Gavial wrote: ↑Wed Jun 09, 2021 9:03 pm
I’m at the verge where I think Nanook and Syn are scum and their partner is Marmot or Mac.
Look Gavial, this theory isn't terrible. In fact, there's some validity to it. I just don't think it has as much strength as the world where Deli is the fakeclaims
I agree that it's an excellent claim from Nanook as wolf. In the world where Nanook is the wolf, presumably, his wolf team knew that there was no parity cop in the game Day 2, and with all of the other PRs having claimed or been killed at the start of Day 3, claiming parity between two non-PRs sets his team up for an easy win if Creature and I are both town.
But this makes a number of jumps in logic that point to Deli being the liar here.
1) Scum killed hollowkatt Night 2. With a JK and a Doctor claimed in thread, and assuming they didn't know who the tracker was, Nanook's team likely kills won of the protective roles, not the tracker. Which leads me to my next point.
2) Hollowkatt claimed that Deli was lying about his JK claim and target Night 1. It was not a CC, no. But hollowkatt was the tracker, and stating such a strong belief leaves an implication that he tracked Deli nowhere (I assume nowhere, but I suppose it's possible he was tracked to Wiml).
3) Nanook voted for me and called me out for a couple things on Day 2. Nanook did seem to want me yeeted, and said as much today, and I believe it's because he'd already had a peek on me as he's now claimed. What I'm saying is that there's evidence in the thread that Nanook was the parity cop already.
Yeah Nanook could be the liar here, I just think there's a lot more evidence on the contrary.