Bread Mafia [Game Over]

[JaggedJimmyJay]

What is the actual claim with checks clearly please and thank you

Made claimed 1-shot cop
He checked Michelle green
This may suggest the night kill was role blocked, which would be a red
Jailkeep possible

[nutella]

Oh okay so Nanook's reaction to the godfather thing makes me think Michelle is godfather and Nanook is her teammate lmfao

But we follow the green for now

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

[nutella]

Who still hasn't checked in? tutuu, grogu, alison? omega?

[Made]

Do y’all really think I put Michelle through yesterday with a green checkmark???

[nutella]

Oh omega posted

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

You always ALWAYS treat the green check as real

That’s just basic optimal play

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Who still hasn't checked in? tutuu, grogu, alison? omega?

Grogu was here briefly. Omega was here a moment ago

[nutella]

Inb4 dkkoba jailkept me and saved me from the kill but instead assumes the other thing

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Like yeah reassess at f whatever if called for, but you always start from the point of treating it as real

[nutella]

Hopefully tutuu is actually rb hahahah

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

How fucking hard is it to just say “I checked Michelle last night”

I’m covering bases dude don’t be a dick about me trying to do due diligence

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I think Nanook's behavior in response to the ~recent developments~ has been very believable.

[Made]

How fucking hard is it to just say “I checked Michelle last night”

I’m covering bases dude don’t be a dick about me trying to do due diligence

Not trying to, it’s just really odd to me to miss that. POV bias, but like still. Yesterday doesn’t make sense if she had a green check Mark. I almost hammered her and you and Alison were like
“Waitwaitwaitwsitwait wtf made”

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Anyway I think you chose a good player to check, Made. There's a good chance the Michelle rollercoaster was going to plummet back down today, and it's good to skip all that.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

In case it isn’t clear

Making you claim what night you checked Michelle is important in the edge case where you’re mafia and you were the JK or RB target last night, as it allows you to be outed without the real cop claiming

If you’re town, which you likely are, there’s literally no downside to saying what night your check was since you already claimed your check

[nutella]

[VOTE: spf] aubergine

basically a placeholder but barring major changes in info i think she's highly likely to be mafia

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

How fucking hard is it to just say “I checked Michelle last night”

I’m covering bases dude don’t be a dick about me trying to do due diligence

Not trying to, it’s just really odd to me to miss that. POV bias, but like still. Yesterday doesn’t make sense if she had a green check Mark. I almost hammered her and you and Alison were like
“Waitwaitwaitwsitwait wtf made”

I mean I assumed but there’s no downside to making it explicit

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Also I never told you not to hammer Michelle idk what you’re talking about with that

[nutella]

I actually have trouble coming up with a wolf team sooooo well fucking played

[Made]

I would probably vote made right now tbh

The towniest thing about jay is that he’s encouraging reads I think are good or mostly good and doing exactly nothing to stop a poe forming that potentially includes him

Michelle/spf/nutella/Ellie/doo/tutu/dk is my seven

Nanook scum

I agree LC, I agree.

Nanook, have your reads moved at all since day 0??

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I would probably vote made right now tbh

The towniest thing about jay is that he’s encouraging reads I think are good or mostly good and doing exactly nothing to stop a poe forming that potentially includes him

Michelle/spf/nutella/Ellie/doo/tutu/dk is my seven

Nanook scum

I agree LC, I agree.

Nanook, have your reads moved at all since day 0??

Yeah, you and esooa are town, doom, spf and/or dk are POE

[Michelle]

We should be in setups 2 or D because only JKer can protect am I right?

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

We should be in setups 2 or D because only JKer can protect am I right?

Rollblock can stop a kill

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Think I'm here right now:

Esooa
Made
Michelle
nutella
tutuu
Nanook

Alison
Omega
DkKoba
Grogu
SPF

Tiers not ordered. A roleblocker in the bottom set would be *Italian finger kiss meme*

GTH the team is Alison, Omega, SPF

[nutella]

Think I'm here right now:

Esooa
Made
Michelle
nutella
tutuu
Nanook

Alison
Omega
DkKoba
Grogu
SPF

Tiers not ordered. A roleblocker in the bottom set would be *Italian finger kiss meme*

GTH the team is Alison, Omega, SPF

Works for me

[Michelle]

We should be in setups 2 or D because only JKer can protect am I right?

Rollblock can stop a kill

That too, you are right.

Going to read the day

[DaughterOfOmega]

I think Nanook's anger today has been pretty awkward, he seems to be forcing this stress level that I don't think exists

[nutella]

heading towards bed, just a heads up i'm gonna be pretty sparse for most of tomorrow


(i really fuckin hoped i would be dead by now F)


(and think maybe i was supposed to be and it was a JK but ah well)

[JaggedJimmyJay]

For those seeking to qualify/strengthen Esooa reads -- if she is believed that her turn on Made to a town read on Day 2 was about suspecting a power role, then that is to her credit (and I'm inclined to believe it). Made may be dead now otherwise. Killing in the POE sucks for mafia, but if they think there's a cop or a roleblocker than can red-check any killer, priority probably goes there.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Granted if the kill was blocked, anyone could have shot Made in theory. but whatever

[nutella]

For those seeking to qualify/strengthen Esooa reads -- if she is believed that her turn on Made to a town read on Day 2 was about suspecting a power role, then that is to her credit (and I'm inclined to believe it). Made may be dead now otherwise. Killing in the POE sucks for mafia, but if they think there's a cop or a roleblocker than can red-check any killer, priority probably goes there.

this makes sense though esooa is one of the trs i need the least shoring up on anyway

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I think Nanook's anger today has been pretty awkward, he seems to be forcing this stress level that I don't think exists

I’m not angry ftr, I just have a tendency for cursing when I’m tired

[nutella]

remember when "if ellie flips v i blast esooa"

and look where we are now


sorry mac

[JaggedJimmyJay]

For those seeking to qualify/strengthen Esooa reads -- if she is believed that her turn on Made to a town read on Day 2 was about suspecting a power role, then that is to her credit (and I'm inclined to believe it). Made may be dead now otherwise. Killing in the POE sucks for mafia, but if they think there's a cop or a roleblocker than can red-check any killer, priority probably goes there.

this makes sense though esooa is one of the trs i need the least shoring up on anyway

I asked myself earlier who I'd move down to the POE first if a slot opened, and I kinda kept veering toward Esooa. Not knowing her at all hinders my certainty. But that little bit is something, so neat.

[nutella]

well

tbf now thinking about it


IF spf is v i prob look more into esooa, and alison


i just feel like spf makes a ton of sense to be mafia here

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Mac said esooa probably town if LC town, so if he’s yelling from dead chat that’s on him tbh

[staypositivefriend]

i'm catching up with the game right now, but it greatly concerns me that three people have expressed that i have a "high" probability of being scum today without seeming to actually have a case against me - just the vague feeling that i "could" be mafia

i can't really do much with that

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I would probably vote made right now tbh

The towniest thing about jay is that he’s encouraging reads I think are good or mostly good and doing exactly nothing to stop a poe forming that potentially includes him

Michelle/spf/nutella/Ellie/doo/tutu/dk is my seven

Nanook scum

I agree LC, I agree.

Nanook, have your reads moved at all since day 0??

Yeah, you and esooa are town, doom, spf and/or dk are POE

I also added mac at some point idr who I kicked to fit him

Doom I think

[staypositivefriend]

in fact, i would very much like jagged to explain how he went from feeling mostly fine about me to having me as his number one scumread today. that progression is worrying

[nutella]

i'm catching up with the game right now, but it greatly concerns me that three people have expressed that i have a "high" probability of being scum today without seeming to actually have a case against me - just the vague feeling that i "could" be mafia

i can't really do much with that

Well worlds are pretty limited rn

I made my points against you yesterday and they still hold, and possibilities are narrowed down more so

make your case for whomever else

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Man can you imagine if spf is mafia that said “I’m gonna kill a mafia and you’re gonna townread me for it” then proceeded to hard push town

That would be hilarious

[staypositivefriend]

i'm catching up with the game right now, but it greatly concerns me that three people have expressed that i have a "high" probability of being scum today without seeming to actually have a case against me - just the vague feeling that i "could" be mafia

i can't really do much with that

Well worlds are pretty limited rn

I made my points against you yesterday and they still hold, and possibilities are narrowed down more so

make your case for whomever else

respectfully, your points were just "SPF talks similar to how she talked in a game where she was mafia", no?

[nutella]

i'm catching up with the game right now, but it greatly concerns me that three people have expressed that i have a "high" probability of being scum today without seeming to actually have a case against me - just the vague feeling that i "could" be mafia

i can't really do much with that

Well worlds are pretty limited rn

I made my points against you yesterday and they still hold, and possibilities are narrowed down more so

make your case for whomever else

respectfully, your points were just "SPF talks similar to how she talked in a game where she was mafia", no?

That's a decent part of it, yeah

bit more to it than that but sure lol

[JaggedJimmyJay]

in fact, i would very much like jagged to explain how he went from feeling mostly fine about me to having me as his number one scumread today. that progression is worrying

You're not my number one scum read, the list wasn't ordered within tiers. I don't really care about ranking the POE that much. You're in it though, and I could see you being on the team. You might make a lot of sense with Alison, since both of you have kind of been right there with me on a lot of game matters, and that could have been deliberate to pocket me.

I will look deeper into interactions later and see how I feel about that. Right now I'm working out of my gut.

[nutella]

anyway really gotta sleep

[Made]

I get the process of elimiation y'all executing here, but like this game is an abnormality just generally.

is it really that impossible anyone is playing outside of their scum range???

it's not a very scientific approach, and i typically hate science, but moments like now make it pretty useful.

I don't get the attachment to the EOD d2 state of the game i'm feeling in thread rn

[staypositivefriend]

in fact, i would very much like jagged to explain how he went from feeling mostly fine about me to having me as his number one scumread today. that progression is worrying

You're not my number one scum read, the list wasn't ordered within tiers. I don't really care about ranking the POE that much. You're in it though, and I could see you being on the team. You might make a lot of sense with Alison, since both of you have kind of been right there with me on a lot of game matters, and that could have been deliberate to pocket me.

I will look deeper into interactions later and see how I feel about that. Right now I'm working out of my gut.

okay, thanks

i'm still very concerned that the reasoning people are giving seems to mostly boil down to "SPF fits as mafia" without further elaboration - if i'm scum then i should be scumtelling, and not vaguely thrust into a POE

will have to figure out who is doing that in good faith

[staypositivefriend]

I get the process of elimiation y'all executing here, but like this game is an abnormality just generally.

is it really that impossible anyone is playing outside of their scum range???

it's not a very scientific approach, and i typically hate science, but moments like now make it pretty useful.

I don't get the attachment to the EOD d2 state of the game i'm feeling in thread rn

i don't either. it's very clear that this game is going to be a tougher solve than "made/grogu/SPF" or w/e

[Made]

I get the process of elimiation y'all executing here, but like this game is an abnormality just generally.

is it really that impossible anyone is playing outside of their scum range???

it's not a very scientific approach, and i typically hate science, but moments like now make it pretty useful.

I don't get the attachment to the EOD d2 state of the game i'm feeling in thread rn

let's make a list: who is currently playing outside of their scum range. I think it's useful to get this down.