The Wire Mafia [END]

[Creature]

Just realized this is still the one site I struggle with.

[Sloonei]

Okay but now I suspect DDL for having such an in-depth take on it. I still don't like that boo's "deal" looks so much like trying to get Rej out of a tight spot in a double lynch. The double lynch aspect of it contributes to what irks me. Why would a townie boo be so invested in who someone else voted for when two people are going to be lynched? Boo already had his man with TSP, but he got greedy and wanted to keep rej safe too.

I do not love this post and I'm not sure I follow it either. The bulk of it seems to be focused on why the Root Vegetable is suspicious of boo, but this is all framed around a suspicion against DDL. TH's focus from this post on is DDL. I strongly disagree with that vote.
[mention]Turnip Head[/mention] could you clarify your reads on boo and DDL here? What are the points against each of them, and why is DDL a better lynch than boo?

[dunya]

but sloonei, what you're missing from that is the shit i gave him for the question before rej answered. i feel like that diminishes the strong response to rej a bit, but i see what you mean...

A: what you're missing from that
B: i see what you mean

(A) implies that Dunya has seen the post (as she has) and that it wasn't enough for her because of reason A.
(B) implies that Dunya is... agreeing? with sloonei?

Do you have a side on this, or are you just gonna waffle around and throw shade?

i mean reading the multiquote like that makes me feel like it is a genuine conversation.

I do not follow. What looks genuine? What is your take on speedchuck/rej here?

i feel like speedchuck's attack was more genuine than i remember feeling about it at the time of his question. i just hated how he asked him is that sarcasm? then said "because it feels like sarcasm to me"

if rej had responded "yes that was sarcasm"

then the conversation would have been...over?

[Jackofhearts2005]

i didnt like how creature didn't know JJJ was replaced.

I’m aware I’m defending a scum read but why is this scum indicative?

[Creature]

but at least isn't many players shouting creature meta every single day

[Sloonei]

Just realized this is still the one site I struggle with.

struggle in what sense?

[speedchuck]

You either love playing with me or hate playing with me.

<3

[dunya]

i didnt like how creature didn't know JJJ was replaced.

I’m aware I’m defending a scum read but why is this scum indicative?

no, my english took a beating lately. read on, i don't think creature is scum lol

[Jackofhearts2005]

i mean, im using it as a point in his favor vs. i think he's bad for it.

bad creature was a lot more active and townie-like. he got more involved. at least in the game i played with him in NF. he totally fooled me. i'm not seeing the same creature here.

[Creature]

Wow forget about the game for a phase

Hello I missed like...

all phases until now and still am missing

[Jackofhearts2005]

Creature fooled Dunya.

I’m still dreaming.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

but at least isn't many players shouting creature meta every single day

Meta exists but it's not as reliable as lot of people think it is.

[speedchuck]

but sloonei, what you're missing from that is the shit i gave him for the question before rej answered. i feel like that diminishes the strong response to rej a bit, but i see what you mean...

A: what you're missing from that
B: i see what you mean

(A) implies that Dunya has seen the post (as she has) and that it wasn't enough for her because of reason A.
(B) implies that Dunya is... agreeing? with sloonei?

Do you have a side on this, or are you just gonna waffle around and throw shade?

i mean reading the multiquote like that makes me feel like it is a genuine conversation.

I do not follow. What looks genuine? What is your take on speedchuck/rej here?

i feel like speedchuck's attack was more genuine than i remember feeling about it at the time of his question. i just hated how he asked him is that sarcasm? then said "because it feels like sarcasm to me"

if rej had responded "yes that was sarcasm"

then the conversation would have been...over?

Admittedly, it was not a trap for Rej. I was only trying to figure out if he was townreading or scumreading, because the post was in a grey area.
Then he replied, and things got worse.

[Sloonei]

but sloonei, what you're missing from that is the shit i gave him for the question before rej answered. i feel like that diminishes the strong response to rej a bit, but i see what you mean...

A: what you're missing from that
B: i see what you mean

(A) implies that Dunya has seen the post (as she has) and that it wasn't enough for her because of reason A.
(B) implies that Dunya is... agreeing? with sloonei?

Do you have a side on this, or are you just gonna waffle around and throw shade?

i mean reading the multiquote like that makes me feel like it is a genuine conversation.

I do not follow. What looks genuine? What is your take on speedchuck/rej here?

i feel like speedchuck's attack was more genuine than i remember feeling about it at the time of his question. i just hated how he asked him is that sarcasm? then said "because it feels like sarcasm to me"

if rej had responded "yes that was sarcasm"

then the conversation would have been...over?

I suppose so. But rej didn't say it was sarcasm, so the conversation didn't end and we got what we got out of it. Townie point for speed imo.

[dunya]

but at least isn't many players shouting creature meta every single day

well, i kind of am using your meta to town read u

did you play ddl's jester game? right? DDL is saying you didn't. how did we meet? what game did we play?

[speedchuck]

I was reading mafia and burned my dinner you trash

[Sloonei]

Creature fooled Dunya.

I’m still dreaming.

Someone oughta get a baguette to the nutsack over this.

[Creature]

I’m saying that FOR TODAY, we have some very strong indicators that there’s scum between sloonei and Colin.

Wasn't it Sloonei and boo initially?

[Creature]

Oh man, and they don't stop coming

[Creature]

Any way I can get rid of the preview new posts thing?

[Jackofhearts2005]

i had a thunderdome with jack this game? was i sleepwalking through it?

Well it was a draw obviously.

[Creature]

Rej interactions

Never watched it but I just realized we can't claim any kind of information in this game ;-; My least favorite rule.

+ its closed rolemadness as it seems

Casual fluff post in response to ZemmiHead. This tells me nothing on its own, but it exists.

gonna say it's town

[dunya]

but sloonei, what you're missing from that is the shit i gave him for the question before rej answered. i feel like that diminishes the strong response to rej a bit, but i see what you mean...

A: what you're missing from that
B: i see what you mean

(A) implies that Dunya has seen the post (as she has) and that it wasn't enough for her because of reason A.
(B) implies that Dunya is... agreeing? with sloonei?

Do you have a side on this, or are you just gonna waffle around and throw shade?

i mean reading the multiquote like that makes me feel like it is a genuine conversation.

I do not follow. What looks genuine? What is your take on speedchuck/rej here?

i feel like speedchuck's attack was more genuine than i remember feeling about it at the time of his question. i just hated how he asked him is that sarcasm? then said "because it feels like sarcasm to me"

if rej had responded "yes that was sarcasm"

then the conversation would have been...over?

I suppose so. But rej didn't say it was sarcasm, so the conversation didn't end and we got what we got out of it. Townie point for speed imo.

i'm just saying for someone who has a long history of asking questions and hating anyone who answers the question for the person or asks him why he asked that question (see speed history), i found it peculiar that speed asked a question and semi answered it himself in one post if he was trying to get a scum lean on someone.

[Creature]

Considering 17 players usually means 4 mafia in a town v mafia singleball but also considering this site is weird, I'd say 3 mafia with chances of a handful of third parties

I could see that, I don't recall ever playing a Nova game though which does make it a bit more murky.

I'd say 3-4 mafia and two third parties probably with survivorish roles, I don't think the game could support a SK given how small it is and there being role reveals. It's also possible one of the third parties is a mechanism against role claiming, if they're not I'd be wary of the mafia having a role that could punish a player for revealing info/claiming.

the way you imply he third parties being survivorish is worrying me
I note it down

Soft shade thrown at sig. Gut instinct is to say this is a good look for sig, but not enough here to get a strong read. I could see it as distancing as well. The exchange continue in a similar manner. It definitely looks manufactured, but I am not able to gauge whether or not sig is part of the manufacturing process as well. His response is a literal shrug.

Oh well, I townread sigh anyway

[Sloonei]

Rej interactions

Never watched it but I just realized we can't claim any kind of information in this game ;-; My least favorite rule.

+ its closed rolemadness as it seems

Casual fluff post in response to ZemmiHead. This tells me nothing on its own, but it exists.

gonna say it's town

Why's that?

[Jackofhearts2005]

jack is obsessed with me.

And that's like the 20th hit for "Jack" in your ISO.

Dunya is obsessed with me.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

[VOTE: LC] aubergine

Let's see what happens

[Sloonei]

I do not object to dunya's initial objection to speedchuck in that exchange.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Based off of Rej alone: Sloonie, Jack and Speed would be 3 to pursue.

Ignoring Rej: Creature, LC, Speed, and Collins. I don't remember why I voted for him, but since I did I'll throw that down.

Combo of both in order of whom I'd lynch: Creature, Speed, LC then Sloonie.

DDL is probably my tin foil mafia read right now.

So like. Players in this game are probably wolves?

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I do not object to dunya's initial objection to speedchuck in that exchange.

I stopped following that a page ago.

[Sloonei]

I do not object to dunya's initial objection to speedchuck in that exchange.

I stopped following that a page ago.

I think it's over now anyway, unless anyone has anything to add.

[Creature]

Rainbow reads based exclusively on these interactions:
DDL
speedchuck
Jack
Colin
dunya
sig
Long Con
boo

Everybody else is null, though I have not actively considered those who are conspicuously absent much. LC gets a negative nod because he was mentioned at the very last second, but there are others who don't show up at all in this ISO.

Missed I was, missed I was
Gonna be hold back on more
Missed I was, missed I was
On my face they just slammed the door

[Sloonei]

I do not object to dunya's initial objection to speedchuck in that exchange.

I stopped following that a page ago.

I think it's over now anyway, unless anyone has anything to add.

this is true of everything, though.

[Creature]

I also have some heavy doubts on whether Rej's role was actually the strongest.

I mean, this is nova we are talking about. He wasn't raised on Mafia Scum. He was raised on sites where roles with 10+ abilities are common. I don't know if he likes writing games with powerful roles, but he certainly is used to them.

Why were we even celebrating Rej's role death?

[Sloonei]

Rainbow reads based exclusively on these interactions:
DDL
speedchuck
Jack
Colin
dunya
sig
Long Con
boo

Everybody else is null, though I have not actively considered those who are conspicuously absent much. LC gets a negative nod because he was mentioned at the very last second, but there are others who don't show up at all in this ISO.

Missed I was, missed I was
Gonna be hold back on more
Missed I was, missed I was
On my face they just slammed the door

see my next post

[dunya]

which player is the one you find most hard to read this game : go

[dunya]

for me: probably jack.

[Dragon D. Luffy]

[mention]dunya[/mention]

I've figured it out.

There is a post from you in the staff forum saying you think Creature is Cooler, whom you had just played with.

Later on you learn CReature is not actually Cooler.

[dunya]

are you coming off sloonei, speedchuck? i thought you said you were.

[Jackofhearts2005]

which player is the one you find most hard to read this game : go

Sloonei.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I assume you mean living players in this game.

[Jackofhearts2005]

@dunya

I've figured it out.

There is a post from you in the staff forum saying you think Creature is Cooler, whom you had just played with.

Later on you learn CReature is not actually Cooler.

That makes more sense.

[dunya]

@dunya

I've figured it out.

There is a post from you in the staff forum saying you think Creature is Cooler, whom you had just played with.

Later on you learn CReature is not actually Cooler.

lmao. oh my! fuck! thanks for checking, i was getting creeped out by things.

well, creature is on the table now. i have no idea who they are.

[Jackofhearts2005]

[mention]Creature[/mention]
Are you playing sword and shield?

[dunya]

[mention]Cooler[/mention] you should come and play with us again. i loved playing with you!

[Sloonei]

which player is the one you find most hard to read this game : go

Sloonei.

Just forget about the first time we met, okay?

[Creature]

Sloonei posts a big thingie and aside from DDL, “good look for X” and “not a great look for Y” appear to be slapped on to interactions at random.

Not a good look for Sloonei.

I do that quite a lot for aesthetic.

[Creature]

Okay so thoughts on Sloonie, he's been a contender last two days, without very strong cases either day.

Oh yeah, scum can get no strong cases on them being scum at all. However, can they get strong cases on them being town?

[Creature]

I'm mainly eyeing two players though Creature and Speed, both have been present but have done very little to the point I keep forgetting they're in the game.

Maybe because you left me untouched until now?

[Sloonei]

sig and jack are probably the two i'm having the most trouble reading this game, all things considered. The other players I lack definitive reads on are that way for other reasons: nanook is new to me and was goofy for two days. Creature is Creature. TH's player slot was empty for a long time. But sig and jack have posted regularly from the beginning and I lack a firm read on each of them.