Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[Alison]

I think the way Sloonei had a read on nook early and then held it until he was more sure is townie. I also believe that it is a real thought he had and that he did not make it up on the spot. If he is wolf it is not with nanook. But if he is wolf I think he would have just outed the read early for free townpoints from Jay who would see him doing solvey stuff.

[Hally]

fwiw nook said he has a claim that will clear him. i don’t know if i believe that, but it’s a thing he said

[Michelle]

After the Champs games I sweared to not put so much effort in games, Sloonei, so i explained it in several games after. I was MLed often for it.
Ted, Hally, Alison, know about this i guess because I talked here few times about it
GoC was exception btw and for nothing, btw
I should stick with low posting

Okay, but you have spent more than enough time in this thread to have looked over the conversation I had with ted last night. It was not extremely long. It would only take a few minutes to look at, and hearing your input on it would be helpful, especially given your strong town read on Ted right now.

I spent time in direct interactions
Overnight i read an Iso. End of story.

[Hally]

i don’t understand why tony’s wagon is that much bigger than ted’s. i think ted is a better lunch personally

i loved the part where you gave a reason

i did

when are you gonna try to find wolves or solve the game? i wanna mark it on my calendar so i don’t miss it

[tedxtr]

Spoiler: show

marmot, when you get the chance, do you mind quickly breaking down your reads for me? just hearing your view of the game rn would be helpful for me

Sure. I'm about to go to bed, but here's where I'm at.

I think some of the players who are steering the thread and maintaining a cohesive, team-oriented approach are town. This includes JJJ and Sloonei. There are probably other such active players that I haven't had the chance to interact with, but these two are standouts.

Tutuu has been high activity, but low commitment to her reads, I don't think there's much sincerity behind it. I can dig into it tomorrow to see if I still feel that way.

I've already explained my read of you. Some good posts. One icky post.

Nanook is in a slightly similar boat, one post that I didn't care for, but overall has been fine. I expressed suspicion of him earlier, but when I think about it, I'd expect more slanking from him as mafia.

TSP and Bo I think are town due to volume and content. Bo in particular seems extremely comfortable and fluid here to an extent that I've never seen from himn, and he's been the Day 1 yeet in multiple recent games.


These are the players that have stood out to me thus far. Thanks for asking, this was a useful exercise for me too

[VOTE: Al] aubergine

This is the best of the current wagons.

Do you genuinely believe Al is the scummiest active wagon or is this self pres?

Also this wording implies there is someone who you'd rather see exed over Al but who isn't an active wagon. Who is it?

It is both.

I've seen reasons for both Ted and TSP to be town. Al on the other hand posted an awkward readlist yesterday and not much since then.


If this game happens to be multi-ball, Nanook and spf should be given another look. They were both suspicions I had earlier on before they claimed mason.

If AL was catching/caught up, I would expect more than just the ted observation

I also disagree on that slot

Hally these are mentions about Ted in Marmot's Iso if my 'find in page' works correct, maybe it was one more post
Level zero says Ted may be aligned, but I am not anymore a level zero player, so I keep my read om Ted.

Explain me your ideas @Hally, why is Ted Marmot's partner?

ctrl+f “marmot” in ted’s iso

maybe whoever said you are masons with mac is correct, it looks like you have the same reasons as him too

[Alison]

fwiw nook said he has a claim that will clear him. i don’t know if i believe that, but it’s a thing he said

He did say that yes. I have no doubt it is well within his scum range to do, but it is a point to consider.

[Hally]

i don’t understand why tony’s wagon is that much bigger than ted’s. i think ted is a better lunch personally

Apologies if you've gone into it already, but why ted > TSP?

ted looks very aligned with marmot and also could possibly be on the other team

the consensus on tony is that if he’s a wolf he can’t be with marmot and would only be on the other team

so to me it makes more sense to lunch ted first

explain for each hypothesis how that is the case

read my posts

[Sloonei]

After the Champs games I sweared to not put so much effort in games, Sloonei, so i explained it in several games after. I was MLed often for it.
Ted, Hally, Alison, know about this i guess because I talked here few times about it
GoC was exception btw and for nothing, btw
I should stick with low posting

Okay, but you have spent more than enough time in this thread to have looked over the conversation I had with ted last night. It was not extremely long. It would only take a few minutes to look at, and hearing your input on it would be helpful, especially given your strong town read on Ted right now.

I thought ted's explanation sounded reasonable. He didn't want to get into it with Alison about opposing views on Marmot because she is notoriously stubborn.

As I said to ted last night, my objection is that I do not believe him. I don't think that explanation is particularly reasonable anyway ("I didn't talk to Alison about the read I asked her for because she's stubborn" is silly and, in my experience, not how mafia works. Among other objections), but I also do not believe that it is an accurate representation of what he was doing and thinking at the time.

It became a bit of a running joke last night, but I am completely serious about the "Got it" accusation. Ted produced a town read on Marmot. He then asked Alison to explain her case against Marmot. When Alison did that, Ted replied by simply saying "Got it" and then shifting the discussion to KZA. Ted later said that "Got it" was supposed to be interpreted as him disagreeing with Alison's case.

I am old and not hip with all the lingo that gets thrown around these days, but I've never seen anyone use the affirmative "got it" to mean "I disagree with you."

[tedxtr]

i don’t understand why tony’s wagon is that much bigger than ted’s. i think ted is a better lunch personally

i loved the part where you gave a reason

i did

when are you gonna try to find wolves or solve the game? i wanna mark it on my calendar so i don’t miss it

i probably won't, it's annoying when all heat is on me

acting like that's an indicator for wolfiness or villageriness in multiball - if i were a wolf i would've done what you all want me to do since ages ago...since it's multiball

[tedxtr]

"Got it" was supposed to be interpreted as him disagreeing with Alison's case.

no - i disagreed and that is my way of acknowledging her post

acknowledge and move on

[Hally]

I think the way Sloonei had a read on nook early and then held it until he was more sure is townie. I also believe that it is a real thought he had and that he did not make it up on the spot. If he is wolf it is not with nanook. But if he is wolf I think he would have just outed the read early for free townpoints from Jay who would see him doing solvey stuff.

i’ve been pretty firmly v reading sloonei for a little bit now. but yes, i agree

[tedxtr]

whenever i'm in thread i just get heat so i'll probably won't solve until it's gone

do with this information what you will

[Alison]

ted can I be blunt with you?

Unless you reveal as innocent child or something similar there is very little that you can do at this point to convince the town that their suspicion of you is wrong. You've been doing this self defense stuff since Night 1 and nobody has been swayed. If you are town, the best way to play to your win condition is to just hunt like a normal person, and leave a strong legacy for town to sheep. People in the POE always have better reads because they have a free cop check on themselves. So if you are town use that to your advantage and give us strong reads to fall back on after you die rather than struggling against an outcome that won't change.

[Strawhenge]

I think i said if you would read my posts that he plays as town free flowing and active.. Now he is neither free flowing, neither active
I think i said the resistance to his wagon looks bad for me.
I don't have cases, Isos, etc. I explained in the most simple words. What do you want more, to beg? Of course i think you can be scum with him after this.

Again, if wanting reasons to jump on a bandwagon is scummy, line me up for the gallows.

I'm going to leave it up to other people to talk to you. You're too aggressive.

[Michelle]

whenever i'm in thread i just get heat so i'll probably won't solve until it's gone

do with this information what you will

Ignore the thread and solve, it's a win/win thing

[fingersplints]

Spoiler: show

Who posted? - This is a list of all members who posted in this topic
UsernamePosts
JaggedJimmyJay573
Sloonei460
Alison454
BoKnows440
TonyStarkPrime414
MacDougall399
Hally384
tutuu330
Esooa296
Long Con251
Justplayingitcool226
KZA213
tedxtr212
falcon45ca203
staypositivefriend192
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME156
Marmot152
Oddmerta122
Michelle114
Strawhenge98
fingersplints82
AL_sama53
novaselinenever7
Dom6
Master Radishes2

Who is lower than me in posts number except Al, who I know is low poster by meta, is suspicious for me.
No one talks about Straw and Fingers, can I know why?
Nanook is in the same tier because he is easy posting one liners as villager, flooding the thread with a specific kind of joy.

Im probably not the one you were looking to to answer this, but we are both returning from a long break, so the quantity of our posting isn’t much of a surprise to many in a game of this size. I feel I’ve been talked about quite a bit lately. There is just stronger suspects right now.

How long was your break?
What do you like in this game (in general)? Fav alignament? Scumhunting methods? Link to last game?
Thanks

My break was 5 years long. I have since my break, played two very small games. G-mans “not really a mafia” game, where we didn’t realise until game over we were all mafia. That game I claimed my role of blocker early on, and was trusted/followed some from the lack of kills. Then I played Sloonei’s bee mafia where I was given a gun (something that only a townie could get) and that confirmed me. Those two games are by far the most trusted I have ever been in a mafia game my entire career. I’ve struggled more this game due to its size and complexity.

I’m confused as to the next question because it says this game then in general? In this game, no offence to the hose because it’s a perfectly good game but I’ve liked not a lot. It’s very tough for me to keep up. In general, I have a hard time pinpointing what I like about mafia. It’s like an addiction. Fleeting bits of fun followed by a lot of regret about tons of time wasting.
In my mafia history (which is the past 10 years or so) I most prefer hosting or being mafia. I think I’m a pretty lousy townie as I don’t think I have any great scum hunting methods. I don’t keep track of anything and play based on gut reactions. I don’t do well with complex games, as it’s too much for me to pay attention to.

I’m playing from my phone (which is where I play all my mafia from) so linking to another game is hard. Maybe @Sloonei or someone will help me out and link the bee mafia, but again that game was much smaller so I felt much more in my element there

[Alison]

i don’t understand why tony’s wagon is that much bigger than ted’s. i think ted is a better lunch personally

i loved the part where you gave a reason

i did

when are you gonna try to find wolves or solve the game? i wanna mark it on my calendar so i don’t miss it

i probably won't, it's annoying when all heat is on me

acting like that's an indicator for wolfiness or villageriness in multiball - if i were a wolf i would've done what you all want me to do since ages ago...since it's multiball

If you're villager the game doesn't end when you die. It's your responsibility as a villa to produce good reads to help the town win after you're gone. Being scumread is annoying. We've all been there. You acknowledge that there is a risk you will be the top suspect at one point or another when you sign up for a game of mafia. Suck it up and play the game. Otherwise you're letting your personal emotions get in the way of your win con.

[Hally]

i don’t understand why tony’s wagon is that much bigger than ted’s. i think ted is a better lunch personally

i loved the part where you gave a reason

i did

when are you gonna try to find wolves or solve the game? i wanna mark it on my calendar so i don’t miss it

i probably won't, it's annoying when all heat is on me

acting like that's an indicator for wolfiness or villageriness in multiball - if i were a wolf i would've done what you all want me to do since ages ago...since it's multiball

alright, well if all you’re going to do is defend yourself and not solve i’m not sure what i’m supposed to do for you

[Long Con]

After the Champs games I sweared to not put so much effort in games, Sloonei, so i explained it in several games after. I was MLed often for it.
Ted, Hally, Alison, know about this i guess because I talked here few times about it
GoC was exception btw and for nothing, btw
I should stick with low posting

Okay, but you have spent more than enough time in this thread to have looked over the conversation I had with ted last night. It was not extremely long. It would only take a few minutes to look at, and hearing your input on it would be helpful, especially given your strong town read on Ted right now.

I thought ted's explanation sounded reasonable. He didn't want to get into it with Alison about opposing views on Marmot because she is notoriously stubborn.

As I said to ted last night, my objection is that I do not believe him. I don't think that explanation is particularly reasonable anyway ("I didn't talk to Alison about the read I asked her for because she's stubborn" is silly and, in my experience, not how mafia works. Among other objections), but I also do not believe that it is an accurate representation of what he was doing and thinking at the time.

It became a bit of a running joke last night, but I am completely serious about the "Got it" accusation. Ted produced a town read on Marmot. He then asked Alison to explain her case against Marmot. When Alison did that, Ted replied by simply saying "Got it" and then shifting the discussion to KZA. Ted later said that "Got it" was supposed to be interpreted as him disagreeing with Alison's case.

I am old and not hip with all the lingo that gets thrown around these days, but I've never seen anyone use the affirmative "got it" to mean "I disagree with you."

I see the acknowledging curtness of "Got it" as conveying "Thanks for your time; I'm not interested in engaging with any of that."

Which I could see a Marmot teammate doing. Would the mindset be that he thought Alison might say something negative about Marmot that he could easily counter, but ted pulled the chute when he thought it wouldn't go well?

[Sloonei]

After the Champs games I sweared to not put so much effort in games, Sloonei, so i explained it in several games after. I was MLed often for it.
Ted, Hally, Alison, know about this i guess because I talked here few times about it
GoC was exception btw and for nothing, btw
I should stick with low posting

Okay, but you have spent more than enough time in this thread to have looked over the conversation I had with ted last night. It was not extremely long. It would only take a few minutes to look at, and hearing your input on it would be helpful, especially given your strong town read on Ted right now.

I spent time in direct interactions
Overnight i read an Iso. End of story.

Well if you would not mind helping me out, I would appreciate it if you read my exchange with ted and gave us your thoughts.
It starts roughly at Post #5468 and ends at Post #5543.
Our focus is mainly on ted's Day 1 post, #2723.

[Michelle]

I think i said if you would read my posts that he plays as town free flowing and active.. Now he is neither free flowing, neither active
I think i said the resistance to his wagon looks bad for me.
I don't have cases, Isos, etc. I explained in the most simple words. What do you want more, to beg? Of course i think you can be scum with him after this.

Again, if wanting reasons to jump on a bandwagon is scummy, line me up for the gallows.

I'm going to leave it up to other people to talk to you. You're too aggressive.

Am i aggressive? Sorry about that, you're still in scum reads for me

[Hally]

whenever i'm in thread i just get heat so i'll probably won't solve until it's gone

do with this information what you will

you are the one who engaged with other people about our suspicions on you just now. you didn’t have to do that. nobody even initiated an interaction with you

[Alison]

i don’t understand why tony’s wagon is that much bigger than ted’s. i think ted is a better lunch personally

i loved the part where you gave a reason

i did

when are you gonna try to find wolves or solve the game? i wanna mark it on my calendar so i don’t miss it

i probably won't, it's annoying when all heat is on me

acting like that's an indicator for wolfiness or villageriness in multiball - if i were a wolf i would've done what you all want me to do since ages ago...since it's multiball

If you're villager the game doesn't end when you die. It's your responsibility as a villa to produce good reads to help the town win after you're gone. Being scumread is annoying. We've all been there. You acknowledge that there is a risk you will be the top suspect at one point or another when you sign up for a game of mafia. Suck it up and play the game. Otherwise you're letting your personal emotions get in the way of your win con.

Look Jay I followed your legacy. Are you proud of me?

[Hally]

ted, you’re acting like you came into the thread, tried to solve and got piled on so you stopped

that is not what happened

you entered by asking me and others directly about the suspicion on you. you brought it up. nobody is piling on you. you could easily have ignored it and done literally anything else

[fingersplints]

i’m kinda shocked town doesn’t have a vig in this setup. having two wolf kp and no village kp seems kinda questionable to me

Why do you think there is no vig?

[tedxtr]

https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/searc ... 0&start=50

https://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/searc ... 0&start=50

here, maybe it paints a better picture of how i handle my wolf partners

[tedxtr]

i'm not an effin rookie, i know i can get away with defending partners if i consciously decide to take that road

villagers are wrong so wolves can be wrong too, i usually double down instead of retracting

[Sloonei]

After the Champs games I sweared to not put so much effort in games, Sloonei, so i explained it in several games after. I was MLed often for it.
Ted, Hally, Alison, know about this i guess because I talked here few times about it
GoC was exception btw and for nothing, btw
I should stick with low posting

Okay, but you have spent more than enough time in this thread to have looked over the conversation I had with ted last night. It was not extremely long. It would only take a few minutes to look at, and hearing your input on it would be helpful, especially given your strong town read on Ted right now.

I thought ted's explanation sounded reasonable. He didn't want to get into it with Alison about opposing views on Marmot because she is notoriously stubborn.

As I said to ted last night, my objection is that I do not believe him. I don't think that explanation is particularly reasonable anyway ("I didn't talk to Alison about the read I asked her for because she's stubborn" is silly and, in my experience, not how mafia works. Among other objections), but I also do not believe that it is an accurate representation of what he was doing and thinking at the time.

It became a bit of a running joke last night, but I am completely serious about the "Got it" accusation. Ted produced a town read on Marmot. He then asked Alison to explain her case against Marmot. When Alison did that, Ted replied by simply saying "Got it" and then shifting the discussion to KZA. Ted later said that "Got it" was supposed to be interpreted as him disagreeing with Alison's case.

I am old and not hip with all the lingo that gets thrown around these days, but I've never seen anyone use the affirmative "got it" to mean "I disagree with you."

I see the acknowledging curtness of "Got it" as conveying "Thanks for your time; I'm not interested in engaging with any of that."

Which I could see a Marmot teammate doing. Would the mindset be that he thought Alison might say something negative about Marmot that he could easily counter, but ted pulled the chute when he thought it wouldn't go well?

And I don't read "Thanks for your time; I'm not interested in engaging with any of that" to be a believable reaction from a civilian who has just ISO'd a player to the tune of a town read and then specifically requested another player present their case against said town read. So in either case, I think Ted looks like he is full of baloney.

I do not know what ted's mindset would be, but the complete lack of follow through on his part makes me believe that he was not actually interested in either the work he'd just done to produce a town read on Marmot, engaging in a discussion about the reads/votes on Marmot, or both.

[tedxtr]

ted can I be blunt with you?

Unless you reveal as innocent child or something similar there is very little that you can do at this point to convince the town that their suspicion of you is wrong. You've been doing this self defense stuff since Night 1 and nobody has been swayed. If you are town, the best way to play to your win condition is to just hunt like a normal person, and leave a strong legacy for town to sheep. People in the POE always have better reads because they have a free cop check on themselves. So if you are town use that to your advantage and give us strong reads to fall back on after you die rather than struggling against an outcome that won't change.

exactly, i know i'm gonna die here for bad reasons

my reads won't really matter in the bigger scheme of things

[Hally]

i’m kinda shocked town doesn’t have a vig in this setup. having two wolf kp and no village kp seems kinda questionable to me

Why do you think there is no vig?

because there was no vig shot last night unless the vig went off the rails and shot mac/jay

it’s also possible they got blocked or something. we shall see

[Sloonei]

i don’t understand why tony’s wagon is that much bigger than ted’s. i think ted is a better lunch personally

i loved the part where you gave a reason

i did

when are you gonna try to find wolves or solve the game? i wanna mark it on my calendar so i don’t miss it

i probably won't, it's annoying when all heat is on me

acting like that's an indicator for wolfiness or villageriness in multiball - if i were a wolf i would've done what you all want me to do since ages ago...since it's multiball

If you're villager the game doesn't end when you die. It's your responsibility as a villa to produce good reads to help the town win after you're gone. Being scumread is annoying. We've all been there. You acknowledge that there is a risk you will be the top suspect at one point or another when you sign up for a game of mafia. Suck it up and play the game. Otherwise you're letting your personal emotions get in the way of your win con.

Look Jay I followed your legacy. Are you proud of me?

Yes, although "suck it up and play the game" is harsher language than I, JaggedJimmyJay, would use.

[fingersplints]

ted can I be blunt with you?

Unless you reveal as innocent child or something similar there is very little that you can do at this point to convince the town that their suspicion of you is wrong. You've been doing this self defense stuff since Night 1 and nobody has been swayed. If you are town, the best way to play to your win condition is to just hunt like a normal person, and leave a strong legacy for town to sheep. People in the POE always have better reads because they have a free cop check on themselves. So if you are town use that to your advantage and give us strong reads to fall back on after you die rather than struggling against an outcome that won't change.

exactly, i know i'm gonna die here for bad reasons

my reads won't really matter in the bigger scheme of things

Your reads only wouldn’t matter after your death if you are revealed to be bad as Alison just explained why you should still post for legacy

[Hally]

ted can I be blunt with you?

Unless you reveal as innocent child or something similar there is very little that you can do at this point to convince the town that their suspicion of you is wrong. You've been doing this self defense stuff since Night 1 and nobody has been swayed. If you are town, the best way to play to your win condition is to just hunt like a normal person, and leave a strong legacy for town to sheep. People in the POE always have better reads because they have a free cop check on themselves. So if you are town use that to your advantage and give us strong reads to fall back on after you die rather than struggling against an outcome that won't change.

exactly, i know i'm gonna die here for bad reasons

my reads won't really matter in the bigger scheme of things

so what are you going to do now? just complain about the suspicion on you every time you post until we lunch you and not solve at all? really?

[tedxtr]

instead of looking for other wolves you're not doing anything better with your time than I am, it's not like you're asking people any questions.

there's at least 5 wolves left

[tedxtr]

ted can I be blunt with you?

Unless you reveal as innocent child or something similar there is very little that you can do at this point to convince the town that their suspicion of you is wrong. You've been doing this self defense stuff since Night 1 and nobody has been swayed. If you are town, the best way to play to your win condition is to just hunt like a normal person, and leave a strong legacy for town to sheep. People in the POE always have better reads because they have a free cop check on themselves. So if you are town use that to your advantage and give us strong reads to fall back on after you die rather than struggling against an outcome that won't change.

exactly, i know i'm gonna die here for bad reasons

my reads won't really matter in the bigger scheme of things

so what are you going to do now? just complain about the suspicion on you every time you post until we lunch you and not solve at all? really?

are you doing anything else atm than I am?

there's nothing for me to engage with because the thread isn't looking for other wolves

[fingersplints]

i’m kinda shocked town doesn’t have a vig in this setup. having two wolf kp and no village kp seems kinda questionable to me

Why do you think there is no vig?

because there was no vig shot last night unless the vig went off the rails and shot mac/jay

it’s also possible they got blocked or something. we shall see

Also possible it was a player who wasn’t around. I don’t know if anyone else besides Dom would fit that profile and it’s kind of a long shot. As you said we will see.

Is it possible it’s just a one shot vig? I don’t know what is the trend for vig these days in mafia

[tedxtr]

ted can I be blunt with you?

Unless you reveal as innocent child or something similar there is very little that you can do at this point to convince the town that their suspicion of you is wrong. You've been doing this self defense stuff since Night 1 and nobody has been swayed. If you are town, the best way to play to your win condition is to just hunt like a normal person, and leave a strong legacy for town to sheep. People in the POE always have better reads because they have a free cop check on themselves. So if you are town use that to your advantage and give us strong reads to fall back on after you die rather than struggling against an outcome that won't change.

exactly, i know i'm gonna die here for bad reasons

my reads won't really matter in the bigger scheme of things

Your reads only wouldn’t matter after your death if you are revealed to be bad as Alison just explained why you should still post for legacy

nah they won't, i've played enough games

nobody cares about a PoE'd person's reads on D2. there's gonna be new info and generally people play good here, they'll stick to their reads

[Sloonei]

Let us all honor ted's wishes by looking at other people.

[Hally]

instead of looking for other wolves you're not doing anything better with your time than I am, it's not like you're asking people any questions.

there's at least 5 wolves left

with respect, what are you talking about? there’s been tons of discussion and questioning of people other than you this day. you are not even the lead wagon. when you entered the thread we were discussing michelle and nanook, both of whom are not you, and instead of weighing in on that conversation you brought up the suspicion on you. you are the one who just made the thread about you again

[Sloonei]

ted can I be blunt with you?

Unless you reveal as innocent child or something similar there is very little that you can do at this point to convince the town that their suspicion of you is wrong. You've been doing this self defense stuff since Night 1 and nobody has been swayed. If you are town, the best way to play to your win condition is to just hunt like a normal person, and leave a strong legacy for town to sheep. People in the POE always have better reads because they have a free cop check on themselves. So if you are town use that to your advantage and give us strong reads to fall back on after you die rather than struggling against an outcome that won't change.

exactly, i know i'm gonna die here for bad reasons

my reads won't really matter in the bigger scheme of things

Your reads only wouldn’t matter after your death if you are revealed to be bad as Alison just explained why you should still post for legacy

nah they won't, i've played enough games

nobody cares about a PoE'd person's reads on D2. there's gonna be new info and generally people play good here, they'll stick to their reads

If you engage with folks in good faith now, there is a good chance you can influence their reads or the way that they are looking at certain players.

This is multiball, so even somebody who is unwilling to consider a world where you are not mafia should be willing to hear what you have to say about suspects from The Other Team.

[tedxtr]

instead of looking for other wolves you're not doing anything better with your time than I am, it's not like you're asking people any questions.

there's at least 5 wolves left

with respect, what are you talking about? there’s been tons of discussion and questioning of people other than you this day. you are not even the lead wagon. when you entered the thread we were discussing michelle and nanook, both of whom are not you, and instead of weighing in on that conversation you brought up the suspicion on you. you are the one who just made the thread about you again

because people keep asking me questions / pushing me

i'm gonna ask them about it at an attempt to sort their push on me at least

[Strawhenge]

you're still in scum reads for me

Just to clarify, this is because I put up the slightest bit of resistance to jumping on a wagon just because you said so?

[Hally]

instead of looking for other wolves you're not doing anything better with your time than I am, it's not like you're asking people any questions.

there's at least 5 wolves left

with respect, what are you talking about? there’s been tons of discussion and questioning of people other than you this day. you are not even the lead wagon. when you entered the thread we were discussing michelle and nanook, both of whom are not you, and instead of weighing in on that conversation you brought up the suspicion on you. you are the one who just made the thread about you again

because people keep asking me questions / pushing me

i'm gonna ask them about it at an attempt to sort their push on me at least

so you’re saying by asking me about my read on you you were trying to sort me? me, who is a confirmed villager? i’m sorted already

[Alison]

instead of looking for other wolves you're not doing anything better with your time than I am, it's not like you're asking people any questions.

there's at least 5 wolves left

we were literally just debating nanook

[falcon45ca]

Feels like finger just straight up pulled players from my POE

[tedxtr]

Michelle, what do you make of our friend's iso?

are you thinking he's town?

[Alison]

Let's talk about the dynamic between Strawhenge and Michelle.

I read it as two players whose playstyles grate against each other, but ultimately they're both villager. Does anyone else have thoughts about this? Those two have been quietly going at it hammer and tongs in the background while we talk about other stuff.

[Sloonei]

Feels like finger just straight up pulled players from my POE

What does this mean and how does it make you feel about fingersplints?

[Hally]

Let's talk about the dynamic between Strawhenge and Michelle.

I read it as two players whose playstyles grate against each other, but ultimately they're both villager. Does anyone else have thoughts about this? Those two have been quietly going at it hammer and tongs in the background while we talk about other stuff.

i agree that they’re probably both villagers

[Michelle]

Spoiler: show

Spoiler: show

Who posted? - This is a list of all members who posted in this topic
UsernamePosts
JaggedJimmyJay573
Sloonei460
Alison454
BoKnows440
TonyStarkPrime414
MacDougall399
Hally384
tutuu330
Esooa296
Long Con251
Justplayingitcool226
KZA213
tedxtr212
falcon45ca203
staypositivefriend192
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME156
Marmot152
Oddmerta122
Michelle114
Strawhenge98
fingersplints82
AL_sama53
novaselinenever7
Dom6
Master Radishes2

Who is lower than me in posts number except Al, who I know is low poster by meta, is suspicious for me.
No one talks about Straw and Fingers, can I know why?
Nanook is in the same tier because he is easy posting one liners as villager, flooding the thread with a specific kind of joy.

Im probably not the one you were looking to to answer this, but we are both returning from a long break, so the quantity of our posting isn’t much of a surprise to many in a game of this size. I feel I’ve been talked about quite a bit lately. There is just stronger suspects right now.

How long was your break?
What do you like in this game (in general)? Fav alignament? Scumhunting methods? Link to last game?
Thanks

My break was 5 years long. I have since my break, played two very small games. G-mans “not really a mafia” game, where we didn’t realise until game over we were all mafia. That game I claimed my role of blocker early on, and was trusted/followed some from the lack of kills. Then I played Sloonei’s bee mafia where I was given a gun (something that only a townie could get) and that confirmed me. Those two games are by far the most trusted I have ever been in a mafia game my entire career. I’ve struggled more this game due to its size and complexity.

I’m confused as to the next question because it says this game then in general? In this game, no offence to the hose because it’s a perfectly good game but I’ve liked not a lot. It’s very tough for me to keep up. In general, I have a hard time pinpointing what I like about mafia. It’s like an addiction. Fleeting bits of fun followed by a lot of regret about tons of time wasting.
In my mafia history (which is the past 10 years or so) I most prefer hosting or being mafia. I think I’m a pretty lousy townie as I don’t think I have any great scum hunting methods. I don’t keep track of anything and play based on gut reactions. I don’t do well with complex games, as it’s too much for me to pay attention to.

I’m playing from my phone (which is where I play all my mafia from) so linking to another game is hard. Maybe @Sloonei or someone will help me out and link the bee mafia, but again that game was much smaller so I felt much more in my element there

Thanks! I vibe with the addiction part and regret