Traitors for Exile

[Poison]

Well we only have until Wednesday to figure it out. Who's been the most quiet since the start?

You?


Is this really the best way to find scum tho, just lynch the low posters?

Exactly, we should just find them differently. I heard Traitors would sweat when you look them in the eye.

Where did you hear that?



Do you have anymore tips for catching Traitors? Cuz you should share your knowledge with the class

Well I'm friends with all sorts of people.

Yes,

We would pressure the shit out of few people and record their reaction if they go OMGUS we town read them mostly but if they are being weird we lynch them.

Oh,

We should also say how shitty the shitposter are, not funny at all. We would get impressive results.

[Poison]

10 mins left before I get to roll on the floor laughing at the miserable failure that is Toronto.

Sorry I'm on the floor, it is my arena for rolling. You can take the stairs.

BTW, are you a Traitor?

[falcon45ca]

10 mins left before I get to roll on the floor laughing at the miserable failure that is Toronto.

why no response to the red check on you?

I don't believe red checks on me when I'm town.



Also, someone red checked me?

[falcon45ca]

10 mins left before I get to roll on the floor laughing at the miserable failure that is Toronto.

Sorry I'm on the floor, it is my arena for rolling. You can take the stairs.

BTW, are you a Traitor?

Hold on, lemme check.

[Poison]

10 mins left before I get to roll on the floor laughing at the miserable failure that is Toronto.

why no response to the red check on you?

I don't believe red checks on me when I'm town.



Also, someone red checked me?

1. You are a failed litmus paper of you are checked red when you are town.

2. Yes.

[Poison]

Oh i read wrong. My bad falcon

[Poison]

Wait DEBIL IS PLAYING!!!!! MARMOT AMD LC TOO. I like this game.

[Gira]

not to towntell or anything but this thing started? lol

[falcon45ca]

Well we only have until Wednesday to figure it out. Who's been the most quiet since the start?

You?


Is this really the best way to find scum tho, just lynch the low posters?

I've been thinking about this and it might not be a bad play to kill whoever seems most afraid to ruffle feathers on D1

we're in a unique mafia environment where NOBODY has TMI so I'm open to hearing other strategies

I dunno, why would Traitors be afraid of ruffling feathers? They don't know who's on their team, I don't think they'd care.

[Poison]

Guys, y'all are dumb.

The host has already declared one Traitor for us.

Look at voting poll.

The host says "I work with him"

And we know the famous saying, "If you know the criminal and keep sush about it, you are the equal criminal they are]

The host knows who the criminals are. The traitors. He is the criminal along with them.

But we can spare the host.

So basically he said he works with Murphy. So Murphy is the Traitor.


Ez.

[falcon45ca]

not to towntell or anything but this thing started? lol

No, it starts 1 hour before NF. That's when shit gets real

[Poison]

not to towntell or anything but this thing started? lol

Ikr. I wish Syndicate had some push notifications. Sometimes I just forget to check the site.

[Poison]

Also, no one replies to my exile confusion.

[Gira]

The thing about the exile vote is if we pick one player to keep sending and we are wrong on that player then we lose the game EoN3.

We can improve on that by picking two players and alternating. Even if we are wrong on one, we lose either EoN5 or EoN6 at the earliest.

If we pick a different player every night we shouldn't ever lose but actually the second option might also be a valid alternative here.

I like the alternate idea tbh.

Why don’t we just send the cop so we don’t ever lose via exile and the franer/lawyer traitor can’t fuck with is?

what a terrible post

[falcon45ca]

Hahahahaha, Maple Laffs never let ya down...unless you're a fan

[Poison]

Hahahahaha, Maple Laffs never let ya down...unless you're a fan

What?






I'm going to bed. Will read the thread when I come back

[Gira]

even though the mechanical stuff is easy i wanna call wiml town regardless

[Gira]

not to towntell or anything but this thing started? lol

Ikr. I wish Syndicate had some push notifications. Sometimes I just forget to check the site.

tbf first game here and i had no idea when it'd start, you're lucky i checked the site out of boredom

[falcon45ca]

Also, no one replies to my exile confusion.

what's the confusion?

[KZA]

Well we only have until Wednesday to figure it out. Who's been the most quiet since the start?

You?


Is this really the best way to find scum tho, just lynch the low posters?

I've been thinking about this and it might not be a bad play to kill whoever seems most afraid to ruffle feathers on D1

we're in a unique mafia environment where NOBODY has TMI so I'm open to hearing other strategies

I dunno, why would Traitors be afraid of ruffling feathers? They don't know who's on their team, I don't think they'd care.

Well they can't lose if they don't get chopped. I think a lot of players, if they randed traitor, would want to pocket/cuddle up to the rest of the roster and skate by in that fashion. Of course I expect at least 1 of the traitors to be a confident wolf that will give us trouble, but on D1 I think I POE and shoot in that pool

[Gira]

I wonder how we'll find the traitors

Do you think the traitors will try to contact eachother? Should we look for softs?

this post is Look At Me I'm So Traitor

[KZA]

current standing

Not Chopping:
KZA - yes this is KZA

MacDougall - cop, wants me to die as is tradition
Marmot - My gut is on a hot streak reading Marmot off his openers so I'll trust it again
falcon45ca - Good ol Falc
112 - I enjoy the brazen FoS of Sparkles and think the thought process has looked good. I'm not really concerned about being called stilted by them it happens to me a decent amount as town
MissSparkles - High posting, asking decent questions, doesn't seem to care about creating friction with other players

WimI - Kinda mixed thoughts here. Is posting a lot, but has seemed kind of, idk friendly/agreeing with a lot of people which could be at traitor attempting to integrate quickly. This could just be playstyle thing too. I'll wait and see if they get a little pointier. I do like their mech plan from early. Either way I'm probably not going here today.

Currently Willing to Chop:
KGMurphy
Long Con
Gira
Creature
Poison
Wisdom
cat
Auwt

these are lower content slots to this point so I'll just wait and see who posts themselves in to towniness

[KZA]

oh Gira is here and they're straight to business, kind of like it

[Gira]

So do we believe the host would force the cop to claim yay or nay?

Seems weird but if we're in a setup where it is pretty much optimal for the cop to claim immediately then I don't see why not (it would prevent a player who is less experienced or a lurker from playing suboptimally if they randed the role and causing town to perform worse as a result).

I'm happy to just believe that Mac is the cop and telling the truth about whatever unless he gets counterclaimed.

If I was a traitor i’d counterclaim though.

oddly i believe this even though counterclaiming is unoptimal given town has a backup

We have a heavy reliance on the cop this game I think (thankfully there's a backup, on the off chance that there's a cc), which means that them claiming might not be in our best interest yet, because it'll give the Anti-Cop more info into who they should frame.

That said, claiming early would prevent cc wars from going down.

whereas this is eh

[Gira]

Marmot knows I'm KZA

Marmot might just be town

How TF do you always get my alignment right from my very first post? Is it a me thing or a you thing.

I'd ask if you have TMI, but even if you're a traitor, you wouldn't know if I was lol.

do like this i suppose

[112]

kaz and i interact a lot and maybe i'm just not used to seeing him post a lot without saying something ironic or half-serious

but something really does feel off about him even when i try to ignore the non-mafia-playing kaz and focus on the mafia-playing one

[falcon45ca]

kaz and i interact a lot and maybe i'm just not used to seeing him post a lot without saying something ironic or half-serious

but something really does feel off about him even when i try to ignore the non-mafia-playing kaz and focus on the mafia-playing one

I tend to agree. He's copying up to me awful damn quick

[MissSparkles]

wait Poison is playing? don't vig me again

uhh that might actually be the correct move here.

I do make the right moves but the games are so wrong. Smh smh.

iktf. i am 100% at reading mac if you discard the games i've misread him.

Ikr. We should try reading him this game correctly. I don't like Mac when he is town and reads me wrong. But I hate scum!mac more.

Well we only have until Wednesday to figure it out. Who's been the most quiet since the start?

You?


Is this really the best way to find scum tho, just lynch the low posters?

Could be seen as scum trying to go for low hanging fruit so no, not really.

Are you talking about Murphy? You think it was a scummy post from her?

Nah I’m answering Fakcon saying it’s a always accurate way to hunt for scum since mafia do go after low hanging fruit

[falcon45ca]

kaz and i interact a lot and maybe i'm just not used to seeing him post a lot without saying something ironic or half-serious

but something really does feel off about him even when i try to ignore the non-mafia-playing kaz and focus on the mafia-playing one

I tend to agree. He's cozying up to me awful damn quick

Fixed

[MissSparkles]

Well we only have until Wednesday to figure it out. Who's been the most quiet since the start?

You?


Is this really the best way to find scum tho, just lynch the low posters?

I've been thinking about this and it might not be a bad play to kill whoever seems most afraid to ruffle feathers on D1

we're in a unique mafia environment where NOBODY has TMI so I'm open to hearing other strategies

I dunno, why would Traitors be afraid of ruffling feathers? They don't know who's on their team, I don't think they'd care.

I don’t think as a general rule they’d want to draw unwanted attention either which happens when you ruffle a few feathers.

[MissSparkles]

The thing about the exile vote is if we pick one player to keep sending and we are wrong on that player then we lose the game EoN3.

We can improve on that by picking two players and alternating. Even if we are wrong on one, we lose either EoN5 or EoN6 at the earliest.

If we pick a different player every night we shouldn't ever lose but actually the second option might also be a valid alternative here.

I like the alternate idea tbh.

Why don’t we just send the cop so we don’t ever lose via exile and the franer/lawyer traitor can’t fuck with is?

what a terrible post

Ok?

[MissSparkles]

I wonder how we'll find the traitors

Do you think the traitors will try to contact eachother? Should we look for softs?

this post is Look At Me I'm So Traitor

Yea we know lol

[MissSparkles]

So do we believe the host would force the cop to claim yay or nay?

Seems weird but if we're in a setup where it is pretty much optimal for the cop to claim immediately then I don't see why not (it would prevent a player who is less experienced or a lurker from playing suboptimally if they randed the role and causing town to perform worse as a result).

I'm happy to just believe that Mac is the cop and telling the truth about whatever unless he gets counterclaimed.

If I was a traitor i’d counterclaim though.

oddly i believe this even though counterclaiming is unoptimal given town has a backup

We have a heavy reliance on the cop this game I think (thankfully there's a backup, on the off chance that there's a cc), which means that them claiming might not be in our best interest yet, because it'll give the Anti-Cop more info into who they should frame.

That said, claiming early would prevent cc wars from going down.

whereas this is eh

Yea true I didn’t think about the backup. Probably would have if I actually drew traitor.

[Gira]

Idk scum like to go against the grain especially when it comes to placing doubt on the most vocal player.

He just gave me suspicion and keft, feels kinda agendy, NO TOWN LEAN FOR U 112

bolded is an interesting assertion because on its face i'd disagree with it although maybe we just have differing experiences. don't think that post from 112 is inherently scummy

the hyperactivity from sparkles in some places sketches me out because it seems like she's trying to reply to literally everything regardless of whether she has something to add, just to appear as involved as possible. but that may just be personal taste of finding it annoying overwhelming reads, on net probably town

[KZA]

kaz and i interact a lot and maybe i'm just not used to seeing him post a lot without saying something ironic or half-serious

but something really does feel off about him even when i try to ignore the non-mafia-playing kaz and focus on the mafia-playing one

Are you finding me scummy or is it mostly a difference in tone you're picking up?

fwiw I understand why I might attract this kind of read when I come in and play focused, TSP had similar thoughts on me in Fargo where I flipped town

I tend to agree. He's copying up to me awful damn quick

well I'm cozying up even harder because of posts like this

[MissSparkles]

oh Gira is here and they're straight to business, kind of like it

Kind of easy to fake “getting down to business” as a traitor considering the content, don’t you think? Let’s not make him look good when he isn’t really, although i’ve liked his input so far.

[KZA]

oh Gira is here and they're straight to business, kind of like it

Kind of easy to fake “getting down to business” as a traitor considering the content, don’t you think? Let’s not make him look good when he isn’t really, although i’ve liked his input so far.

I agree, definitely not too hard to fake that type of catchup, but they feel okay in real time

[Gira]

tbh what i've posted is entirely not out of scumrange, but also everything in this setup is entirely trivial to fake and getting real reads is next to impossible

on a technical level this isn't really mafia but YOLO

[Gira]

[VOTE: VOTE WIML] aubergine

Bit of backpedalling, sheeping reads, and too much insight into what LWs would or would not do for my taste

meh vote

[MissSparkles]

tbh what i've posted is entirely not out of scumrange, but also everything in this setup is entirely trivial to fake and getting real reads is next to impossible

on a technical level this isn't really mafia but YOLO

Figured, based on what you’ve responded too, you’re probably pretty good as scum. Probably pretty good as town too.

[Creature]

current standing

Not Chopping:
KZA - yes this is KZA

MacDougall - cop, wants me to die as is tradition
Marmot - My gut is on a hot streak reading Marmot off his openers so I'll trust it again
falcon45ca - Good ol Falc
112 - I enjoy the brazen FoS of Sparkles and think the thought process has looked good. I'm not really concerned about being called stilted by them it happens to me a decent amount as town
MissSparkles - High posting, asking decent questions, doesn't seem to care about creating friction with other players

WimI - Kinda mixed thoughts here. Is posting a lot, but has seemed kind of, idk friendly/agreeing with a lot of people which could be at traitor attempting to integrate quickly. This could just be playstyle thing too. I'll wait and see if they get a little pointier. I do like their mech plan from early. Either way I'm probably not going here today.

Currently Willing to Chop:
KGMurphy
Long Con
Gira
Creature
Poison
Wisdom
cat
Auwt

these are lower content slots to this point so I'll just wait and see who posts themselves in to towniness

I'm fine with this list

[Creature]

I feel like wolves itg have the incentive to be fairly active though

[112]

kaz and i interact a lot and maybe i'm just not used to seeing him post a lot without saying something ironic or half-serious

but something really does feel off about him even when i try to ignore the non-mafia-playing kaz and focus on the mafia-playing one

Are you finding me scummy or is it mostly a difference in tone you're picking up?

fwiw I understand why I might attract this kind of read when I come in and play focused, TSP had similar thoughts on me in Fargo where I flipped town

I tend to agree. He's copying up to me awful damn quick

well I'm cozying up even harder because of posts like this

i'd say much to most of it is tone, some of it is that beyond the tone you just don't seem as easygoing as usual

what sparked that post in particular was the list you posted. it felt like it was crafted to be offensive to the fewest amount of players as possible. it didn't have outright egregious or bad takes but it also didn't really inspire anything

[MissSparkles]

current standing

Not Chopping:
KZA - yes this is KZA

MacDougall - cop, wants me to die as is tradition
Marmot - My gut is on a hot streak reading Marmot off his openers so I'll trust it again
falcon45ca - Good ol Falc
112 - I enjoy the brazen FoS of Sparkles and think the thought process has looked good. I'm not really concerned about being called stilted by them it happens to me a decent amount as town
MissSparkles - High posting, asking decent questions, doesn't seem to care about creating friction with other players

WimI - Kinda mixed thoughts here. Is posting a lot, but has seemed kind of, idk friendly/agreeing with a lot of people which could be at traitor attempting to integrate quickly. This could just be playstyle thing too. I'll wait and see if they get a little pointier. I do like their mech plan from early. Either way I'm probably not going here today.

Currently Willing to Chop:
KGMurphy
Long Con
Gira
Creature
Poison
Wisdom
cat
Auwt

these are lower content slots to this point so I'll just wait and see who posts themselves in to towniness

So we basically have the same reads then? I’ve posted and gave reads to all the same players u have just didn’t MAKE A LIST. Mindmelding town or scum leech? Go on tell me why it’s a mindmeld and not a leech situation, here’s the mic 🎙

Although I’d swap out Wiml for 112. But I can see where you’re coming from re: Wiml.

[Creature]

I feel like wolves itg have the incentive to be fairly active though

Traitors will have to town up as they need to be among the top town either to be exiled or survive nightless.

[MissSparkles]

current standing

Not Chopping:
KZA - yes this is KZA

MacDougall - cop, wants me to die as is tradition
Marmot - My gut is on a hot streak reading Marmot off his openers so I'll trust it again
falcon45ca - Good ol Falc
112 - I enjoy the brazen FoS of Sparkles and think the thought process has looked good. I'm not really concerned about being called stilted by them it happens to me a decent amount as town
MissSparkles - High posting, asking decent questions, doesn't seem to care about creating friction with other players

WimI - Kinda mixed thoughts here. Is posting a lot, but has seemed kind of, idk friendly/agreeing with a lot of people which could be at traitor attempting to integrate quickly. This could just be playstyle thing too. I'll wait and see if they get a little pointier. I do like their mech plan from early. Either way I'm probably not going here today.

Currently Willing to Chop:
KGMurphy
Long Con
Gira
Creature
Poison
Wisdom
cat
Auwt

these are lower content slots to this point so I'll just wait and see who posts themselves in to towniness

I'm fine with this list

I mean so am I considering i’ve given the same reads.

[MissSparkles]

kaz and i interact a lot and maybe i'm just not used to seeing him post a lot without saying something ironic or half-serious

but something really does feel off about him even when i try to ignore the non-mafia-playing kaz and focus on the mafia-playing one

Are you finding me scummy or is it mostly a difference in tone you're picking up?

fwiw I understand why I might attract this kind of read when I come in and play focused, TSP had similar thoughts on me in Fargo where I flipped town

I tend to agree. He's copying up to me awful damn quick

well I'm cozying up even harder because of posts like this

i'd say much to most of it is tone, some of it is that beyond the tone you just don't seem as easygoing as usual

what sparked that post in particular was the list you posted. it felt like it was crafted to be offensive to the fewest amount of players as possible. it didn't have outright egregious or bad takes but it also didn't really inspire anything

It was a nice list of all my reads put together in a cute box with an even cuter ribbon wrapped around it

[MissSparkles]

KZA has been basically answering things with “Wait and See” all game so far, doesn’t seem like he really wants to go after anyone and “ruffle feathers”, yet has been giving reads (MINE) and offering thoughts on a lot of things.

Might wanna switch your avatar, cause like Gengar is not the vibe I’m getting, more like Humpty Dumpty before he falls from his wall

[Gira]

I feel like wolves itg have the incentive to be fairly active though

Traitors will have to town up as they need to be among the top town either to be exiled or survive nightless.

this is correct but also u might be scum

[KZA]

well I don't really feel like checking but I'm pretty sure I voiced town reads on Marmot, Falcon, and 112 before you...?

and it's not like anyone is gonna be townreading any of the orange names at this point