U-Pick Mafia Vol 1 - Game Over

[colonialbob]

the greatest trick the devil ever pulled was letting epignosis force me to learn baseball vocabulary in my free time

One of the options I considered instead of becoming a grandmother was being a person who speakes entirely in baseball euphamisms. It would have been a bit redundant in this game, as it turns out. Don’t want to clog the bases.

Didn't you replace in?

I did

The bob man asked Sloonei if he replaced in. Bob, why did you ask that?

Because it seemed he was speaking about his role, when he wasn't the one who submitted it.

[colonialbob]

colonialbob voted for Kites. Kylemii voted for insertnamehere, along with Sloonei.

Lynch Away Lynchy Lynchers

Poll ended at Sun Jun 03, 2018 10:47 pmPlease note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

ColinIsCool
0
No votes


Voters: None

colonialbob
0
No votes


Voters: None

Dragon D. Luffy
0
No votes


Voters: None

insertnamehere
4
24%


Voters: Kylemii, Turnip Head, Dragon D. Luffy, Sloonei

juliets
0
No votes


Voters: None

Kites
5
29%


Voters: insertnamehere, sig, ColinIsCool, colonialbob, juliets

Kylemii
0
No votes


Voters: None

motel room
0
No votes


Voters: None

sig
0
No votes


Voters: None

Sloonei
1
6%


Voters: MacDougall

Turnip Head
0
No votes


Voters: None

CM Punk (For the non voters)
7
41%


Voters: wolbre04, lapluie, Zephyrus, JaggedJimmyJay, M Plus 7, Charlie Blackmon, nutella


Total votes: 17

Point of order though I voted Kites to preserve the tie, my vote was on TH most of the day.

[Kylemii]

What have you done each evening and what were your results?

I used the protection I got from quin on jay on night 2 and I used the role check I got from cbob the second time on turniphead. cbobs first gift is still in stock. i missed two nights of targets in the sex cave and ddl blew me off two times in a row, though one of them was my fault.

Why does your result on Turnip Head seem so crucial when it is anything but revelatory?

I think that's extremely subjective? turnip head was the most likely to have been lying about his role so I targeted him and found out he wasn't. if you don't think that's value added then cool, whatever, but I'm trying to help solve the game and I thought it might be useful information.

[Epignosis]

What does "DDL blew me off two times in a row" mean? I need people to speak like I'm a dumb jock.

[Epignosis]

the greatest trick the devil ever pulled was letting epignosis force me to learn baseball vocabulary in my free time

One of the options I considered instead of becoming a grandmother was being a person who speakes entirely in baseball euphamisms. It would have been a bit redundant in this game, as it turns out. Don’t want to clog the bases.

Didn't you replace in?

I did

The bob man asked Sloonei if he replaced in. Bob, why did you ask that?

Because it seemed he was speaking about his role, when he wasn't the one who submitted it.

What did he response do for you?

the greatest trick the devil ever pulled was letting epignosis force me to learn baseball vocabulary in my free time

One of the options I considered instead of becoming a grandmother was being a person who speakes entirely in baseball euphamisms. It would have been a bit redundant in this game, as it turns out. Don’t want to clog the bases.

Didn't you replace in?

I did

Did your role change to suit you? Or are you just doing a bit?

Colin knows all my secrets

[Kylemii]

What does "DDL blew me off two times in a row" mean? I need people to speak like I'm a dumb jock.

it means he didn't play either time i invited him to, so I missed out on two possible items.

[Epignosis]

I have more questions, but I have to pee.

[Epignosis]

I do have questions, but I also have some ideas, but I want to keep them to myself while I sulk on getting beaten by the Diamondbacks tonight.

[Kylemii]

did you wash your hands

[Epignosis]

did you wash your hands

Nobody does.

[Epignosis]

Kylemii has an illogical reason for believing Turnip Head is playing for the bad team.

If Kylemii is on the bad team himself, why is he using poor logic to call Turnip Head good at this juncture?

[Quin]

did i win yet

[Epignosis]

Kylemii has an illogical reason for believing Turnip Head is playing for the bad team.

If Kylemii is on the bad team himself, why is he using poor logic to call Turnip Head good at this juncture?

I phrased this poorly. I'm not great with words.

Kylemii has an illogical reason for believing Turnip Head is NOT playing for the bad team.

If Kylemii is on the bad team himself, why is he using poor logic to call Turnip Head good at this juncture?

[Epignosis]

Kylemii- do you dispute my view that your reason is illogical?

[Kylemii]

Kylemii- do you dispute my view that your reason is illogical?

illogical seems kind of harsh :\

but i don't disagree that it's possible Al Pieda may have had 2 info roles

[Kylemii]

did sloonei or long con ever make any moves against isis cream that seemed like they might have been aided by alignment information?

[Epignosis]

Kylemii- do you dispute my view that your reason is illogical?

illogical seems kind of harsh :\

but i don't disagree that it's possible Al Pieda may have had 2 info roles

I don't mean to be harsh. I mean that we've seen a hurricane and a sex cave and a chat guy and not one but two stumps.

What I want to know is why learning anything about Turnip Head's role is so important to you, given that it doesn't say anything about his alignment.

[Kylemii]

I don't mean to be harsh. I mean that we've seen a hurricane and a sex cave and a chat guy and not one but two stumps.

fair enough

What I want to know is why learning anything about Turnip Head's role is so important to you, given that it doesn't say anything about his alignment.

because i had a role check at near endgame and i wanted to make it count somehow, and the best way i could think of to do that was to verify turnip head's at the time unverified power claim. sig, juliets, and ddl seemed unlikely to be mafia, and cbob's power has been physically demonstrated

[juliets]

Ok, heres the deal. I alignment checked c-bob and he was civ. I also alignment checked Turnip Head and he was also civ. So Kyle, that's how I come to the conclusion that you are bad. I think we should lynch you and if it turns out you are civ, that means one of my alignment checks was wrong, maybe due to a role card saying "If checked you will appear as civ". So at that point whoever is left can vote c-bob.

[colonialbob]

the greatest trick the devil ever pulled was letting epignosis force me to learn baseball vocabulary in my free time

One of the options I considered instead of becoming a grandmother was being a person who speakes entirely in baseball euphamisms. It would have been a bit redundant in this game, as it turns out. Don’t want to clog the bases.

Didn't you replace in?

I did

The bob man asked Sloonei if he replaced in. Bob, why did you ask that?

Because it seemed he was speaking about his role, when he wasn't the one who submitted it.

What did he response do for you?

the greatest trick the devil ever pulled was letting epignosis force me to learn baseball vocabulary in my free time

One of the options I considered instead of becoming a grandmother was being a person who speakes entirely in baseball euphamisms. It would have been a bit redundant in this game, as it turns out. Don’t want to clog the bases.

Didn't you replace in?

I did

Did your role change to suit you? Or are you just doing a bit?

Colin knows all my secrets

It neither reassured me nor pinged me. It was null.

[colonialbob]

Kylemii has an illogical reason for believing Turnip Head is playing for the bad team.

If Kylemii is on the bad team himself, why is he using poor logic to call Turnip Head good at this juncture?

I phrased this poorly. I'm not great with words.

Kylemii has an illogical reason for believing Turnip Head is NOT playing for the bad team.

If Kylemii is on the bad team himself, why is he using poor logic to call Turnip Head good at this juncture?

Pocketing. Especially since the early choice floated was Kyle or cbob, getting TH (and/or potentially others) to see him as civ because he's town-reading people makes him more likely to stay alive the last couple of cycles he needs to win.

[colonialbob]

Ok, heres the deal. I alignment checked c-bob and he was civ. I also alignment checked Turnip Head and he was also civ. So Kyle, that's how I come to the conclusion that you are bad. I think we should lynch you and if it turns out you are civ, that means one of my alignment checks was wrong, maybe due to a role card saying "If checked you will appear as civ". So at that point whoever is left can vote c-bob.

When in doubt trust the cop

[VOTE: kyle] aubergine

[Turnip Head]

Why would Kyle townfirm me if he's the last baddie?

[juliets]

Why would Kyle townfirm me if he's the last baddie?

He seems to be saying the last baddie is c-bob.

[Turnip Head]

Why would Kyle townfirm me if he's the last baddie?

He seems to be saying the last baddie is c-bob.

Happy Saturday

[juliets]

Why would Kyle townfirm me if he's the last baddie?

He seems to be saying the last baddie is c-bob.

Happy Saturday

Hahaha - so what I said didn't make sense?

[juliets]

And Happy Saturday to you too TH.

[Turnip Head]

It definitely makes sense [mention]juliets[/mention]. You said you townfirmed C-bob, and you and Kyle both townfirmed me, and I'm civ as fuck, so we're all good there... I'm just wondering if vouching for me is a move that a baddie-Kyle would make at this stage.

[Turnip Head]

I also can't help but wonder if C-bob's interaction with Sloonei is nefarious. It looks like Bobbo tried to "catch" Sloonei's "slip" before anybody else did.

By slip, I mean... Sloonei claimed to make up his own role but also he replaced into the game, so how could that be? And Bob questioned him on it, but it never led anywhere?

Color me intrigued

[Kylemii]

Ok, heres the deal. I alignment checked c-bob and he was civ. I also alignment checked Turnip Head and he was also civ. So Kyle, that's how I come to the conclusion that you are bad. I think we should lynch you and if it turns out you are civ, that means one of my alignment checks was wrong, maybe due to a role card saying "If checked you will appear as civ". So at that point whoever is left can vote c-bob.

okay that is extremely concerning news actually

if everything juliets is saying is true then unless cbob has a role that is "add a vote to other people and also you look civ if checked" then the mafia has to be a recruited juliets or a wildcard ddl, but neither of those seem right... if juliets were recruited then there's no reason why she'd need to pull any of this, right? She was already in a good position to win, and ddl... hm...

th's role text doesnt say anything about being a seemer either.

im going to have to review things, i fully expect to be lynched today but i want to do everything I can to make sure the game can work itself out after my death

[juliets]

c-bob, humor me please by answering this question: what did you mean by the underlined below? How is your game here different from your typical game and why is it different?

also, I'm sorry, but cbob I know asking all these probing questions that actually lead to places isn't in this game. It's the same feeling I got when I said Scotty was not himself, LC was trying to hard to appear clueless...and you're just doing homework to look like you're invested but reach a decision to lynch Sloonei, the only player who hasn't broken roleplay all game because he won't put up a fight? that was your best pick?

You know there's something else about this that bothers me.

"Sloonei hasn't broken roleplay all game" -> not suspicious
"This cbob is different" -> suspicious

Why the discrepancy? Neither Sloonei nor I are playing pur typical games here, but I'm a lot closer to mine than he is to his.

[Turnip Head]

I'm pretty into the idea of lynching Bobbaroonie atm

[juliets]

Well if I was al-Pieda anyway

C-bob, please humor me with another question. What did you mean with this statement? You had just said if you were mafia you would not have played the previous day as you did (it was the tie Lynch between Kites and INH). What did you mean by that and this statement?

[juliets]

I'm pretty into the idea of lynching Bobbaroonie atm

TH do you think I got a false civ read? If so, why would that have happened?

[juliets]

Oh, another thing. Mac said he could make our day end earlier than 4 am tomorrow morning. Do we want to do that? I'm in favor of ending it tonight at a reasonable hour.

[Sloonei]

did you wash your hands

Nobody does.

They say peeing on your hands helps with blisters.

[Turnip Head]

I'm pretty into the idea of lynching Bobbaroonie atm

TH do you think I got a false civ read? If so, why would that have happened?

I mean there's really only one option, that it's something built into his role or an item blocked it or whatever. Otherwise I assume your read should be clear. I'm just trying to look at every angle

[Kylemii]

oh fuck

[Kylemii]

[mention]Turnip Head[/mention] what do you think of the idea that cbob and juliets are both mafia, cbob an original member and juliets a recruit who bussed long con to maintain the momentum created in the abstinence cave?

[Turnip Head]

@Turnip Head what do you think of the idea that cbob and juliets are both mafia, cbob an original member and juliets a recruit who bussed long con to maintain the momentum created in the abstinence cave?

[juliets]

Kyle, here is the explanation of "escape" that presents an opportunity to be recruited:

"At night there is a random chance that a person confined to the Chatzy of Lost Souls finds a way to escape. This starts at 5% and goes up by 5% each phase that they reside there.

If that player escapes there is a random event. In the event the player is a civilian there is a ⅓ chance they will die upon escape, a ⅓ chance they will fall in love with the Abyss and have their win con switched to the same win con as The Endless Void and a ⅓ chance they will escape freely."

Now, look at what Mac posted about my release:

"At the end of day four Lapluie and Zephyrus were lynched. Juliets was freed."

Note the way you get recruited is escape at night through the night escape route, the "open door." I was released at the end of the day phasebecause I was rescued by DDL.

Thus, I am not recruited Al Pieda.

[Kylemii]

i don't really see what you mean. day or night, you escaped from long con's void, so wouldn't you still have been subject to the 1/3 roll chance? the first paragraph refers to a way you could have escaped, 2nd paragraph refers to the things that might happen in the event that you did escape.

[Kylemii]

@Turnip Head what do you think of the idea that cbob and juliets are both mafia, cbob an original member and juliets a recruit who bussed long con to maintain the momentum created in the abstinence cave?

it's a real question, th. do you think it's possible juliets was recruited

[Turnip Head]

[mention]Kylemii[/mention] yeah for sure it's possible.

[Turnip Head]

@Turnip Head what do you think of the idea that cbob and juliets are both mafia, cbob an original member and juliets a recruit who bussed long con to maintain the momentum created in the abstinence cave?

If that is the case then you and me are the only civs left

[juliets]

i don't really see what you mean. day or night, you escaped from long con's void, so wouldn't you still have been subject to the 1/3 roll chance? the first paragraph refers to a way you could have escaped, 2nd paragraph refers to the things that might happen in the event that you did escape.

No No No - you do not understand. Look at the first paragraph again -

At night there is a random chance that a person confined to the Chatzy of Lost Souls finds a way to escape. This starts at 5% and goes up by 5% each phase that they reside there.

Do you see where it says AT NIGHT????? This is talking about the escape that can happen at night which I posted about earlier in the game. It is NOT TALKING ABOUT A DAY ESCAPE! I escaped via DDL which was a DAY ESCAPE. My freedom happened at the end of DAY four. The NIGHT ESCAPE was the only one that was subject to recruitment.

[Kylemii]

@Turnip Head what do you think of the idea that cbob and juliets are both mafia, cbob an original member and juliets a recruit who bussed long con to maintain the momentum created in the abstinence cave?

If that is the case then you and me are the only civs left

although then on the other hand i guess it's equally likely that it's you and juliets as it is cbob and juliets :\

[juliets]

In case you have forgotten what I posted or do not want to look back, each NIGHT we were each advised whether the "door" was open for us. It could be open for one of us but not the others. If we escaped through the door one of three things could happen - recruited, die, escape with no change. This was not the same as a DDL rescue which happened during the DAY.

[Kylemii]

i don't really see what you mean. day or night, you escaped from long con's void, so wouldn't you still have been subject to the 1/3 roll chance? the first paragraph refers to a way you could have escaped, 2nd paragraph refers to the things that might happen in the event that you did escape.

No No No - you do not understand. Look at the first paragraph again -

At night there is a random chance that a person confined to the Chatzy of Lost Souls finds a way to escape. This starts at 5% and goes up by 5% each phase that they reside there.

Do you see where it says AT NIGHT????? This is talking about the escape that can happen at night which I posted about earlier in the game. It is NOT TALKING ABOUT A DAY ESCAPE! I escaped via DDL which was a DAY ESCAPE. My freedom happened at the end of DAY four. The NIGHT ESCAPE was the only one that was subject to recruitment.

I think I understand it fine? the random event where recruitments happen doesn't specify that it can only happen at night, only that it happens when an escape happens. it doesn't specify that it can only happen during night escapes. it doesn't imply anywhere that day and night escapes would be treated differently.

[Turnip Head]

@Turnip Head what do you think of the idea that cbob and juliets are both mafia, cbob an original member and juliets a recruit who bussed long con to maintain the momentum created in the abstinence cave?

If that is the case then you and me are the only civs left

although then on the other hand i guess it's equally likely that it's you and juliets as it is cbob and juliets :\

Kyle man come on, listen don't you forget, I am completely in the dark here. My own role doesn't even work here.