Amdibals at the Zoo! [END]

[Carotenoid]

Anybody know if Alison is the type of player that would make this post to a scummate so early on?

Town
tutuu
Amy
Urist
Mac

I hate this post.

It's not out of her scumrange

[ColinIsCool]

Jumping around to read proto in light of that post

pretty sure it was Alison who was describing that sometimes they like to get scrumread at start of game and then climb out of the hole they dug for themselves as some sort of challenge. Might also be toitally mistaking that for another player. Cant 100% be sure it was alison. If it was, someone else can probably confirm it.

Open wolfing is also something Alison would do as mafia. It is also something they would need to do as actual mafia since they do it as town for balance reasons. You either dont understand this logic, or you do.

I have seen tutuu be more towny when town. She is not lock town to me at the moment. She in POE with everyone else.

No hard town reads or scumreads other than Alison atm.

Joseph prides himself on being good at mafia. He currently thinks I am mafia. Gonna omgus and lean Joseph as mafia here for scumreading me. Not as direct omgus, but more based on the fact that he should be able to read me as town. Granted I havent been very towny, but even so.

This post itself likely to get me more scumread. oh well.

Game is easier if I am scumread because when everyone pockets me as clear town, the game is harder. OMGUS to find the mafia usually isnt a terrible strategy.

Is it just me or does everything in this post feel calculated/hedgy/insincere

[ColinIsCool]

Can anyone see a potential world of Mac and TSP? Not super pushing it since it's unlikely but can we consider it?

Tutuu has now voted on and killed 2 town. She will say she was sheeping the votes on day 2 but it's a little convenient. Don't think they are ever dying in the next night phase.

Nothing else super constructive re game or finding scum/town.

Mac/TSP world means they both agreed to bus 112 super early and that they're still bussing, unlikely

tutuu has a good point. How do you know Alison is town?

Re: your first graf — does it? Mac didn’t vote for 112 until right before EOD, which sure fine, wolf killed, but we’ve all seen wolves coast to victory doing that exact thing.

graf?
They both opened pretty aggressively against 112 and they're thunderdomingish each other. I don't think TSP/Mac team thinks their best shot is to bus this aggressively

Sorry, journo slang for paragraph

I’ll have to check that over.

[ColinIsCool]

Does a townie really feel the need to respond to one vote like this? Does this not look like textbook buddying?

Proto, your post up there weirded me out, felt like comments for the sake of comments. [VOTE: Proto] aubergine

That's fine. We don't have much meta with eachother. You should suspect me in this spot. I townread you for it.

[Carotenoid]

Hell, Alison pretty much dogged 112 from the get-go and didn’t let up. If there’s any pre-determined bus plan, it’s there ... but I don’t think there is. I doubt the mafia were truly planning on dunking one of their own from the very first.

Agree with it was probably not their plan to bus from the very start. Alison vocally disliked 112 but only voted there a few hours before EoD and 112 didn't vote Alison before she had no other choice for self-pres, so I could see the team being something like 112/TTC/Alison and the wagons on D1 being w/w.

[ColinIsCool]

This is proto’s only significant mention of 112:

Mafia team

112
nutella
proto

disgusting

Take proto out and put Urist in

lol did I just need to OMGUS you and vote you to get townread?

i dont like the push on Nutella either.

No idea on 112. I TR Nutella kinda and she seems pretty sure 112 is maf for meta reasons, I assume.

Later proto calls 112 “meh” and eventually ends up voting there to save Alison. It could be that proto just really strongly townreads Alison which would make that “slip” not really a slip, just imprecisely written. This vote does feel somewhat more crucial than some others in getting to the 112 yeet, too, and I hesitate to say it was a bus-in-the-making. Tonally though the rest of the ISO just feels off to me. My mind isn’t made up here

[Carotenoid]

Jumping around to read proto in light of that post

pretty sure it was Alison who was describing that sometimes they like to get scrumread at start of game and then climb out of the hole they dug for themselves as some sort of challenge. Might also be toitally mistaking that for another player. Cant 100% be sure it was alison. If it was, someone else can probably confirm it.

Open wolfing is also something Alison would do as mafia. It is also something they would need to do as actual mafia since they do it as town for balance reasons. You either dont understand this logic, or you do.

I have seen tutuu be more towny when town. She is not lock town to me at the moment. She in POE with everyone else.

No hard town reads or scumreads other than Alison atm.

Joseph prides himself on being good at mafia. He currently thinks I am mafia. Gonna omgus and lean Joseph as mafia here for scumreading me. Not as direct omgus, but more based on the fact that he should be able to read me as town. Granted I havent been very towny, but even so.

This post itself likely to get me more scumread. oh well.

Game is easier if I am scumread because when everyone pockets me as clear town, the game is harder. OMGUS to find the mafia usually isnt a terrible strategy.

Is it just me or does everything in this post feel calculated/hedgy/insincere

Nah, the Alison read is especially hedgy. I pointed it out but I don't think proto ever actually answered it. I'll go check.

Alison/Proto is not w/w. At first I thought Alison was trying to pocket Proto, but it might actually be the opposite that's happening.

[ColinIsCool]

Carote handles 112 pretty well throughout D1, imo. The ISO seems pretty pure to me — there are a lot of recurring suspicions that progress logically, in a way that feels hard to fake.

[tutuu]

i would never consider town alison getting pocketed by wolf proto. she just cant. she owns his soul imo.

pre-agreed bus is definitely something alison would do @ colin. not to say that she is scum for lynching a wolf, or that i am scumreading her atm, but im saying how it is. she has even said it herself this game "why would u consider me not being w/w with 112 tutuu" if u go iso her posts and control + f that. outside of the game she has mentioned that her scum game relies on bussing and focusing on reaching the conclusion that someone is scum rather than naturally getting around to making the read

[ColinIsCool]

Eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeh Mac has a really good D1. Think I’m just tinfoilling by having any suspicion there

[ColinIsCool]

i would never consider town alison getting pocketed by wolf proto. she just cant. she owns his soul imo.

pre-agreed bus is definitely something alison would do @ colin. not to say that she is scum for lynching a wolf, or that i am scumreading her atm, but im saying how it is. she has even said it herself this game "why would u consider me not being w/w with 112 tutuu" if u go iso her posts and control + f that. outside of the game she has mentioned that her scum game relies on bussing and focusing on reaching the conclusion that someone is scum rather than naturally getting around to making the read

Ok, thanks.

[ColinIsCool]

Popping out of the game for a while but to reiterate: proto????

[Carotenoid]

This is the post where proto addresses the hedgy read on Alison -->

Spoiler: show

pretty sure it was Alison who was describing that sometimes they like to get scrumread at start of game and then climb out of the hole they dug for themselves as some sort of challenge. Might also be toitally mistaking that for another player. Cant 100% be sure it was alison. If it was, someone else can probably confirm it.

Open wolfing is also something Alison would do as mafia. It is also something they would need to do as actual mafia since they do it as town for balance reasons. You either dont understand this logic, or you do.

I have seen tutuu be more towny when town. She is not lock town to me at the moment. She in POE with everyone else.

No hard town reads or scumreads other than Alison atm.

Joseph prides himself on being good at mafia. He currently thinks I am mafia. Gonna omgus and lean Joseph as mafia here for scumreading me. Not as direct omgus, but more based on the fact that he should be able to read me as town. Granted I havent been very towny, but even so.

This post itself likely to get me more scumread. oh well.

Game is easier if I am scumread because when everyone pockets me as clear town, the game is harder. OMGUS to find the mafia usually isnt a terrible strategy.

... Is Alison a town read or a scum read?

@protocultures You missed this post >:( Anyway:

[...]
Alison - prob still mafia but not voting them day 1 because: they are currently hard defending me when a couple people want to kill me. If they are town, its good I am not pushing them. If they are mafia, they are doing a good job townsiding by pocketing and hard defending me.

I assume I misremembered the name of the player who likes being scumread at start of games to dig themselves out of a hole since Alison is saying this not NOT something she said, and also nobody else remembers this either so think its a conversation I had with someone else in another mafia community. Oddly she notes she thinks I am fabricating this whole thing but still townreads me. Either way, look to point above - Alison is town and defending me or she is hard defending me as mafia, both of which are good for now and why I wont vote her day 1. Kind of unfairly, I will probably always have a suspicion of Alison in every single game I play with them.

My second point on alison i am pretty sure is NOT a lie. That is that they claim mafia on day 0/1 - pretty sure Alison did this in Lion King as town and they did it in this game as well. My point remains that if she will do this as town, she must do this as mafia as well for balance reasons.
[...]

So this implies the first quoted post was a scumread, which is ??? For every reason you think she's mafia you also give the counterargument. Second quote is even worse, t!protocultures doesn't accept nonsense like that and isn't afraid to get engaged against his scumreads.

It doesnt matter what alignbment Alison is for Day 1, because I am not voting them day 1 today. It is beneficial for my alignment if alison stays alive at the moment.

Basically it's like :
- Hey proto why are you so unsure on Alison.
- ...
- Hey proto why are you so unsure on Alison.
- I don't care as long she's townreading me.

He did the same thing townreading nutella since she had a slight townread on him. The thing with tracking Nanook's behaviour/shrug emoji is kinda meh, he keeps going back to it but there's no real conclusion.

[Carotenoid]

Hmn I found another post where proto just never followed-up with me. He says in #881 the only thing he finds scummy from me is my readlist. Okay, I ask him to be more precise and it results it #945. I answer on #959 that our reads are actually not that different and then he just never follows-up but say he likes me for "trying to figure him out" later on. I dislike that he cares more about me trying to figure him out than trying to figure me out.

The difference in his readlist/my readlist are basically just Turnip Head & Alison (he townread her at the time but like, he scumread her for most of the day so the fact he doesn't really relate feels off). I think he only disliked my readlist because I put him at the bottom, it just doesn't seem like genuine solving concerns and the fact he just never followed-up makes me think he felt a bit caught and just hoped that I forget about that.

[protocultures]

Can anyone see a potential world of Mac and TSP? Not super pushing it since it's unlikely but can we consider it?

Tutuu has now voted on and killed 2 town. She will say she was sheeping the votes on day 2 but it's a little convenient. Don't think they are ever dying in the next night phase.

Nothing else super constructive re game or finding scum/town.

Mac/TSP world means they both agreed to bus 112 super early and that they're still bussing, unlikely

tutuu has a good point. How do you know Alison is town?

Decided early on in the game that game is easier if I just assume Alison is town. If we had 2 wagons on 2 mafia and assume mafia may or may not have been bussing, this game is super hard.

Amy and Alison just read town to me.

Also where in my post did I say Alison is town?

[protocultures]

aaaaaaah is this a slip is this a slip???
Why was proto towncored in the first place?

I assume because I vote 112 to save Alison?

[Carotenoid]

Awww the more I think about this game the more it feels solvable. Like, mind-map solvable. I have a doctor appointment in the afternoon, I'll get on it after!

[tutuu]

Also where in my post did I say Alison is town?

"tutuu has now voted on and killed 2 town"

[protocultures]

Also where in my post did I say Alison is town?

"tutuu has now voted on and killed 2 town"

Ooooh so you think that's a slip.

Makes sense now.

I'm living in the world where Alison is town because otherwise game is too hard.

[Carotenoid]

Can anyone see a potential world of Mac and TSP? Not super pushing it since it's unlikely but can we consider it?

Tutuu has now voted on and killed 2 town. She will say she was sheeping the votes on day 2 but it's a little convenient. Don't think they are ever dying in the next night phase.

Nothing else super constructive re game or finding scum/town.

Mac/TSP world means they both agreed to bus 112 super early and that they're still bussing, unlikely

tutuu has a good point. How do you know Alison is town?

Decided early on in the game that game is easier if I just assume Alison is town. If we had 2 wagons on 2 mafia and assume mafia may or may not have been bussing, this game is super hard.

Amy and Alison just read town to me.

Also where in my post did I say Alison is town?

You assumed Alison is town but you never really read her town!
You said tutuu has voted two towns, implying Alison is town.

aaaaaaah is this a slip is this a slip???
Why was proto towncored in the first place?

I assume because I vote 112 to save Alison?

The huge caveat is: is Alison really town? From her PoV it makes sense to towncore you I guess, for the rest you got cleared way to quickly for ??? reason.

[protocultures]

[mention]Carotenoid[/mention]

I don't need to super work out your alignment yet. You can chill in the middle ground for a bit. There are scummier people than you who exist today.

[Carotenoid]

@Carotenoid

I don't need to super work out your alignment yet. You can chill in the middle ground for a bit. There are scummier people than you who exist today.

Who are these scummier people? Who are your confident town reads?

[protocultures]

Amy and Alison - town

Wiley/turnip - mafia maybe

[tutuu]

Also where in my post did I say Alison is town?

"tutuu has now voted on and killed 2 town"

Ooooh so you think that's a slip.

Makes sense now.

I'm living in the world where Alison is town because otherwise game is too hard.

i didnt say its a slip

[Carotenoid]

Amy and Alison - town

Wiley/turnip - mafia maybe

loltownreading the night kill

I thought "(scummier) people" was the plural form of "person"

[TonyStarkPrime]

Can anyone see a potential world of Mac and TSP? Not super pushing it since it's unlikely but can we consider it?

Tutuu has now voted on and killed 2 town. She will say she was sheeping the votes on day 2 but it's a little convenient. Don't think they are ever dying in the next night phase.

Nothing else super constructive re game or finding scum/town.

Mac/TSP world means they both agreed to bus 112 super early and that they're still bussing, unlikely

tutuu has a good point. How do you know Alison is town?

Re: your first graf — does it? Mac didn’t vote for 112 until right before EOD, which sure fine, wolf killed, but we’ve all seen wolves coast to victory doing that exact thing.

graf?
They both opened pretty aggressively against 112 and they're thunderdomingish each other. I don't think TSP/Mac team thinks their best shot is to bus this aggressively

Alternatively, if anyone would do it...

[TonyStarkPrime]

Amy and Alison - town

Wiley/turnip - mafia maybe

good town slip

[tutuu]

i think i wanna vote 10k -> nanook -> TSP -> alison (but would depend very much on the night kils)

[protocultures]

i think i wanna vote 10k -> nanook -> TSP -> alison (but would depend very much on the night kils)

Why are you locking me town?

[protocultures]

Also, I see Amy died now.

Def paying attention to this game....

[protocultures]

just looked at remaining players on page 1.

Is it bad I want to policy 10k here? Rather do it now than have regret in f5 or something like that.

[tutuu]

i think i wanna vote 10k -> nanook -> TSP -> alison (but would depend very much on the night kils)

Why are you locking me town?

i am not locking you town. i am trusting alison's townread on you. if she happens to be scum then i'd consider you scum in f3, depending on how night kills go

[tutuu]

Also, I see Amy died now.

Def paying attention to this game....

ok u can be lock town

also i agree, id rather get rid of 10k sooner rather than later. other people are at least posting

[TonyStarkPrime]

I am anti-10k policy chop for the reason that I think 10k is town. I have no clue who 10k is and I know nothing about them and so I might be vastly misapproaching this read

[tutuu]

isnt it someone from flow

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

[VOTE: TSP] aubergine

Still sheeping broseph


Kinda want to kill 10k too tbh

[ColinIsCool]

10K makes a fine policy lynch today. No way to say they’re town imo

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

It’s less policy and more that there’s a bunch of probably town players

[ColinIsCool]

I would say both.

[MacDougall]

gotta say Proto is starting to look mighty poo to me

[protocultures]

If I'm a poo, I'm a mighty fine poo my good sir.

[protocultures]

gotta say Proto is starting to look mighty poo to me

I also find this post incredibly towny

[TonyStarkPrime]

gotta say Proto is starting to look mighty poo to me

I also find this post incredibly towny

why

[MacDougall]

@1612 / @tedxtr - Just town for me. Have found their content totally fine.
@Alison - Can be mafia. Her content has dropped off. There were things that happened around day 1 (ie. no activity at EOD) that sometimes indicate a w/w wagon pairing. Totally capable of wolfing to this level I have first hand evidence of such.
@Carotenoid - Pretty sure she is just town, spewed by 112.
@ColinIsCool - Still just think he's town but tinfoil is starting to appear on day 3. We probably lose to Colin wolf unless we get a partner first anyway and nab him at f3 or something.
@NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME - Town fmpov. Too much pro Mac material lol. The way that he lamented the potential of me pocketing specifically him just to troll him was very town and I don't think mafia manufacture that shit.
@protocultures - I think there is a definite possibility that Proto/Alison/112 is the team. If Proto doesn't have that 112 vote from day 1 I think he's probably flipped today by most.
@TenThousandCalories - Probably town for just being like completely ambivalent to how they are perceived.
@TonyStarkPrime - I'm probably wrong with my TSP read. It profiles as one of my non gut more brain wrong dumb shit cases that backfire. His "Joe calm down" post was really town and hit me in the face like a bucket of cold water.
@Turnip Head - Post history / @DrWilgy - Can be mafia, but only in like world building ways, his play hasn't really been bad at all. Still want to town read him for shielding me.
@tutuu - Just defer to the Amy read here I guess.

For me it's like

Alison/Proto
>
TSP/Wilgy
>
>
>
>
Colin + who the fuck knows maybe Carot or something I dunno.

and as this day has progressed I'm leaning more towards the top.

Separating worlds I think the best flip today is probably TSP or Alison still though.

[TonyStarkPrime]

@Carotenoid - Pretty sure she is just town, spewed by 112.

can you explain this?

[TonyStarkPrime]

Carote can be town too

cause to my eye this is the only post by which you can make that read

[TonyStarkPrime]

it's day 3 it's carrot chopping time

[Alison]

Anybody know if Alison is the type of player that would make this post to a scummate so early on?

Town
tutuu
Amy
Urist
Mac

I hate this post.

It's not out of her scumrange

thanks

[Alison]

i would never consider town alison getting pocketed by wolf proto. she just cant. she owns his soul imo.

pre-agreed bus is definitely something alison would do @ colin. not to say that she is scum for lynching a wolf, or that i am scumreading her atm, but im saying how it is. she has even said it herself this game "why would u consider me not being w/w with 112 tutuu" if u go iso her posts and control + f that. outside of the game she has mentioned that her scum game relies on bussing and focusing on reaching the conclusion that someone is scum rather than naturally getting around to making the read

???

When did I ever say this?

Also I'm semi-considering subbing out because I have been abruptly and unexpectedly buried under work which is why you notice a sharp drop in my activity recently. To be clear this should be treated as NAI - I'll sub out as either alignment if I think I'm too busy to play properly, and if I'm not busy I'll play as hard as I can regardless of the gamestate.

[Alison]

i think i wanna vote 10k -> nanook -> TSP -> alison (but would depend very much on the night kils)

This makes no sense, wtf?