Alison wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 8:38 pm
The following people in this game are from Canucks:
falcon
KZA
BoKnows
Canucks has a reputation as a forum that is dominated by extremely strong meta reads, to the point that every game is heavily town favored because all the townies find each other too easily. I would like each of these three to offer reads on the other two.
Falcon is making me pause for thought with his latest antics. He's normally self-resolving and seemed towny enough early on but his EoD was awful. I don't really know why he tried to shield me earlier though if he's Mafia since I can't be on either scum team. Still lean town.
BoKnows I haven't gotten a good read on so far. What he says is true that we didn't play that much together on CDC. I've at times felt like he's asking questions to look busy but haven't felt like he's doing anything overtly malicious at any point. So yeah he's null sorry. I have no idea how he has so many posts and would rather not ISO him right now because I'm not in the mood.
Justplayingitcool wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 4:16 pm
My only experience of marmot is that he is silly when mafia and pretty serious when town. My sample size is only three games so I acknowledge i need more data.
This is true based on the one game I saw him as Mafia
Which game was that?
I don't think JPIC is on the Marmot team
in case anyone hasn't brought this up yet
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 8:59 pm
by Hally
Tedextr
Dom
TSP
Long Con
Fingersplints
JPIC
Al Sama
who on this list doesn’t deserve to be blasted? who not on this is in need of blasting?
I've actually been working on it since last week, I think it turned out pretty good!
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:00 pm
by JaggedJimmyJay
Okay I'm home. Now, due to the immense chip on my shoulder of not being recognized as the amazing and wonderful JJJ that I am, I will begin a thorough pursuit of my civilian victory.
Alison wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 8:38 pm
The following people in this game are from Canucks:
falcon
KZA
BoKnows
Canucks has a reputation as a forum that is dominated by extremely strong meta reads, to the point that every game is heavily town favored because all the townies find each other too easily. I would like each of these three to offer reads on the other two.
Falcon is making me pause for thought with his latest antics. He's normally self-resolving and seemed towny enough early on but his EoD was awful. I don't really know why he tried to shield me earlier though if he's Mafia since I can't be on either scum team. Still lean town.
BoKnows I haven't gotten a good read on so far. What he says is true that we didn't play that much together on CDC. I've at times felt like he's asking questions to look busy but haven't felt like he's doing anything overtly malicious at any point. So yeah he's null sorry. I have no idea how he has so many posts and would rather not ISO him right now because I'm not in the mood.
EOD suggestion to CFD Alison? What else ya got? Since she's been, and continues to be, a scum read of mine it should've come as little surprise.
How about not buying Odds "lock clear town" thats based solely off what Alison tells us?
You got something that doesn't involve Alison?
You got something real and tangible?
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:02 pm
by Hally
i’ve determined there are too many people in this game
if there isn’t like three kills a night i will be sad
Alison wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 8:38 pm
The following people in this game are from Canucks:
falcon
KZA
BoKnows
Canucks has a reputation as a forum that is dominated by extremely strong meta reads, to the point that every game is heavily town favored because all the townies find each other too easily. I would like each of these three to offer reads on the other two.
Falcon is making me pause for thought with his latest antics. He's normally self-resolving and seemed towny enough early on but his EoD was awful. I don't really know why he tried to shield me earlier though if he's Mafia since I can't be on either scum team. Still lean town.
BoKnows I haven't gotten a good read on so far. What he says is true that we didn't play that much together on CDC. I've at times felt like he's asking questions to look busy but haven't felt like he's doing anything overtly malicious at any point. So yeah he's null sorry. I have no idea how he has so many posts and would rather not ISO him right now because I'm not in the mood.
If you are town and you have seen your role card then you know that you can't be scum. Does Falcon know this? Do you think you have been sufficiently townie that you are confident Falcon would be able to get there on you if he is town?
Justplayingitcool wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 4:16 pm
My only experience of marmot is that he is silly when mafia and pretty serious when town. My sample size is only three games so I acknowledge i need more data.
This is true based on the one game I saw him as Mafia
Which game was that?
I don't think JPIC is on the Marmot team
in case anyone hasn't brought this up yet
Why is that interaction clearing JPIC from being a Marmot teammate?
This is rather important because JPIC is currently trying to clear the person who I most suspect of being a Marmot teammate.
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:03 pm
by KZA
falcon45ca wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:02 pm
EOD suggestion to CFD Alison? What else ya got? Since she's been, and continues to be, a scum read of mine it should've come as little surprise.
How about not buying Odds "lock clear town" thats based solely off what Alison tells us?
You got something that doesn't involve Alison?
You got something real and tangible?
Okay fine I lean scum on you now for this nonsense. What do you think Alison and Odd are up to?
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:05 pm
by Alison
Hally wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 8:59 pm
Tedextr
Dom
TSP
Long Con
Fingersplints
JPIC
Al Sama
who on this list doesn’t deserve to be blasted? who not on this is in need of blasting?
If everyone on this list was blasted I think there is a decent chance the game would either end or be sufficiently solved that the remaining scum would concede or be outed soon.
I continue to be ambivalent on BK but he has enough of my townreads shielding him that I am willing to compromise there especially when the list of alternatives is a mile long.
Alison wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 8:38 pm
The following people in this game are from Canucks:
falcon
KZA
BoKnows
Canucks has a reputation as a forum that is dominated by extremely strong meta reads, to the point that every game is heavily town favored because all the townies find each other too easily. I would like each of these three to offer reads on the other two.
Falcon is making me pause for thought with his latest antics. He's normally self-resolving and seemed towny enough early on but his EoD was awful. I don't really know why he tried to shield me earlier though if he's Mafia since I can't be on either scum team. Still lean town.
BoKnows I haven't gotten a good read on so far. What he says is true that we didn't play that much together on CDC. I've at times felt like he's asking questions to look busy but haven't felt like he's doing anything overtly malicious at any point. So yeah he's null sorry. I have no idea how he has so many posts and would rather not ISO him right now because I'm not in the mood.
If you are town and you have seen your role card then you know that you can't be scum. Does Falcon know this? Do you think you have been sufficiently townie that you are confident Falcon would be able to get there on you if he is town?
If Falcon is scum he only knows that I'm not on his team. If that's the case why would he stick up for me when I'm widely PoE'd?
Justplayingitcool wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 4:16 pm
My only experience of marmot is that he is silly when mafia and pretty serious when town. My sample size is only three games so I acknowledge i need more data.
This is true based on the one game I saw him as Mafia
Which game was that?
I don't think JPIC is on the Marmot team
in case anyone hasn't brought this up yet
Why is that interaction clearing JPIC from being a Marmot teammate?
This is rather important because JPIC is currently trying to clear the person who I most suspect of being a Marmot teammate.
I don't see why JPIC would bring up something so pertinent that damns Marmot at that point, since Marmot was firmly in his silliness meta.
Hally wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 8:59 pm
Tedextr
Dom
TSP
Long Con
Fingersplints
JPIC
Al Sama
who on this list doesn’t deserve to be blasted? who not on this is in need of blasting?
If everyone on this list was blasted I think there is a decent chance the game would either end or be sufficiently solved that the remaining scum would concede or be outed soon.
I continue to be ambivalent on BK but he has enough of my townreads shielding him that I am willing to compromise there especially when the list of alternatives is a mile long.
I would not clear anyone from that list.
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:07 pm
by Alison
KZA wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:06 pm
I don't see why JPIC would bring up something so pertinent that damns Marmot at that point, since Marmot was firmly in his silliness meta.
You do not get credit for throwing shade on someone who turns out to be a mafioso if you attached the sentence: "My sample size is only three games so I acknowledge i need more data." to it.
KZA wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:06 pm
I don't see why JPIC would bring up something so pertinent that damns Marmot at that point, since Marmot was firmly in his silliness meta.
You do not get credit for throwing shade on someone who turns out to be a mafioso if you attached the sentence: "My sample size is only three games so I acknowledge i need more data." to it.
I don't really agree with that but okay.
How do you feel that I backed him up on that with my own experience with Mafia Marmot in Shadow Corridors?
Re: Fargo Mafia [DAY 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:10 pm
by Long Con
Fingersplints' posts look fine and towny enough, but sometimes it's in a too 'safe' way, so it could be an act. A couple of her Marmot posts could end up being somewhat relevant:
fingersplints wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 5:11 pm
I still think tsp is most suspicious, but I think Marmot doesn’t look great, and I’m ok with that lynch as well. A lot of my suspicion of tsp stems from their talk of Marmot such as suspecting jay for voting their before calling their read on Marmot null and finally moving their vote their abruptly.
Justplayingitcool wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 1:28 pm
Tsp - gut read but the exchange with him and odd was peculiar a couple of pages which I didn’t really understand. His read on you which fingersplints brought up implied he had a bigger read on marmot than just null
This is worth exploring. @TonyStarkPrime please tell me about Marmot.
If you read TSP posts they are a bit all over the place in their feeling on Marmot. Suspecting you for your vote on Marmot, next calling their read on Marmot null, before voting for Marmot themselves.
She belongs in the PoE.
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:15 pm
by Hally
@falcon45ca your tunnel of alison and insistence that she’s pulling some gambit by clearing oddmerta strains belief
alison has claimed a provable pr and is insanely villagery. if she has worked herself into a position where if she lives more than a night or two she will be outed. i highly suggest that if you’re a villager you allow her to be nk’d and drop this tunnel
Justplayingitcool wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:12 am
- This whole interaction to start with. I didn't think much of it to start with but it just feels like random filler which seems to be a frequency of BK.
- The iso of Al felt random and forced
- his reaction to mac's cop claim was scummy and felt fake
- I don't think point one is necessarily AI. Many players fill the game with fluff and will do it as town.
- I didn't see the Al iso, but I'll look at it.
- I do agree about the Mac cop post thingy. Well sorta. I think that reaction looks more nervous than fake.
AL_sama wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 7:11 pm
jjj looks townie but feels he could pull it off even if he is scum
alison is giving similar vibes as jjj
tututu is null for me right now
ted isn't playing his usual town game
michelle from what little she posted looks town bit would love to see or from her
falcon looks townie
KZA null
mac townie maybe
esona null
stou looks townie
odd with the way he dipped is making me think he is scum
long con null
marmot null
TSP slight scum lean
straw looks townie
stay null
fingers null
JPIC null
boknows slight scum lean
AL_sama wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 5:36 pm
ok finally caught up
no matter how I see it I can't see a townie ted playing like this so
vote lynch ted
I don't have a lot to say about most of these posts on an individual level. Marmot didn't do much with AL until the very end of the day phase, and AL did exactly nothing with Marmot until the same period (and perhaps nothing even then). In the end, we're left assessing vote patterns, which I tend to loathe.
Marmot placed a self-preservation vote on AL. I believe in that moment Marmot held a 6-3-3-3 vote lead over AL, Tony, and ted. So take note then that he voted AL among the three to emphasize that as the 6-4 counterwagon. AL's own vote came later, when the poll was tied 5-5 between Marmot and AL himself. Rather than place his self-preservation vote on Marmot to give his premier counterwagon the lead, he voted for ted instead. That made the wagons 5-5-4. I think this is at least a teammate-compatible vote considering the strength of Marmot's role. If they expected to lose one out of two or three possible members, I suspect Marmot was not the one they wanted to lose.
I'm not exonerating AL_sama. He can be Marmot's teammate and is a high candidate.
falcon45ca wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:02 pm
EOD suggestion to CFD Alison? What else ya got? Since she's been, and continues to be, a scum read of mine it should've come as little surprise.
How about not buying Odds "lock clear town" thats based solely off what Alison tells us?
You got something that doesn't involve Alison?
You got something real and tangible?
Okay fine I lean scum on you now for this nonsense. What do you think Alison and Odd are up to?
Alison's PR claim early really reminds me of her Champs game recently, and Odds comes to play after NF? You damn well know what I think of that.
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:20 pm
by Hally
what’s interesting to me is that i think ted is highly likely to be aligned with marmot and ted/al_sama do not look aligned. i suspect exactly one of ted/al_sama is teamed with marmot
falcon45ca wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:02 pm
EOD suggestion to CFD Alison? What else ya got? Since she's been, and continues to be, a scum read of mine it should've come as little surprise.
How about not buying Odds "lock clear town" thats based solely off what Alison tells us?
You got something that doesn't involve Alison?
You got something real and tangible?
Okay fine I lean scum on you now for this nonsense. What do you think Alison and Odd are up to?
Alison's PR claim early really reminds me of her Champs game recently, and Odds comes to play after NF? You damn well know what I think of that.
falcon45ca wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:02 pm
EOD suggestion to CFD Alison? What else ya got? Since she's been, and continues to be, a scum read of mine it should've come as little surprise.
How about not buying Odds "lock clear town" thats based solely off what Alison tells us?
You got something that doesn't involve Alison?
You got something real and tangible?
Okay fine I lean scum on you now for this nonsense. What do you think Alison and Odd are up to?
Alison's PR claim early really reminds me of her Champs game recently, and Odds comes to play after NF? You damn well know what I think of that.
I don't really care about what time OddMerta showed up. I don't know where he lives. That isn't a reasonable read.
Is the PR claim your biggest reason to scumread Alison? Because she apparently does that as any alignment.
falcon45ca wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:02 pm
EOD suggestion to CFD Alison? What else ya got? Since she's been, and continues to be, a scum read of mine it should've come as little surprise.
How about not buying Odds "lock clear town" thats based solely off what Alison tells us?
You got something that doesn't involve Alison?
You got something real and tangible?
Okay fine I lean scum on you now for this nonsense. What do you think Alison and Odd are up to?
Alison's PR claim early really reminds me of her Champs game recently, and Odds comes to play after NF? You damn well know what I think of that.
What does "Odds comes to play after NF" mean?
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:28 pm
by falcon45ca
Hally wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:15 pm
@falcon45ca your tunnel of alison and insistence that she’s pulling some gambit by clearing oddmerta strains belief
alison has claimed a provable pr and is insanely villagery. if she has worked herself into a position where if she lives more than a night or two she will be outed. i highly suggest that if you’re a villager you allow her to be nk’d and drop this tunnel
falcon45ca wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:02 pm
EOD suggestion to CFD Alison? What else ya got? Since she's been, and continues to be, a scum read of mine it should've come as little surprise.
How about not buying Odds "lock clear town" thats based solely off what Alison tells us?
You got something that doesn't involve Alison?
You got something real and tangible?
Okay fine I lean scum on you now for this nonsense. What do you think Alison and Odd are up to?
Alison's PR claim early really reminds me of her Champs game recently, and Odds comes to play after NF? You damn well know what I think of that.
What does "Odds comes to play after NF" mean?
It means Odds was absent all day and popped in after the lynch
falcon45ca wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:02 pm
EOD suggestion to CFD Alison? What else ya got? Since she's been, and continues to be, a scum read of mine it should've come as little surprise.
How about not buying Odds "lock clear town" thats based solely off what Alison tells us?
You got something that doesn't involve Alison?
You got something real and tangible?
Okay fine I lean scum on you now for this nonsense. What do you think Alison and Odd are up to?
Alison's PR claim early really reminds me of her Champs game recently, and Odds comes to play after NF? You damn well know what I think of that.
I don't really care about what time OddMerta showed up. I don't know where he lives. That isn't a reasonable read.
Is the PR claim your biggest reason to scumread Alison? Because she apparently does that as any alignment.
Since when did you become the police of reasonable reads?
No, I have other reasons to scum read Alison. If I'm the only one scum reading her, I'm fine with that. She'll get solved soon enough I'm sure, so in the meantime I'm gonna leave her be to scum hunt
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:39 pm
by Hally
falcon, what are your other reads besides alison/odd?
falcon45ca wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:02 pm
EOD suggestion to CFD Alison? What else ya got? Since she's been, and continues to be, a scum read of mine it should've come as little surprise.
How about not buying Odds "lock clear town" thats based solely off what Alison tells us?
You got something that doesn't involve Alison?
You got something real and tangible?
Okay fine I lean scum on you now for this nonsense. What do you think Alison and Odd are up to?
Alison's PR claim early really reminds me of her Champs game recently, and Odds comes to play after NF? You damn well know what I think of that.
What does "Odds comes to play after NF" mean?
It means Odds was absent all day and popped in after the lynch
I thought it was convenient that Odd found it necessary to claim the very role that Alison can verify just because of a cop-connection in a show that I think is somewhat about cops? Maybe five other players are a cop role from the show. Why didn't they consider outing themselves? It's not even the same name as Marmot's fakeclaim, I just don't really get it.
I could see Alison saying "wow that opening-post claim worked so well in GoC, maybe I'll try that variation I always wanted to do, and fakeclaim a town role off the bat!"
I really don't care for her over-the-top warning that anyone who questions any of that will get vigged. I guess I'm getting vigged then? Bring it, I promise not to be grumpy.
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:40 pm
by falcon45ca
Hally wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:39 pm
falcon, what are your other reads besides alison/odd?
I just posted my list of 9 PoE, check it yo
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:42 pm
by falcon45ca
To be clear, Odd is not a top scum read of mine. I just don't think he's "lock town"
Justplayingitcool wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 4:16 pm
My only experience of marmot is that he is silly when mafia and pretty serious when town. My sample size is only three games so I acknowledge i need more data.
This is true based on the one game I saw him as Mafia
Which game was that?
Shadow Corridors
he was known as Thundercat, some sort of villainous alter ego of his I'm sure
Side note, since you bring this up. I wonder if @BoKnows ever realized he and I were teammates in that game.
BoKnows wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 9:38 pm
Can you expand your thoughts on Odd, and Straw please?
My read on Oddmerta is a bit of a product of my other reads. A lot of my town reads have to be wrong about Oddmerta for him to be mafia, and I don't think he's that suspicious myself anyway. If one of my town reads that has vouched for Oddmerta ends up mafia, perhaps that'll be something to revisit later. For now I'm fine with him.
Strawhenge is probably the easiest read on the board for me. His posts radiate the purity of a player returning after five years away from Mafia with a town role card, uncertainty about how to get into business, and an admirable motor to do it anyway.
I'm a huge fan of the Odd reasoning tbh. It reminds me of synthetic CDOs. You're betting (reading) on other peoples reads and hoping it all falls in place. Is there anything in Odds content that makes you believe he's town?
I do agree with this. I also think if Straw randed wolf in his first game back in five years he would be playing a little more conservative and not sticking out his neck like he did earlier today.
What's a CDO?
Marmot wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 1:34 amTSP and Bo I think are town due to volume and content. Bo in particular seems extremely comfortable and fluid here to an extent that I've never seen from himn, and he's been the Day 1 yeet in multiple recent games.
Marmot wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 5:07 pm
Marmot is not a good chop today, but Marmot is probably a more expendable option
why you being sussed?
Ask them, I no longer find myself suspicious
From Marmot's side this is an extremely chummy dialogue. I think that makes sense; I view Bo and Marmot as similar Mafia play personalities. It figures that they'd get on as bonafide silly billies. None of this makes me feel inclined to dissociate the two of them. I highlighted one comment that could be meaningful, but I'm not entirely sure how it's meaningful. It's a frivolous town read, but one that had also been growing increasingly popular for Bo. I think it's possible enough that this was solely a matter of riding the thread wave, and as such I don't take much from it.
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Mon Apr 05, 2021 8:56 pm
A few things have thrown me off from the beginning but his current vote for Marmot is something that inclines me to think that way as well. I also just don't think his iso is carrying the proper tone and I'm wondering if his read on sloonei was developed improperly. He also also seems hesistant to say things that I wouldn't usually think he'd be hesitant to say. I did like the post he made where he talked about sloonei/jay mutual TRs and how seriously they're taken or something though idk
this is probably just the usual day 1 jay tinfoil but that's where I'm at
@JaggedJimmyJay Seems pretty run of the mill to me. He admitted it was "usual day 1 tinfoil", it can also be seen as hedging though. At this time Marmot had what 0-5 posts and you voted for him, gonna call it RVS for the sake of labelling that vote. I don't know how a read is developed properly and inproperly tbh so no comment. (Is that even a thing?). The second part is meta, and I got no meta on you. I wish he supplied this read with examples though. Sorta seems like TSP is thinking outloud with this one. Like I said run of the mill day 1 "throw something togehter" read.
JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 10:59 am
Let's play a game:
Is this low-hanging fruit, or is this a justifiable suspect?
AL_sama
BoKnows
fingersplints
JPIC
KZA
Long Con
Marmot
tedxtr
I extract these specific names because they strike me as applicable to the question -- either facing generic suspicions or otherwise pretty blank slates.
AL_sama - null
BoKnows - Town
fingersplints - low-hanging
JPIC - null
KZA - low-hanging
Long Con - low-hanging
Marmot - null
tedxtr - null
I don't have a solid scum suspect yet, but Oddmerta is starting to cross my mind
JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 1:58 pm
You DID inspire the siren button, Strawhenge, those years ago.
YUP. TEARS. :,)
Okay, so it's based on that you think Marmot is scum and me saying that I have good vibes about marmot immediately followed up with that the vibes wore off and it was due to the pfp?
BoKnows wrote: ↑Mon Apr 05, 2021 10:18 pm
Marmot is giving me good vibes.
BoKnows wrote: ↑Mon Apr 05, 2021 10:41 pm
marmot's vibes faded away. thinking the source of the vibes are from the pfp, love it.
The space between these posts occupies 24 minutes of time, and during those 24 minutes (and just prior to the first Bo post) Marmot made one of his more substantive appearances in the game thread. Bo, what about Marmot's posts in that space changed your view?
Nothing about his posts it was just a vibe.
Please, to the best of your ability, describe the original good vibes and then the changed vibes.
Marmot came in and felt light hearted. Then he got semi serious so the feel good vibe faded I guess. His pfp adds to the feel good vibes.
BoKnows wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 2:04 pm
Okay, so it's based on that you think Marmot is scum and me saying that I have good vibes about marmot immediately followed up with that the vibes wore off and it was due to the pfp?
My feeling about you was regardless of my feeling of Marmot. It was that you switched from having 'good vibes' to 'not good vibes' after Alison said Marmot was part of a scummy exchange. The timing seems really convenient.
Justplayingitcool wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 4:16 pm
My only experience of marmot is that he is silly when mafia and pretty serious when town. My sample size is only three games so I acknowledge i need more data.
This is true based on the one game I saw him as Mafia
Which game was that?
Shadow Corridors
he was known as Thundercat, some sort of villainous alter ego of his I'm sure
Side note, since you bring this up. I wonder if @BoKnows ever realized he and I were teammates in that game.
Does it concern you that you seem to read half the consensus POE pool as civilian?
No, I'd prefer if the consensus was right over myself being right anyway.
So you're not concerned if someone you view as civilian ends up getting chopped (other than yourself)?
I'm playing a game of mafia where I'm surrounded by players of a higher skill level than I. If enough players conclude something that I don't see eye-to-eye with and they're right, then no I'm not concerned.
I don't know what to do with this laissez-faire mindset. I don't see this much if ever.
This is just a fancy way of saying "the wagon is probably correct because everyone on it is town".
I agree with Marmot on this. Idc if one of my town reads gets chopped with good reason.
staypositivefriend wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 5:33 pm
i dislike this POE because i am in it
I dislike that this is your first post in an hour and a half
Not everyone can 400 post on Day 1 and post at a higher frequency than that
Bo I liked this particular post from marmot, which Jay thinks (correctly) has no reason to exist
I agree not everyone has access to post as often
I put a big row of equals signs in there to sort of cordon off a specific portion of interest. Strawhenge first noticed this exchange, and it's a somewhat curious progression. Marmot had done very little prior, and during this brief period he'd actually started to make Real Posts of a sort. That's what turned off Bo, and it came right on the heels of Marmot getting a little shit from Alison. It feels like a bit of a reach to call this "damage control" or something like that, as an effort to distance, but it's reasonably possible. He talked about this a bit when I prodded him (highlighted in orange). The rest of it up to and through EOD is kinda nothing.
I can't clear Bo as a Marmot teammate. Gun to my head I probably say no, but for the moment I don't have a gun to my head.
This was a fun read. I agree that Marmot and I are chummy.
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:56 pm
by Hally
i have no idea how to read boknows. he feels like the kind of player i’d wolf read or not be able to understand regardless of his alignment
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:58 pm
by falcon45ca
Hally wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:47 pm
falcon, is kza not in your poe? earlier when i asked you it seemed like you didn’t v read him
Imma eat dinner first and get back to you
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 10:00 pm
by BoKnows
Hally wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 9:56 pm
i have no idea how to read boknows. he feels like the kind of player i’d wolf read or not be able to understand regardless of his alignment
yes
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 10:01 pm
by BoKnows
i feel like i'm a polarizing player 99% of the time. @falcon45ca thoughts on this statement
fingersplints wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 5:11 pm
I still think tsp is most suspicious, but I think Marmot doesn’t look great, and I’m ok with that lynch as well. A lot of my suspicion of tsp stems from their talk of Marmot such as suspecting jay for voting their before calling their read on Marmot null and finally moving their vote their abruptly.
What about Al?
That's it. And I actually think it's a somewhat telling post. It's 48 minutes pre-EOD. I had missed it in my AL review because my search was thrown off by the question mark. fingersplints' suspicion of TSP was in part driven by his treatment of Marmot. It's a reasonable mindset for splints to justify having Marmot as the "okay with that chop as well" option between the two. Marmot's response looks to me like someone talking to a non-teammate, as much as a two-word post can at least. Whatever AL's association with Marmot, I get that impression. If AL is not aligned with Marmot, then this looks like aw, but what about that other counterwagon? as some feigned investment in the hunting interests of someone semi-threatening his safety (in a way that I don't think traces fluidly back to a mafia chat). If AL is mafia with Marmot, then it looks like a smear designed to make splints look compatible with AL.
fingersplints wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 6:15 am
Up to page 24 now, I don’t agree with the suspicion of Jay (from TonyStarkPrime) and Alison (from staypositivefriend).
Both seem pretty townie to me right now.
TonyStarkPrime’s seems more flimsy out of the two, but I still have more to go. We’ll see
What was flimsy about it?
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Mon Apr 05, 2021 8:56 pm
A few things have thrown me off from the beginning but his current vote for Marmot is something that inclines me to think that way as well. I also just don't think his iso is carrying the proper tone and I'm wondering if his read on sloonei was developed improperly. He also also seems hesistant to say things that I wouldn't usually think he'd be hesitant to say. I did like the post he made where he talked about sloonei/jay mutual TRs and how seriously they're taken or something though idk
this is probably just the usual day 1 jay tinfoil but that's where I'm at
The talk of jay’s tone and being hesitant both of which I’m not really seeing. Not really sure I understand the Sloonei comparison as a negative. They’ve always played kind of similar to me so it’s not really something I find suspicious.
I’m also not really sure I understand the Marmot vote comment. It reads to me that it’s making him also suspect marmot while simultaneously suspecting jay.
fingersplints wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 6:15 am
Up to page 24 now, I don’t agree with the suspicion of Jay (from TonyStarkPrime) and Alison (from staypositivefriend).
Both seem pretty townie to me right now.
TonyStarkPrime’s seems more flimsy out of the two, but I still have more to go. We’ll see
What was flimsy about it?
TonyStarkPrime wrote: ↑Mon Apr 05, 2021 8:56 pm
A few things have thrown me off from the beginning but his current vote for Marmot is something that inclines me to think that way as well. I also just don't think his iso is carrying the proper tone and I'm wondering if his read on sloonei was developed improperly. He also also seems hesistant to say things that I wouldn't usually think he'd be hesitant to say. I did like the post he made where he talked about sloonei/jay mutual TRs and how seriously they're taken or something though idk
this is probably just the usual day 1 jay tinfoil but that's where I'm at
The talk of jay’s tone and being hesitant both of which I’m not really seeing. Not really sure I understand the Sloonei comparison as a negative. They’ve always played kind of similar to me so it’s not really something I find suspicious.
I’m also not really sure I understand the Marmot vote comment. It reads to me that it’s making him also suspect marmot while simultaneously suspecting jay.
I didn't really get that from TSP's post in regards to sussing marmot from the voting comment with marmot/JJJ, it read like he suspects JJJ for voting Marmot. It's worth noting though that TSP elaborated later that he didn't have a read on Marmot.
That makes more sense. I was confused why they would want to follow someone they suspected. I still don’t really like the vague suspicion of Jay, and I’ll need to see more about his later comments about Marmot that you mentioned, because I’m still not sure why if you don’t have a read on someone a vote against them would be a factor. But I’ll see how it’s explained as the thread progresses
Justplayingitcool wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 1:28 pm
Tsp - gut read but the exchange with him and odd was peculiar a couple of pages which I didn’t really understand. His read on you which fingersplints brought up implied he had a bigger read on marmot than just null
This is worth exploring. @TonyStarkPrime please tell me about Marmot.
If you read TSP posts they are a bit all over the place in their feeling on Marmot. Suspecting you for your vote on Marmot, next calling their read on Marmot null, before voting for Marmot themselves.
fingersplints wrote: ↑Tue Apr 06, 2021 2:30 pm
@JaggedJimmyJay I need some more work on the last group, but right now this is where I feel right now. Sorry making dinner and can’t do colours
These people I feel very good about
JJJ
Sloonei
Alison
Falcon
Strawhenge
These people I feel good/ok about right now
Esooa
BoKnows
JPIC
This person has not posted
Dom
These people I feel ok but sometimes wary about due to posting styles
Nanook
Long Con
I don’t remember what the term PoE that you all keep using means but perhaps it’s applicable here. This group I either have mild bad feelings about or are neutral to the point of wary/need revisiting.
Tedextr
Staypositivefriend
Oddmerta
KZA
MacDougall
Marmot
Tutuu
Michelle
Al Sama
fingersplints wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 5:11 pm
I still think tsp is most suspicious, but I think Marmot doesn’t look great, and I’m ok with that lynch as well. A lot of my suspicion of tsp stems from their talk of Marmot such as suspecting jay for voting their before calling their read on Marmot null and finally moving their vote their abruptly.
What about Al?
Posts haven’t seen especially townie, but not my top suspect. I wouldn’t be opposed to the lynch, but not sure I’d be ready to vote there
Here you get a little more of fingersplints' thought process regarding TSP and Marmot. I view much of it as tangential. She featured Marmot on a pseudo POE list alongside 8 others, "tied" for second most suspicious behind Tony. That doesn't do anything for me. The last post there shows her own response to the thing I talked about in Marmot's spoiler. It's a small moment and interpretations may vary, but I don't really think this looks like fingersplints talking to her mafia teammate.
~~~
Overall I'd say they're "technically compatible", but it doesn't feel right to me. She would be a secondary or tertiary Marmot teammate suspect.
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 10:04 pm
by BoKnows
@JaggedJimmyJay can you do an analysis of KZA and marmot please? I'd do it but I'd end up butchering it and leave people more confused.
Re: Fargo Mafia [NIGHT 1]
Posted: Wed Apr 07, 2021 10:04 pm
by JaggedJimmyJay
BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 10:04 pm
@JaggedJimmyJay can you do an analysis of KZA and marmot please? I'd do it but I'd end up butchering it and leave people more confused.
BoKnows wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 10:04 pm
@JaggedJimmyJay can you do an analysis of KZA and marmot please? I'd do it but I'd end up butchering it and leave people more confused.
Bring it, I promise not to be grumpy.
