Fargo Mafia [Game Ends]

[Alison]

if i get soup killed i hope it’s wonton soup. i like wantons

as a townie I am obligated to pick potato soup

[Long Con]

I'll try it out.

AL_sama - Being quieter and having a tough time forming strong reads is believable for a new player who is town / General thread distrust and lack of solid reads
Alison - Big bold meaty claim and arrogance / Capable of twisting truth into "truth + I'm town" / Occurred to me she could be hostile 3p with the same powers / Multiball makes her open claim dangerous as a EvilMasterPlan but maybe some deflective action on to the troopers...
BoKnows - They tell me pie charts are super towny, also some good looking posting today / Some sketchy posting earlier, possible pocket attempt on me
Dom - Suave and debonair / Sometimes snarky when defensive
Esooa - Has a provable claim tucked away / I can't remember her overall contribution level
falcon45ca - Hasn't pinged me yet / Kind of slid into some towncore lists for reasons I'm not sure about, but I feel like he's probably well within his wolf range
fingersplints - Gave a full simple rainbow earlier on / Few suspicions, mostly TSP-focused. Some of her phrases ping me, like " No post since have inspired me with any confidence", it just sounds like stock suspicion-phrase.
hally - Shines like a star in the sky / I never checked for myself that Mac even hinted at all that Hally was his mason. I took that totally on trust.
Justplayingitcool - He said he didn't think I'm w/w with marmot based on marmot's treatment of me. I think a wolf would rather push that as being teamy. / Maybe he's TOO clean
KZA - Casual and believable trooper claim / Possible phony humility "I should be on the blast list..."
Michelle - Savage original viewpoints and a fiesty attitude / These things could be a wolf cover plan
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME - Sensible haircut / pretty lacklustre ISO, not much hunting
Oddmerta - Trooperville / Shallow reads, sometimes with dubious logic
Sloonei - Very proactive / Most of the time, I get the feeling that he's following a playbook of town tactics
staypositivefriend - Vagueclaim of provability / I dunno, I'm getting tired of this
Strawhenge - towny on the play / vibes can be wrong
tedxtr - looked better than Sloonei in their interaction / maybe Sloonei is right
TonyStarkPrime - Towncorest / There's a lot of negative vibes in the thread about him.

I got tired toward the end, sorry.

[falcon45ca]

the only bad thing about claiming is I can't eat a night kill but whatever

What's the positive to you claiming? Sry, missed that

I wanted to

Least townie answer to that question IMO

[TonyStarkPrime]

No more talk on aliens no spoilers

[Hally]

i really would be shocked if roles are linked to flavor AND flavor is alignment indicative AND there’s no downside to claiming roles or flavor

it seems like a recipe for a broken game to me even with wolves having fake claims

[Alison]

Roles seem to be linked to flavor to at least some degree. Peggy and Ed are masons, I can order my troopers around, etc.

You are correct that it does sound broken.

[Strawhenge]

AL_sama — new to Syndicate crew, intimidated by post count / evasive, overcautious about incriminating himself
Alison — highly believable roleclaim, Jaylike energy / roleclaim gambit to protect herself and her scummates
BoKnows — made fucking pie charts, but for serious is highly involved in the conversation / made fucking pie charts to effortclear himself
Dom — is virtually nonexistent / is virtually nonexistent
Esooa — is purportedly a doctor, which, in a game with a bunch of power roles/abilities, would've garnered a counterclaim by now if untrue / fakeclaimed doctor to, as Alison pointed out, have a continual reason not to be chopped
falcon45ca — good scumhunting / is clever scum who puts up a good scumhunting guise, and might be genuinely hunting the other team
fingersplints — vibes / vibes could be off
Justplayingitcool — keeps himself involved in the conversation, handled his early suspicions well / clever scum who can stay active
KZA — vibes + believable trooper claim / vibes could be off, could be an evil trooper
Long Con — noncommittal could be his usual style, as he proclaims; really doesn't like being falsely accused / see my ISO on him
Michelle — paranoid townie / combative, evasive scum
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME — vibes / not-great Marmot association
Oddmerta — blunt accusation based town meta / evasive scum
Sloonei — heavily involved in the conversation, is literally the same human being as JaggedJimmyJay / has a very unassuming meta as scum, going off my years-old data
staypositivefriend — vibes / vibes could be off
tedxtr — doesn't like being falsely accused / very bad Marmot associations
TonyStarkPrime — chaotic townie / evasive and chaotic scum
tutuu / hally — Mac mason, good scumhunting / clever scumhunting, big mason claim gambit

Anyone who just has 'vibes' is someone I need to focus on more.

[Esooa]

I'm actually mafia but slanking cause last time I got killed by a mafia as mafia

[Hally]

I'm actually mafia but slanking cause last time I got killed by a mafia as mafia

i believe you. what now?

[Hally]

@staypositivefriend where’s your head at?

[Esooa]

I'm actually mafia but slanking cause last time I got killed by a mafia as mafia

i believe you. what now?

[VOTE: Esooa] aubergine

[Hally]

I'm actually mafia but slanking cause last time I got killed by a mafia as mafia

i believe you. what now?

[VOTE: Esooa] aubergine

that doesn’t even count. you cannot escape

[BoKnows]

my ugly looking trustfall list took a lot out of me.

[Strawhenge]

Okay, can't look at the screen anymore. My to-do list for tomorrow consists of looking at the people I haven't been paying enough attention to: Esooa, SPF, fingersplints, nanook

[Michelle]

Hally I will not read that, i have a life

okay. well then it’s hard to care about your defense of ted unless you have mechanical information suggesting he’s a villager

I note this as role fishing and put you in my Poe

michelle you're not speaking my language anymore and we need to talk about this

I never speak your language, i don't speak English
I later understood that Hally is ok mechanically, but I disliked her reaction. Of course, I know is in her town range to say such things so

[Michelle]

The trustfall list from me will come in the morning

Who has the idea to colour these?

[Michelle]

Although, I remember it striking me at the time that al didn’t vote for marmot to self-pres

Was he posting in that moment? Because a possibility for him being AFK exists.
I don't say that happened, but is possible.

[falcon45ca]

Hally I will not read that, i have a life

okay. well then it’s hard to care about your defense of ted unless you have mechanical information suggesting he’s a villager

I note this as role fishing and put you in my Poe

michelle you're not speaking my language anymore and we need to talk about this

I never speak your language, i don't speak English
I later understood that Hally is ok mechanically, but I disliked her reaction. Of course, I know is in her town range to say such things so

I am now looking up a Bucharest accent to get an idea of what you may sound like.



You can look up a Canadian accent and do the same if you like! Or you can hear my actual voice on YouTube, just type in my name and something'll pop up

[Michelle]

Hally I will not read that, i have a life

okay. well then it’s hard to care about your defense of ted unless you have mechanical information suggesting he’s a villager

I note this as role fishing and put you in my Poe

michelle you're not speaking my language anymore and we need to talk about this

I never speak your language, i don't speak English
I later understood that Hally is ok mechanically, but I disliked her reaction. Of course, I know is in her town range to say such things so

I am now looking up a Bucharest accent to get an idea of what you may sound like.



You can look up a Canadian accent and do the same if you like! Or you can hear my actual voice on YouTube, just type in my name and something'll pop up

Wow thanks, being night now I will wait till morning ^^

[Michelle]

Does anyone have a feeling that wolves are happy with the gamestate? i am looking at the 2 big wagons and not grewing counters and i like both Ted and Tony and I am terribly confused

Full VC

Spoiler: show

Who's not cooperating?
Poll runs till Sun Apr 11, 2021 1:00 am
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


AL_sama
1
5%
Voters: staypositivefriend
Alison
0
No votes
Voters: None
BoKnows
0
No votes
Voters: None
Dom
0
No votes
Voters: None
Esooa
1
5%
Voters: Esooa
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
fingersplints
0
No votes
Voters: None
Hally
0
No votes
Voters: None
Justplayingitcool
0
No votes
Voters: None
KZA
0
No votes
Voters: None
Long Con
0
No votes
Voters: None
Marmot
0
No votes
Voters: None
Michelle
0
No votes
Voters: None
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
2
9%
Voters: Michelle, Sloonei
Oddmerta
0
No votes
Voters: None
Sloonei
0
No votes
Voters: None
staypositivefriend
0
No votes
Voters: None
Strawhenge
0
No votes
Voters: None
tedxtr
7
32%
Voters: Justplayingitcool, Strawhenge, Hally, AL_sama, TonyStarkPrime, BoKnows, KZA
TonyStarkPrime
6
27%
Voters: Oddmerta, Alison, NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, fingersplints, falcon45ca, tedxtr
Unvote
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Elimination
0
No votes
Voters: None
I'm cooperatin' here darn tooting! (Host/Dead/Non)
5
23%
Voters: MacDougall, nutella, novaselinenever, JaggedJimmyJay, Marmot
Total votes: 22

And the 2 biggest wagons

tedxtr
7
32%
Voters: Justplayingitcool, Strawhenge, Hally, AL_sama, TonyStarkPrime, BoKnows, KZA
TonyStarkPrime
6
27%
Voters: Oddmerta, Alison, NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, fingersplints, falcon45ca, tedxtr

I don't like how people said 'i am happy with these lynches' this is a sentence that shows lack of concern for being wrong and they are apparently scum hunting but not all of them.

[Michelle]

Players I feel best about in the Trustfall/Distrustfall exercise: Hally, Alison, SPF, Falcon
Players I feel pretty good about, but not quite as good as above: Bo, Strawhenge
Players I felt better about than I expected to: Michelle, Esooa, KZA
Players I was ambivalent about/could go either way: fingersplints, Long Con, TSP, Oddmerta, JPIC

That leaves me with the following players in a group that I felt more strongly about in the distrustfall than the trustfall exercise:
al_sama, dom, nanook, ted

That is four names, and four is almost certainly not enough to net us all of the mafia members left in the game.
I did not include a tier for "players I felt worse about than I expected." If I had done that, Odd and fingersplints would have been the names on the list. I do not wish to give the impression that either of them are outright suspects right now, but if anyone took a hit in this exercise, it was the two of them.

I have no read on JPIC except that he's not aligned with Marmot. I do not have time to sort him out this instant.

Reading this post and Dom's Iso i don't understand how everyone let him be no matter alignament.
And I don't understand how come this idea that no one is pushing him generated in a town read for Dom, i know i read this but idk who posted it

Also I don't understand why is everyone so reluctant in voting Nanook

[Hally]

Does anyone have a feeling that wolves are happy with the gamestate? i am looking at the 2 big wagons and not grewing counters and i like both Ted and Tony and I am terribly confused

Full VC

Spoiler: show

Who's not cooperating?
Poll runs till Sun Apr 11, 2021 1:00 am
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


AL_sama
1
5%
Voters: staypositivefriend
Alison
0
No votes
Voters: None
BoKnows
0
No votes
Voters: None
Dom
0
No votes
Voters: None
Esooa
1
5%
Voters: Esooa
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
fingersplints
0
No votes
Voters: None
Hally
0
No votes
Voters: None
Justplayingitcool
0
No votes
Voters: None
KZA
0
No votes
Voters: None
Long Con
0
No votes
Voters: None
Marmot
0
No votes
Voters: None
Michelle
0
No votes
Voters: None
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
2
9%
Voters: Michelle, Sloonei
Oddmerta
0
No votes
Voters: None
Sloonei
0
No votes
Voters: None
staypositivefriend
0
No votes
Voters: None
Strawhenge
0
No votes
Voters: None
tedxtr
7
32%
Voters: Justplayingitcool, Strawhenge, Hally, AL_sama, TonyStarkPrime, BoKnows, KZA
TonyStarkPrime
6
27%
Voters: Oddmerta, Alison, NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, fingersplints, falcon45ca, tedxtr
Unvote
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Elimination
0
No votes
Voters: None
I'm cooperatin' here darn tooting! (Host/Dead/Non)
5
23%
Voters: MacDougall, nutella, novaselinenever, JaggedJimmyJay, Marmot
Total votes: 22

And the 2 biggest wagons

tedxtr
7
32%
Voters: Justplayingitcool, Strawhenge, Hally, AL_sama, TonyStarkPrime, BoKnows, KZA
TonyStarkPrime
6
27%
Voters: Oddmerta, Alison, NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, fingersplints, falcon45ca, tedxtr

I don't like how people said 'i am happy with these lynches' this is a sentence that shows lack of concern for being wrong and they are apparently scum hunting but not all of them.

well tony and ted have emerged as suspects because of some good work done by both dead villagers and living (likely) villagers, so it’s not as though we’ve arbitrarily decided they should be the wagons. and particularly in a multiball setup, most people itt will not be teamed with ted or tony if either is a wolf and will be fine with their lunch. marmot was eliminated with 9 votes and he was a wolf. thread dynamics are just different in a multiball environment because there’s villagers AND wolves hunting wolves

[Hally]

[VOTE: nook] aubergine

[Michelle]

post #6100 says at distrusfall that I caused a ruckus.
What make you think I would risk to attract attention to myself if i were scum @BoKnows, what benefit I would have?
Your way of playing is in your villa meta, but this logic is twisted

[falcon45ca]

Players I feel best about in the Trustfall/Distrustfall exercise: Hally, Alison, SPF, Falcon
Players I feel pretty good about, but not quite as good as above: Bo, Strawhenge
Players I felt better about than I expected to: Michelle, Esooa, KZA
Players I was ambivalent about/could go either way: fingersplints, Long Con, TSP, Oddmerta, JPIC

That leaves me with the following players in a group that I felt more strongly about in the distrustfall than the trustfall exercise:
al_sama, dom, nanook, ted

That is four names, and four is almost certainly not enough to net us all of the mafia members left in the game.
I did not include a tier for "players I felt worse about than I expected." If I had done that, Odd and fingersplints would have been the names on the list. I do not wish to give the impression that either of them are outright suspects right now, but if anyone took a hit in this exercise, it was the two of them.

I have no read on JPIC except that he's not aligned with Marmot. I do not have time to sort him out this instant.

Reading this post and Dom's Iso i don't understand how everyone let him be no matter alignament.
And I don't understand how come this idea that no one is pushing him generated in a town read for Dom, i know i read this but idk who posted it

Also I don't understand why is everyone so reluctant in voting Nanook

Who's reluctant?

[VOTE: VOTE NOOK] aubergine

[Hally]

post #6100 says at distrusfall that I caused a ruckus.
What make you think I would risk to attract attention to myself if i were scum @BoKnows, what benefit I would have?
Your way of playing is in your villa meta, but this logic is twisted

the point of a distrustful is to actively search for reasons that every player could be a wolf. it’s not a wolf read. he’s just saying IF he were to look for a reason to wolf read you, that’s the reason he’d come up with

[Michelle]

Does anyone have a feeling that wolves are happy with the gamestate? i am looking at the 2 big wagons and not grewing counters and i like both Ted and Tony and I am terribly confused

Full VC

Spoiler: show

Who's not cooperating?
Poll runs till Sun Apr 11, 2021 1:00 am
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


AL_sama
1
5%
Voters: staypositivefriend
Alison
0
No votes
Voters: None
BoKnows
0
No votes
Voters: None
Dom
0
No votes
Voters: None
Esooa
1
5%
Voters: Esooa
falcon45ca
0
No votes
Voters: None
fingersplints
0
No votes
Voters: None
Hally
0
No votes
Voters: None
Justplayingitcool
0
No votes
Voters: None
KZA
0
No votes
Voters: None
Long Con
0
No votes
Voters: None
Marmot
0
No votes
Voters: None
Michelle
0
No votes
Voters: None
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
2
9%
Voters: Michelle, Sloonei
Oddmerta
0
No votes
Voters: None
Sloonei
0
No votes
Voters: None
staypositivefriend
0
No votes
Voters: None
Strawhenge
0
No votes
Voters: None
tedxtr
7
32%
Voters: Justplayingitcool, Strawhenge, Hally, AL_sama, TonyStarkPrime, BoKnows, KZA
TonyStarkPrime
6
27%
Voters: Oddmerta, Alison, NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, fingersplints, falcon45ca, tedxtr
Unvote
0
No votes
Voters: None
No Elimination
0
No votes
Voters: None
I'm cooperatin' here darn tooting! (Host/Dead/Non)
5
23%
Voters: MacDougall, nutella, novaselinenever, JaggedJimmyJay, Marmot
Total votes: 22

And the 2 biggest wagons

tedxtr
7
32%
Voters: Justplayingitcool, Strawhenge, Hally, AL_sama, TonyStarkPrime, BoKnows, KZA
TonyStarkPrime
6
27%
Voters: Oddmerta, Alison, NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, fingersplints, falcon45ca, tedxtr

I don't like how people said 'i am happy with these lynches' this is a sentence that shows lack of concern for being wrong and they are apparently scum hunting but not all of them.

well tony and ted have emerged as suspects because of some good work done by both dead villagers and living (likely) villagers, so it’s not as though we’ve arbitrarily decided they should be the wagons. and particularly in a multiball setup, most people itt will not be teamed with ted or tony if either is a wolf and will be fine with their lunch. marmot was eliminated with 9 votes and he was a wolf. thread dynamics are just different in a multiball environment because there’s villagers AND wolves hunting wolves

I know this, but wolves are not really hurting each other so early in a multiball, they try to read the other team and are helping each other to mischop. Scumhunting is a thing, but they are faking it, so who is complacent is a question mark for me.

I agree, each team killed the most dangerous townie for them, i will search in the morning for their Poe. But if they were wrong, killing them and after accusing people based on their Poe is a good scum tactic and I know people in this game who would do it

[Michelle]

post #6100 says at distrusfall that I caused a ruckus.
What make you think I would risk to attract attention to myself if i were scum @BoKnows, what benefit I would have?
Your way of playing is in your villa meta, but this logic is twisted

the point of a distrustful is to actively search for reasons that every player could be a wolf. it’s not a wolf read. he’s just saying IF he were to look for a reason to wolf read you, that’s the reason he’d come up with

That's exactly my town indicative, so who played with me lately should know it.
I forgot to say, probably because I want to forget that game, i was scum recently at Bo's homesite with him, replacing Alison. My play in that game was nothing like in this game, but Bo seems to ignore that piece of meta..

[Michelle]

Btw Hally, what's your conclusion of the game i linked?

[Hally]

i’m not sheeping jay and mac’s reads because they died, i’m sheeping their reads because they’re jay and mac. i’d sheep them if they were alive too

[Hally]

Btw Hally, what's your conclusion of the game i linked?

you’re probably a villager

[Michelle]

Update: I don't have to wash dishes tonight after all. Life is good. I'll be home from work earlier and more energized!

[Michelle]

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME
4
18%
Voters: Michelle, falcon45ca, Sloonei, Hally

tedxtr
6
27%
Voters: Justplayingitcool, Strawhenge, AL_sama, TonyStarkPrime, BoKnows, KZA

TonyStarkPrime
5
23%
Voters: Oddmerta, Alison, NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, fingersplints, tedxtr


Slight change in better

Spoiler: show

i am watching wagonomics, hope it works to catch scum again

[Hally]

i also looked at w!michelle’s posts in spiderverse and there’s a marked difference to here, so that strengthens my v read on her

[Michelle]

Btw Hally, what's your conclusion of the game i linked?

you’re probably a villager

I am a villager

[Michelle]

And i have to sleep, is 2am

[Hally]

night mich

[Hally]

spf hasn’t solved the game yet therefore she’s a wolf. my logic is flawless

[staypositivefriend]

@staypositivefriend where’s your head at?

i don't carry the resounding confidence that everyone else in this game does that falcon is a villager, but i do think that he is probably just a villager. i don't currently have a reason to be concerned about him and i don't intend to tinfoil this slot unless it's proven that the consensus POE is broken.

there have been some small moments from tedextr that have made me doubt myself, (mostly just the authenticity of emotion in some of his more recent posting, but i am deliberately refusing to base my reads on that foundation) but i still find him holistically pretty wolfy. i have zero issue with his slot being resolved

nanook has been a slot that i've mostly ignored reading throughout this game, for whatever reason. i usually think that nanook's alignment is obvious as either alignment (ie: i read him as mafia immediately in the zelda mash, i read him as town immediately in bread mafia), but he's been in this weird neutral space where most of the posts that he has made have completely unmoved me in either direction. the lack of clarity that i feel about nanook's alignment indicates to me that he might just be a wolf - i am doubtful that i would have this little to say about nanook's posting if he was a villager

i haven't untangled whether or not alison being a villager also makes oddmerta a villager by default. i'm not sure if it does. regardless, i have found oddmerta's posting mildly villagery. he would probably be the top of my priority list to sort if the POE ended up being way off, but he is a slot that i'm also not very concerned about right now

i still feel that sloonei is a villager. i have very much felt myself being in line with his solving today and i have been given zero reason to believe that he's playing w/a ulterior motive. his solving is good. his lines of reasoning are good and easy to follow. his reads align with mine. i am not currently concerned about the sloonei slot

i have carried a secret tinfoil wolfread on esooa for a little while now . i know that wolf!esooa loves to subvert her meta, and i felt that her lack of investment in this game could have been an attempt to subvert her meta from fallout mafia for the sake of looking townier. esooa made a post yesterday that said: "if you want an easy reason to clear me, then just compare this game to how i played in fallout mafia!". that concerned me and validated that my worry about esooa could be coming from a reasonable place. i am also skeptical about how confidently esooa townreads me in this game, as much as i like it

even so, esooa is not on the top of my priority list to sort due to her claim, and due to the fact that i have still found her posts mostly villagery. i do think there's some truth to the idea that esooa would be more interested in the narrative and direction of this game if she was a wolf. she's a slot that i would come back to if we've wiped out the majority of the POE and things are looking bad.

strawhenge has made a couple of posts that have raised my eyebrows and pinged me the slightest bit. i still feel that they are most likely a villager based on the overwhelming villageryness of their early posting.

if i'm putting mechanics aside, then KZA is still in my POE, although not top priority. i have not sorted out whether or not alison's claim makes KZA a villager

Dom is rand. i have no opinion on his alignment and i'm skeptical of those who say they do. i have no idea. his slot should probably be resolved at some point.

i wolflean TSP, but i find myself scrambling into knots every time I try to articulate my thoughts on him. a lot of his posts just feel off to me - as though i am watching someone take a picture of another person scumhunting, as opposed to watching him scumhunt himself. i might ISO him and see if i can put some of those thoughts into words. i wolflean him.

some posts from long con have felt pretty villagery to me. i don't feel that i can comfortably take him out of my POE.

i remain fairly neutral about fingersplints. i feel that she is a plausible fit as a member of either wolf team, but there is nothing about her that particularly stands out to me as wolfy

i have found JPIC's posts significantly more villagery than in the one game where i saw him as a wolf - make of that what you will. he is in the upper echelons of my POE. not my preferred chop at all

michelle had a strong opening, and has done nothing since then that i have found particularly villagery. i think that she may just be a wolf on autopilot that is scrambling to keep up with the pace of the game. not my preferred chop but would probably sort sooner than later

i think that alison is a villager

i lean village on BoKnows. the level of comfort to his game is not the type of comfort that i feel a wolf would easily be able to replicate

i wolfread al_sama. almost all of their posts have pinged me. i have seen nothing today that changes my perspective about him. would chop.

[staypositivefriend]

spf hasn’t solved the game yet therefore she’s a wolf. my logic is flawless

LMAOOOOO the timing of this coming immediately before my giant wall is so perfect

[Esooa]

I only read the parts mentioning me and all I have to say is:

Be paranoid, feed it, I love it

Try and kill me

You can't

I can't die

[Hally]

incredible x post

[falcon45ca]

@staypositivefriend where’s your head at?

i don't carry the resounding confidence that everyone else in this game does that falcon is a villager, but i do think that he is probably just a villager. i don't currently have a reason to be concerned about him and i don't intend to tinfoil this slot unless it's proven that the consensus POE is broken.

there have been some small moments from tedextr that have made me doubt myself, (mostly just the authenticity of emotion in some of his more recent posting, but i am deliberately refusing to base my reads on that foundation) but i still find him holistically pretty wolfy. i have zero issue with his slot being resolved

nanook has been a slot that i've mostly ignored reading throughout this game, for whatever reason. i usually think that nanook's alignment is obvious as either alignment (ie: i read him as mafia immediately in the zelda mash, i read him as town immediately in bread mafia), but he's been in this weird neutral space where most of the posts that he has made have completely unmoved me in either direction. the lack of clarity that i feel about nanook's alignment indicates to me that he might just be a wolf - i am doubtful that i would have this little to say about nanook's posting if he was a villager

i haven't untangled whether or not alison being a villager also makes oddmerta a villager by default. i'm not sure if it does. regardless, i have found oddmerta's posting mildly villagery. he would probably be the top of my priority list to sort if the POE ended up being way off, but he is a slot that i'm also not very concerned about right now

i still feel that sloonei is a villager. i have very much felt myself being in line with his solving today and i have been given zero reason to believe that he's playing w/a ulterior motive. his solving is good. his lines of reasoning are good and easy to follow. his reads align with mine. i am not currently concerned about the sloonei slot

i have carried a secret tinfoil wolfread on esooa for a little while now . i know that wolf!esooa loves to subvert her meta, and i felt that her lack of investment in this game could have been an attempt to subvert her meta from fallout mafia for the sake of looking townier. esooa made a post yesterday that said: "if you want an easy reason to clear me, then just compare this game to how i played in fallout mafia!". that concerned me and validated that my worry about esooa could be coming from a reasonable place. i am also skeptical about how confidently esooa townreads me in this game, as much as i like it

even so, esooa is not on the top of my priority list to sort due to her claim, and due to the fact that i have still found her posts mostly villagery. i do think there's some truth to the idea that esooa would be more interested in the narrative and direction of this game if she was a wolf. she's a slot that i would come back to if we've wiped out the majority of the POE and things are looking bad.

strawhenge has made a couple of posts that have raised my eyebrows and pinged me the slightest bit. i still feel that they are most likely a villager based on the overwhelming villageryness of their early posting.

if i'm putting mechanics aside, then KZA is still in my POE, although not top priority. i have not sorted out whether or not alison's claim makes KZA a villager

Dom is rand. i have no opinion on his alignment and i'm skeptical of those who say they do. i have no idea. his slot should probably be resolved at some point.

i wolflean TSP, but i find myself scrambling into knots every time I try to articulate my thoughts on him. a lot of his posts just feel off to me - as though i am watching someone take a picture of another person scumhunting, as opposed to watching him scumhunt himself. i might ISO him and see if i can put some of those thoughts into words. i wolflean him.

some posts from long con have felt pretty villagery to me. i don't feel that i can comfortably take him out of my POE.

i remain fairly neutral about fingersplints. i feel that she is a plausible fit as a member of either wolf team, but there is nothing about her that particularly stands out to me as wolfy

i have found JPIC's posts significantly more villagery than in the one game where i saw him as a wolf - make of that what you will. he is in the upper echelons of my POE. not my preferred chop at all

michelle had a strong opening, and has done nothing since then that i have found particularly villagery. i think that she may just be a wolf on autopilot that is scrambling to keep up with the pace of the game. not my preferred chop but would probably sort sooner than later

i think that alison is a villager

i lean village on BoKnows. the level of comfort to his game is not the type of comfort that i feel a wolf would easily be able to replicate

i wolfread al_sama. almost all of their posts have pinged me. i have seen nothing today that changes my perspective about him. would chop.

Holy fuck, I can't read this.


I'm already reading Bleak House, and I don't have time for another Epic Novel

[Hally]

spf hasn’t solved the game yet therefore she’s a wolf. my logic is flawless

LMAOOOOO the timing of this coming immediately before my giant wall is so perfect

i knew you would post that just now. we’re telepathically linked, remember?

[Esooa]

spf hasn’t solved the game yet therefore she’s a wolf. my logic is flawless

LMAOOOOO the timing of this coming immediately before my giant wall is so perfect

i knew you would post that just now. we’re telepathically linked, remember?

jealous tbh

[Hally]

thanks spf. i think the only major disagreement we have is that i think michelle is a villager

what do you think of her recent posting?

[Esooa]

me when hally says villager

[Hally]

me when hally says villager

at least i don’t say civilian like @JaggedJimmyJay

[Hally]

how can you call someone town? the people are IN the town. they aren’t the town. the town is full of villagers. a town is a place and a villager is a person. get with it esooa

[Esooa]

just call them a towny