Cindy Kate & Percy Date Night Mafia <3 [ENDGAME]

[MacDougall]

what if the poisoner is tangy?

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I am very wary of such red herrings because I implement them all the time as a host.

I’ve never played a game that used red herring mechanics (not saying they don’t exist lol). Is this a common thing on this site?

Yes. Role claiming used to be against the rules entirely in most games. Ours is a culture built around solving games with reads more than with roles.

[Allcrab]

To be clear: are you claiming a full watcher with no limited shots?

Correct.

And you’re completely cool with lost monkey’s role being a weak version of yours? Not meant to be a butthead question, just looking to understand Allcrab better.

Nah it cool.

Again don't see the value in that being a wolf role and he was 100% telling the truth because I got same results that they did but as I've said I could be completely wrong on that but it's a as you say solving the hosts more than lomo kinda thing although idk he's been kinda cool with me and my claim and feel like he wouldn't as a wolf.

I don’t think there would be two watchers in the game, one being x-shot and one being full use. That feels odd to me. I know you say you don’t see a scum reason to have a watcher, and I can agree with that. But can you explain the logics of town having two watchers like this?

Red herring plant by the hosts to punish us for trying to solve mechanically.

And you think they did the same thing with healers?

Not really I think martin is a wolf I'm just humoring alison because I think orange can also be a wolf and an 11 vote circlejerk on martin would be boring.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

what if the poisoner is tangy?

That was the second name to come to mind.

I do think her early game enthusiasm was more town-indicative though.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

what if the poisoner is tangy?

Not interested while mafia are alive

[Seanzie]

what if the poisoner is tangy?

I'm tellin' ya:

[Actvscenei]

Anyone want to take a stab at a poisoner read? First name that comes to mind?

JaggedJimmyJay

NGL I kinda have thought this but JJJ been sticking their neck out too far to be 3p.

GTH I think it's nanook.

Could be. Or Actv.

Act was the first name for me. My reasons for that are as follows:

Spoiler: show

no reasons

she has a sense of desperation mixed with desire to low fly

Can you explain more what you mean here? I’ve been in the top three most posting PerC players...so like lol. No.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Sloonei is town and will resolve himself anyway. If there’s another Syndicate mafioso that doesn’t demand undue tinfoil, nobody is left but Made and Martin.

[Sloonei]

I think people should only give suggestions for wolves for Sloonei to shoot. None of this "oh shoot me, it will do us good" crap I'm seeing from Orange and AllCrab. Unless you're admitting to a wolf, you should give a target that you think is a wolf to help Sloonei decide and to help us read you.

Yes

[MacDougall]

what if the poisoner is tangy?

Not interested while mafia are alive

Jay asked.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

what if the poisoner is tangy?

Not interested while mafia are alive

Jay asked.

Reasonable

[MacDougall]

bum bum tam tam

[MacDougall]

[Sloonei]

how bout made. what do we think of made?

Day 1 wagonomics are in his favor.

[Sloonei]

I am going to Read.

[MacDougall]

I am going to Read.

where's that?

[Sloonei]

I am going to Read.

where's that?

just north of shitterton.

[MacDougall]

I am going to Read.

where's that?

just north of shitterton.

heh

[Sloonei]

Okay nutella's ISO is pretty fluffy for how big it is but it's not so bad as to warrant them being a runaway wagon like this so that's pinging me after I do Owner I need to see what everyone's reasons are for voting there.

Owner can definitely be a wolf they're not going after anyone the way they usually do as village and they feel less paranoid than usual.

allcrab is town based on these two posts back-to-back.

[Seanzie]

[VOTE: OrangeCrush] aubergine

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Thanks Sloonei will take as irrefutable gospel

[Sloonei]

I expect Belzy, Owner and Seanzie at the least to post enough to give reads and am sad they're not here yet.

The hallowed Rule of Three.

[Sloonei]

I thought most Syndicate players had Nutella as townie, no? Why is Jay reading them as town wrong? Did I miss something here?

Also, when did Jay call Owner town, she only just started playing?

There has been very little on-topic chatter about nutella to this point in Sonny's iso. A sudden statement indicating sharp awareness of nutella reads is jarring.

[Sloonei]

No one's commented on my vote.

Oh hey, you voted. When did that happen?

Was it the Kito read? If not, why?

Couple hours ago.

I don't want to talk about why it's there just yet. I simply want it to be acknowledged that my vote is where it is.

Ok. Sure [validation given].

I should have pressed harder here. I don't love that Sonny, who has had absolutely nothing to say about Hawk, is equipped with a speculative reason for me to suspect her on Day 1 in the first post. I also do not like that he had absolutely nothing to say when I answered him in the goofiest way possible. But it was 2 in the morning, and I wasn't paying attention.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Is there a reason I'm missing that you're reading sonny/orange for spew

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Also if you can put all this in one post so I van ignore it more easily id appreciate it

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Also if you can put all this in one post so I van ignore it more easily id appreciate it

It’s good stuff tho

[Sloonei]

Well, unless I'm not following then maybe I'm drunk too

who's maf

I'm bothered by Belzy's lack of well, Belzy, and Owner just pinged me. Still don't know what Bunny is doing.

Hawks vote timing was poor too, but I'm not sold on Made.

Have only been skimming the thread at work so am behind, getting there.

A messy salad.

[Sloonei]

Is there a reason I'm missing that you're reading sonny/orange for spew

I have a gun and I'm trying to figure out where to point it.

If I make a bunch of short observations it looks more ominous.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Also if you can put all this in one post so I van ignore it more easily id appreciate it

It’s good stuff tho

Eh maybe I'll iso orange today and update my read but im still defaulted to a TR

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Is there a reason I'm missing that you're reading sonny/orange for spew

I have a gun and I'm trying to figure out where to point it.

If I make a bunch of short observations it looks more ominous.

Just shoot martin imo

Or if you value the Alison read shoot crabs

[Sloonei]

Is there a reason I'm missing that you're reading sonny/orange for spew

I have a gun and I'm trying to figure out where to point it.

If I make a bunch of short observations it looks more ominous.

Just shoot martin imo

Or if you value the Alison read shoot crabs

But I just called allcrab town.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Is there a reason I'm missing that you're reading sonny/orange for spew

I have a gun and I'm trying to figure out where to point it.

If I make a bunch of short observations it looks more ominous.

Just shoot martin imo

Or if you value the Alison read shoot crabs

But I just called allcrab town.

I mean I lowkey think an every night watcher claim is kinda outing, literally every other flip or claim is one shot and one one shot one every night watcher (admittedly different varieties, still tho) is kinda fucked up

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

It sticks out from the rest of the claims and flips like a sore thumb

[MacDougall]

lowkey

[MacDougall]

Dana, Kito and Gavial all unlimited btw.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

I loki think it

[Sloonei]

Is there a reason I'm missing that you're reading sonny/orange for spew

I have a gun and I'm trying to figure out where to point it.

If I make a bunch of short observations it looks more ominous.

Just shoot martin imo

Or if you value the Alison read shoot crabs

But I just called allcrab town.

I mean I lowkey think an every night watcher claim is kinda outing, literally every other flip or claim is one shot and one one shot one every night watcher (admittedly different varieties, still tho) is kinda fucked up

This is reasonable. I was a 1-shot role that turned into a different 1-shot role.

[Sloonei]

Dana, Kito and Gavial all unlimited btw.

This is also a point.

[Sloonei]

Unlimited shot watcher is a much more powerful role than an unlimited shot bodyguard, though.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Dana, Kito and Gavial all unlimited btw.

Sure, point

They're also three negative utility roles

Arguably bodyguard isn't negative utility, its sideways really, but

Point stands, the good stuff has all been gated and the negative stuff has not

[MacDougall]

Unlimited shot watcher is a much more powerful role than an unlimited shot bodyguard, though.

when did all town PR needing to be equal become a thing?

[MacDougall]

@Seanzie are you unlimited?

[MacDougall]

If I had the desperado shot I'd always shoot Jay. I'm not even joking. Either you kill the deepest of wolves or confirm Jay.

[Sloonei]

@orangecrush I am currently leaning towards using my shot on you. You are not allowed to say that you want me to do this. If you are town, shooting you ensures a town death. Please give me a better name to pick than yours.

[Seanzie]

@Seanzie are you unlimited?

I'm VT. I just guessed with that Owner shit

[Sloonei]

@Seanzie are you unlimited?

I'm VT. I just guessed with that Owner shit

lol

[Sloonei]

I have not actually seen/read the posts where allcrab or martin roleclaim.

[NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME]

Least believable claim so far

[Sloonei]

I have determined that actv is not aligned with Owner and nutella. She ain't gettin' shot. in case this was an idea on anyone's mind. I am not up to date.