i'd follow u anywhere rn lol
i led town to 2 town kills, jjj is literally suffering watching me play
Moderator: Community Team
i'd follow u anywhere rn lol
yeah, no wonder wolves didnt axe u if you are not one of them, lol
Scotty wrote: ↑Tue Dec 12, 2023 2:46 pm
-makes a weird assertion that she saw something in Robyn calling cape/bereft town. That makes no sense. I mean, cape/Robyn all but claimed that they’re masons, so that as given. But bereft once again being pushed as noble for associations rings hollow to me. Unless he’s exactly the cop. But why would mafia leave cop alive N1 if they thought that was the case? Makes no sense.
Who the $%#! did you think I was????RondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:15 pm @robyn I have to admit my faith was shook last night. I dont understand why bereft is town now. I had a whole crisis of if I flip on you today but I decided Ive already lost if you are wolf so I have to accept you and cape are town but bereft is not who I thought he is. There is a second option but I need some assurance
Well I really hate how scotty has been trying to push me and you and DM just keeps giving me weird vibes. What about Thunal/Scotty? or Scotty/X+1?
what did TS flip?Bereft wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:16 pmWho the $%#! did you think I was????RondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:15 pm @robyn I have to admit my faith was shook last night. I dont understand why bereft is town now. I had a whole crisis of if I flip on you today but I decided Ive already lost if you are wolf so I have to accept you and cape are town but bereft is not who I thought he is. There is a second option but I need some assurance
Thunal/Scotty works possibly. Check J^3s massive walls oopsRondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:16 pmWell I really hate how scotty has been trying to push me and you and DM just keeps giving me weird vibes. What about Thunal/Scotty? or Scotty/X+1?
ahhhhRondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:17 pm thats why I said it was improbable that Robyn/Cape/Bereft start shielding each other day 1 so hard. But not unlikely.
I really dont want to. I have very little bandwith and cant be assed much today. I know how today is going to go already assuming that I can get Robyn to agree that your block will vote with me and Thunal too. So I am just going to save brain space for tomorrowBereft wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:17 pmThunal/Scotty works possibly. Check J^3s massive walls oopsRondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:16 pmWell I really hate how scotty has been trying to push me and you and DM just keeps giving me weird vibes. What about Thunal/Scotty? or Scotty/X+1?
bereft is town, trust meRondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:15 pm @robyn I have to admit my faith was shook last night. I dont understand why bereft is town now. I had a whole crisis of if I flip on you today but I decided Ive already lost if you are wolf so I have to accept you and cape are town but bereft is not who I thought he is. There is a second option but I need some assurance
yeah dw i don't trust myself on much besides bereft read which hasn't shaken in confidenceRondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:19 pmI really dont want to. I have very little bandwith and cant be assed much today. I know how today is going to go already assuming that I can get Robyn to agree that your block will vote with me and Thunal too. So I am just going to save brain space for tomorrowBereft wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:17 pmThunal/Scotty works possibly. Check J^3s massive walls oopsRondoDimBuckle wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 9:16 pmWell I really hate how scotty has been trying to push me and you and DM just keeps giving me weird vibes. What about Thunal/Scotty? or Scotty/X+1?
Wow quoting existsJaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Sat Dec 09, 2023 7:26 pm Do Thunal33 and Scotty fit together as mafia teammates?
From Thunal
Spoiler: show
There's a ton going on in this spoiler, which is already telling to me (it's by far the most interactive review I have done so far). This level of attention is often not compatible. However, to be more thorough, let's follow the progression from Thunal's side. She started with a town read on Scotty relatively early. She sustained it for a while and then noticed him getting some heat from a few town reads of hers (including me). She explored that, offered a few protests, considered some stronger points, and ended up kind of siding with the anti-Scotty camp. She didn't end up voting for him at EOD. Do we believe she started by supporting her active teammate and then pivoted to distancing when the heat came, or do we think she followed a natural trajectory? I dangerously lean to the latter, because her progression was pretty damned similar to mine. The only hesitation I have is that she could have done that on purpose for a "mindmeld", but in the moment at least it felt reasonably authentic to me. Couple that with the sheer volume of interactivity here, and I lean toward dissociation.
From Scotty
Spoiler: show
This is almost the perfect inverse of the previous spoiler. Scotty started harshly with an early vote, and by the end Thunal was in his top town tier. If we assume Scotty is mafia, this looks like someone trying out a mischop and determining that his best interests would be best served canceling that and town reading her instead. I doubt these two coordinated this perfect yin-yang progression on one another.
~~~
I'd call them unlikely teammates.
There is only one world where there was 0 shot.
Bereft wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 7:52 pmIt is unfortunate that I quite literally don't see any way that I can reasonably suspect Robyn.DarlingMonroe wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 7:24 pm wait, so no night kill?
also at least one wolf in: Bereft, Cape, Robyn or Thunal.
They are the only ones who voted to lynch town twice: seanzie and ts account,
I apologize for my lack of a case at this current moment.
By extension, I also cannot reasonably suspect Cape.
I can reasonably suspect Thunal, but I'd still be hesitant to, given everything.
I believe that today we should try to figure out just what has been going on this game. I think it is pro-ev for town to do so, and will decrease general confusion.
I know I cannot reasonably suspect you but man what does "given everything" mean in terms of your read on Thunal?Bereft wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 7:54 pm I will vote Scotty in the meantime for no reason other than that I think the Scotty probably tmi'ed ts town but was otherwise the biggest wolf agenda pusher besides robyn, who I unfortunately have no reason to suspect like I have already stated. My opinion on Scotty may change given what I read.
What does DM's alignment have to do with TS' flip?Bereft wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 7:58 pm I quite frankly have no clue of DM's alignment at this stage of the game. Sorry but that's what happens the inactive guy that everyone just assumes has to be a part of the team, flips.
I similarly have no clue of what LoRab's alignment. That their slot continues to exist with any reasonable conclusions on the slot is worrying.
If you believe that it was obvious that Mich/LoRab was v/w, then you should probably state your reasoning as such.
[VOTE: Scotty] aubergine
too bad ur wolf team is falling apart isn't it
8-3
SVS saying this but never giving a definitive read on TS is not a good look
I will say I don't think S~V~S/LoRab are w/w because of this particular commentS~V~S wrote: ↑Wed Dec 13, 2023 6:55 am Guys I'm really sorry, for some reason I am very demoralized right now. Maybe being suspected after literally making one or two posts (for an actual not real reason) then every time I try to explain where I'm coming from, well I can't do it without mentioning Scotty, and he's like fucking Beetlejuice lol.
I had mostly town reads this whole game. Right now I am one zillion percent not caught up.
Town
Robyn, Cape, Rondo. I feel Befert for reasons, some things they've said . Maybe cause Robyn vouches, and I guess they know each other that well? I also feel Abi is town, but that could be a warm fuzzy cause she t/r'ed me early. I find it super unlikely I'll vote for these people. Or even impossible.
Not Sure, no reason to town read these people, but no reason to wolf read them either.
Thunal, Wilgy, they both seem in their possible town meta as I've observed it, Wilgy tries a bit more to act innocuous when he's bad, and Thunal is a bit more level when she's bad, imo. But they've both fooled me, and rather spectacularly might I add lol
Iffy imo (if it's possible Conf Bias, I'll note it):
Darling (possible conf bias), I'm not sure why Jay was so sure of towniness here, maybe cause Darling bolstered his hypotheses? At one point I thought DM and Jay could be the BTS roles, but apparently not. Scotty, I just can't shake it tbh. And the uber aggro way he comes at me every time I say "beetlejuice", um, Scotty, yeah, that's it.
I have no clue:
T's (it appears they've shown up, but I haven't read their posts yet) and LoRab. I doubt LoRab is gonna show, and that makes me sad, maybe more sad than people trying to wagon her on Hanukkah. But that's also based on personal info that I'm fairly sure no one else in game had. LC prolly knew but he was dead. On the night y'all were trying to lynch her, she was having her head shaved as part of a fund raiser for a childrens cancer charity. So I was in here watching pitchforks get shaken at her, and then on social watching her do good in the real world. So I kinda got salty and over reacted I guess.
And someone in my @'s said something about how my Michelle vote was too little too late or something to that effect.
I baldly stated I wanted to save LoRab regardless of affiliation, I wasn't exactly having a ball in here, lol, and wanted to make sure that LoRab wagon hadn't formed before I voted. I voted left the thread and apparently missed the LoRab wagon that subsequently formed.
I'll be back after work to hopefully read some more (like T's posts) and vote.
I was townreading the Bereft section here though from day 2S~V~S wrote: ↑Sun Dec 10, 2023 5:07 pmI think Robyn is town. They are not doing their usual town leader thing, trying to force the thread into submission thing they usually do, but I would guess it's hard to compete with you (no shade meant here, just the facts). They also said they were switching it up in the beginning of the game. Also somethings they said early into Day 2 led me to think they were town.JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Sun Dec 10, 2023 1:59 pm I would very much love to hear reads on Bereft and robyn from @S~V~S, @DrWilgy, @LoRab, @Michelle, and anyone else that hasn’t recently stated them. That’ll be nice for me to assess the general game state. Thanks.
Bereft, I would like to think is town although I have seen him other places, it was mainly in Severance where he affected a unique posting style, so I have no real baseline for his game. His tone seems to have changed from earlier; he started out mildly curmudgeony, now it's a bit more pronounced~ his avatar befits his tone. I would say solely based on tone and content, he's a null for me, BUT, not unlike Robyn, he made a few posts earlier that led me to possibly lean town.
To your other "SVS hasn't updated reads" I've been in abd out of here much of the day cold reading, but I was exhausted from yesterday and had to take a nap. Ill be here till pretty much EOD, and will try to comply.
So you've said earlier, can you explain why? Thanks!DarlingMonroe wrote: ↑Sun Dec 10, 2023 4:50 pm If I had to say my four biggest pings right now are:
SVS
Michelle
Bereft
LoRob/PrincessA.
girlyDarlingMonroe wrote: ↑Fri Dec 15, 2023 4:30 am @RondoDimBuckle @robyn @Bereft what's the case for Scotty over Thunal/Cape?
Huh... maybe bereft is town.Bereft wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 7:52 pmIt is unfortunate that I quite literally don't see any way that I can reasonably suspect Robyn.DarlingMonroe wrote: ↑Thu Dec 14, 2023 7:24 pm wait, so no night kill?
also at least one wolf in: Bereft, Cape, Robyn or Thunal.
They are the only ones who voted to lynch town twice: seanzie and ts account,
I apologize for my lack of a case at this current moment.
By extension, I also cannot reasonably suspect Cape.
I can reasonably suspect Thunal, but I'd still be hesitant to, given everything.
I believe that today we should try to figure out just what has been going on this game. I think it is pro-ev for town to do so, and will decrease general confusion.