Radiohead Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Long Con]

Damn fine work!

[juliets]

OMG he was Mafia! [mention]dyachei[/mention] gg, [mention]Logic[/mention] gg! I was so wrong about them! The rest of you rock!

[juliets]

Did they not use their kills? Or did the mafia miss kills? Very odd.

[Dyslexicon]

I'm so tooting my own horn here. Fuck yeah!

I'm not actually bad at mafia.

I have godly reads and Dya and Samu are scum.

Thank me later.

Meh, no. I just know she also has a tracker claim. Town could have two trackers I guess, I think hers is also conditional. Of the few posts I've read this game I remember Dya and Samu asking me if it was "normal" for me to tunnel Nut when I made a joke about it, and that pinged me a bit after Nut flipped mafia. But that's like super minor, and only reason I'm bringing it up is probably because it's the only thing I have that's not claim related.

Why is it that everytime I ever express something as a blatant statement like that (which basically happens like once in a game) I'm so often correct? But I say it with like a jokey tone and I don't explain it before later and then nobody cares including me lol. The exact same thing happened in semis in champs. =p

Beware the Dizzy prophecies as they shall come to pass!

Ok. Done tooting my horn now, but that was satisfying.

[MacDougall]

Come on people that was all me lol

[juliets]

[mention]Long Con[/mention] I will look at others too now that we're down to just the Rogue. As I said, I don't want to tunnel you.

[juliets]

I'm so tooting my own horn here. Fuck yeah!

I'm not actually bad at mafia.

I have godly reads and Dya and Samu are scum.

Thank me later.

Meh, no. I just know she also has a tracker claim. Town could have two trackers I guess, I think hers is also conditional. Of the few posts I've read this game I remember Dya and Samu asking me if it was "normal" for me to tunnel Nut when I made a joke about it, and that pinged me a bit after Nut flipped mafia. But that's like super minor, and only reason I'm bringing it up is probably because it's the only thing I have that's not claim related.

Why is it that everytime I ever express something as a blatant statement like that (which basically happens like once in a game) I'm so often correct? But I say it with like a jokey tone and I don't explain it before later and then nobody cares including me lol. The exact same thing happened in semis in champs. =p

Beware the Dizzy prophecies as they shall come to pass!

Ok. Done tooting my horn now, but that was satisfying.

Congrats Dizzy lol!

[juliets]

Ok goodnight and congrats all around!

[MacDougall]

Ok we got 8 v 1 mountainous now kids.

[MacDougall]

Okay the rogue is 100% not Nook, Ted or Dizzy.

SPF/PC
Long Con
Juliets/Oddmerta

Rogue will probably inherit the kill here. Hopefully just a factional and we didn't just activate a worse killer.

I'm a bit worried all the magpie visitors might die tonight. If we do just yeet SPF and win.

[MacDougall]

First cab off the ranks is executing Mr. Magpie imo. I wanna see wtf that shit be doin.

[Long Con]

Beware the prophecies of Dizzy.

[Long Con]

First cab off the ranks is executing Mr. Magpie imo. I wanna see wtf that shit be doin.

Magpie definitely is Rogue flavoured.

It may also be some sort of recruitment, in which case it's pretty scary.

[Long Con]

And obviously Joseph and I are still not within the ranks of the magpie, but if it is a recruitment, I'd like to volunteer tonight!

[Dyslexicon]

Come on people that was all me lol

Of course <3

I'm not doing much with them, but it's just I very often have these prophecies. =p

So next time I say something declarative out of the blue like that, just sheep it lol. (Now it won't work)

[Dyslexicon]

I have literally no clue what you are all talking about re Magpie lol.

If this is going to become important and I'm going to see my first Day 8 (fuck) of a mafia game, can someone please please please @ me with an explanation of what this is?

Sorry for being a wet noodle this game. Thank you all for carrying.

[staypositivefriend]

so, how the hell do we hunt for 3p?

the strongest argument i can provide in favor of me not being 3p is the fact that i have townsided INCREDIBLY hard. i hardpushed on nearly all of the mafia, and in my position as a 3p, i would want to have the mafia around for quite a long time so that i don't get steamrolled when they all get eliminated. i would NEVER participate in a steamrolling of the mafia team like i did as 3p if my sole motivation was self-preservation. i would stoke paranoia and tear people apart

you can not read my game w/a straight face and tell me you believe that i had a 3p strategy in mind

[Dyslexicon]

Being 3p =/= having a 3p strategy in mind.

Or maybe that's just me. =p

[staypositivefriend]

Being 3p =/= having a 3p strategy in mind.

Or maybe that's just me. =p

well the 3p strategy is to self-preserve, right? 3p generally wants to survive until endgame. i, spf, do not survive until endgame by eliminating the mafia team incredibly fast

[Long Con]

Being 3p =/= having a 3p strategy in mind.

Or maybe that's just me. =p

well the 3p strategy is to self-preserve, right? 3p generally wants to survive until endgame. i, spf, do not survive until endgame by eliminating the mafia team incredibly fast

Yeah, but you wouldn't know if you were right or wrong about any given mafia member. And you would want to actually try to find scum because you need to appear townish to the townsfolk.

[staypositivefriend]

Being 3p =/= having a 3p strategy in mind.

Or maybe that's just me. =p

well the 3p strategy is to self-preserve, right? 3p generally wants to survive until endgame. i, spf, do not survive until endgame by eliminating the mafia team incredibly fast

Yeah, but you wouldn't know if you were right or wrong about any given mafia member. And you would want to actually try to find scum because you need to appear townish to the townsfolk.

true, but since the majority of the scumreads i outed in this game were mafia, you know for a fact that i gave you my real reads, and pushed on them. if my strategy was to self-preserve, then i would absolutely obfuscate my reads and pressure people that i didnt actually suspect

[Long Con]

Being 3p =/= having a 3p strategy in mind.

Or maybe that's just me. =p

well the 3p strategy is to self-preserve, right? 3p generally wants to survive until endgame. i, spf, do not survive until endgame by eliminating the mafia team incredibly fast

Yeah, but you wouldn't know if you were right or wrong about any given mafia member. And you would want to actually try to find scum because you need to appear townish to the townsfolk.

true, but since the majority of the scumreads i outed in this game were mafia, you know for a fact that i gave you my real reads, and pushed on them. if my strategy was to self-preserve, then i would absolutely obfuscate my reads and pressure people that i didnt actually suspect

So you say.

[staypositivefriend]

Being 3p =/= having a 3p strategy in mind.

Or maybe that's just me. =p

well the 3p strategy is to self-preserve, right? 3p generally wants to survive until endgame. i, spf, do not survive until endgame by eliminating the mafia team incredibly fast

Yeah, but you wouldn't know if you were right or wrong about any given mafia member. And you would want to actually try to find scum because you need to appear townish to the townsfolk.

true, but since the majority of the scumreads i outed in this game were mafia, you know for a fact that i gave you my real reads, and pushed on them. if my strategy was to self-preserve, then i would absolutely obfuscate my reads and pressure people that i didnt actually suspect

So you say.

well if i have any sense of basic strategy, then yeah, i do :P

[Long Con]

Being 3p =/= having a 3p strategy in mind.

Or maybe that's just me. =p

well the 3p strategy is to self-preserve, right? 3p generally wants to survive until endgame. i, spf, do not survive until endgame by eliminating the mafia team incredibly fast

Yeah, but you wouldn't know if you were right or wrong about any given mafia member. And you would want to actually try to find scum because you need to appear townish to the townsfolk.

true, but since the majority of the scumreads i outed in this game were mafia, you know for a fact that i gave you my real reads, and pushed on them. if my strategy was to self-preserve, then i would absolutely obfuscate my reads and pressure people that i didnt actually suspect

So you say.

well if i have any sense of basic strategy, then yeah, i do :P

The idea that there is only one possible strategy that you could follow as a 3p doesn't hold any weight at all with me, sorry.

[staypositivefriend]

Being 3p =/= having a 3p strategy in mind.

Or maybe that's just me. =p

well the 3p strategy is to self-preserve, right? 3p generally wants to survive until endgame. i, spf, do not survive until endgame by eliminating the mafia team incredibly fast

Yeah, but you wouldn't know if you were right or wrong about any given mafia member. And you would want to actually try to find scum because you need to appear townish to the townsfolk.

true, but since the majority of the scumreads i outed in this game were mafia, you know for a fact that i gave you my real reads, and pushed on them. if my strategy was to self-preserve, then i would absolutely obfuscate my reads and pressure people that i didnt actually suspect

So you say.

well if i have any sense of basic strategy, then yeah, i do :P

The idea that there is only one possible strategy that you could follow as a 3p doesn't hold any weight at all with me, sorry.

there isnt only one strategy i could follow as 3p, but my point is that my strategy this game would be diametrically opposed to how a 3p strategy should be. the fact that nobody believes that i am not 3p is proof of that

[Long Con]

How about this strategy: do well against the mafia so the town likes you, but don't be the main voice in the thread; let others draw the nightkills with their many town posts and outed power roles. Just tell everyone you can't claim.

[staypositivefriend]

How about this strategy: do well against the mafia so the town likes you, but don't be the main voice in the thread; let others draw the nightkills with their many town posts and outed power roles. Just tell everyone you can't claim.

if the strategy involves playing a decent role in killing several of the mafia, which both puts you at risk at being nightkilled while eliminating the mafia pool so quickly that you become more suspicious when the mafia are gone, then that strategy doesn't work very well at all, does it?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Hell yeah

I hate 3p tbh 3p hunting is the worst

[MacDougall]

Same. We won this game and we all know it.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Hell yeah we did

So my 3p pool is like

Spf/PC

And fuck me if it’s not one of those yeah?

I guess LC maybe I haven’t read Jules’ thing there yet idk if it makes sense or not

[Oddmerta]

I thought dyachei was faking those tracker results, I guess not

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

They clearly weren’t faking the track results but trackers can be mafia too lol

[staypositivefriend]

Hell yeah we did

So my 3p pool is like

Spf/PC

And fuck me if it’s not one of those yeah?

I guess LC maybe I haven’t read Jules’ thing there yet idk if it makes sense or not

break down how that's your POE pool for me. what makes the other players not 3p?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Magpie makes some sense as 3p I think

PC’s bunch of stuff role also makes sense as a 3p role to me

I am but a simple man tbh

[staypositivefriend]

Magpie makes some sense as 3p I think

PC’s bunch of stuff role also makes sense as a 3p role to me

I am but a simple man tbh

this seems like an extremely bad way to hunt for the 3p but in fairness to you, i dont see many other feasible ways to hunt for the 3p other than identifying who was the most "out of place" in the game overall

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Magpie makes some sense as 3p I think

PC’s bunch of stuff role also makes sense as a 3p role to me

I am but a simple man tbh

this seems like an extremely bad way to hunt for the 3p but in fairness to you, i dont see many other feasible ways to hunt for the 3p other than identifying who was the most "out of place" in the game overall

I mean

Do you have a better way than “who has a role that makes sense as 3p”

Cause I don’t think I do kek

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I mean moving forward it’s basically scumhunting

But rn we’re basically in D1 with an inno child in ted, none of our other clears are meaningful AFAIK

[staypositivefriend]

Magpie makes some sense as 3p I think

PC’s bunch of stuff role also makes sense as a 3p role to me

I am but a simple man tbh

this seems like an extremely bad way to hunt for the 3p but in fairness to you, i dont see many other feasible ways to hunt for the 3p other than identifying who was the most "out of place" in the game overall

I mean

Do you have a better way than “who has a role that makes sense as 3p”

Cause I don’t think I do kek

it just seems like meaningless speculation to me, though. we know nothing about the magpie and to assume that it inherently has 3p equity is again, an assumption based off of wishful thinking. the same goes for poison's role - it makes sense if poison's role could be 3p, but i feel the same way about nearly every player here. judging 3p equity by roleclaims just feels flimsy to me

we should basically be treating like this we just entered a daystart game with one mafia who has no partners

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I disagree that it’s particularly flimsy, some role claims have considerably more 3p equity than others. I’m not going to gamble the game entirely on that but ignoring it completely seems stupid to me, YMMV

I get that you’re going to push magpie as not being 3p cause there’s a good chance you are magpie but FMPOV I think there’s a solid chance it is

[staypositivefriend]

I get that you’re going to push magpie as not being 3p cause there’s a good chance you are magpie but FMPOV I think there’s a solid chance it is

based on what? wishful thinking? the train of thought of: "i do not particularly know what a role does, so it's more likely to be 3p than not" is flimsy. i get that the options are narrow, but i'd rather base my vote on "scumhunting" instead of speculation over mechanics

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Speculation over mechanics caught three or four scum so

Meh

[staypositivefriend]

Speculation over mechanics caught three or four scum so

Meh

ehhhh i would definitely argue that we would have caught those scum solely through partner equity/scumhunting

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Idk how you can look at this game with scum getting rekt by mechanics left and right and go “the cultured view is that mech sux”

[Oddmerta]

Samusamu is mafia mvpor sure, it was really hard to suspect him from his play. He got meched

[Oddmerta]

*mvp for sure

[staypositivefriend]

Idk how you can look at this game with scum getting rekt by mechanics left and right and go “the cultured view is that mech sux”

nutella/jpic/spirit all definitely would have still died with or without mechanics

[tedxtr]

Wow, dya’s good

[tedxtr]

I need more self-appreciation

I am glad I sheeped Mac and I was right about Nanook’s argument being NAI :P

[tedxtr]

I’m yeeting Oddmerta next, probably

Unknown claims gotta go

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I don’t think we have time to get rid of all the unknowns