am SUPER tempted to shoot maple and see what happens

same tbh

[DaisyCloud]

I'm an un cc'ed vig, I shot a wolf, and an investigator targeted me last night and said I was v

this was information I needed like 40 mills hours ago.

thats like the third time she claimed it and you couldve isoed her at any point

I'm on mobile. sorry.

[Hyena]

I'm back for a bit! Welcome back, Tim!

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

[mention]DaisyCloud[/mention] poison claimed a same check between myself and logic.

[Timsup2nothin]

Ngl I am SUPER tempted to shoot maple and see what happens

same tbh

This might be an entertaining cosmological question for immortal trees to ponder...not fluffy rabbits.

[Timsup2nothin]

I'm back for a bit! Welcome back, Tim!

Hey!

We're gonna be shooting people here in a bit! That's always fun.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean if maple is mafia

There’s a decent chance it benefits him to be voted out rather than ITA’d right?


And if he’s town then me shooting him should override the downsides, I would think

[Timsup2nothin]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Beeboy
DrWigly
Iwan
TenThousandCalories

IF AND ONLY IF THOSE FOUR ARE ALL DEAD:

Spoiler: show

Colin
ColonialBob

IF THOSE TWO ARE ALSO DEAD AND BY SOME MIRACLE YOU STILL HAVE BULLETS YOU CAN SHOOT:

Spoiler: show

Logic

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

HOLDING YOUR FIRE WILL BE FROWNED UPON

[Hyena]

I'm back for a bit! Welcome back, Tim!

Hey!

We're gonna be shooting people here in a bit! That's always fun.

Oh fun! I'll read back a little bit then, maybe just the past couple of pages, to catch up.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I have a nagging feeling that bob is town but I can’t justify it so meh

[iaafr]

Ngl I am SUPER tempted to shoot maple and see what happens

same tbh

This might be an entertaining cosmological question for immortal trees to ponder...not fluffy rabbits.

if he's actually scum there's no reason to believe that we shouldnt be ITAing him

also im not a fluffy rabbit in this game i am an extremely powerful entity

[Timsup2nothin]

I mean if maple is mafia

There’s a decent chance it benefits him to be voted out rather than ITA’d right?


And if he’s town then me shooting him should override the downsides, I would think

Man I'm in. You had me at "just to see what happens."

[Timsup2nothin]

I'm back for a bit! Welcome back, Tim!

Hey!

We're gonna be shooting people here in a bit! That's always fun.

Oh fun! I'll read back a little bit then, maybe just the past couple of pages, to catch up.

There's a list.

[Hyena]

SHOOTING LIST IS:

Beeboy
DrWigly
Iwan
TenThousandCalories

IF AND ONLY IF THOSE FOUR ARE ALL DEAD:

Spoiler: show

Colin
ColonialBob

IF THOSE TWO ARE ALSO DEAD AND BY SOME MIRACLE YOU STILL HAVE BULLETS YOU CAN SHOOT:

Spoiler: show

Logic

DO NOT SHOOT OFF THE LIST

HOLDING YOUR FIRE WILL BE FROWNED UPON

Oh, nevermind. Something like this is what I was gonna look for, lol.

[DaisyCloud]

Given the Strongman Cop claim, I wouldn't be surprised if the wolves have a Godfather regardless of whether or not it's real

I interpreted strongman as being able to go through stuff like miller modifier and gf invest immunity.

I know strongman means a kill modifier thst bypasses protections etc but why would cop need to kill and invest? i mean thst be cool but would thry do both at same nite or choose? like why force cop to choose between killing or investing? invest is soo important.

I never heard of this role. seems cool tho.

[Maple]

If me and Nanook end up in DVC, that isn't on me

[Hyena]

Wait, you think BOTH of Colin and CBob should be shot? There was some interesting hostile interactions between them earlier. I'll pull them up for you.

[Timsup2nothin]

Ngl I am SUPER tempted to shoot maple and see what happens

same tbh

This might be an entertaining cosmological question for immortal trees to ponder...not fluffy rabbits.

if he's actually scum there's no reason to believe that we shouldnt be ITAing him

also im not a fluffy rabbit in this game i am an extremely powerful entity

Me too if I can ever activate the qualifier...which would basically require the accidental cooperation of the entire player list.

[WerewolfHunter]

Could someone repost the format? Last time I stole it from iaafrs post

[Logic]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Ok, yeah, the misunderstanding is on my end.
I thought you were doubling down on who I said I was talking to and thought it was a scummy frame job.

I'm just being dumb.

The initial misunderstanding was mine and I misread a lot of things that day lol

In absence of someone who knows how to read Logic, I am gonna say Logic might just be a villager

@Adam_ got me vibes from this (as a follow-up)

FWIW I have seen Logic get himself early mischopped over very similar differences of opinion...and have also seen w!Logic get chopped properly over very similar differences of opinion. He in my opinion is a tough read.

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

[Hyena]

I see we have reached the portion of the game where town-Colin gets murked via POE. I am fine with this.

This is what I'm talking about. Care to grace us with whatever reads you might have?

Well I don’t trust you!

I like Long Con and Nanook and the sheep person right now. Sprit is putting a good foot forward. Tbh Epi is probably town cause even though he’s retired-ish I can’t see him just posting GIFs as scum.

Somebody said cbob was over-explainy earlier and that has pinged me. iaafr still feels off to me compared to earlier games we’ve played, extremely different energy than those (both townie). I’m still kind of struggling to figure out the people I haven’t played with though

pls point to me over-explaining

Mostly in your defense of Sloonei, felt TMIy reading back too.

>accurately townreads sloonei
>it's TMI

Here's part of the interaction.

[DaisyCloud]

@DaisyCloud poison claimed a same check between myself and logic.

thank you so much for the infos. ♡

I'm almost in this page. just gotta read a few more posts!!

[Timsup2nothin]

Wait, you think BOTH of Colin and CBob should be shot? There was some interesting hostile interactions between them earlier. I'll pull them up for you.

If one flips wolf I might call for a stop on shooting the other, if you have something really good.

[Maple]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

The initial misunderstanding was mine and I misread a lot of things that day lol

In absence of someone who knows how to read Logic, I am gonna say Logic might just be a villager

@Adam_ got me vibes from this (as a follow-up)

FWIW I have seen Logic get himself early mischopped over very similar differences of opinion...and have also seen w!Logic get chopped properly over very similar differences of opinion. He in my opinion is a tough read.

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

Sounds fake to me

[iaafr]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

The initial misunderstanding was mine and I misread a lot of things that day lol

In absence of someone who knows how to read Logic, I am gonna say Logic might just be a villager

@Adam_ got me vibes from this (as a follow-up)

FWIW I have seen Logic get himself early mischopped over very similar differences of opinion...and have also seen w!Logic get chopped properly over very similar differences of opinion. He in my opinion is a tough read.

I happen to think that Logic fellow is a really easy read.
He's either free dead wolf or innocent child.

logics guntohead town for me because not sure he'd post this as wolf + his attitude in general is on the villagery side (kind of abrasive/demanding)

@Logic come play

decent chance he forgot this game existed too lol

I didn't forget; I'm at my second job that has less time for mafia throughout the day.

I have a claim to make. Not sure how to reveal it.

Before ITAs is highly recommended.

I received an alignment peek of Unknown source.
It gave me a redpeek regarding sheepsaysmeep.

I hardclaim almost VT

dank i was lowkey scumreading him again recently