U-Pick Mafia Vol 1 - Game Over

[dunya]

I do appreciate we should always lynch speed first usually cos he's always scum though, so I don't suspect sprityo for thinking it. in fact, have a green townie pass for the day.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I think either JJJ, dunya and Golden are either all town or all scum.

I think we’re all just trying to find our way in a world that does not lend a hand or even remember that it could.

I cannot see who posted the .gif in my linki, but I know it to be Jack.

[Turnip Head]

WHat has eyes but cannot see?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

The means which got these two to this point were created by Dunya as she wanted to get a reaction out of JJJ. Okay I guess.

no. I was provoking him, sure. I had no expectations of him. Honestly, I thought he was going to continue roleplaying the whole game as he has expressed desire to kinda half-ass this game in signups (as have a few others). I was intentionally provoking him cos I love teasing Jay.

I don't like this post. Feels like backpedalling now that you're realized provoking Jay had the wrong effect.

alright, let's play along. backpedalling from what exactly? you're saying "wrong effect", what was the "right effect" I was going for? what was I trying to accomplish from my interactions with Jay before he called me scum? have a look at my posts, and then come back to me.

Look like you are scumhunting.

What else?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Why people always ask "what would scum X try to accomplish by doing Y?" Scum doesn't try to accomplish anything most of the time, they just try to look like they are trying to get things done.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I do appreciate we should always lynch speed first usually cos he's always scum though, so I don't suspect sprityo for thinking it. in fact, have a green townie pass for the day.

Thanks.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Why people always ask "what would scum X try to accomplish by doing Y?" Scum doesn't try to accomplish anything most of the time, they just try to look like they are trying to get things done.

Fair. See: Dunya trying to switch the lynch from Kyle to Nova in Greece.

[dunya]

The means which got these two to this point were created by Dunya as she wanted to get a reaction out of JJJ. Okay I guess.

no. I was provoking him, sure. I had no expectations of him. Honestly, I thought he was going to continue roleplaying the whole game as he has expressed desire to kinda half-ass this game in signups (as have a few others). I was intentionally provoking him cos I love teasing Jay.

I don't like this post. Feels like backpedalling now that you're realized provoking Jay had the wrong effect.

alright, let's play along. backpedalling from what exactly? you're saying "wrong effect", what was the "right effect" I was going for? what was I trying to accomplish from my interactions with Jay before he called me scum? have a look at my posts, and then come back to me.

Look like you are scumhunting.

What else?

you didn't read my posts then and you're bullshitting because it's easy to do.

now try again. give me quotes, before Jay said "dunya is scum", where I was "scumhunting Jay".

[colonialbob]

WHat has eyes but cannot see?

A double hurricane

[dunya]

Why people always ask "what would scum X try to accomplish by doing Y?" Scum doesn't try to accomplish anything most of the time, they just try to look like they are trying to get things done.

Fair. See: Dunya trying to switch the lynch from Kyle to Nova in Greece.

actually, I was trying to lynch wolbre. and it was for a reason: we weren't sure if we would win the game after our next kill, so I was setting wolbre up for the next mislynch. everything has a purpose.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

The means which got these two to this point were created by Dunya as she wanted to get a reaction out of JJJ. Okay I guess.

no. I was provoking him, sure. I had no expectations of him. Honestly, I thought he was going to continue roleplaying the whole game as he has expressed desire to kinda half-ass this game in signups (as have a few others). I was intentionally provoking him cos I love teasing Jay.

I don't like this post. Feels like backpedalling now that you're realized provoking Jay had the wrong effect.

alright, let's play along. backpedalling from what exactly? you're saying "wrong effect", what was the "right effect" I was going for? what was I trying to accomplish from my interactions with Jay before he called me scum? have a look at my posts, and then come back to me.

Look like you are scumhunting.

What else?

you didn't read my posts then and you're bullshitting because it's easy to do.

now try again. give me quotes, before Jay said "dunya is scum", where I was "scumhunting Jay".

I don't care what you were trying to do. You said something about Jay because scum needs to say things about people. Jay didn't like it. You went and then argued with him about it. Jay still didn't like it. Jay and Golden started attacking you. You realized you had created a conflict earlier than you wanted and backed away from it.

Well that's one theory, I'm not saying I'm sure of it.

[dunya]

The means which got these two to this point were created by Dunya as she wanted to get a reaction out of JJJ. Okay I guess.

no. I was provoking him, sure. I had no expectations of him. Honestly, I thought he was going to continue roleplaying the whole game as he has expressed desire to kinda half-ass this game in signups (as have a few others). I was intentionally provoking him cos I love teasing Jay.

I don't like this post. Feels like backpedalling now that you're realized provoking Jay had the wrong effect.

alright, let's play along. backpedalling from what exactly? you're saying "wrong effect", what was the "right effect" I was going for? what was I trying to accomplish from my interactions with Jay before he called me scum? have a look at my posts, and then come back to me.

Look like you are scumhunting.

What else?

you didn't read my posts then and you're bullshitting because it's easy to do.

now try again. give me quotes, before Jay said "dunya is scum", where I was "scumhunting Jay".

I don't care what you were trying to do. You said something about Jay because scum needs to say things about people. Jay didn't like it. You went and then argued with him about it. Jay still didn't like it. Jay and Golden started attacking you. You realized you had created a conflict earlier than you wanted and backed away from it.

Well that's one theory, I'm not saying I'm sure of it.

bullshit.

i call...bull...shit.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Like I couldn't care less what was your motivation to argue with Jay in the first place. What concerns me is that after seeing you three argue for two pages, you were the first to back away.

[dunya]

ddl just moved to my scumpile for doing pretty much what nutella did, but a little more aggressively, I'll hand it to him.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

ddl just moved to my scumpile for doing pretty much what nutella did, but a little more aggressively, I'll hand it to him.

I'm honored by getting someone to OMGUS me under 10 posts. Means I'm playing a good game.

[dunya]

Like I couldn't care less what was your motivation to argue with Jay in the first place. What concerns me is that after seeing you three argue for two pages, you were the first to back away.

again: back away from what?

you're saying: dunya was accusing jay

jay flipped on dunya

dunya retracted

i call bullshit because i didn't accuse of jay, indeed i townread him as soon as he broke roleplay, and never accused him while he was in roleplay.

if you want something to stick on me when i'm town, you gotta try harder.

[ColinIsCool]

I think either JJJ, dunya and Golden are either all town or all scum.

Mostly a gut thing. Dunya’s play reminds me of the exasperated scum I saw in Greece. I don’t buy into Golden’s characterization of her and think his take on me was belabored. JJJ just scares me generally. Don’t take this too seriously yet.

[dunya]

it's not omgus, because you can't even actually outright accuse me. all you can do is throw a little shade and then put a safe little cushion to fall back on. it's weak. and your reasoning is bullshit. i call your bullshit.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Why people always ask "what would scum X try to accomplish by doing Y?" Scum doesn't try to accomplish anything most of the time, they just try to look like they are trying to get things done.

Fair. See: Dunya trying to switch the lynch from Kyle to Nova in Greece.

Dude did you see the gargantuan effort I made to lynch Marmot in the last day of Ass Class?

It was all smoke and mirrors. I did it while planning to switch to Pennywise later on. The point wasn't to get Marmot lynched, it was to make people think I had a point in the first place.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

it's not omgus, because you can't even actually outright accuse me. all you can do is throw a little shade and then put a safe little cushion to fall back on. it's weak. and your reasoning is bullshit. i call your bullshit.

Yes it is a little shade.

We'll see later if that shade turns into something big.

But anytime you say something suspicious, I'll point it out.

[wolbre04]

WHat has eyes but cannot see?

A potato

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Like I can create a real case by only reading Day 0. I'm not that good.

[dunya]

humility will get you everywhere.

[wolbre04]

Why people always ask "what would scum X try to accomplish by doing Y?" Scum doesn't try to accomplish anything most of the time, they just try to look like they are trying to get things done.

See: My Ass Class final day and night before we won

[JaggedJimmyJay]

dunya you’re calling DDL on perceived bullshit. Okay.

Is he bad?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

humility will get you everywhere.

dunya if you have a beef with me you can tell me. I don't accuse people in mafia games because I think I'm better than them. I just... accuse them.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Also I checked your ISO quickly and you have a point. You didn't accuse Jay early like I remembered.

Still think your post felt like you trying to defuse something, and that makes me feel suspish.

[ColinIsCool]

I would be interested in nutella’s rebuttal to the argument against her

[dunya]

dunya you’re calling DDL on perceived bullshit. Okay.

Is he bad?

I moved him to my suspect list because he's creating a case that doesn't exist and fabrication isn't something that townies usually do. he's latching onto the "dunya is suspicious" environment of the thread and it's weak. i give him more credit than nutella for at least trying to give a reason, and saying what i was doing was scumhunting is actually kinda funny. he couldn't provide examples, so he moves onto the "i don't care what you were doing cos scum dont have to do anything at all" as a second attack. but...the whole basis of his shade is that i was scumhunting you and decided oops i couldn't take you on and fell back into place. not buying it.

[JaggedJimmyJay]

dunya you’re calling DDL on perceived bullshit. Okay.

Is he bad?

Nevermind, I just saw your affirmative post.

[speedchuck]

If you guys want to lynch me that's fine, but wait till at least day two so I can establish a new town meta for myself.

[dunya]

humility will get you everywhere.

dunya if you have a beef with me you can tell me. I don't accuse people in mafia games because I think I'm better than them. I just... accuse them.

i have no beef with you, my friend

[JaggedJimmyJay]

dunya you’re calling DDL on perceived bullshit. Okay.

Is he bad?

I moved him to my suspect list because he's creating a case that doesn't exist and fabrication isn't something that townies usually do. he's latching onto the "dunya is suspicious" environment of the thread and it's weak. i give him more credit than nutella for at least trying to give a reason, and saying what i was doing was scumhunting is actually kinda funny. he couldn't provide examples, so he moves onto the "i don't care what you were doing cos scum dont have to do anything at all" as a second attack. but...the whole basis of his shade is that i was scumhunting you and decided oops i couldn't take you on and fell back into place. not buying it.

Why does anyone need fabrication in a game with two mafia teams? I believe you asked me something similar earlier.

[speedchuck]

Only 8 votes on the board. Sad!

[nutella]

[long post of bullshit]

you don't know what you're talking about. my meta is not as consistent as you seem to think. you claim to be confident in all these "tells" but I have no idea where you're getting them from and you're wrong. yes, my opinion on you has flip-flopped a couple times already. no, my posts are not fake. also I'm flattered that you think I am "calculated and scheming" but I'm really not. I'm drifting along with no idea of anyone else's alignment and just saying what i think in the moment.

[speedchuck]

[VOTE: sprityo] aubergine

OMG U ssuck mate

[Jackofhearts2005]

Why people always ask "what would scum X try to accomplish by doing Y?" Scum doesn't try to accomplish anything most of the time, they just try to look like they are trying to get things done.

Fair. See: Dunya trying to switch the lynch from Kyle to Nova in Greece.

actually, I was trying to lynch wolbre. and it was for a reason: we weren't sure if we would win the game after our next kill, so I was setting wolbre up for the next mislynch. everything has a purpose.

[dunya]

dunya you’re calling DDL on perceived bullshit. Okay.

Is he bad?

I moved him to my suspect list because he's creating a case that doesn't exist and fabrication isn't something that townies usually do. he's latching onto the "dunya is suspicious" environment of the thread and it's weak. i give him more credit than nutella for at least trying to give a reason, and saying what i was doing was scumhunting is actually kinda funny. he couldn't provide examples, so he moves onto the "i don't care what you were doing cos scum dont have to do anything at all" as a second attack. but...the whole basis of his shade is that i was scumhunting you and decided oops i couldn't take you on and fell back into place. not buying it.

Why does anyone need fabrication in a game with two mafia teams? I believe you asked me something similar earlier.

actually someone else asked me that, I didn't ask that to you. you told me I had you down as a "firm civ read" because of TMI, and I said even if I was scum, I couldn't possibly have you down as a firm civ read then since there were 2 scum teams and 3ps.

and I don't know why. people don't like to play with me, probably

[colonialbob]

Why people always ask "what would scum X try to accomplish by doing Y?" Scum doesn't try to accomplish anything most of the time, they just try to look like they are trying to get things done.

Fair. See: Dunya trying to switch the lynch from Kyle to Nova in Greece.

Dude did you see the gargantuan effort I made to lynch Marmot in the last day of Ass Class?

It was all smoke and mirrors. I did it while planning to switch to Pennywise later on. The point wasn't to get Marmot lynched, it was to make people think I had a point in the first place.

But "looking like I'm being productive" is a valid answer to "what was scum trying to accomplish"

I mean, the whole game is "what is X trying to accomplish by Y"

[nutella]

3. scum nutella also has a tendency to not harp on one person and have no definite reads on them. civ nutella is organically paranoid, with a healthy dose of tinfoil. scum nutella tries to find posts that wouldn't be deemed scummy if she looks into them and also scum reads them. she doesn't build cases of her own accord on someone with no suspicion. she would love to see a high poster like me, Jay or Sloonei or Golden (if he's not on her team), to get lynched early on. see above. she also adds little quips like "yo" "ayy" and similar when she is scum and trying to downplay something.

please, stop doing this. stop making shit up about me and saying it like you know me better than i know myself. your tone in this game is fucking toxic. please stop. none of these generalizations are reliably true. I use slang all the time regardless of alignment, I promise you if you look at my recent civ games it's there. I almost never build cases. I almost never have definite reads, especially on day 1.

[ColinIsCool]

Why people always ask "what would scum X try to accomplish by doing Y?" Scum doesn't try to accomplish anything most of the time, they just try to look like they are trying to get things done.

This rings untrue.

[dunya]

my meta is not as consistent as you seem to think.

funny you say that.

dunya's tone overall sounds very much like her mafia game so far.

[nutella]

I'm gonna bet my right and left paws that she is definitely one rotten egg.

I'm so sorry. If you lynch me you'll lose your paws and get some nice runny yolk all over your face.

[Turnip Head]

If you guys want to lynch me that's fine, but wait till at least day two so I can establish a new town meta for myself.

hey man. hey man. Do you want to be a part of my town meta? I want to it to be like the antithesis of the talking-in-circles town meta that some people really like.

[Turnip Head]

3. scum nutella also has a tendency to not harp on one person and have no definite reads on them. civ nutella is organically paranoid, with a healthy dose of tinfoil. scum nutella tries to find posts that wouldn't be deemed scummy if she looks into them and also scum reads them. she doesn't build cases of her own accord on someone with no suspicion. she would love to see a high poster like me, Jay or Sloonei or Golden (if he's not on her team), to get lynched early on. see above. she also adds little quips like "yo" "ayy" and similar when she is scum and trying to downplay something.

please, stop doing this. stop making shit up about me and saying it like you know me better than i know myself. your tone in this game is fucking toxic. please stop. none of these generalizations are reliably true. I use slang all the time regardless of alignment, I promise you if you look at my recent civ games it's there. I almost never build cases. I almost never have definite reads, especially on day 1.

rally to meeee nutella

I sense a kindred spirit

Let's just be the coolest mofos in the game amirite

[dunya]

3. scum nutella also has a tendency to not harp on one person and have no definite reads on them. civ nutella is organically paranoid, with a healthy dose of tinfoil. scum nutella tries to find posts that wouldn't be deemed scummy if she looks into them and also scum reads them. she doesn't build cases of her own accord on someone with no suspicion. she would love to see a high poster like me, Jay or Sloonei or Golden (if he's not on her team), to get lynched early on. see above. she also adds little quips like "yo" "ayy" and similar when she is scum and trying to downplay something.

please, stop doing this. stop making shit up about me and saying it like you know me better than i know myself. your tone in this game is fucking toxic. please stop. none of these generalizations are reliably true. I use slang all the time regardless of alignment, I promise you if you look at my recent civ games it's there. I almost never build cases. I almost never have definite reads, especially on day 1.

i'm sorry you don't like my suspicions, but these are my opinions, and you can build your own cases and form your own opinions. everyone's entitled to that, just like jay sees a correlation between me TMIing in FE and Ancient Greece and here. i'm not trying to be toxic, but i do suspect you a healthy amount. this is just a game.

[dunya]

I'm gonna bet my right and left paws that she is definitely one rotten egg.

I'm so sorry. If you lynch me you'll lose your paws and get some nice runny yolk all over your face.

challenge accepted

[speedchuck]

If you guys want to lynch me that's fine, but wait till at least day two so I can establish a new town meta for myself.

hey man. hey man. Do you want to be a part of my town meta? I want to it to be like the antithesis of the talking-in-circles town meta that some people really like.

Sure. How do we do it?

[Turnip Head]

i'm not trying to be toxic, but i do suspect you a healthy amount. this is just a game.

there there dunya. we are all friends here

now kith

[Turnip Head]

If you guys want to lynch me that's fine, but wait till at least day two so I can establish a new town meta for myself.

hey man. hey man. Do you want to be a part of my town meta? I want to it to be like the antithesis of the talking-in-circles town meta that some people really like.

Sure. How do we do it?

idk man I'm just going for it really