RPG Mafia MAFIA WIN

[dunya]

I don't really have a good idea of where I am at everyone else. I might be tempted to sheep NAA on Scotty because he seems to be accurate at reading Scotty.

I hope you die

(In the game)

I hope you live

(in real life too)

[MacDougall]

the case on creature is literally "he is doing his wolf meta of retreating into his shell when suspected"?
ngl that's a really weak reason to chop anyone and the only day you can get away with that is D1 so I'm not at all surprised really.

pretty fine reason and shieldy post tbh

[Scotty]

@Scotty did you read my scum game?

I got bits and pieces, and what I was looking for seems similar to this one. Which is why I’m not sold on you being town

[hollowkatt]

seems to me it's basically this:

what'd I miss? I'm like 400 posts behind and running on about 4 hrs of sleep

i added NAA and Rask to our towncore.

we think creature is firmly in his wolf meta

some people think scotty is wolfin

i do not understand any of creature's progression on me. i am left blind by the severity of omgus i just witnessed.

[VOTE: creature] aubergine

hate to be that person, but creature has distinctly different metas when wolf/town and so far, he is firmly in wolf meta.

I think we can all confidently say creature has sadly rolled wolf.

His wolf tell don't lie.

some nebulous "wolf tell", then an accusation of omgus, and then more meta discussion.

If I'm wrong great, but you'll have to show me where I'm wrong.

[hollowkatt]

the case on creature is literally "he is doing his wolf meta of retreating into his shell when suspected"?
ngl that's a really weak reason to chop anyone and the only day you can get away with that is D1 so I'm not at all surprised really.

pretty fine reason and shieldy post tbh

yeah I'm not sure I care though.

[TonyStarkPrime]

mac read creature

[dunya]

1.5 hrs till eod post count



Hammer is at 9
Poll runs till Tue Mar 15, 2022 12:00 am
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option


Creature
5
28%
Voters: dyachei, Scotty, Marmot, Le petit poussin, dunya
urist
0
No votes
Voters: None
Dolby
1
6%
Voters: DrWilgy
DrWilgy
0
No votes
Voters: None
Dunya
1
6%
Voters: Creature
dyachei
0
No votes
Voters: None
hollowkatt
0
No votes
Voters: None
Jackofhearts2005
0
No votes
Voters: None
Le petit poussin
1
6%
Voters: MacDougall
LinearPoint
2
11%
Voters: Dolby, hollowkatt
MacDougall
0
No votes
Voters: None
Marmot
0
No votes
Voters: None
NotAnAxehole
0
No votes
Voters: None
Scotty
6
33%
Voters: LinearPoint, Urist, Jackofhearts2005, TonyStarkPrime, NotAnAxehole, Syn
sig
0
No votes
Voters: None
syn
0
No votes
Voters: None
TonyStarkPrime
0
No votes
Voters: None
Sleep (can be hammered)
0
No votes
Voters: None
No vote (cannot be hammered)
0
No votes
Voters: None
Host/dead/spec
2
11%
Voters: NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME, juliets

[Dolby]

the case on creature is literally "he is doing his wolf meta of retreating into his shell when suspected"?
ngl that's a really weak reason to chop anyone and the only day you can get away with that is D1 so I'm not at all surprised really.

yeah last game I played with him was harry potter mash and he was suspected largely for defeatism that isn't really wolf meta for him he was town that game

[Dolby]

I'm not reading 500 posts before eod kinda forgot about the game sorry

[dunya]

@Scotty did you read my scum game?

I got bits and pieces, and what I was looking for seems similar to this one. Which is why I’m not sold on you being town

that's pretty vague but okay.

[MacDougall]

mac read creature

I already have. Creature is meh. He can be either alignment as meh in my recent experience. If he is town however it becomes relatively apparent.

[TonyStarkPrime]

mac read creature

I already have. Creature is meh. He can be either alignment as meh in my recent experience. If he is town however it becomes relatively apparent.

ok

[MacDougall]

the case on creature is literally "he is doing his wolf meta of retreating into his shell when suspected"?
ngl that's a really weak reason to chop anyone and the only day you can get away with that is D1 so I'm not at all surprised really.

yeah last game I played with him was harry potter mash and he was suspected largely for defeatism that isn't really wolf meta for him he was town that game

he was not suspected in that game for defeatism lol

[Scotty]

Creature’s meta aside:

-he hasn’t backed up any of his suspicions.
-he’s telegraphed that he’s not willing to put forth any effort on D1, but is still giving forth enough effort to give unsubstantiated suspicions

[hollowkatt]

the case on creature is literally "he is doing his wolf meta of retreating into his shell when suspected"?
ngl that's a really weak reason to chop anyone and the only day you can get away with that is D1 so I'm not at all surprised really.

yeah last game I played with him was harry potter mash and he was suspected largely for defeatism that isn't really wolf meta for him he was town that game

my last game was the amrock discord game. he was kinda deflated there too, lots of wolf reads on him on D1. Marry shot him D2 with moderate support. He was the one I was wrong on when I suggested he was a good shot. He was not a good shot.

I also played with him as wolf in the Rings game that just wrapped up here a few days ago or something like that. Very deflated wolf team that game ngl

[Dolby]

the case on creature is literally "he is doing his wolf meta of retreating into his shell when suspected"?
ngl that's a really weak reason to chop anyone and the only day you can get away with that is D1 so I'm not at all surprised really.

yeah last game I played with him was harry potter mash and he was suspected largely for defeatism that isn't really wolf meta for him he was town that game

he was not suspected in that game for defeatism lol

eh it felt like it essentially amounted to that imo. A lot of EoD3 and EoD4 from him he basically kinda just went "this feels liek a loss"

[Scotty]

mac read creature

I already have. Creature is meh. He can be either alignment as meh in my recent experience. If he is town however it becomes relatively apparent.

If I am mafia, it will become relatively apparent as the game goes on. Gods honest truth, I don’t make endgame.

Hell, ima be vigged before d3 at this rate anyway

[NotAnAxehole]

Hi Scotty

[dunya]

Syn, Scotty

DrWilgy, Marmot, NAA, HK

Urist, Dya, TSP, Jack, Dunia

Dolby, LP, Mac, Creature

--------------------

Syn, Scotty obv town
DrWilgy I like because of some mindmields (the Urist/dya stuff, stance on Mac's posts); Marmot because he seems careless and inquisitive enough (these switchs on Scotty, voting Dunia because she takes notes etc). I don't like the pushes but they still fit well with town!Marmot to me. NAA just don't give a crap lol and do his stuff. HK same (also no agenda/strong pushes is a town tell for him smh).

Dolby started by going crazy about CFCers towncoring, then posted that him low efforting was townie, then disappeared lmao. I won't die on that hill (happened already lol) but this is > rand scum.
LP because there is a real dichotomy between the stuff being pushed (early posters > rand wolves, HK/Syn fake, Marmot being opportunistic on Scotty) and the energy displayed. Like someone pushed the button a tidy bit too much and I am not vibing. Also I agree with whoever said she was fishing for claims yesterday.
Mac just seems too similar to our last game. Weak unexplained pushes. Feels pocketie again (I am not falling for cereals)
Creature was the first to speak about mechs (in what, 10 posts), but didn't follow up when I gave him the occasion to, which strikes me as too cautious and fishy. The vote on Dolby was awfully opportunistic (I can't say Creature has read anything hence I have a problem with that sort of pilling) too. This is the weakest lead I have because I am conflicted between him being cautious and lacking self-awareness. So I am prolly not ending there.

The rest are nulls rn.

[NotAnAxehole]

Scotty, gimme a town game I'll check it now.

[Scotty]

Posing this question to everyone:

What do we learn if I die and flip town?

[MacDougall]

rask is still scum fwiw

[NotAnAxehole]

I want to read you correctly, so if I'm wrong you gotta help me out here.

[dunya]

rask is still scum fwiw

i disagree bruh

[Dolby]

Syn, Scotty

DrWilgy, Marmot, NAA, HK

Urist, Dya, TSP, Jack, Dunia

Dolby, LP, Mac, Creature

--------------------

Syn, Scotty obv town
DrWilgy I like because of some mindmields (the Urist/dya stuff, stance on Mac's posts); Marmot because he seems careless and inquisitive enough (these switchs on Scotty, voting Dunia because she takes notes etc). I don't like the pushes but they still fit well with town!Marmot to me. NAA just don't give a crap lol and do his stuff. HK same (also no agenda/strong pushes is a town tell for him smh).

Dolby started by going crazy about CFCers towncoring, then posted that him low efforting was townie, then disappeared lmao. I won't die on that hill (happened already lol) but this is > rand scum.
LP because there is a real dichotomy between the stuff being pushed (early posters > rand wolves, HK/Syn fake, Marmot being opportunistic on Scotty) and the energy displayed. Like someone pushed the button a tidy bit too much and I am not vibing. Also I agree with whoever said she was fishing for claims yesterday.
Mac just seems too similar to our last game. Weak unexplained pushes. Feels pocketie again (I am not falling for cereals)
Creature was the first to speak about mechs (in what, 10 posts), but didn't follow up when I gave him the occasion to, which strikes me as too cautious and fishy. The vote on Dolby was awfully opportunistic (I can't say Creature has read anything hence I have a problem with that sort of pilling) too. This is the weakest lead I have because I am conflicted between him being cautious and lacking self-awareness. So I am prolly not ending there.

The rest are nulls rn.

honestly from the mash that's what I'd expect from Creature as default

Also I hate Rasks read on me. He should know I was joking then began feeling that CFCers were town later

[Scotty]

Scotty, gimme a town game I'll check it now.

Here’s a random one:

viewtopic.php?t=1002

[dunya]

@MacDougall switch to creature

[dunya]

@MacDougall switch to creature

if he flips town blame me

[Scotty]

I want to read you correctly, so if I'm wrong you gotta help me out here.

lol I don’t know how much else I can help besides
Use this game as a measure of guilt as opposed to others.


Like ok if you think my behavior this game has seemed whack enough to warrant suspecting me. But no, you’re not playing this game, you’re playing my previous games.

[Syn]

I am largely in agreement with this. Creature is playing as he has in every other TS game. I don't understand what makes this time wolfy compared to the town games.

iso him in panda mafia then iso him in LOTR and tell me you don't see a difference

(Sorry, Creature) He was aimless and disconnected in Panda Mafia, and he's aimless and disconnected here. Was he materially different in LOTR?

(I'm not arguing against your point, I just don't want to actually go check myself )

the difference is drive and defeatist attitude imo, that's the distinction between his town and scum games.

but there's no drive in the town games either tho

but there are reads. and like...pushes

yes, and w!creature retreats in his shell at any sight of suspicion, very much like he's done here.

ok he can die

[Scotty]

I’m that annoying paper clip guy except instead of giving the thread tips and tricks I’m trying to vault Microsoft Word into the next millennium babay

[hollowkatt]

rask is still scum fwiw

lol no

[TonyStarkPrime]

My plan to break the game has been foiled

[Syn]

Posing this question to everyone:

What do we learn if I die and flip town?

that linearpoint should die next?

[TonyStarkPrime]

Vote chicken little

[Syn]

I like Scotty's energy regarding Creature.

[dunya]

i thought syn switched to creature and got super excited for a moment

[Scotty]

Ok I stand by my last readlist if I die with a few changes: Move dolby to townlean.

Dya isn’t doing anything specifically bad, bump them to Townlean too

[hollowkatt]

Posing this question to everyone:

What do we learn if I die and flip town?

that linearpoint should die next?

does that work in reverse?

[Scotty]

I like Scotty's energy regarding Creature.

Who should go if your vote was worth 9?

[Scotty]

I’d vote LP just because I’m more sure of them than anyone right now

[Syn]

I like Scotty's energy regarding Creature.

Who should go if your vote was worth 9?

Jackofhearts tbh.

[DrWilgy]

Savin the Scotty

[Syn]

[VOTE: LinearPoint] aubergine

[Scotty]

I like Scotty's energy regarding Creature.

Who should go if your vote was worth 9?

Jackofhearts tbh.

I like this response. Seemingly out of nowhere but with a pulse on the thread.

His boomeranging with me is frankly scummy as shit

[hollowkatt]

I like for town:
rask
dolby
syn
mac
dunya

creature

don't particularly have a read on anyone else

[Scotty]

[VOTE: LinearPoint] aubergine

[dunya]

I like Scotty's energy regarding Creature.

Who should go if your vote was worth 9?

Jackofhearts tbh.

yeah wolfy popin voting for scotty

[Dolby]

I'm staying on LP but to be 100% clear I'd rather yeet Creature than Scotty

just don't feel that the wolf meta point is anywhere near concrete

[Scotty]

Vc:

Spoiler: show

oll runs till Mon Mar 14, 2022 7:00 pm
Please note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

You may select 1 option

Creature
5
28%
Voters: dyachei, Marmot, Le petit poussin, DrWilgy, dunya
urist
0
No votes
Voters: None
Dolby
0
No votes
Voters: None
DrWilgy
0
No votes
Voters: None
Dunya
1
6%
Voters: Creature
dyachei
0
No votes
Voters: None
hollowkatt
0
No votes
Voters: None
Jackofhearts2005
0
No votes
Voters: None
Le petit poussin
2
11%
Voters: MacDougall, TonyStarkPrime
LinearPoint
4
22%
Voters: Dolby, Syn, hollowkatt, Scotty
MacDougall
0
No votes
Voters: None
Marmot
0
No votes
Voters: None
NotAnAxehole
0
No votes
Voters: None
Scotty
4
22%
Voters: LinearPoint, Urist, Jackofhearts2005, NotAnAxehole
sig
0
No votes
Voters: None
syn
0
No votes
Voters: None
TonyStarkPrime
0
No votes
Voters: None
Sleep (can be hammered)
0
No votes
Voters: None
No vote (cannot be hammered)
0
No votes