OK, imma start this, but may have to post it incomplete to go get ready for work. But no rainbow lists for me, look where it got Marmot. Maybe.
bea
She didn't know the game had started, she started a job last week. I think she'd make more effort if bad, especially if one of the nubs was on the bad team; see breakout re OG's
Dennis
Dennis is asking the right questions, at first I thought he was maybe being coached, but I don't anymore. Leaning more town than not
falcon45ca
Gonna be honest, only have a passing 'no reason to think they're bad', I have to read falcon and get a more solid read. Loved his CLR joke.
fingersplints
No clue, could be bad, could be not bad. I'd like to see her post more, or at all. See breakout re OG's
Golden
He looks completely different to me to Game 1 (sorry Sabi). He feels like civ Golden to me, but I need to see more analysis from him to know for sure. I want to reread Marmot to see why he read Golden as bad.
jack shepherd
Unlike most people, I thought as a twin, if he was bad, he might be more likely to not want to expose himself much with his brother here. The more civ Dennis looked to me, the less Jack did. Or he could just be disinterested. This game isn't everyones cup of tea.
Kate
At first I wasn't really sure; she seemed to think some things contrary to what I'd expect, and seemed fluffier than normal. But that was likly proud Mama, and now I'm seeing more of her civ game.
lucy
I have to reread here. I feel like I need to be a tad tiptoey since I have obvs come across as aggro to her. I thought she was bad, and would have left my vote on her if not for the chance to tie.
Matahari
See breakout. She digs deep into posts and finds tiny nuggets of suspicion mno one else would see, I've only seen surface nuggets. I could vote here. I would def like to see more from her.
Roxy
See breakout. I think Roxy was hoping for a bit of an old home week lol, and her and Splints are . No real read, I don't feel actively bad about her, also don't feel actively town
S~V~S
Bit of a bull in a china shop. She certainly doesn't mean to break china and hurt feelings, but she somehow still manages to do so.
Sabiplz
See breakout.
Scotty
He seems much more relaxed than he did in G1, BUT I joined that a few days in, so I didn't see his early game in real time. I'm kinda susceptible to buddying, so I'm wary, but haven't seen anything overtly bad so far
Seanzie
Breakout. I don't always agree with his conclusions, but I still don't understand why he took such suspicion. He's engaging in good faith, and taking info from a changing thread into account.
Soneji
No clue. I've only played maybe 1-2 games with them. falcons clr joke is the strongest mental association I have for Soneji.
OG Inactives: Several of the OG players seem to be ghosting a bit (or a lot). Could be since they're out of the mafia habit, they don't come here when they should be working like some of us
but someone, or a few someones, has said it's possible there is a bad in the inactives, and with so many of them, that's probably true. I really don't like bringing out of thread into the thread, but meh. Odds are one is bad, but if they don't post, who's to know?
Mata: I knew
@Matahari was having surgery on her hand, but I don't know if that has happened yet. So it could account for not really posting much or in depth. If I find she is still two handed though, she jumps to the top of the list.
Seanzie: I don't understand the argument against Seanzie, as it applies outside of his interaction with me. Re his interactions with me, I think he either misread or misunderstood something I said, which happens to me ALL THE TIME. ALL THE FREAKING TIME. I say alot of stupid shit and it gets me in trouble. So a me thing. Thought I was bad and went with it. Then maybe reread me, or took my well reasoned defenses to heart (maybe I should put that in orange lol, most of my defenses consisted of, "NO, you're wrong. No Just stop") and changed his mind. I don't associate backing away from a suspect you have been notably aggressively pursuing as a baddie move
Unless he always comes out of the gate so aggressively as a baddie, I'm not sure I see it.
This is why I forced the tie. ^^ I wanted another day to discuss it.
Sabi: I have some mixed feels with them. I don't understand the aggro push on Seanzie, I get tunnels, I'm a tunneler myself, but their posts are not very detailed outside of their time with marmot. Also, I was glad to see that it wasn't just me who thought it, and that they are salty in general. Whenever I interact with them, I feel like an almost disapproving schoolmaster vibe from them. But I can be salty, too (Hi Lucy!) and don't have much of a filter on top of it. So perhaps that is coloring my read on them.
Okey Dokey, might be back before 6PM eastern, might not. Have fun happy mafia people!