RondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Fri Jul 08, 2022 7:43 pm
Oh yeah, this is a tl;dr post I skimmed because I wanted to catch up before EOD but I actually have time this time to go back and read
Why town reading boq and jay specifically? How does yesterday clear them in your mind?
Lucy said she would get involved when we had more info, we have 100 pages of info and I have yet to see a proper case by her
I dont really want to talk about slots that arent the five so I will leave finger/creature alone for now.
So you are saying Marmot/Alison/Myself and one of Finger/Creature are wolf?
I keep having to force myself to go back and read the creature/finger stuff. ughhhh yeah I dont really have anything to say about that. I thought this was going to be about Boq/JJJ?
===========================
So you are saying that the wolf kill points to Boq/Alison/JJJ but it could just be wolf theater?
Cappu? Oh another game
Wait so you are saying Boq is a wolf?
viewtopic.php?t=2389&start=4850#p932744
I can kinda see what you are saying here, I did kinda just move past your posts. My bad
viewtopic.php?t=2389&start=4850#p932752
So this is calling Marmot town?
viewtopic.php?t=2389&start=4900#p932757
I could see a world where JJJ/Boq are town but if I had to choose between the two at this point its JJJ I am voting for and if boq is the wolf this game state is pretty fucked anyway.
Why town reading boq and jay specifically? How does yesterday clear them in your mind?
The town read is stronger on Boq. Suggesting a POE of 3 that includes himself I could only see as wolf if the purpose was to force a chop on Alison/Jay, but then he backed off Jay and townread him. And I see the interaction the same way Boq does, that Jay offering the olive branch was a towny thing to do there.
So you are saying Marmot/Alison/Myself and one of Finger/Creature are wolf?
Based on townreading Boq/Jay/Lucy/(one of Finger/Creature), that leaves 3 wolves in Marmot/Alison/you/(the other of Finger/Creature), yes. But I'm less certain now that Lucy should be in the town list rather than Marmot or you (partly because Boq is strongly town reading you).
So you are saying that the wolf kill points to Boq/Alison/JJJ but it could just be wolf theater?
No I was saying it fits with a wolf being in that group, but I'm not as certain that it points that way as Boq is.
Wait so you are saying Boq is a wolf?
No, that was a general statement. What I was doing was treating Boq/JJJ as town and solving from there.
So this is calling Marmot town?
No, just that if Jay is a wolf, it's notable that nobody else has seemed interested in Marmot as a counterwagon.