Radiohead Mafia [GAME OVER]

[TonyStarkPrime]

Here's what's going to happen, jpic gets voted tomorrow (if vigi isn't shooting him right now) and he flips mafia rolecop but not a postcapper. so that leaves us with Nanook to get killed next because he must be the postcapper, he flips town and a spotter like he says he is. This is the part when we all start to suspect Mac, our glorious town leader. "omg he must be lying about being postcapped, why would he do that? This cannot be, maybe he was scum all along, hang on a second...... Hally, they set this whole thing up. What a brilliant mastermind, hellbussing so many teammates like that but there's one thing they didn't count on and thar is us townies being super smart and figuring it out. Let's vote Hally" then Hally flips town and that leaves us with Mac, the evil mastermind, the core of cores left as the only possibility. Lying about being postcapped, we all believed it. (there will be a lot of dead townies by this stage of the story) things are rough now, tensions are high there's no way we can ignore this evidence and we vote up MacDougall. He flips town

It was timsup2nothing all along, he was the rogue. Undetectable by watchers, gaining power from stealng posts, his fakeclaim complete and now there is nobody left to stop him because there was always someone that had to be voted instead of him, always a townie that had to be NK'd instead of him and now it's too late, he has stolen enough power to win the game. GG

if this happens I'll eat both my hat and this bowl of cereal

[TonyStarkPrime]

though tbf I'm eating the bowl of cereal anyways

[tedxtr]

Here's what's going to happen, jpic gets voted tomorrow (if vigi isn't shooting him right now) and he flips mafia rolecop but not a postcapper. so that leaves us with Nanook to get killed next because he must be the postcapper, he flips town and a spotter like he says he is. This is the part when we all start to suspect Mac, our glorious town leader. "omg he must be lying about being postcapped, why would he do that? This cannot be, maybe he was scum all along, hang on a second...... Hally, they set this whole thing up. What a brilliant mastermind, hellbussing so many teammates like that but there's one thing they didn't count on and thar is us townies being super smart and figuring it out. Let's vote Hally" then Hally flips town and that leaves us with Mac, the evil mastermind, the core of cores left as the only possibility. Lying about being postcapped, we all believed it. (there will be a lot of dead townies by this stage of the story) things are rough now, tensions are high there's no way we can ignore this evidence and we vote up MacDougall. He flips town

It was timsup2nothing all along, he was the rogue. Undetectable by watchers, gaining power from stealng posts, his fakeclaim complete and now there is nobody left to stop him because there was always someone that had to be voted instead of him, always a townie that had to be NK'd instead of him and now it's too late, he has stolen enough power to win the game. GG

I haven’t read past here’s what’s going to happen but I assume this is good copypasta material nonetheless

[Hally]

The title Rogue in particular makes me thinks of stealth and thievery

It's interesting, I looked up Rogue on MU and the definition of the role is:

The Rogue may target another player every night and copy their night action, allowing the Rogue to use it the next night.

which is a stealth/thievery kind of thing. It just really doesn't make sense to me though in a game where we already have a role that can copy the abilities of the dead (MRs claimed role) but maybe I'm thinking about that wrong.

i don’t think sloonei is referring to that role in particular

[juliets]

The title Rogue in particular makes me thinks of stealth and thievery

It's interesting, I looked up Rogue on MU and the definition of the role is:

The Rogue may target another player every night and copy their night action, allowing the Rogue to use it the next night.

which is a stealth/thievery kind of thing. It just really doesn't make sense to me though in a game where we already have a role that can copy the abilities of the dead (MRs claimed role) but maybe I'm thinking about that wrong.

i don’t think sloonei is referring to that role in particular

Yeah that's my inclination but I thought I'd bring it up in case it made some sense to someone else.

[tedxtr]

Or maybe MR is the rogue

[juliets]

I saved all my housework for today thinking we would not be posting so I will be in and out.

[tutuu]

[mention]DrWilgy[/mention] ur mafia dude

[Long Con]

Oddmerta's reality is awesome.

Jules, I don't know if Sloonei would stick to the strict definition when using Rogue, or if he would just mean third party generally.

[juliets]

Oddmerta's reality is awesome.

Jules, I don't know if Sloonei would stick to the strict definition when using Rogue, or if he would just mean third party generally.

after seeing what the definition said and considering MR's claim, I think he's probably just using it to mean 3P generally yeah. I just wanted to make no one saw something I didn't (which, lets face it, happens all the time with me in mafia lol),

[Hally]

my brilliant powers of deduction have led me to conclude the rogue is someone in this game

[Sloonei]

Hi. I was hoping to end Night 2 at 9 PM EDT but I just got called into work yet again, so expect the deadline to be closer to 9:30 now. My apologies for this.

[juliets]

So let's assume JPIC is mafia. His first inclination when pushed to produce content was to push against Juliets. Nutella pushed against Juliets. If JPIC flips mafia it strongly suggests the mafia genuinely think Juliets is the 3p.

I don't remember JPIC pushing against me so I went through his ISO to find it. I didn't find anything though. Mac, what are you referring to here? [mention]Justplayingitcool[/mention] do you know what he is talking about?

[Timsup2nothin]

Here's what's going to happen, jpic gets voted tomorrow (if vigi isn't shooting him right now) and he flips mafia rolecop but not a postcapper. so that leaves us with Nanook to get killed next because he must be the postcapper, he flips town and a spotter like he says he is. This is the part when we all start to suspect Mac, our glorious town leader. "omg he must be lying about being postcapped, why would he do that? This cannot be, maybe he was scum all along, hang on a second...... Hally, they set this whole thing up. What a brilliant mastermind, hellbussing so many teammates like that but there's one thing they didn't count on and thar is us townies being super smart and figuring it out. Let's vote Hally" then Hally flips town and that leaves us with Mac, the evil mastermind, the core of cores left as the only possibility. Lying about being postcapped, we all believed it. (there will be a lot of dead townies by this stage of the story) things are rough now, tensions are high there's no way we can ignore this evidence and we vote up MacDougall. He flips town

It was timsup2nothing all along, he was the rogue. Undetectable by watchers, gaining power from stealng posts, his fakeclaim complete and now there is nobody left to stop him because there was always someone that had to be voted instead of him, always a townie that had to be NK'd instead of him and now it's too late, he has stolen enough power to win the game. GG

I haven’t read past here’s what’s going to happen but I assume this is good copypasta material nonetheless

I'm keeping it for future use, yeah.

[dyachei]

i didn't realize we'd have the thread open and I was at work when i happened to reload my syndicate page

I'm still at work, basically skimmed the thread to get here

I might just be a sucker but I kind of like jpic rn

still think tim is towny

if you had a choice between confirming someone like jpic or looking at someone new, what would you do?

[Dyslexicon]

What's going on in this game?

[dyachei]

oh hey dizzy how's it going?

[Timsup2nothin]

[mention]Justplayingitcool[/mention] I have a problem.

I asked you for one name that was NOT the 3P.

I got sort of a bonus in the "well these town cores are pretty obv town so not them probably" form. But I wasn't looking for probablies.

I gave a name. Hally. Hally is confirmed watcher. Watcher is not 3P so Hally is just NOT 3P.

Maybe someone else would say "this isn't fair, you took the only one that is really that certain." They could make me feel bad about jacking them up.

But you couldn't have made me feel bad. You're the alignment cop. You already checked Mac. You should be certain.

Why you didn't say Mac is not the 3P JPIC?

[dyachei]

i guess everyone else left when I got here

[Dyslexicon]

oh hey dizzy how's it going?

Good, I think. I finished my other game. Still won't be able to catch up and stuff here. Consider myself on a break until champs, so I guess I have an actual slank meta now. You got two mafia. =p

Who's next, and is there anyone who needs "looking into"? I have absolutely no idea what's going on here other than Nutella and Sprit being yeeted.

[Timsup2nothin]

What's going on in this game?

We gonna have to chop you to prove you aren't 3P.

There's some other stuff, but that's probably most relevant.

Killed a couple woofs already, so that's good.

[Timsup2nothin]

i guess everyone else left when I got here

I just got up!

[dyachei]

oh hey dizzy how's it going?

Good, I think. I finished my other game. Still won't be able to catch up and stuff here. Consider myself on a break until champs, so I guess I have an actual slank meta now. You got two mafia. =p

Who's next, and is there anyone who needs "looking into"? I have absolutely no idea what's going on here other than Nutella and Sprit being yeeted.

we know that someone postcapped mac. spirit (mafia) didn't have that role function. nanook and jpic were also seen visiting mac. It's possibly one of their actions and tinfoil me is worried that maybe there was a 4th ninja option but we should deal with nanook and jpic first.

[dyachei]

i didn't realize we'd have the thread open and I was at work when i happened to reload my syndicate page

I'm still at work, basically skimmed the thread to get here

I might just be a sucker but I kind of like jpic rn

still think tim is towny

if you had a choice between confirming someone like jpic or looking at someone new, what would you do?

[mention]Timsup2nothin[/mention]

[Dyslexicon]

What's going on in this game?

We gonna have to chop you to prove you aren't 3P.

There's some other stuff, but that's probably most relevant.

Killed a couple woofs already, so that's good.

Lol ok.

Would prefer other stuff.

[Dyslexicon]

we know that someone postcapped mac. spirit (mafia) didn't have that role function. nanook and jpic were also seen visiting mac. It's possibly one of their actions and tinfoil me is worried that maybe there was a 4th ninja option but we should deal with nanook and jpic first.

Aight, that seems reasonable. Is Hally watcher and targeted Mac?
Is Tim in the clear or not? Asking for a friend.

[Timsup2nothin]

oh hey dizzy how's it going?

Good, I think. I finished my other game. Still won't be able to catch up and stuff here. Consider myself on a break until champs, so I guess I have an actual slank meta now. You got two mafia. =p

Who's next, and is there anyone who needs "looking into"? I have absolutely no idea what's going on here other than Nutella and Sprit being yeeted.

we know that someone postcapped mac. spirit (mafia) didn't have that role function. nanook and jpic were also seen visiting mac. It's possibly one of their actions and tinfoil me is worried that maybe there was a 4th ninja option but we should deal with nanook and jpic first.

Tinfoil me is worried that Hally did it. I cannot make any sense of that at all, and Hally is just town...but that's what makes it tinfoil, right?

[Justplayingitcool]

@Justplayingitcool I have a problem.

I asked you for one name that was NOT the 3P.

I got sort of a bonus in the "well these town cores are pretty obv town so not them probably" form. But I wasn't looking for probablies.

I gave a name. Hally. Hally is confirmed watcher. Watcher is not 3P so Hally is just NOT 3P.

Maybe someone else would say "this isn't fair, you took the only one that is really that certain." They could make me feel bad about jacking them up.

But you couldn't have made me feel bad. You're the alignment cop. You already checked Mac. You should be certain.

Why you didn't say Mac is not the 3P JPIC?

Because I didn't understand the relevance of your question and I feel pretty certain on all three lol

[dyachei]

hally hasn't outright claimed it but it's heavily implied and the target was mac.

tim is...he played really villagery yesterday so I tend to think he's v, but nothing other than that rn

[dyachei]

oh hey dizzy how's it going?

Good, I think. I finished my other game. Still won't be able to catch up and stuff here. Consider myself on a break until champs, so I guess I have an actual slank meta now. You got two mafia. =p

Who's next, and is there anyone who needs "looking into"? I have absolutely no idea what's going on here other than Nutella and Sprit being yeeted.

we know that someone postcapped mac. spirit (mafia) didn't have that role function. nanook and jpic were also seen visiting mac. It's possibly one of their actions and tinfoil me is worried that maybe there was a 4th ninja option but we should deal with nanook and jpic first.

Tinfoil me is worried that Hally did it. I cannot make any sense of that at all, and Hally is just town...but that's what makes it tinfoil, right?

then why claim anything?

[Dyslexicon]

Somebody should postcap everyone tbh tbh

[Timsup2nothin]

@Justplayingitcool I have a problem.

I asked you for one name that was NOT the 3P.

I got sort of a bonus in the "well these town cores are pretty obv town so not them probably" form. But I wasn't looking for probablies.

I gave a name. Hally. Hally is confirmed watcher. Watcher is not 3P so Hally is just NOT 3P.

Maybe someone else would say "this isn't fair, you took the only one that is really that certain." They could make me feel bad about jacking them up.

But you couldn't have made me feel bad. You're the alignment cop. You already checked Mac. You should be certain.

Why you didn't say Mac is not the 3P JPIC?

Because I didn't understand the relevance of your question and I feel pretty certain on all three lol

You do feel more certain on Mac, right?

[Justplayingitcool]

So let's assume JPIC is mafia. His first inclination when pushed to produce content was to push against Juliets. Nutella pushed against Juliets. If JPIC flips mafia it strongly suggests the mafia genuinely think Juliets is the 3p.

I don't remember JPIC pushing against me so I went through his ISO to find it. I didn't find anything though. Mac, what are you referring to here? @Justplayingitcool do you know what he is talking about?

Wasn't really pushing, I was just trying to determine if the thing about sprit earlier had any real relevance. You're probably spewed clear as mafia from Nutella, but there's a chance of 3p. Though, I probably wouldn't go in that direction anyway

[dyachei]

tim don't ignore my ping pls

[Dyslexicon]

hally hasn't outright claimed it but it's heavily implied and the target was mac.

tim is...he played really villagery yesterday so I tend to think he's v, but nothing other than that rn

Alright, thanks. I'll try to use my limited ways of being helpful while I'm still around. I guess as Tim says at this rate I'll be a yeet at some point because "we just have to do it" or something.

[dyachei]

you're basically either in the poe or just outside of the poe for most people, dizzy

[juliets]

So let's assume JPIC is mafia. His first inclination when pushed to produce content was to push against Juliets. Nutella pushed against Juliets. If JPIC flips mafia it strongly suggests the mafia genuinely think Juliets is the 3p.

I don't remember JPIC pushing against me so I went through his ISO to find it. I didn't find anything though. Mac, what are you referring to here? @Justplayingitcool do you know what he is talking about?

Wasn't really pushing, I was just trying to determine if the thing about sprit earlier had any real relevance. You're probably spewed clear as mafia from Nutella, but there's a chance of 3p. Though, I probably wouldn't go in that direction anyway

Yeah JPIC I didn't interpret you as pushing me at all so I'm not sure what Mac is talking about. He'll answer when he gets here I guess.

[mention]dyachei[/mention] I am thinking about your question. It is hard. (I guess that's why you asked for opinions.)

[Dyslexicon]

you're basically either in the poe or just outside of the poe for most people, dizzy

I'm basically just outside of the game. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Sorry. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[Justplayingitcool]

@Justplayingitcool I have a problem.

I asked you for one name that was NOT the 3P.

I got sort of a bonus in the "well these town cores are pretty obv town so not them probably" form. But I wasn't looking for probablies.

I gave a name. Hally. Hally is confirmed watcher. Watcher is not 3P so Hally is just NOT 3P.

Maybe someone else would say "this isn't fair, you took the only one that is really that certain." They could make me feel bad about jacking them up.

But you couldn't have made me feel bad. You're the alignment cop. You already checked Mac. You should be certain.

Why you didn't say Mac is not the 3P JPIC?

Because I didn't understand the relevance of your question and I feel pretty certain on all three lol

You do feel more certain on Mac, right?

Not really, as I would say hally and mac are probably on equal footing despite my cop result on Mac, as I don't think a watcher fits a rogue type character

[Timsup2nothin]

oh hey dizzy how's it going?

Good, I think. I finished my other game. Still won't be able to catch up and stuff here. Consider myself on a break until champs, so I guess I have an actual slank meta now. You got two mafia. =p

Who's next, and is there anyone who needs "looking into"? I have absolutely no idea what's going on here other than Nutella and Sprit being yeeted.

we know that someone postcapped mac. spirit (mafia) didn't have that role function. nanook and jpic were also seen visiting mac. It's possibly one of their actions and tinfoil me is worried that maybe there was a 4th ninja option but we should deal with nanook and jpic first.

Tinfoil me is worried that Hally did it. I cannot make any sense of that at all, and Hally is just town...but that's what makes it tinfoil, right?

then why claim anything?

This particular tinfoil started when, right before I logged out for the night I said "Hally is the one person I KNOW is not the 3P because 3P Watcher makes no sense." So of course then I tossed and turned not sleeping over "what if Hally is a 3P watcher who postcapped Mac and gets us to kill all these potential postcappers?"

I'm gonna stick with 3P watcher doesn't make sense, but this is my life.

[dyachei]

3p watcher doesn't make sense, tim. hally is very much in their village meta

[Oddmerta]

The prophecy is coming true in real time

[dyachei]

The prophecy is coming true in real time

which prophecy is that?

[Oddmerta]

The prophecy is coming true in real time

which prophecy is that?

The one I wrote just before, timsup is already planting seeds of doubt about Hally being a 3p

[juliets]

[mention]dyachei[/mention] I guess I'm somewhat afraid confirming JPIC is a waste because if he doesn't die tonight he'll die tomorrow or the next night. So I think I would choose to confirm someone new.

[Timsup2nothin]

i didn't realize we'd have the thread open and I was at work when i happened to reload my syndicate page

I'm still at work, basically skimmed the thread to get here

I might just be a sucker but I kind of like jpic rn

still think tim is towny

if you had a choice between confirming someone like jpic or looking at someone new, what would you do?

@Timsup2nothin

I think the only person like JPIC is JPIC, and "confirm" is sort of nebulous regarding JPIC. If I could get a rock solid "JPIC is town, deal with that" result then I would know he was really an alignment cop, had a real green check on Mac, and was not the post cap stealer. That would be great.

If I could get "JPIC is absolutely an alignment cop" that would be a little less great, because in some paranoid corner of my mind a voice would say "the wolves have an alignment cop so they can look for the 3P." These paranoid voices are stupidly unlimited in the things they say.

In any event, if I had to kill him to confirm him I would feel bad because if I confirmed him I would also cut off whatever results he is about to get.

If confirming involved killing I would look in the really unknown range. People who haven't claimed anything, have a vague "maybe town, definitely POE, dunno and not ever likely to know" feel about them. Dizzy is one example but there are a few others who genuinely don't come to mind. Like you look at the player list and say "hmmm."

With a non-fatal method of confirming I would go in the pretty solid not wolf, but could be 3P range. Oddmerta, me, Juliet, you, Poison...that sort. I don't really want to kill active people just to see if they are 3P, but we may have to eventually in some cases.

[dyachei]

@dyachei I guess I'm somewhat afraid confirming JPIC is a waste because if he doesn't die tonight he'll die tomorrow or the next night. So I think I would choose to confirm someone new.

what if it could stop him from being killed at all? or do you think there's no point atp

[Timsup2nothin]

The prophecy is coming true in real time

which prophecy is that?

I saved it for future use:

Here's what's going to happen, jpic gets voted tomorrow (if vigi isn't shooting him right now) and he flips mafia rolecop but not a postcapper. so that leaves us with Nanook to get killed next because he must be the postcapper, he flips town and a spotter like he says he is. This is the part when we all start to suspect Mac, our glorious town leader. "omg he must be lying about being postcapped, why would he do that? This cannot be, maybe he was scum all along, hang on a second...... Hally, they set this whole thing up. What a brilliant mastermind, hellbussing so many teammates like that but there's one thing they didn't count on and thar is us townies being super smart and figuring it out. Let's vote Hally" then Hally flips town and that leaves us with Mac, the evil mastermind, the core of cores left as the only possibility. Lying about being postcapped, we all believed it. (there will be a lot of dead townies by this stage of the story) things are rough now, tensions are high there's no way we can ignore this evidence and we vote up MacDougall. He flips town

It was timsup2nothing all along, he was the rogue. Undetectable by watchers, gaining power from stealng posts, his fakeclaim complete and now there is nobody left to stop him because there was always someone that had to be voted instead of him, always a townie that had to be NK'd instead of him and now it's too late, he has stolen enough power to win the game. GG

[Oddmerta]

We have 20 players...

Who is NOT the third party?

Gimme ONE name...

I'll start...Hally. 3P watcher is just out.

my brilliant powers of deduction have led me to conclude the rogue is someone in this game

@Justplayingitcool I have a problem.

I asked you for one name that was NOT the 3P.

I got sort of a bonus in the "well these town cores are pretty obv town so not them probably" form. But I wasn't looking for probablies.

I gave a name. Hally. Hally is confirmed watcher. Watcher is not 3P so Hally is just NOT 3P.

Maybe someone else would say "this isn't fair, you took the only one that is really that certain." They could make me feel bad about jacking them up.

But you couldn't have made me feel bad. You're the alignment cop. You already checked Mac. You should be certain.

Why you didn't say Mac is not the 3P JPIC?

oh hey dizzy how's it going?

Good, I think. I finished my other game. Still won't be able to catch up and stuff here. Consider myself on a break until champs, so I guess I have an actual slank meta now. You got two mafia. =p

Who's next, and is there anyone who needs "looking into"? I have absolutely no idea what's going on here other than Nutella and Sprit being yeeted.

we know that someone postcapped mac. spirit (mafia) didn't have that role function. nanook and jpic were also seen visiting mac. It's possibly one of their actions and tinfoil me is worried that maybe there was a 4th ninja option but we should deal with nanook and jpic first.

oh hey dizzy how's it going?

Good, I think. I finished my other game. Still won't be able to catch up and stuff here. Consider myself on a break until champs, so I guess I have an actual slank meta now. You got two mafia. =p

Who's next, and is there anyone who needs "looking into"? I have absolutely no idea what's going on here other than Nutella and Sprit being yeeted.

we know that someone postcapped mac. spirit (mafia) didn't have that role function. nanook and jpic were also seen visiting mac. It's possibly one of their actions and tinfoil me is worried that maybe there was a 4th ninja option but we should deal with nanook and jpic first.

Tinfoil me is worried that Hally did it. I cannot make any sense of that at all, and Hally is just town...but that's what makes it tinfoil, right?

oh hey dizzy how's it going?

Good, I think. I finished my other game. Still won't be able to catch up and stuff here. Consider myself on a break until champs, so I guess I have an actual slank meta now. You got two mafia. =p

Who's next, and is there anyone who needs "looking into"? I have absolutely no idea what's going on here other than Nutella and Sprit being yeeted.

we know that someone postcapped mac. spirit (mafia) didn't have that role function. nanook and jpic were also seen visiting mac. It's possibly one of their actions and tinfoil me is worried that maybe there was a 4th ninja option but we should deal with nanook and jpic first.

Tinfoil me is worried that Hally did it. I cannot make any sense of that at all, and Hally is just town...but that's what makes it tinfoil, right?

then why claim anything?

This particular tinfoil started when, right before I logged out for the night I said "Hally is the one person I KNOW is not the 3P because 3P Watcher makes no sense." So of course then I tossed and turned not sleeping over "what if Hally is a 3P watcher who postcapped Mac and gets us to kill all these potential postcappers?"

I'm gonna stick with 3P watcher doesn't make sense, but this is my life.

[Timsup2nothin]

@dyachei I guess I'm somewhat afraid confirming JPIC is a waste because if he doesn't die tonight he'll die tomorrow or the next night. So I think I would choose to confirm someone new.

what if it could stop him from being killed at all? or do you think there's no point atp

If he gets confirmed as alignment cop the wolves are gonna kill him the first chance they get I think.